Album Review – “Lifers” By Cody Jinks
True country fans don’t need to be told that trying to hold onto the roots of the music has been a war of attrition over the last 20 years or so. As more legends and oldtimers pass away or get put out to pasture each season—and so often it seems the promising young names who are coming up through the ranks inevitably veer away from their original country sound—you search for stability and glimmers of promise as the heap of shoes to fill of the artists gone by continues to grow.
Over the last few years though, a strong contingent of country musicians whose fortitude is unquestionable and uncompromising have come together to form a nucleus of true country music for a new generation. They come from diverse and sometimes unusual backgrounds, but they’re all united by the purpose of keeping the music “real,” and not just as a marketing slogan.
On the surface, Flint, Michigan does not sound like a proving ground for a modern honky tonk hero, but that’s exactly what Whitey Morgan has become. At one point Sunny Sweeney was signed right beside Taylor Swift to Big Machine Records, and now she is a mother hen of hard Texas country. Ward Davis was a songwriter from Arkansas who had Willie and Merle cut one of his tunes, and has since turned into a strong performer to tussle with all his own.
And they’re all being managed by a man named Arthur Penhallow, whose stable at True Grit Management is becoming a good place to point your nose when looking for great country music, just like how Dave Cobb’s name emerged a few years ago as a common tie among many of the most promising voices and projects coming to the forefront in independent country. You can even put Canadian folk singer Colter Wall as a cousin to this cadre who are trying to build their own and industry apart from Nashville or Texas, even playing together this August at their own festival.
And at the forefront of this movement, and helping to shake things up in the country music space by posting swelling numbers like Sturgill Simpson, Jason Isbell, and Chris Stapleton did before him is Cody Jinks. He is the franchise of the current roots music insurgencency, and one who is untarnished by outside influences or swayed by wayward trajectories, regardless of his early experimenting with heavy metal before he found his righteous country music path. Now signed with Rounder Records, the latest release Lifers very well may be the moment that puts him over the top, foisting him from the looming periphery of independent artists lapping at the sides of the mainstream industry like annoying chop, to crashing over the bows like a tidal wave.
Lifers might not be the best record Cody Jinks has ever released, but that’s more a testament to the stout competition Cody has created for himself over his career, making such a feat difficult to impossible to attain. However Lifers might be the record best suited to introduce Cody Jinks to the hungry masses of country music fans looking for something authentic in an increasingly plastic and unfulfilling industry. It has the right combination of easy and amiable tunes to perk the ears of everyday listeners, while also delivering some of the more deep efforts Cody Jinks has forged his name around with his devoted fans.
Some artists build their careers behind major marketing campaigns or riding the wave of some short-term trend. Cody Jinks has build his momentum by singing songs that seem to be direct recitations of the lives of his supporters. His appeal to the self-proclaimed “flockers” is not that he stands on a stage and commands a superhero status, it’s that he feels just like one of them who happens to be the man in the middle of the spotlight. This is blue collar music, and not in the pandering way the mainstream handles such business, but in a way that fills the audience with meaning, self-worth, and assurance as individuals with strong backbones, worthy convictions, and value.
And it’s country, unquestionably. Cody’s career has never been dogged by questions about the authenticity of his voice, or concerns that his compositions could be considered more rock than country. The music of Cody Jinks is straight down the middle, but with its own unique character and wrinkles where it’s not a reenactment of anything. It’s true country music in the modern context, and his dedication to the music is what has led to the undying loyalty of true country fans.
Early songs from the album like the Josh Morningstar-penned “Must Be The Whiskey” and “Lifers” had some worried this record might be a little light on heavy material, but such is the head space some fans will get themselves into when a record is so highly-anticipated. “Must Be The Whiskey” is a grower for sure, and smart as a lead track. The third song released from the album, “Somewhere Between I Love You and I’m Leavin’ ” showed the slower, more touching side of Cody Jinks that we knew would emerge on the record once heard it in full.
