Album Review – Josh Abbott Band’s “Front Row Seat”
There’s something about being a Texan that makes you regard what happens in Texas as being the most important thing in the world. It’s the center of the universe, so to speak. For Texans at least.
So when Josh Abbott felt the need to pronounce his infidelity to the world in February of 2014, the little hamlets that harbor the support network for Texas music were sent reeling. The “why” and the “how” of Abbott’s announcement seemed to play right into the hands of some of his critics who say he’s sort of the Texas music drama queen and needs to be the center of attention at all times, even when announcing he cheated on his wife. It was good old-fashioned Texas music chili pot stirring of the highest order if there ever was one.
And here Saving Country Music was, recently declaring the video for Josh Abbott’s version of “I’ll Sing About Mine” the best of 2013 and specifically citing the values the song and video entailed, wondering if I should be feeling buyer’s remorse. Generally speaking, it’s not uncommon to hear about the average musician having a broken home life. What made Abbott’s situation so different was how public he’d decided to make it all, almost forcing fans to play the whole People Magazine gossip game.
Many months later, Josh Abbott announced a new album called Front Row Seat where it was said he would unflinchingly face his infidelity and the fallout in song, resulting in his most personal work to date. Yeah, okay. And compounding the concerns that Josh Abbott was parlaying his indiscretions into marketing copy and even more attention for himself was the fact that over his career he’s become the poster boy for how music doesn’t have to emanate from Music Row to be considered country pop. Abbott has been one of the kings of incorporating “sensibilities” into his softcore style of country. He’ll cut a song from one of the best songwriters in Texas on you, but the result will make sure he doesn’t ever have to worry about missing any car payments.
So all of this is the backdrop when Front Row Seat comes across the desk. Oh, and let’s not forget the unprecedented shift in 2015 for artists and bands sitting right around Josh Abbott’s shelf life that are all of a sudden are deciding it’s time to start running with the young dogs and begin cutting country EDM songs like his buds in the Eli Young Band. Shane McAnally’s name was also associated with the project, so who knows where it could lead.
Sometimes cynicism for a project going in can kill your chances of ever giving it a fair shake and finding something you enjoy, and other times it can set the table for being pleasantly surprised and connecting with music you otherwise thought you would never appreciate. In the case of Josh Abbott Band’s Front Row Seat, it was the latter. Though still very much the classic late night Saturday Cinemax version of country, it’s not too terrible.
Josh Abbott said this would be a very personal album, and this wasn’t just table talk. Segmented into five acts, Front Row Seat takes the listener on a journey through the various phases of human emotional development as it coincides with the courtship of the opposite sex. Each song is like a hue in the emotional spectrum, and though that means at times you move through the sort of adolescent-feeling or douchebag sectors that young adults invariably go through, the album touches on some very real emotions and moments that you can’t help feel are bred directly from Abbott’s near-term experiences and realizations.
Abbott set out a goal for himself to unburden his heart, and he does so. Aiding in this experience is really juicy melody and chorus development that will be too saccharine for most leathery-skinned country listeners, but for others will be ear candy.
Just as much as the depth Abbott pursues in this record is surprising, so is the re-connection to the country foundations of the band. While everyone else seems to be leaning on songs with drum machine opens and electronic accessorizing, Josh Abbott puts the banjo and fiddle right out front in Front Row Seat. Granted, they’re usually more texture than leading the charge or taking extended breaks, but that’s more within the established style of the Josh Abbott Band to begin with. Rock guitar still gets its licks in plenty, but the country-ness of this album was a bit surprising for the Abbott legacy.
Though Shane McAnally’s name is used as a big splash in the promotion of this record, he only shows up in ostensibly one song. It’s folks like Brent Cobb, Radney Foster, and William Clark Green who come in with assists for Josh Abbott’s songwriting. There are a lot of songwriters on this record, but a few of the songs are from Abbott himself, and even when they’re not, you feel his vision is still the impetus of what made it on tape.
The first two “acts” that comprise the first half of the record are very sumptuous in a sort of 2005 radio country manner. All of the first six songs could be singles. “Live It While You Got It” is like a late 90’s one hit wonder radio anthem, “Wasn’t That Drunk” explores how inhibitions in many ways are only clever illusions, and each song in the first half of this record has a lyrical hook that works devilishly well.
Moving to the second-half, this is when the heartbreak sets in, and the song “Born To Break Your Heart” really hits home. It wasn’t written by Abbott, but it slips right into the track list like the rest of the record was written around it.
