Oliver Anthony Proves He’s No One Hit Wonder with “Scornful Woman”

It’s almost like the entire music industry has memory holed Oliver Anthony. It was just two short years ago that he took a video of him hollering out in the woods all the way to #1 in all of music and to headliner slots at major festivals. Though some consider him a one hit wonder with his fudge rounds song, Anthony’s “Ain’t Gotta Dollar” has 43 million spins on Spotify alone—not to mention other top tracks—and he continues to be booked at top spots at festivals, drawing large crowds live.
Granted, over the last year or so, Oliver’s seemed more interested in citing Bible verses and participating in advocacy for rural communities as opposed to pushing his music career forward. But as few people are paying attention, his new song and the video for the track “Scornful Woman” has exploded.
Ever since the video for “Scornful Woman” was released on Wednesday, June 4th, it’s been trending at the top on YouTube. It probably didn’t hurt that the song got big shout outs from major online personalities like Joe Rogan and Jocko Willink. Joe Rogan is known shouting out important independent artists. Tyler Childers, Colter Wall, and especially Sturgill Simpson received big boosts from Rogan, even if he’s pretty novice when it comes to actual music knowledge.
After complaining about the ills of the music industry recently to the chagrin of some of his contemporaries, Anthony has side stepped the whole music world entirely, and is making his way in a lane that’s less musical, and more cultural, creating an interesting test case, and potentially, another paradigm shift in how music can be pushed, similar to how he did with “Rich Men North of Richmond.”
As opposed to using conventional radio and media promotion like major label artists—or even more independent channels like social media or TV/movie placement—Oliver Anthony is taking his music to people who identify with him over cultural concerns. And though on the surface this might code political, Anthony has proven to be difficult to pigeon hole in the political binary. He once again appeared on the Joe Rogan podcast on Friday (6-13).
“Scornful Woman” isn’t exactly a country song, despite the prominent fiddle from the legendary Billy Contreras who is also given a songwriting credit on the track. It’s more like an explosive blues song bordering on rock, with a blistering, emotionally-charged performance from both Anthony, and his accompanying musicians. Guitarist Joey Davis is also credited on the track.
The song was inspired by Oliver Anthony’s divorce. As Joe Rogan touted about the track, “He starts making millions of dollars, playing arenas. The wife divorces him. She wants everything. She wants more than half. She wants all the money he’s going to be making in the future because she was with him when he was broke … He’s just tortured. He wants to die. Wants to die — and writes this song.”
The producer for “Scornful Woman” is Draven Riffe, who along with being a musician too, he’s also one of the guys behind the RadioWV YouTube channel that blew up Oliver Anthony originally, along with other performers from the West Virginia region.
Oliver Anthony has most certainly become a strongly polarizing character. Yet despite the accusations of being an “industry plant” or the product of “Astroturfing,” he continues to soldier forward completely independently with the same original people who he started with.
Anthony is also moving forward and finding success in a way that completely side steps not just the conventional major label industry, but that takes him into uncharted territory even for independent artists, opening up new avenues of how to get attention for music, and well after any big “10 minutes of fame” moment has faded.
June 14, 2025 @ 8:43 am
Did she eat all his fudge rounds?
June 14, 2025 @ 8:48 am
Am I allowed to just not find an artist interesting
June 14, 2025 @ 9:10 am
Absolutely. And you can just not know exactly what to do with an artist. That’s what I feel about Oliver Anthony. But he’s here, and clearly having an impact. So it feels like something that at the least should be studied.
June 14, 2025 @ 10:23 am
I suspect part of the challenge with Anthony is that his primary audience is content to stream the hell out of one of his viral songs, but is less interested in actually sitting down and listening to an entire album of his.
Which probably explains why folks more invested in music – notably folks who seek out songs/artists based on the quality of the songwriting, vocals, instrumentation, etc. – sort of shrug their shoulders with him.
At least that is why I think he mostly leaves me cold. Thanks to this website and other outlets, I can find better singers, better writers, etc. and listen to them happily. But if you are some guy who your buddy forwards you a YouTube link from Joe Rogan and you hear this song and all you typically listen to is whatever slop is on FM radio these days I can see/get the appeal.
