50 Years Ago: George Jones is Ahead of His Time Addressing PTSD with “The Door”

Sometimes when sifting through the volumes of old country songs, you’re left outright stunned by the depth and foresight some of them include. The beauty of country music is often found in its simplicity and plainspoken nature. It’s not trying to save the world. It’s simply trying to speak to everyday feelings and struggles. But some country songs go far beyond that, to touch on much deeper things, or ultimately prove to be ahead of their time.
In 1974, George Jones was enjoying a resurgence of interest in his career. After years of his demons getting in the way of his success, he finally achieved a #1 song in partnership with producer Billy Sherrill with the heartbreaking tune “The Grand Tour” (read more). It was George’s first #1 song in seven years, and reminded country listeners what an incredible singer George Jones was.
Jones followed up the success of “The Grand Tour” with the song “The Door” that was written by Billy Sherrill and songwriter/performer Norro Wilson, who was also one of the co-writers on “The Grand Tour.” “The Door” really is not like any other country song you can find, certainly not in the catalog of George Jones, but especially not in country music in 1974. It touched on things people just didn’t talk about in country music at the time.
“The Door” tells the story of a former soldier suffering from what today would be called PTSD, or Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. But that disorder would not even be officially defined for another six years, and was decades away from being a term recognized in common parlance. “Shell shock” was the term some gave when bangs and loud noises like a door slamming could rattle former soldiers. But really, people weren’t talking about the toll on mental health that war took on soldiers at all.
On September 5th, 1974, George Jones recorded “The Door” at Nashville’s Columbia Studios. In the song, the soldier recalls how his experiences of war haunt his memories.
The awful sound of a thousand bombs exploding
And I wondered if I could take it anymore
There were times when they almost drove me crazy
But I did my best and took it like a man
It’s important to point out that George Jones himself enlisted in the United States Marine Corps in 1951, and served until 1953. Though it doesn’t appear Jones ever saw combat himself, this was during the Korean War and in the aftermath of WW2 when he would have known many who did.
It’s probably a stretch to say that “The Door” was “controversial.” Unlike other risque songs of the era such as Loretta Lynn’s “The Pill” or Conway Twitty’s “I Can Tell You’ve Never Been This Far Before,” it wasn’t “banned” by some radio stations. But “The Door” certainly made some country listeners and DJs feel uncomfortable. You weren’t supposed to talk about the ravages of war at that time.
“I don’t think it quite got to the whole entire public because of the type of song that it was,” Jones said later. “It was a number one song, but…a lot of it was about the [Vietnam] war…It was the type of song people didn’t wanna really talk about that much.”
But what allowed the song to still make it to #1 is that just like so many country songs, it was ultimately about heartbreak. This is how songwriters Billy Sherrill and Norro Wilson were able to slip in a deeper discussion. The closing of the door by the narrator’s lover is compared to the sounds of war, but ultimately considered even worse. Billy Sherrill recorded his own office door closing to create the door closing sound effect featured in the song.
But most paramount to the song’s success was the voice of George Jones. Nobody could put as much pain behind a performance, and make you believe it was so sincere and straight from the heart like The Possum. Anyone considering criticizing the song had to concede that George Jones singing it was country music mastery. “The Door” remains one of George’s greatest performances of his career, right up there with “The Grand Tour” and “He Stopped Loving Her Today.”
Of course these days, society is much more open to speaking about PTSD, especially for our combat Veterans. We understand what the ravages of war can do to good people’s psyche and personal lives. If anything, at times modern country music has turned exploitative of the “support the troops” narrative. It’s become a trope. But when George Jones, Billy Sherrill, and Norro Wilson broached the subject, it was bold and revolutionary.
What’s great about “The Door” is that the story and writing still hold up, even if the Billy Sherrill Countrypolitan string arrangements will feel stuffy and outdated to most modern country fans. “The Door” was dramatically ahead of its time, and has withstood the test of time as one George Jones’s and country music’s greatest compositions.
September 5, 2024 @ 10:15 am
RUBY, written by Mel Tillis would be in the same vein?
