Album Review – Lee Ann Womack’s “The Way I’m Livin'”
This isn’t just your average album release, or even your average album release from Lee Ann Womack. There’s a lot of moving parts involved here that make this album one to watch, and one to pay a little extra attention to. Lee Ann Womack has earned the listening public’s undivided attention already from her years of stellar contributions, but this one has a little more special meaning for Womack since it is her first release without a major label, and a release that helps rate of progress for both women and traditional country artists looking to revitalize their place to a wider audience.
The evolution of The Way I’m Livin’ was a little strange. Made with Lee Ann’s husband Frank Liddell (producer for Miranda Lambert, Eli Young Band, others), the album has been finished now for two years and just sitting on a shelf. While still signed with MCA Nashville, label head Luke Lewis told Lee Ann to make the album that she wanted, to pick the songs herself and not worry about any commercial concerns. And so that is what she did.
The choices of where to find songs to record in Nashville are endless, but Lee Ann took a unique approach, especially for an artist who has amassed as many industry trophies as she has over the years. Her litmus test was that the song had to be written with the intent of being performed by that writer. Think of the exact opposite of Music Row’s songwriting-by-committee approach. She wanted songs culled from inspiration. This resulted in Womack acquiring material from a list of artists that is mouth watering all to itself: Chris Knight, Bruce Robison, Hayes Carll, Brennen Leigh, and Mando Saenz just to name some of them. This isn’t a rundown of the songwriting credits from a major Nashville release, this is an All-Star guitar pull lineup in Austin, TX on a Saturday night.
“In the past, Merle and Willie and Hank would sing real lyrics about life,” Womack tells Dallas News. “But today’s Music Row records don’t talk about those subjects, at least not in a grownup way. That’s one reason all these songs spoke to me.”
And though The Way I’m Livin’ began on Music Row with a major label, that’s not where it ended up. After Womack wiggled her way out of her MCA Nashville contract, she ended up working with the independent bluegrass label Sugar Hill Records to finally release this album. Even though it might officially symbolize Lee Ann taking a step down from the top-tier level she’s enjoyed for most of her career, she seems perfectly fine with that. “Let’s face it. Award shows are not really about who was best,” Womack continues to Dallas News. “They’re about selling advertising. I’m grateful for the awards I have, but if you came to our house, you’re not going to see any of them out. You’re gonna see guitars and music everywhere, but not awards or platinum records on the wall.”
This is still Lee Ann Womack though, and don’t think the industry isn’t paying close attention. That voice is too powerful, and her fans are too loyal to ignore. The title track off this album was the very first single to be added to Cumulus Media’s NASH Icon network as an example of new music from a seasoned artist that the new radio format boasts as wanting to champion. Lee Ann Womack hasn’t been put out to pasture by any stretch. She’s the female that is leading the pack of artists left behind by country radio and trying to revitalize the market for more classic-sounding country, and The Way I’m Livin’ is just the album to do it with both country roots and relevancy embedded in its songs, and a salivating public who’s waited six years for new, original music from the singer.
Recorded mostly live, The Way I’m Livin’ pins its eye to Lee Ann’s voice as its focal point, and never strays. You hear this emphasis immediately on the very first track “Prelude: Fly,” which leaves you inspired and primed for what lies ahead. The Way I’m Livin’ pulls from two primary influences: traditional country marked with loud and present steel guitar, and a more progressive “Americana” approach that has a lot of gospel and blues textures intermixed with a rootsy feel. God and Mammon are at war in The Way I’m Livin’ for the soul of the song’s protagonists more often than not, and though it would be a misnomer to label it a concept album, this battle is a recurring theme of the album, and one that illustrates the more true reality of things where good and evil are not always polar opposites separated by tremendous space, but side by side separated only by a thin membrane that temptation is always trying to pull you across.
This eternal pull and tug gives The Way I’m Living a vitality, whether it is portrayed in a gospel tradition like the song “All His Saints,” a more grounded atmosphere like in her take on Hayes Carll’s “Chances Are,” or the traditional country, folklore-style approach like on Brennen Leigh’s “Sleeping With The Devil.” These are story songs one after another filled with internal strife, and the arrangement present on The Way I’m Livin’ is truly masterful one track after another. There’s both a sparsity, and a robust presence to the instrumentation that makes sure nothing suffocates, and everything soars. There’s not a lot of layering that goes on here. You have your primary instruments only, and if there’s anything diverting your attention from Lee Ann’s voice, it is a singular lead instrument, usually a steel guitar set high in the mix that eventually gives way once again to Lee Ann. The song “Nightwind” isolates Lee Ann’s voice once again, and never on this album do you feel as if doubt or indecision filled what direction this record should take.