One issue with Front Row Seat is it stretches out to 16 total tracks. You start to get tired of the same approach to virtually every song. It’s the same band, the same basic setup, and virtually every song sits down in the same mid-tempo section until your mind just starts to wander. This album could have used either some fat trimming or a little more spice. Abbott had a lot to say, but at some point you get tired of listening. And though the songwriting is solid, and the music is more country than you anticipate, this is still significantly within the borders of radio-friendly pop country, more aimed toward the girls who flock to the front of the stage at concerts as opposed to the folks listening for something more real than corporate radio offers.
But hey, hats off to Josh Abbott for having a vision, seeing it through, and accomplishing what he set out to do. Front Row Seat is Josh Abbott and The Josh Abbott Band pushing their limits, saying something, yet keeping within their realm of wanting to entertain fans first.
We can all sit back and second guess Josh Abbott’s judgements, actions, and indiscretions, but as he accurately portrays in this album, love and night life is not all the endless party represented in mainstream country. It’s a knock down, drag out fight that gets very lonely at times, very-emotionally charged in other instances, and tends to get the better of even the most emotionally-steeled individuals. Temptations lurk around every corner, the human brain is designed to trick itself and entice one into doing wrong for extra rewards of passion that we pay for negatively and in double fold for on the back end. We’re all emotional wrecks until we find someone else to latch onto and hold on for dear life, and even then there’s a 50/50 chance it all goes south at some point.
So we do our best, and sometimes music helps us get through it all.
1 1/4 of 2 Guns Up (6/10)
– – – – – – – – – – – –
November 9, 2015 @ 7:45 pm
So is Josh Abbot generally tolerable to be around or is all this rhetoric about him indicative of some bad character flaws? I generally like his music, but some of it is really bad too, like Hangin’ Around.
November 10, 2015 @ 9:30 am
I’ve had a few interactions with him at shows, (with multiple bands on the bill, definitely wasn’t there to see him) and I have some friends that have worked directly with him at venues n such here in San Marcos n New Braunfels. Hes not the worst person in the world, but generally he’s been a pretty big douchebag.
November 10, 2015 @ 12:18 pm
I’ve had a couple of personal encounters with the dude, usually had buddies that opened up for him and the like, and I’m going to second the generally a douchebag sentiment. Again, this is just personal anecdotes from less than a handful of times, so not Gospel by any means. And I do understand artists have their bad days just like the rest of us, however, common courtesy is not a stretch, no matter personal demeanor.
November 9, 2015 @ 7:51 pm
Are they still on Atlantic Records or are they going to stay on their own label?
November 9, 2015 @ 8:06 pm
This was released through Thirty Tigers, not Atlantic.
November 9, 2015 @ 8:12 pm
They left Atlantic Records.. Probably because Atlantic didn’t want to do a concept album with a new signee that deal with alcoholism, extra-marital affairs, and divorce.
November 9, 2015 @ 8:17 pm
Thanks Trig, I thought this was pretty fair. I’ve been listening to the album all day and thats basically what I felt about about it.. Coulda used more fiddle/pedal-steel, coulda used less rock guitar. But the sound was there. I felt like (instrumentally) the band got caught between making a more pop country record, and breaking off into Stapleton, Simpson, Isbell territory. At times I thought they were really pop sounding but other times I could kinda hear that grittier, more developed sound. I don’t know I felt like it just left something to be desired. I really enjoyed the second half of the album lyrically though.
November 9, 2015 @ 8:54 pm
I generally tend to hang around more of the Texas/Red Dirt sounds of Turnpike, Randy Rogers, Wade, Boland etc. and the Isbell, Sturgill and Stapleton sounds as well. But I’ll admit there’s some stuff by JAB that I’ve enjoyed. Not all of it but some. It’s kinda like at times they will be my guilty pleasure versus some mainstream act. I haven’t bought the album yet, but previewed the album and it seemed like it was not as bad as I feared. Most of it seems harmless. I’ve seen them live a few times and they always put on a good show and have always thought Josh has a good voice. I’ll admit as well that it’s the same for me with Casey Donahew. Another guilty pleasure with some of their stuff.
November 9, 2015 @ 9:41 pm
+1
Everyone around here loves to hate on JAB and Casey Donahew. They’re by no means the cream of the crop and definitely reside on the pop end of the country spectrum, but both make enjoyable music frequently enough. Not only enjoyable, but relatable as well.
It makes a nice compromise. The music appeals to mainstream listeners and offers something a little different from standard radio fare.
I think Donahew gets a lot of shit simply because a lot of the music isn’t serious. It’s light, fun, and sometimes funny.
I’m by no means a huge fan of either, but both have made enjoyable pop-country. I would certainly see either live if they came to my area (which will never happen).
November 10, 2015 @ 9:39 am
My wife was a fan of Abbott, and he frequents or town so I have seen him several times. I think the infidelity, plus seeing isbell and todd snider have kinda broken her of his nonsense. Having seen him several times I find the music Blah, nothing really stands out, that being said I don’t get anyone being into Donahue. Donahue to me is as bro country as anything on the radio.