Play the song above next to a Jason Aldean or Luke Bryan song and you can easily see where someone would be like “wow, this Oliver Anthony is a raw, emotional songwriter”.
Maybe I am selling short Anthony fans – I’m sure there are fans who love Anthony AND can name off their favorite Chris Knight or Joe Stamm songs. But it feels very much like he (Anthony) has been able to tap into a segment of the country that sadly has no idea who those guys are, but are longing for more “real” songwriting, but can’t cut through what the algorithms feed them.
June 14, 2025 @ 9:08 am
I’m not a fan of his music or his vocal style and weird guttural enunciation on some words. However his wife wanting 60% of his future earnings, not to mention taxes, that’s ridiculous. What incentive is there to keep pushing if you only get to keep 10% of the pie? I am aware that the divorce hasn’t been finalized but if his wife all of a sudden went missing – I wouldn’t morally agree but I would understand.
June 15, 2025 @ 8:26 am
Ruinous taxation and alimony.
That isn’t what we fought the British to establish.
June 15, 2025 @ 8:46 am
Worth noting this is just Anthony’s claims. We have no clue if they are true or not. Maybe they are, maybe they aren’t.
But the more Oliver Anthony speaks, the more it seems clear he is content to constantly make himself out to be the victim in every story.
Maybe his wife is trying to leech every cent she can out of him. Or maybe Anthony is just someone who is content….being flexible with the truth in an effort to make himself look like the victim as he does anytime he talks about Nashville.
I’m not defending Nashville, but it is pretty convenient that anytime Anthony talks about Nashville/the music industry it is HE that is the victim of all these supposed shenanigans.
I have never been a recording artist and never will be. But doing a simple Google search will show you that the record industry can and is pretty exploitative. It appears Mr. Anthony does not know what “Google” is since he acts like “oh my God, I can’t believe it!” so often when he talks about the music industry.
Which plays pretty conveniently into the narrative he is selling. I listened to his first and only record. Dude has a few lines that are good here and there, but he is a below average songwriter for the genre he wants to play in (Americana/alt-Country) compared to his peers. So it seems rather than allowing his music to speak for him, he is content going on podcasts and making himself out to be some victim in an attempt to hide the fact his first album was a clunker that made no impact.
June 15, 2025 @ 12:08 pm
Lotta half-truths on every side I think. OA is still essentially a one-hit wonder with a novelty song and didn’t pay any dues. Not to mention he found instant fanship with a side of the political aisle that was gonna cause the other side to reject him for being MAGA-adjacent. (regardless of whether that was true or not)
His instant fame put him on tours with well established artists with their proffesional musicians and more polished presentation (and some with backing tracks, yes that’s a thing) – that made him the odd man out. I agree that he is a below average singer-songwriter. As far as him not getting respect from his peers, I feel the same about it as I do with Zach Bryan; each of them has to earn it. Fame doesn’t equal musical talent.
Speaking somewhat in defense of Anthony – most aspiring artists do not understand how exploitative the record industry is – certainly not when it involves their own career and they are contending with their own egos in the moment. OA admitted that he wasn’t sure how to handle the million dollar contract offers and called Joe Rogan for advice – which was smart to have that restraint and not immediately sign papers. I can understand feeling pissed when you realize people flocking around you are not actually your friends and want to take advantage of you.
OA rocketed to fame by being the bearded appalachian crybaby but he needs to develop an internal filter and code switch between proffesional artist looking out for his own business interests, and another for when it’s ok to be candid.
June 16, 2025 @ 6:18 am
I don’t know–you remove the Fudge Rounds line and Rich Men… is probably a liberal anthem.
June 16, 2025 @ 10:27 am
To have the perfect Liberal anthem it would be closer to this:
I was on anti-depressants the day my mama transitationed to my dad
and he went to pick his pronouns in the rain
but before I could get to him in my electric vehicle
he got ran over protesting in the street
June 17, 2025 @ 2:05 pm
He asks Rogan for advice and then does the opposite. Then goes on Rogan to complain about people taking advantage of him…
June 14, 2025 @ 9:51 am
Wasn’t it Jamey Johnson who swooped in and linked up in some way with Oliver as soon as he hit? I can’t remember if it was just a mentor thing or they actually put ink to paper. I’m curious if they’re still working together?