Looking for deeper material, you also come across “Colorado” co-written with Ward Davis, and it doesn’t get much tear-jerking than the Billy Don Burns-penned “Stranger,” which was so highly regarded by Saving Country Music back in 2012 when Burns cut it himself, it became the Song of the Year. The Jinks version is respectful to the original, and most importantly, will serve the song to a greater audience. Then depending you speak to, the folksy and reminiscent “Head Case” that finishes that album might be the best of Cody’s career.
My heroes are all dying, or they’re sitting in a cell
Through the years of medicating minds that hurt so well
There’s a thin line don’t you see, between genius and insanity
Which am I?
There are a few tracks you may find yourself skipping over on Lifers, like the fun but mild “Big Last Name,” or the meandering “Desert Wind.” But the big expectations that precede a record like this are pretty well fulfilled by the end, while Cody’s worth is enhanced once again with songs and performances that reassure the opinions that he’s one of preeminent true country performers of our time.
The annals of country music are peppered with entries on folks who poked their head into the genre for a few years before deciding to jump ship or switch styles. But the folks who dedicated their lives to the music are the ones that history remembers most fondly, and receive their name in headers of chapters, helping to mark the guideposts of the music’s chronological eras. They’re the “Lifers,” who just like the people they sing for, take pride in their unwavering commitment to plying a trade behind a purpose, and the craftsmanship and heart they put into those efforts, knowing the music and its lineage will always be bigger than them, their work will be rewarded and judged most harshly in hindsight, and that country music holds no guarantee of sustaining into the future unless someone is willing to pick up the yoke left by their predecessors, and get to work.
8.5/10
– – – – – – – – – – – – –
tucker33585
July 27, 2018 @ 8:35 am
I have to disagree on Desert Wind. I think it is one of the best tracks on the album
sbach66
July 27, 2018 @ 8:44 am
Yeah, I think I liked it more than Trig as well. You just don’t hear that kind of country & western song anymore.
Rob
July 27, 2018 @ 10:58 am
It immediately struck me as one of my favorites from the album, if not my favorite. Could see Marty Robbins singing it, it’s a great western themed song that we don’t see much anymore. But that’s the great thing about an album like this, when a song like “Desert Wind” could actually be seen as a relatively weaker track to somebody in comparison to the music that surrounds it.
Eden
July 27, 2018 @ 11:32 am
Desert Wind definitely reminded me of Marty Robbins!
Bo Fiddley
July 27, 2018 @ 5:43 pm
Count me as one who immediately thought of Marty Robbins when I first heard it.
Montanaman
July 30, 2018 @ 8:16 am
Glad I scrolled down before replying to Tucker. You described exactly how I felt from the first few seconds of hearing the song for the first time. That’s it reminds many of Marty Robbins is NOT a bad thing
LawDog
August 3, 2018 @ 5:54 am
I like the Marty Robbins aspect…I didn’t even think of that. What it reminded me of was more of a Jim Morrison (Doors) song. It made me think Jinks was pulling from his rock roots a little…
karl
July 27, 2018 @ 12:17 pm
It caught my attention, as well. I really think it’s in the top two or three songs here.
H.P. @ Hillbilly Highways
July 28, 2018 @ 10:01 am
Me too. I’m a big fan of Desert Wind, maybe my favorite song from the album after Must Be The Whiskey (with Head Case in there somewhere too).
Lifers doesn’t have any songs that hit me as hard as Mamma Song, David, or Loud and Heavy, but it might be a strong album top to bottom than Adobe Sessions.
Wobblyhorse
July 28, 2018 @ 1:10 pm
I love traveling songs in country. Be it the trucker, drifting cowboy, hobo, or struggling musician. It is life I’ve lived and better than the tired love gone wrong songs.
Colter
July 27, 2018 @ 8:35 am
Jinks has done it again. Impressive.
Gina
July 27, 2018 @ 8:39 am
Love it. I can’t wait to get this.
Brandon
July 27, 2018 @ 8:53 am
This is what disappoints me about Saving Country Music. This album is above average at best, but because it “sounds” country it gets a big score and a review that offers no real criticism or insight. There are a few gems here sure but for the most part it just sounds uninspired and lacks cohesion. “I’m not the Devil” was modern country near-masterpiece. And while this is a fine album that I’ll listen to on occasion it feels more like a missed opportunity than anything else.