November 10, 2015 @ 9:55 am
Bands like Donahew and Abbott get crap because much like Rich O’Toole everything they seem to do feels very calculated and rehearsed and “safe”. The kinda stick out like a sore thumb when you have a lot of the pillars of the “Red Dirt” scene preaching authenticity like Boland, Canada/The Departed, RRB, Bowen, LaRue, etc.
Then you have Abbott and Donahew and the bands/artists they inspire who just feel like they are completely manufactured.
November 10, 2015 @ 10:59 am
The problem I have with artists like Josh Abbott Band is people just looks at the name as opposed to listening to the music. “I’ll Sing About Mine” was an excellent song, and most of what I heard from people was “Josh Abbott sucks!” Well okay, but what about the song? And the response is “I heard his last album, and it sucks.” And my response is, “Well this wasn’t on that album,” and it goes on and on from there. Some people approach music like cheering for laundry in sports. Yes, Josh Abbott Band is more pop than the Turnpike Troubadours. Doesn’t mean they can’t do a good song. And specific to this album, they had a conceptualized approach, used some excellent songwriters, and I thought this was a step up from previous efforts.
I don’t review artists. I review albums and songs. I’m not sure a lot of folks get that.
November 10, 2015 @ 3:30 pm
I will check it out, I usually agree with most of what you like. He also has a great band, and a really good fiddle player. Did he write I’ll sing about mine??
November 10, 2015 @ 4:09 pm
I think Adam Hood wrote I’ll Sing About Mine
November 10, 2015 @ 4:13 pm
Adam Hood n Brian Keane wrote that one.
November 10, 2015 @ 6:22 pm
I gave this record a “1 1/4 Guns Up” grade. That means I’m not confident enough to try and convince anyone to buy it. However, I do think it’s better than the median of what else is out there. 1 3/4 and 2 Guns Up grades are the ones where I’m highly recommending folks purchase them.
November 9, 2015 @ 10:02 pm
Almost exactly how I feel, I like the duet he did with Kacey Musgraves.
November 9, 2015 @ 10:03 pm
Even if it’s on the poppier side of country, I think this album deserves at least a 7 or 8 because they don’t rap, there’s no R&B, and they actually have something to say besides beer and girls.
November 9, 2015 @ 10:32 pm
Great music and lyrics, but the vocals sound rather whiny, much like today’s typical male pop singer.
Maybe Wade Bowen and Randy Rogers could do a cover of these songs and make the vocals sound more country.
November 10, 2015 @ 8:05 am
Pop country is kind of like summer work beer. You’re hot, thirsty, and you want something cold that isn’t water or tea. I have a playlist of lighter weight stuff that I keep for when I’m running around in the truck with the family and this is a solid record for that playlist. It’s tuneful and Texas (khakis and ball caps Texas) and it’s relatively thoughtful. If radio country was stuff like this it wouldn’t be perfect but it would be a sight better than what it is.
Very fair review, right on the money imo.
November 10, 2015 @ 8:07 am
I’m a big JAB fan. But honestly, my hopes were not high for this record and they were more or less met. As Trig says, it is way too long. I get exhausted half way through thinking “Is this thing still going?” Especially with so many songs that frankly sound the same and have the same tempo. Maybe it is a grower, as many of the best records are. I haven’t given up on it. But so far my rating would be “meh.”
If you told me a week ago that Eric Church and JAB would release records on the same day and I would prefer the Eric Church, I would have told you you were crazy. But there it is.
November 10, 2015 @ 9:37 am
Pretty dull and insubstantial, but typical of the weaker Texas music. A lot of this type of music just runs together for me. It all sounds the same, and while its inoffensive, it doesn’t make any significant impact or forge any untrod earth. If it were on in the background, I wouldn’t have to drop what I was doing to change it. That is about the best that can be said for it. And like most of these types of albums, there are WAY too many loves songs to take it seriously or enjoy it.
November 10, 2015 @ 9:45 am
“Born to Break Your Heart” is a Dave Fenley song. Now there’s a guy who really brings it and could be a BIG deal in Stapleton’s wake.
November 10, 2015 @ 1:27 pm
Josh Abbott has gone down hill since the She’s Like Texas album. Used to love them but they’re just a bit too generic. They seem to have a college/high school feel.
November 11, 2015 @ 9:55 am
Half of the second one is ‘Keep Them Kisses Coming’. The other half is ‘Hard to Love’.
I hope Craig Campbell and Lee Brice got writing credits.
Mash Abbott
November 11, 2015 @ 6:54 pm
I have one of their cd’s “Small town family dream” and it was good and I would like to get this new cd and all of their cd’s.