June 14, 2025 @ 10:53 am
I believe he’s continuing to mentor Anthony, but I don’t know if anything is on paper.
June 14, 2025 @ 10:12 am
This song stinks. And that’s a bipartisan take.
June 14, 2025 @ 1:48 pm
It’s not a good song but neither is anything Jesse Welles puts out. Political songs are only valid if they come from one side.
June 14, 2025 @ 11:07 pm
The only thing that stinks is your reply. Since it is your opinion it can’t be washed out so I guess you will stink forever.
June 14, 2025 @ 10:16 am
I am not quite sure what to make of Oliver Anthony. I thought Rich Men North of Richmond was good and I have enjoyed some of his songs including this one. His album with biblical quotes was unusual in many ways and did not include the songs he is best known for which I thought odd. I read somewhere he has had some $800,000 for North of Richmond song so far so if that is right, he appears to be doing well. I have a ticket to see him later in the year and really do not know what to expect. An interesting artist who is definitely making an impact.
June 14, 2025 @ 10:29 am
I would be open to seeing him live, but I would want to know beforehand if he is gonna spend like half his stage time reading Bible verses or ranting about the Clinton machine.
Good on ya if that floats your boat, but I ain’t dropping money to have scripture read to me on a Saturday night or have the equivalent of “Uncle Jim’s Tweets” read to me.
Anthony complaining about how his grandstanding at the Opry “lost him friends in Nashville” made my eyes roll so much they damn near fell out of my head. Dude makes some decent points, but the victim complex he showed with that story was “eeesh”.
June 15, 2025 @ 4:46 am
This is a good comment. The theme of his singles all seem to be about how bad things – from society’s woes writ large to his marriage failing – aren’t his fault. It’s the victimhood whining that is the most eye rolling part of his music and approach to public life
June 14, 2025 @ 10:31 am
Enjoy the tune and his recent appearance on Rogan.
June 14, 2025 @ 12:10 pm
The story behind the recording in the YouTube description is kinda cool. Song is pretty good. But half of what I enjoyed about Rich Men was how it triggered and necessitated gatekeeper commentary from the more fragile songwriters of these soft times.
June 14, 2025 @ 12:56 pm
Not hearing greatness here or even decent songwriting. All its got is a fiddle that wants to be a rock guitar.
June 14, 2025 @ 1:30 pm
TFW you live where 30 oz. of fudge rounds are <$5 at the grocery a block away, and where Sierra Ferrell plays 5 concert in about a year's time, including two that were free, but the closest Oliver Anthony concert was 2 states away. :0
June 14, 2025 @ 2:14 pm
I think it is the authenticity that appeals to me. (A steady diet of raw authenticity would probably be overwhelming however.) This song feels intense & powerful with somewhat soothing interludes of instrumentation. I suggest that Oliver Anthony deserves to be respected for how he is making authenticity the focus of how he is handling the world of music.
June 15, 2025 @ 8:43 am
I think some are mistaking poor writing and production for authenticity, but whatever floats your boat. If you enjoy Anthony more power to ya.
June 14, 2025 @ 2:41 pm
Who is the drummer?
June 14, 2025 @ 2:45 pm
This is great. Raw, blazing, and fiddle that cuts like a saw.
June 14, 2025 @ 3:20 pm
First song of his that I’like. I tried with all his previous stuff, but didn’t care for a single song. This one ain’t bad at all. Kinda kicks.
June 14, 2025 @ 5:38 pm
He’s back.Where’d he go,looking for obese folk who eat junk food?
June 14, 2025 @ 6:32 pm
How dare you.
June 14, 2025 @ 5:44 pm
Basically,not-so-jolly Ollie remade “She Got The Gold Mine,I Got The Shaft” (one of my favourite songs,incidentally) for a 2025 audience so people will re-remember him. (Ollie looks something like the late wrestling manager John Jay [“Sir Oliver Humpderdink,””Big Daddy Dink,”] Sutton,whose most famous charge was the late WWE “Beast From the East,” Bam Bam Bigelow).
June 15, 2025 @ 12:02 pm
That dude wrestled the One Man Gang in like ’83.