Trigger
July 27, 2018 @ 8:56 am
“There are a few tracks you may find yourself skipping over on Lifers, like the fun but mild “Big Last Name,” or the meandering “Desert Wind.” “
“Lifers might not be the best record Cody Jinks has ever released, but that’s more a testament to the stout competition Cody has created for himself over his career…”
Brandon
July 27, 2018 @ 9:16 am
Again, I said “no real criticism or insight”. Two short sentences that gloss over the inadequacies of the record without any proper analysis doesn’t count. I have a deep respect for good music criticism and consider it a vital component of pop culture but playing favorites doesn’t do us any favors.
Trigger
July 27, 2018 @ 9:37 am
I don’t feel like this album is perfect or a masterpiece, and I feel like my review and the grade reflected that. If you think the album has inadequacies, then by all means, share your thoughts on them here. I would love to read them. Saving Country Music is not an autocracy. I never claim to have the only valid opinion. I think there are some flaws on the album as well. But with such highly-anticipated releases such as this one, expectations sometimes become unattainable, and I saw that bubbling up before this release with many listeners. It’s an excellent record in my opinion, but I agree there’s issues. Taste is never right or wrong.
Trigger
July 27, 2018 @ 9:20 am
I don’t think “Lifers” is the greatest Cody Jinks record. I would agree that “I’m Not The Devil” is better. That said, I don’t want that to come across as criticism of “Lifers” because Cody has set such a high bar for himself, it may be impossible for him to top his own work. And I still think that “Lifers” is very, very top notch. You and others may disagree and I respect that. But don’t think this is anything short of my true opinion.
As for this record being a “missed opportunity,” I think there is a TON more to happen before we can even come close to making that determination. As I said in the review, the accessibility of this record may be one of its greatest assets. Some of the songs Cody’s core fans or true country fans think are mild may be the gateway to Cody Jinks and the independent world. We’ll just have to see.
IF this records ultimately results in a missed opportunity, it won’t be because of the music. It will be because this record was released on a condensed schedule, and there just hasn’t been much media buzz or coverage for it beyond the usual publications. The record doesn’t feel rushed, but the rollout does. Also, releasing it the same day as Kenny Chesney assures it won’t go #1, so you won’t get that boost we’ve seen with Sturgill/Isbell/Blackberry Smoke/Aaron Watson, though I still expect sales to be strong and very impressive.
Also thanks to “Rolling Stone,” the big narrative right now in country music is Eric Church’s political comments, NOT music of any sort. This will hurt all artists, and all releases today.
But give this thing time. I think “Lifers” is a grower, just like “Must Be The Whiskey.”
Brandon
July 27, 2018 @ 10:04 am
That’s a fair assessment. It was probably hasty of me use the expression “missed opportunity”. And to clarify, I’d much rather folks fall in love with an “average” Cody Jinks record than the tripe that passes for country music these days. In the end though I think it’s important for us to be just as critical of artists like Cody Jinks as we are of lesser acts like Sam Hunt, Florida Georgia Line, etc… Maybe more so. After all, guys like Cody are the ones carrying the torch. Without ‘em there is no country music. Well, no country music worth listening to at least.
Trigger
July 27, 2018 @ 10:19 am
“In the end though I think it’s important for us to be just as critical of artists like Cody Jinks as we are of lesser acts like Sam Hunt, Florida Georgia Line, etc… Maybe more so.”
I agree, and I pride myself in being one of the toughest critics on guys like Sturgill, Isbell, and Chris Stapleton, despite the underlying and deserved praise for the quality of their music. But I also think it’s fair to judge music on a global scale. Regarding “Lifers,” I think it is WAY better than the vast majority of music being put out in “country” at the moment. That said, I also think there’s been better this year, and better from Cody Jinks. I think my review reflects that.
scott
July 27, 2018 @ 11:03 am
If I ever wondered whether Eric Church was a full on asshole, the RS interview brought it home. Yep, dude is a piece of work. Or, a piece of something.
Johnny
July 27, 2018 @ 5:13 pm
You can tell 100% that he hasn’t looked into any of the things that he talked about as far as politics go. I feel like it would take a 10 minute conversation to change his mind on any subject matter.