The Way I’m Livin‘s true country songs are slightly more backloaded towards the end of the project, but no matter where you start this album, it’s hard not to land on something to like. A few of the tracks came across as a little bit sleepy towards the center, and initially I was concerned that the song “Don’t Listen to the Wind” borrowed too much of the melody from the song “All My Tears” from Emmylou Harris’s Wrecking Ball album until I deduced both songs were written by Julie Miller.
Lee Ann Womack seems almost ethereal at this point in her career: timeless, and like an apparition of authentic country music who drifts above the rest of the genre’s singers and pickers as they slave away at their little songs and albums and daily deeds and dilemmas. Yet she still has that endearing element of the small town girl at home in the Texas pines, simply wanting to make a career out of what she would be doing if nobody was listening or watching. She’s an artist who has the freedom to truly do what she wants, while she still enjoys the attention of the industry, however muted it might be these days.
There may be a few more albums that are better than The Way I’m Livin’ that will be released this year, but none that are this good that will reach as many ears. Lee Ann Womack is a heavyweight for women, for hard country, and now for independent artists, and with this Sugar Hill release she releases and lands a haymaker.
1 3/4 of 2 Guns Up.
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
September 23, 2014 @ 11:45 am
I was excited for this album and when I saw that the video for “The Way I’m Livin” was released I immediately watched it. I made it a bit over a minute and shut it down. Not to her fault but the fascination of the devil in the underground in recent years makes me cringe when I hear it mentioned in any song these days. I do the same thing when I hear Outlaw or eff Pop Country. All of the above are key words that make me not want to listen.
September 23, 2014 @ 1:02 pm
Lyricists have been writing about the dark side of life since the first note was sounded. I’m puzzled why someone would limit their music repertoire to sunny side lyrics only. They are missing 1/2 of life and some truly great music, especially within the country genre.
September 23, 2014 @ 1:57 pm
I’m fully aware of the darker side of lyrics. Let me elaborate why I feel the way that I do. With this song in particular I had just read a post by Sugar Hill saying she had returned to her roots so I wanted to give it a try. Within a minute the topic of the devil was going on and to be honest I immediately thought of what has happened in the underground in the last few years where every song is about or the band name is about the devil this or outlaw that. I’m just tired of it.. Not to mention I found it predictable and not really creative at all.
September 23, 2014 @ 2:31 pm
Yeah, I totally agree with you about that underground assessment, but that’s not what’s going on here whatsoever. I would say what’s going on here is almost the exact opposite in some respect.
September 24, 2014 @ 8:16 am
In all fairness I need to quit being hard headed and give it a listen and I will do just that. I think I am a prime example to prove your point as to why this should not have been the first single. I think I have grown a bit bitter due to what has happened in the last few years in the underground scene and I have let it get in the way of finding good new music.
September 23, 2014 @ 1:19 pm
It is my opinion that both the song and video for “The Way I’m Livin'” do not represent this album either well or accurately, and honestly I have been frustrated from the beginning that this was the song released as a single. That’s one of the reasons that I did not include the video for the song here, and I would have included a different song if one was available. I wouldn’t use that to judge this album whatsoever.
September 23, 2014 @ 1:53 pm
It didn’t make me hit the stop button, but yea – when the first words I hear are “Met the devil on the side of the road” all I could think was, “Great! Another cliche’ pile of crap like almost every other album that’s come out in the last decade.”
Beyond that though, not a bad song – not a great song. Hopefully that was the token cliche’ for the album, but I have a feeling it won’t be…
I was never a huge Womack fan to begin with, but I’ll try to listen to the whole album tonight. I don’t do reviews, but I’ll count cliches and report back. 😀
September 23, 2014 @ 7:47 pm
I wish there wasn’t a video for the title track. It was so unnecessary.
September 23, 2014 @ 12:00 pm
They’ve put “The Way I’m Livin'” into rotation on the local station I listen to, which really surprised me when I heard it (and loved it). The numb nuts DJ actually said that when he first heard it he didn’t think it had a place on country radio. WTF? What a nice reprieve from Luke and FGL.
September 23, 2014 @ 12:30 pm
Stories like this are why this album is much more important than the music itself. We may look back at this album as when seasoned artists and traditional country started making its comeback on American radio.
September 23, 2014 @ 12:11 pm
Chris Knight, Bruce Robison, Hayes Carll, Brennen Leigh, and Mando Saenz
I know LAW has recorded a couple of Bruce Robison songs on previous albums; she’s also drawn from the likes of Rodney Crowell and Buddy and Julie Miller.
This looks quite promising.