June 14, 2025 @ 7:18 pm
Not a huge fan of this song so far, but enjoyed his “Richmond” song that made him famous.
But whatever, good for that dude. I suppose it’s probably pretty cool being a one-hit wonder, if you play your cards right you can set yourself up nice for life just based off one song. Then again, I’m sure an artist like this (or any musical artist) would want to prove it to themselves and the world that their success just wasn’t lightning in a bottle.
Back to the song, it just didn’t hit right for me. The “broke as a joke” line was a little cringe. But it’s not hard to figure out why a song like this would hit and stick…there are a lot of people that can think “hey, this song is about me.”
June 15, 2025 @ 5:27 am
“…there are a lot of people that can think “hey, this song is about me.””
Isn’t that what it’s all about?
June 14, 2025 @ 8:54 pm
His vocals are great: he sings with a conviction few others do. Instrumentation and production work well also. However, the melody sucks; it feels very awkward. Lyrics could be better too.
June 14, 2025 @ 9:13 pm
I just want to say that I like saving country music a lot more now that I’m reading in the comments that you guys agree this is a bad song.
June 15, 2025 @ 8:56 am
Sadly, “Rich Men North of Richmond” got caught up in the political swamp of the internet to actually be fairly critiqued for the mediocre (at best) songwriting it was.
I said it when that song came out and have seen no evidence to the contrary. Oliver Anthony *could* be a good songwriter. He just badly, badly, badly needs an experienced hand to check his bad ideas/lines and amplify the good ones.
But he seems content to not go down that path, instead continuing to churn out amateurish efforts like the song above while his diehard fans become convinced that anyone critiquing him is some loony liberal.
June 15, 2025 @ 3:48 am
…the times are almost crying out for rock – and one of the most unlikely performers on the planet got a whiff of that call, with all the benefit of the doubt existing of course. then again, he did a stunt like that before. need some oreos to think this new miracle over.
June 15, 2025 @ 12:05 pm
He is clearly ripping off Shaman’s Blues by the Doors
June 15, 2025 @ 5:43 am
“ONE-hot wonder?” I’m a NO-hit wonder !!!!!!!!!!
June 15, 2025 @ 5:46 am
We don’t have fudge rounds in Windsor,Ont.,Can.,across the order from Detroit,Mich.,where my mother was born,but at a muscular,beefy 5’9″,193 lb.,if we had them here,I’d consume more than my share of them.(Of course,Ollie would likely body shame me,though I’ve got 17-inch arms…)
June 15, 2025 @ 12:06 pm
Go eat your Peek Freens, boy.
June 15, 2025 @ 6:30 am
I initially liked Rich Man as a song about the hard times of an average dude coming out of the COVID era. But then the whole jumping on of celebrities and politicians, and his own often weird reactions to the instant fame made Oliver into some cult hero/hated evil. I tried to be open minded about the musical future of a guy who may have just been barreled over by unexpected success, but wasn’t impressed with his debut last year.
I had pretty much written this guy off as a one hit wonder who seized his moment of fame as the hero of the little guy to survive a little bit longer. But I have to say I like this song. I think the instrumentation of the fiddle and guitar are well done. The song itself is enjoyable, and for once, the production doesn’t sound like it was recorded in someone’s basement.
Not sure if this is a step in the right direction, or just a blip in the weird tale of Oliver Anthony.
June 15, 2025 @ 12:08 pm
He is a creation out of Langley.
June 15, 2025 @ 2:22 pm
I know,Hank33,and I think Bam Bam beat the One Man Gang,the future Akeem the African (?) Dream.(I’m African-Canadian/American and Akeem was my nightmare,not my dream !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)
June 15, 2025 @ 2:25 pm
Peak Freans are OK,but I might give you my finishing move,the Brady Breaker,Hank 33!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
June 15, 2025 @ 7:36 pm
I guess nothing screams “authenticity” like the poorly played intro before his vocal started. Contrast that with the upper fret register guitar histrionics later in the song and the January 6 date in the title and you can color me a bit confused as to what statement he is trying to make, but he does sound legitimately pissed, and I can feel his pain. BTDT myself.