Thebugman10
July 28, 2018 @ 9:01 am
I hate that they had to bring up guns, and other political stuff. People can believe what they want, and Eric can believe what they want, but I hate when RS says that Eric supports “common sense” gun control it means that anyone who disagrees isn’t using common sense, despite what their argument is.
sbach66
July 27, 2018 @ 9:07 am
You also need to remember that Trigger mixes up his review rating system.
Trigger
July 27, 2018 @ 10:15 am
I don’t like when people focus on review grades, and that’s why I purposely mix them up. That said, 8.5 puts “Lifers” behind “I’m Not The Devil,” as well as half a dozen other records released so far this year. I feel like expectations for this record were really really high, and I understand some folks are disappointed. But you also have to look bigger picture. If “Lifers” is competing with other Cody Jinks records, I completely understand why some see it as a letdown, and expounded on that specific point in the review. But if you zoom out and compare it to the rest of material coming out in the greater “country” realm in 2018, “Lifers” is way better than most, though there are a handful of albums that are better. I think the 8.5 grade reflects that.
Michael
July 27, 2018 @ 9:11 am
Man I totally agree. These artist have put out great albums and it’s time we actually start being critical of when they put out mediocrity. Just because name “Cody Jinks” is attached to this album doesn’t mean it deserves an automatic 8.5 out of 10. To me the production on this album is off. From the vocals to the backing of the instrumental tracks. Some songs are way to drum heavy to where it’s just sounds annoying. I was expecting I’m Not the Devil 2.0 and so far this album has fallen flat from the first couple of run throughs.
MH
July 28, 2018 @ 6:42 am
Why do you listen to music, for the effect the lyrics have on you, or for the production value?
ScottG
July 27, 2018 @ 10:32 am
I really like Trigger’s reviews. I have to say that this one does dwell on the context of the album a little much vs. actual analysis of the record. However, context and actual knowledgeable perspective are things sorely missing in a lot of reviews, especially of country music…and Trigger is a good person to provide it. Could he instead break down his opinions methodically and deconstruct every single track? Sure, but there are problems with doing that too. Will I end up agreeing with his relatively high score? My guess is I might score it a bit lower once I get a few more chances to listen to it. So what. It’s his opinion. Lot’s of other great perspectives in the comment section.
Rob
July 27, 2018 @ 10:59 am
Wrong
– Donald Trump
Donny
July 27, 2018 @ 8:53 am
Stranger/Head Case is unbelievable. Of course this album is superb.
North Woods Country
July 27, 2018 @ 9:01 am
Very disappointed in this release. I could skip 5 of the first 6 songs, with only “Somewhere Between I Love You and I’m Leavin'” being the only standout song. At least the last 5 songs are classic Jinks.
It’s not that the early songs are bad–it’s that they’re boring. I’ve heard them all before aside from the aforementioned third track.
6/10. At best. I hope it grows on me.
JRK
August 2, 2018 @ 2:32 pm
I felt like the first 5 had completely different vocal sounds, like they took the boom out of his voice. Bad call, IMO.
Stringbuzz
July 27, 2018 @ 9:06 am
Get’s better with each listen.. I do need to give It more time, but I like it. If I could play one Jinks album for someone, not sure if this would be it yet.
I’m not sure about the production. Could’ve been a better sounding album, but I am nitpicking I guess.
Has a live vibe to a lot of it.
Another solid Jinks album.
He is what he is.
Stringbuzz
July 29, 2018 @ 1:19 pm
I’ve decided I really enjoy this album. It’s a good listen and fits right into his discography well.
joe
July 27, 2018 @ 9:07 am
His worst material to date. Uninspired and insipid. Shame. Another bad release I was looking forward to. I can barely differentiate between the songs. It all blends into one big pot that I’ve all heard before.
tucker33585
July 27, 2018 @ 9:38 am
I think it is the worst followed by 30 and then blacksheep.