September 23, 2014 @ 12:30 pm
I heard her perform Hayes Carll’s “chances are” on The Marty Staurt Show. What a great version of that tune. The samples I heard of the other songs on I tunes were all great. Looking foward to hearing the whole record.
September 23, 2014 @ 12:51 pm
This album is really good. Like Trigger stated in the review, the song material is an interesting mix of traditional country and hard-hitting Americana. Some of the tracks like “Don’t Listen to the Wind,” and “The Way I’m Livin” have a real bite and intensity to them.
I think this is a pivotal moment in LAW’s career. We all know that some mainstream artists who’ve passed their commercial primes continue to chase the spotlight by adopting trendy songs and productions styles, some disappear off the map entirely, and some take the opportunity to work on new projects that will contribute to their artistic legacies. With this album, Lee Ann Womack comes down decisively in the latter camp, and the country music world is better off for it.
September 23, 2014 @ 12:59 pm
Even though I was very turned off by “I Hope You Dance” being heavily played on the radio, I may give this one a chance in the future because it’ll be a good idea to get away from the current radio climate.
September 23, 2014 @ 1:54 pm
The song “I Hope You Dance” is unquestionably the most overrated thing LAW ever recorded, but the rest of that album looks pretty promising, at least on paper. I really, really liked her renditions of “Lord I Hope This Day Is Good” and “Does My Ring Burn Your Finger,” and “Stronger Than I Am” is a great song too.
September 24, 2014 @ 4:19 am
I would probably buy every version of ‘Lord I Hope This Day Is Good’ that was ever recorded, or ever will be.
World’s most un-fuck-uppable song, ever? Probably.
Good on ya, Dave Hanner.
Loves me some LAW!
September 25, 2014 @ 1:10 am
Since you brought of Dave Hanner, Corbin & Hanner just had their last concert here in Pittsburgh last month – they retired. For those who don’t know, C&H are credited with writing 8 top five country singles (3 major Alabama hits) among recording their own albums. And probably the most annoying song I woke up to every morning as a kid while going to school …. “Work Song.”
If Trig allows, here’s a nice write up about the boys calling it quits….
http://triblive.com/aande/music/6501887-74/corbin-hanner-says#axzz3EJRORJCw
September 24, 2014 @ 7:06 am
People forget her “Mendocino County Line” duet with Willie in 2002 which was: (1) a good song, (2) a Grammy winner, and (3) Willie’s only Top 40 song in the last 25 years or so.
She’s pushed the adult contemporary/pop border, but in that light “I Hope You Dance” is actually not too bad. I thought she was awesome after I saw her open for George Strait in the early 2000s.
September 23, 2014 @ 1:22 pm
The Wall Street Journal site had a stream of this last week, and I checked it out on a whim. Besides the title cut, I was especially partial to “Same Kind of Different,” “Tomorrow Night in Baltimore,” the lovely closer “When I Come Around,” and the cover of “Not Forgotten You” (much as I like the version recorded by Kelly Willis in the late ’90s, I’d say LAW’s is just as good). 🙂
September 23, 2014 @ 8:02 pm
Kelly Willis’ album, “What I Deserve,” is one of the most underrated albums! For me, it was my intro to alt-country and paved the way for my love of artists like the Old 97’s, Wilco, and Whiskeytown … way back in 1999 (unbelievable)!
This is the second track from the that album (penned by her husband Bruce Robison) recored by a major country artist. George Strait had a minor hit with “Wrapped” back in 2006. That’s crazy! But in both cases, I prefer the original.
September 23, 2014 @ 2:03 pm
I’ve got the whole album playing right now, and my only questions are:
Does Nashville just have the one Auto-Tune machine? And can they not afford to have it calibrated every few albums?
5 writers. 12 musicians. 1 broken auto-tune machine. I think I’m done with Nashville recordings. They’re kind of like the Monsanto of the recording industry. No natural ingredients.
September 23, 2014 @ 2:06 pm
I DO have to give credit though for not drowning the album under that Trashville hiss that gets passed off as instrumentation on most of their albums. You can actually pick out real instruments on this! AND – it’s not compressed to death!
Now just get rid of that god damn auto-tune…
September 23, 2014 @ 3:46 pm
I consider myself extremely sensitive to Auto-tune use. I pick up on it constantly on commercial recordings, even though I don’t bother complaining about it anymore since most people just think I’m imagining things when I mention it. 🙂 The vocals on this album, however, sound refreshingly natural to me. Lee Ann is a strong singer with a natural vibrato (the type of singer that used to be common in mainstream popular music), but the one thing her vocals on this album lack is the eerily “perfect” quality characteristic of even subtly altered vocal recordings. In other words, she actually sounds human, which is as it should be!