That song is a killer.
September 5, 2024 @ 10:32 am
That’s another good example, though it’s not really addressing PTSD as much as an injured Veteran. A lot of folks overlook that Waylon Jennings was the first to record that song in 1966, though most known it from The First Edition with Kenny Rogers as the lead singer before he officially went country. At that time, it was considered more of a folk/pop song, though looking back, it did chart at #39 in country.
September 5, 2024 @ 11:20 am
Waylon was first to record Ruby, Don’t Take Your Love To Town in Sept. 1966. His version was just a couple of months ahead of recordings by Mel Tillis and Johnny Darrell. But only Darrell’s version was released as a single. It climbed to #9 on the Billboard Country survey in May 1967.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TQR_hR32e3M
The 1969 Kenny Rogers & The First Edition version has an uneven country chart history. Although it was a #6 hit on the Billboard Hot 100 pop survey, the single only peaked at #39 on the Billboard Country chart. However the song performed much better on the Cashbox Country Top 60 survey climbing to #5.
September 5, 2024 @ 10:40 am
I played The Door on the radio during it’s chart run in 1974/75. Like his previous solo single The Grand Tour, this recording was also very well-received by country listeners. The PTSD connection that you mention was really not on anybody’s radar in 1974. The record was primarily perceived as yet another George Jones “heartbreak” song. I don’t recall it being analyzed to the extent that you have regarding the battle imagery. Cannot disagree with your analysis, but your perspective is from 2024 not 1974. It was not viewed that way by most country listeners 50 years ago. I cannot recall any negativity from listeners or any controversy regarding the lyrics. It was just another great George Jones record that received a ton of airplay and became a #1 hit. To my knowledge the song was never banned anywhere.
I classify this song, along with many other Jones’ classics, as “a sorry SOB” song. That is a song about a guy that through his own actions or negligence drove away the greatest love of his life and often his family too. Vintage country music overflows with that fertile topic.
September 5, 2024 @ 11:41 am
Thanks for the insight Country DJ.
I thought I went out of my way in the article to explain that it was NOT a “controversial” song, and how it was not “banned.” And I agree that I am bringing a 2024 perspective to a 1974 song, but that’s sort of the whole point of a retrospective.
All that said, the reason I included the quote from George Jones is because Jones himself saw the subject matter as “touchy” at the least, and thought the war references in the song held it back from being as big of a hit as it could have been otherwise.
September 5, 2024 @ 12:38 pm
@countrydj
I agree. “The Door” was seen at the time as much about PTSD as Loretta’s “Fist City” was about PMS.
Or “A Boy Named Sue” was about gender fluidity; or the Beatles’ “Run For Your Life” was about domestic violence.
“The Door” was in the vein as “The Grand Tour”–which was Jones’s preceding single.
September 5, 2024 @ 1:14 pm
That’s kind of my whole point though.
“‘The Door’ tells the story of a former soldier suffering from what today would be called PTSD, or Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. But that disorder would not even be officially defined for another six years, and was decades away from being a term recognized in common parlance. “Shell shock” was the term some gave when bangs and loud noises like a door slamming could rattle former soldiers. But really, people weren’t talking about the toll on mental health that war took on soldiers at all.”
September 5, 2024 @ 2:20 pm
I had to re-listen to “The Door.” I had not heard it in years and, truthfully, I did not remember that it was about a soldier. I think the song is aboout a guy who’s pining over being dumped by a spouse/lover, like a substantial number of country songs, from “Walking the Floor” to Jones’s previous single, “The Grand Tour.” I think most listeners take the part about him being a soldier as metaphoric.
“Ruby, Don’t Take Your Love to Town” comes off as much more literal.
September 5, 2024 @ 3:03 pm
I think the references to being a solider from the perspective of the song’s character are completely literal. And I agree (as I said in the article) that it ultimately boils down to a song about heartbreak. But I also think that the characters experience as a solider is where the story builds from. I mean, if you read the lyrics, that’s pretty clear. We all can interpret songs differently and that’s cool. But I think you would have a very difficult time arguing that the song is not about a solider suffering from what we refer to today as PTSD.