Sereg3ti
July 27, 2018 @ 12:10 pm
I agree, it’s not bad but it isn’t his best. I’ll still listen all weekend. I really dig “Colorado”
CountryRoads
July 27, 2018 @ 9:16 am
Only been through it once, but definitely some better songs here than the initial pre-releases were hinting at. Definitely not his best album, as Trigger points out, but I think this one will grow on me over time. I also wish the production was a bit warmer. That snare drum, for example, is pretty harsh. But maybe that’s the sound they were going for.
Whiskey_Pete
July 27, 2018 @ 9:23 am
He sounds 10X better live. It’s weird phenomenon.
North Woods Country
July 27, 2018 @ 12:05 pm
The production on this album is fucking awful. That’s the polite way of saying it.
Johnny
July 27, 2018 @ 5:15 pm
Id have to agree. His voice sounds very unfamiliar in some of the songs.
JB-Chicago
July 27, 2018 @ 3:26 pm
Which is why he should’ve put out a beautiful well produced live album/Blu-Ray from the Devil tour before this album. The 20 track setlist I’ve been listening to spans the entire career before Lifers. I know it’s easy to say but the vid shoot would cost a lot but a good board mix from a few shows with crowd reaction wouldn’t.
Cameron
July 27, 2018 @ 9:26 am
New album is good.
On first listen there are some really good songs (head case, desert wind, I love you and I’m leaving, and big last name) and one great one (Colorado). But for the most part I wasn’t as impressed as I was with “I’m Not The Devil”. Lifers is more on par with Adobe Sessions. Solid album but I thought I’m not the devil was a great one.
Dirt Road Derek
July 27, 2018 @ 9:33 am
I can’t wait to dive into this one, the wait has been killing me. And it sounds like it’s been worth it.
JB-Chicago
July 27, 2018 @ 9:40 am
After a couple of full listens I like the album as a whole I’m not sure if any of these songs are as great as the standout tracks on Adobe or Devil but that’s near impossible. I reserve the right to not make snap judgments and live with this album awhile, see how it grows on me or doesn’t. I think we all owe Cody that time. The problem with someone like Cody is in the live setting he’ll have to cut a few incredible classics from the setlist that should be played to play new songs that we may not hear as classics………..yet?
ScottG
July 27, 2018 @ 9:41 am
Me personally, it’s hard to judge the the songwriting on an album within a few hours. And that, to me is the most important thing. I do have a few first impressions though. Cody never disappoints with the energy and vibe he puts into a record, which seems to be the case here. I always loved his phrasing…he just has such a smooth way of singing. Sonically: Seems a step back from Devil. Unless they somehow did this on purpose, there’s some subtle amateurish mistakes in the production. The low end is kind of a mess. Both kick drum and the bass are too boomy, with lack of definition. Then there is the acoustic guitars being overly scooped to the point that they sound harsh. Even a little harshness on his voice. Anyway, like I said, these are subtle, and not enough to hurt the songs if they do grow on me.
Wes
July 27, 2018 @ 9:41 am
He tried something that’s sounds a bit different which is good. Cody tweaked the sound a bit on this record. I get that you dont want all your stuff to sound the same but I was not a fan of how the production sounded. It’s not what what I have come to expect in quality of Cody Jinks. I don’t see this being the breakout year for Cody like trigger had planned because this is just alright in my opinion. And as I scroll through the comments I believe that sentiment as being echoed by several others. There isn’t the universal love that his two albums had before this. Disappointed after all the hype for an average album from Cody.
ScottG
July 27, 2018 @ 10:07 am
Where did you read / hear that “he” tried something different? My issues with the production mostly have to do with the mixing and engineering. Did Cody direct either of those? The producer maybe? P.S. I’m not saying that in hostility, I’m genuinely curious. He might have…
Bobby
July 27, 2018 @ 10:09 am
Man, a lot of negativity on this. Surprising. I wonder what these comments would look like if it was his first album, and not judged against Adobe Sessions and I’m not the Devil? This release is a win for the good guys, lets be thankful for guys like Cody putting in the time and the miles to keep this dying tradition alive, whether you think it is a top notch effort or not. Being an artist in any endeavor is a hard business to make a living, combined with balancing touring and a family, I don’t know how a lot of these guys and gals do it and manage to put out almost an album a year.