September 24, 2014 @ 9:15 pm
I’m surprised anyone mentioned auto-tune. I doubt there’s any on this and I don’t hear it so if there is it must be very minimal. I don’t see how you could think it’s annoying. Like most female country singers, Lee Ann does not need auto-tune, she’s one of the best singers and isn’t going pop so why would she use it? As much as I hate auto-tune I’m ok with a very small amount, so small you can’t hear it and it doesn’t make the singer sound unnatural or droning. It’s better to do another take or not than use auto-tune though.
September 23, 2014 @ 2:09 pm
I’m not hearing any Auto-Tune on this album whatsoever. Not saying it isn’t there, but I certainly would call it as obvious to an ear that especially recently has become very sensitive in picking it up. Lee Ann is one of the greatest singers of our generation. It still is possible for some artists to sing on tune, even though the top of Top 40 radio would lead you to believe otherwise.
September 23, 2014 @ 2:47 pm
I have no idea what you’re referring to. Sounds like Lee Ann’s natural voice to me.
September 23, 2014 @ 5:18 pm
In my opinion, the following are the main reasons why “The Way I’m Livin'” falls short of being a great album.
1. At times, it feels like a covers album. The average Womack fan may not recognize some of these songs, but many were included on major releases. Although it’s neat to hear Womack’s good interpretations, in a few weeks I’ll just go back to the originals.
2. It’s more Americana than Country. I feel Americana is were country music artists go to retire after their artistic spirit has dimmed and their edges have rounded.
September 23, 2014 @ 6:28 pm
I haven’t heard the album yet, but I’m looking forward to hearing it ”“ Specifically “Same Kind Of Different” which was penned by Adam Hood. I’m also interested in hearing her take on “Chances Are” since that’s one of my favorite Hayes Carll tracks. I liked the first single in comparison to the current landscape of country radio.
September 23, 2014 @ 8:10 pm
I’ll be interested in hearing your take on Womack’s version of “Chances Are.” I love Carll’s version, too. Although LAW sings the hell out of the song, it’s missing that lonesome desperation that’s in Carll’s voice and that serenading spanish guitar.
September 23, 2014 @ 6:48 pm
I was very confused when Womack was playing on SiriusXMOutlaw, yesterday.
September 23, 2014 @ 7:03 pm
Which is the Chris Knight cut here? Can someone post the writers/songs please? I don’t see any merit to the talk of the title track being cliched at all, she sounds good.
September 23, 2014 @ 7:14 pm
The Chris Knight cut is “Send It On Down” (track 5). 🙂 As for the rest (according to allmusic.com):
1. Fly (Brent Cobb / Reed Foehl)
2. All His Saints (Mindy Smith)
3. Chances Are (Hayes Caril)
4. The Way I’m Livin’ (Adam Wright)
6. Don’t Listen to the Wind (Julie Miller)
7. Same Kind of Different (Natalie Hemby / Adam Hood)
8. Out on the Weekend (Neil Young)
9. Nightwind & 11. Not Forgotten You (Bruce Robison)
10. Sleeping With the Devil (Brennen Leigh)
12. Tomorrow Night in Baltimore (Kenny Price)
13. When I Come Around (Mando Saenz)
September 24, 2014 @ 8:20 pm
Where are the weak vocals, auto-tune, synthesized pop music, and checklist lyrics? 😉 This is perfect and should be a frontrunner for Saving Country Music Album of the Year.
September 25, 2014 @ 4:54 pm
I’m a huge LAW fan . Short and sweet – VERY disappointed in this effort from her . It feels amateurish…it sounds like a lazy effort musically and man if this collection of material is what LAW considers to be the best stuff she can find I hope another label throws her a lifeline and a better set of headphones .
LOVE LAW’s vocals….not so with this particular CD.
September 27, 2014 @ 12:28 pm
What a beautifully written article! 1 and 3/4 is justified – I adore this album, minus ‘Out on The Weekend’ (I think this is where that mid-album slouch you mentioned occurs) and the production on ‘Tomorrow Night in Baltimore’.
‘Send It on Down’ stopped me dead in my tracks when I heard it.
September 28, 2014 @ 10:53 am
This is an album I will not buy, simply because of the annoying title track. She’s not a bad girl, and hearing her sing about walking with the devil is absurd. “if I ever get to heaven it’s a doggone shame” is just jibberish and bad english, words forced together because they rhyme.
Not a fan of her anyway, always thought she was wise though for ripping off Dollys act.
November 2, 2014 @ 9:00 am
She’s saying she sold her soul to the Devil lol.