September 6, 2024 @ 8:06 am
“But I think you would have a very difficult time arguing that the song is not about a solider suffering from what we refer to today as PTSD.”
Trig, i couldn’t agree more.
“Shell shock” was the term some gave when bangs and loud noises like a door slamming could rattle former soldiers.”
Had a flashbang explode at feet while on maneuvers. Ripped gas mask off, so could get at some clear air. Was pissed as all get out.
Answer to the flashbang, was to take the First sergeant out.
Powder burned him. Then radioed that Top was out. No matter what he did, he was dead to our team.
Took a few years to get rid of the entire sensation of that nifty little experience.
But the tinnitus goes on.
September 5, 2024 @ 3:03 pm
Nobody is trying to make this song political.
September 6, 2024 @ 6:26 am
What I think “The Door” and other songs like this that deal with what soldiers are placed into a war, regardless of how one feels politically about that war, is that none of them ever come back home the same way they left, providing they even come back physically alive to begin with. Anyone who is the offspring of a soldier who has seen war (my father was in two extremely divisive wars, Korea and Vietnam) can attest to this.
And just on the level of “The Door” as a song, it’s interesting that the subject matter might have caused some people a bit of discomfort. The country music genre is often said to be about “three chords and the truth”, which is all good and fine when it comes to the three chords part. But the Truth part is a little stickier, because we tend to think of soldiers as gung-ho tough guys, when they are all just as human (if not more so) as the rest of us.
September 5, 2024 @ 10:48 am
Another great song on this topic, though slightly newer and more rock than country, is Charlie Daniels “Still in Saigon”.
September 5, 2024 @ 5:13 pm
Yes, Still in Saigon is 100% without question about PTSD. Charlie got a lot of credit for addressing it head on in that song.
” that was ten long years ago and time has gone on by, now and then I catch myself, eyes searching thru the sky, all the sounds of long ago will be forever in my head, mingled with the woundeds cry and the silence of the dead…cause I’m still in Saigon, still in Saigon, in my mind.
I wasn’t aware the door was about PTSD. Perhaps it is. Agree with Country DJ it probably got thought of as a love gone wrong song with analogies to the war. But you make a decent case that Sherrill may have had that in mind. Thoughtful analysis.
September 5, 2024 @ 2:30 pm
Another sad “war” song, though not about PTSD, is Merle Haggard’s “I Wonder If They Ever Think of Me.”
September 5, 2024 @ 3:38 pm
Mamma bake a pie, daddy kill a chicken.
September 5, 2024 @ 6:36 pm
And, folks like them did a lot of clean livin’.
September 5, 2024 @ 5:05 pm
I had to go back and listen, it had been a while. I like the song but for me its low on the jones pedigree. I dont really get the ptsd angle with it. I get that the bombs bothered him while he served, metaphorically since jones i believe didnt actually see combat, but he didnt let it get to him then. But nowhere could i hear that it was still bothering him. It was jusr a woman leaving him which is bad enough but i dont see the ptsd stuff. But thats just my take.
September 6, 2024 @ 7:16 am
I think John Prine covered it pretty well in 1971 with Sam Stone.
September 6, 2024 @ 7:29 am
Jones the GOAT
September 6, 2024 @ 6:41 pm
what really strikes me beyond the insightful lyrics and prescient way to address an issue that had plagued vets throughout their lives, is how much he really does look like a possum
them beady little eyes staring at me, i feel like i am looking at a little fella on my porch, after dark.
he was a tortured genius and they dont make em like george, anymore
September 8, 2024 @ 1:57 pm
Sure this will be an unpopular opinion. It would have been hard for me to reflect on the lyrics without the attachment to this article because I would have not gotten to the end of the song. Not a fan of the strings, they made a sleepy song even more boring. Trig alluded to this above.
Also, disagree about the vocal, I don’t hear any pain. Seems like a flat delivery. Appreciate that this song is enjoyed by many on this site and it hits hard for them as well. Just not for me.