Cody, thanks for the hard work and good music!!
Benny Lee
July 27, 2018 @ 10:25 am
Agree, Bobby. My perspective, Cody Jinks has no grading curve to help him out because he’s delivered near perfect scores his last two outings. I’d say Trigger’s 8.5 for Jinks would be like a 17 for somebody like FGL.
strait country 81
July 27, 2018 @ 2:03 pm
Sturgill and Isbore are the only ones that can do no wrong according to SCM readers.
Benny Lee
July 27, 2018 @ 10:19 am
Early returns:
This is good, but definitely not as good as his last 2 albums, both of which I though were about as good as it gets.
There’s something I don’t like about the electric guitar in a bunch of these songs, too. Too much crunch or high gain? Not sure, but it just doesn’t sound right to me.
One thing he does really well is make an album that you can just listen to on repeat on a drive, and I feel this album has that same quality.
It’s a letdown, but only because I expected clear, flat-out AOTY. Given reasonable expectations this is a very nice country album.
Sarah Shook is still #1 in 2018, IMO. This one is probably tied with Mike and the Moonpies and just behind American Aquarium for me.
Black Boots
July 27, 2018 @ 10:27 am
I must admit I like it more and more with each subsequent listen….
Trigger
July 27, 2018 @ 10:49 am
It’s a grower.
Black Boots
July 27, 2018 @ 11:06 am
It’s seeming like it , yea
matthew rutledge
July 27, 2018 @ 11:13 am
totally agree!
ShadeGrown
July 29, 2018 @ 8:44 am
Most every album that stands the test-of-time is a grower.
Black Boots
July 29, 2018 @ 9:22 am
Hmm I’d have to think about that. Not totally sure if I agree.
RedDirtCyclone
July 27, 2018 @ 10:37 am
Head Case may have moved in to the top spot for my favorite Jinks song.
Trigger
July 27, 2018 @ 10:50 am
Excellent song. Song of the Year contender. And if they’d put it in the middle of the track list as opposed to last, we wouldn’t be seeing half as many negative comments on this record.
Rob
July 27, 2018 @ 11:09 am
Maybe not, but it has an introspective vibe hat seems perfect to close the record.
kross
July 27, 2018 @ 10:46 am
this album for me is like chasing that one girl for months just finally get her in bed and she just kind of lays there. You still had a lot of fun, but you walk away a little underwhelmed.
highlights:
1. Holywater
2. Colorado
3. Lifers
4. Somewhere between I love you and I’m leaving
5. Stranger
Lows:
1. Big Last name
2. Head Case
3. Desert Wind
4. 7th floor
Aggc
July 27, 2018 @ 11:01 am
The reality is rarely as good as the fantasy. 😉
DS
July 27, 2018 @ 12:39 pm
Head Case is a low for you???
Trigger
July 27, 2018 @ 10:48 am
A few generalized observations re: all of the critical comments of this record.
1. This is a grower. And without the benefit of a “First Listen” feature on NPR or pre-orders going out a week before like we’ve seen with some albums this year, folks are listening with very fresh ears. Not to discount anyone’s opinion, but I’m simply cautioning to give this record a little time. I wrote this review after listening to the record on and off over the last month. When I first heard “Must Be The Whiskey,” I thought it was kind of mild, and then it came to grow on me, and now I love it. I think that’s a microcosm of “Lifers.”
2. The two best songs are arguably the last two. Perhaps the album could have been better sequenced, but if you’re waiting for those gut punch songs, keep listening till the end.
3. Expectations were extreme for this record, and this evidenced itself early on. You’re fair to judge this record against Cody’s others, but you’re unfair to try and not look bigger picture and judge it across ALL the records released in the greater country music realm. If I made any mistake personally, it was feeding those high expectations. I feel my review is very fair.
4. Some complaining about productions issues. I personally think the production is good, but that’s a matter of taste. In my opinion what holds the record back is just some weak tracks songwriting wise. When you’re not connecting with a song, you start hearing deeper imperfections. Just like if you do connect with a song emotionally , you don’t care what the mix of the drums and bass is. And again, putting the two best songwriting tracks at the end, and putting some of the weaker material at the beginning challenges the listener to fight through it.