I’ll probably get rolled here for admitting I like his songs “Gotta get sober” and “90some Chevy”, and I think this song might not represent the best of his music (fiddle aside, that was burnin’ hot) but he doesn’t have big machine presence and marketing to filter his public image and as a result comes across as honest and flawed as pretty much any of the rest of us would. My personal preference is to listen to stuff like OA over most of the overproduced stuff that has the label “authenticity” and winds up being more Velvetta than cheese. It’s almost like he was a dog chasing a car and managed to catch it, and now he’s trying to figure out how to drive it two years later.
I wish him happiness and as much success as he wants. If he doesn’t care to cater to the masses or play the game, good for him, It’s the rare person that can sniff the brass ring and then not try to grab it, hopefully other people’s opinions about what he *should be* never influence him. If his music ultimately is something less than what the public wants, so be it.
We all have different ears, enjoying using yours.
June 16, 2025 @ 7:38 am
This tune seems under-cooked and over-emoted. Nothing new or interesting in it for me. I think this guy is more useful as a conversation piece about the times and the industry. He is also a social bell-weather, like asking who likes Jeeps in a group of strangers.
June 16, 2025 @ 10:14 am
He’s more like a social bed-wetter.
June 16, 2025 @ 8:47 am
I actually think this guy’s music is okay, but unfortunately he is kind of a moron. The songs just have a really weird convoluted message. Who can’t get behind raging against Rich Men North of Richmond? Except that somewhere is verse 2 or 3 we start punching down on food stamp recipients. It’s like wait, I thought we were raging against the rich here, I’m confused.
Similarly, in Rich Man’s Gold, off the album, I’m lovin the line about how I wasn’t born to just pay bills and die. Yes! Except that on a closer listen you hear that he is glorifying a way of life that has vanished, never to return. Sleeping on a dirt floor isn’t going to save you from the bills that will be piling up nowadays for anyone with 7 youngins and some old dogs. I mean I get the message of the song but but it’s like he accidentally just ends up glamorizing poverty.
His inability to be pinned down politically is because of his inability to think clearly about these issues. Most people who think it through can pick a side pretty easily
June 16, 2025 @ 4:40 pm
Sheeesh. Bunch of jealous songwriters in here I guess. Connection beats out “great” songwriting each and every time. Lotta songs missing that these days.
June 17, 2025 @ 1:48 am
Oh, great. Yet another tune in which Anthony complains about his (alleged) problems, fails to acknowledge his own culpability and shows zero evidence of self-examination, insight or growth.
If his story (demands for 60 percent of future earnings, etc.) is true — and I have my doubts — my response is, “Well, bud, *you* are the one who married her.”
Anthony is the perfect chronicler of contemporary toxic masculinity: All his problems are somebody else’s fault. If only folks would let him stay drunk or high and not take taxes out of the low wages he makes (because he’s constantly drunk or going off to smoke a bowl) then life would be ok. He’s had meteoric success in music and he’s still bitching about his life.
His soon-to-be ex is probably smart in getting out.
June 17, 2025 @ 1:58 pm
Why does everyone embellish what she’s asking for to make it sound as if it’s somehow unprecedented and unfounded? Everyone loves to say “Future Income” like it’s somehow some treasure trove that he will have coming. When a wife gets alimony and child support guess where that comes from? Most people just call that from the husband’s “Income”. Yes, money he makes after the divorce. He also has 3 kids and she was with him from when they were dirt poor in that camper and stayed with him. Courts will definitely grant her a large portion of that and the kids will get their share as well until they’re 18.
Also, if it’s true that he did his touring around the world while she stayed behind raising the newborn and 2 other kids in that camper is despicable. Anyone can easily look up online how much the booking agents were charging for each event he played and he definitely is cashing in on his success.
June 18, 2025 @ 11:20 pm
Played with him one time. Smelled like wet dogs.
June 19, 2025 @ 7:45 am
Heyday,Anthony is the poster boy for stupid MAGA manhood.
June 19, 2025 @ 7:46 am
I’m sick of the lauding of “the average man.” Most have below-average looks and intelligence.
June 19, 2025 @ 7:49 am
Wouldn’t shock me if Ollie wets the bed,Hank33.