5. I respect everyone’s opinions and understand the disappointment, some of which is probably warranted. But I just would counsel everyone to give it a little time, skip over the tracks that don’t appeal to you, and look bigger picture. This is a really solid record in my opinion, and don’t let lofty expectations get in your way of enjoying good music.
ScottG
July 27, 2018 @ 11:14 am
Well said…which is why I’m still holding judgement on my overall impression. Couldn’t disagree with you more on the quality of the production though. And the mix of the bass and kick isn’t just nitpicking. It effects the overall flow and feel of the songs. Does it ruin it? No, and I clearly said that. But It could have been better, and it’s surprising, because it’s mixing 101 and a mistake that engineers usually make at a very early stage of their careers. Also, in 2018, it’s surprising to hear instruments and even vocals that sound sizzly and harsh. Numerous people seem to feel that various instruments sound harsh.
Agreeing also with Head Case being special, and again, I like how you handled this review and the comments overall, for what it’s worth.
North Woods Country
July 27, 2018 @ 12:08 pm
Tell you what, Trig, I’m sure glad I bought A Dying Machine by Tremonti at the same time. That way I’ve had somewhere to go while digesting my first listen to Lifers. I intend to listen at least twice more before writing my own review for my site, but songs 1-6 just depressed me that first time through. I don’t think time and layers of listens are going to make diamonds out of these sub-par songs for me.
Texas_1836
July 27, 2018 @ 12:48 pm
Great advice Trig. I got up this morning so excited to listen to the album while driving to work. At first I was really disappointed. However, after the drive home and additional time at home, l’m really enjoying the album. Headcase is definitely my favorite. Thanks for the review and keep up the good work.
Truth5
July 27, 2018 @ 9:15 pm
The album is damn good and I’m still trying to figure out why folks are bitching. No it’s not as good as I’m not the devil, but it’s still great music. Jamey hasn’t topped that lonesome song, Sturgill hasn’t topped high top mountain, Stapleton hasn’t topped traveler…just be glad for new good music, and stop trying to completely shut it down because it doesn’t top I’m not the devil. Must be the whiskey, somewhere between, Colorado, lifers, can’t quit enough are damn good. I’m just halfway through the album and trying to figure out the reason for the negativity.
North Woods Country
July 28, 2018 @ 7:36 am
This is not necessarily true. I could make an argument for Metamodern over High Top Mountain and The Guitar Song over That Lonesome Song. Granted, I’ll take the former when it comes to Sturgill and the latter when it comes to Jamey. As for Stapleton….aside from a handful of songs, I’m not that impressed. I’m glad he’s on the radio. I’m glad he’s found his success. With the exceptions of “Fire Away” and “Scarecrow in the Garden,” a lot of his songs don’t do a whole hell of a lot for me. Overrated. What’s crazy is that even though he is, it’s better to have him around than to not. That’s how bad mainstream is. I’m waiting for him to make a more traditional country album. Or a bluegrass album–I don’t even care if it’d be redundant considering his career with The Steeldrivers. Not a fan of this mostly blues with slight country influence sound.
As for Lifers, as I said in my initial comment in this thread–it’s growing on me. Including the first 6 songs. I quite like “Holy Water” now and “Big Last Name” is a blast. I just don’t care for “Lifers” or “Desert Wind.”
Truth5
July 28, 2018 @ 10:30 am
I’m as big of a Jamey fan as anyone and seen him live 30 times, if you can make an argument for guitar song over lonesome song, I really don’t see anyone who would make that argument but everyone has a different opinion. To me, lonesome song is one of the greatest albums in country music history…guitar song is good, but not on that level. As far as Sturgill, metamodern has 3 highlights (life of sin, living dream, long white line)and then some sturgill weird shit as expected. High top mountain solid top to bottom. But everyone has a different opinion…… hank 3 may never top straight to Hell….we could go on with examples.
Truth5
July 28, 2018 @ 10:36 am
Sorry, add Voices to metamodern….4 highlights
Stephanie
July 28, 2018 @ 4:46 pm
I totally agree with your take on Jamey’s and Sturgill’s albums!
ShadeGrown
July 29, 2018 @ 10:34 am
Almost every artist/band peaks within their first 3-5 albums. Some peak on album one – see GNR’s “Appetite…”
matthew rutledge
July 27, 2018 @ 11:05 am
So DAMN SPOT ON with “Head Case” Trig. I waited until midnight last night to give it a listen. Just an “above average” album until I got to the last track and then suddenly I found myself fist pumping in the air around 12:45 last night. Great review as always man!
Andrew
July 27, 2018 @ 11:05 am
Judging from the comments, a lot of people had totally unreasonable expectations. I agree it’s not as good as “I’m Not the Devil” but it’s still really damn good and “Head Case” is Song of the Year material.
albert
July 27, 2018 @ 11:07 am
I think that a big part of the connection a record makes with listeners is ‘vibe’ . That is …a cohesion of the efforts each track represents which give the overall collection a focus ( Miranda’s TWOTW and pehaps KC’s Golden Hour are solid current mainstream examples of my point )
The tracks posted above seem to hang together very well in that respect ….can’t comment on that unequivocally having yet to hear the entire album . Certainly tempo issues , tuning and pitch issues , ‘ambient distractions ‘ etc are valid concerns and should be on any release .Its often just oversight , or just amateur in terms of production . But unless these things are overwhelming I think the substance , the writing/narrative and emotional intent should still be paramount in the final analysis . Patti Griffin’s stuff of late , for example , has been more than a little suspect in the vocal pitch dept….but the material is so incredible its easily forgiven by her hardcore following . I’m all for slick , polished , flawless production ….but I wouldn’t ignore a stellar writing-based project if the aforementioned weren’t in place . I’ll take a slightly-vocally challenged Jimmy Webb over an auto-tuned FGL any day , to use a ridiculous example.
I suspect this record’s vibe is intact . I like what I’m hearing . I hope CJ reaches interested and concerned fans of the genre with this one…….or folks who didn’t know how concerned they were until this hit their ears .
Rob
July 27, 2018 @ 11:27 am
Fantastic album. Definitely believe you guys should give it more listens. I put this one right there with Adobe Sessions as my favorite Cody Jinks effort. My only problem lies in that I think Cody has a powerhouse voice and I don’t feel as if his voice was give as much opportunity to shine on these tracks, which would be a production issue. Still a fantastic album though, and Cody will remain at the top of my list of favorite singers.
As for the songs, I liked them all, but some of my favorites are “Desert Wind,” which was a great throwback to the western story songs of old, the title track “Lifers,” “7th Floor,” “Must Be the Whiskey” (took a few listens when it first came out but it really grew on me), and “Head Case.” “Head Case” was the type of introspective well written and well performed song that goes on to define an artist’s career. interestingly, while I still liked it, I argue that the weakest track on the album was “Stranger.” That clashes with the opinion of most of you, but I personally liked it the least of all the songs on the album.
This was another great Cody Jinks effort and I hope that the album grows on you guys, because I truly think it is a phenomenal album. Just because “Adobe Sessions” and “I’m Not the Devil” were fantastic does not mean that anything that you find below those albums is a disappointment. That’s a hard threshold to meet for an artist, and I believe Cody jinks has done it here.
North Woods Country
July 27, 2018 @ 12:11 pm
Perhaps he wanted to show that he’s a multi-faceted vocalist, but I kind of feel like he hid how deep his voice really is on this album. He should always sing like he does on Adobe and most of of Devil. That works so well, and to me his voice never seemed one-dimensional to begin with. Do what sounds best
Rob
July 27, 2018 @ 1:21 pm
Agreed. He has one of our modern classic country voices. That is one of his biggest assets.
JohnS
July 27, 2018 @ 12:40 pm
The thing about Cody Jinks is that his album tracks grow on you. After a few listens, this is like one of those movies when you can hear it a good few times and still enjoy it and discover brand new things. I remember not quite liking “I’m Not The Devil” as much as “Adobe Sessions”, but then I just loved it. This album seems to be just that for me. We all have our opinions though, and our favorite tracks.
Jack Young
July 27, 2018 @ 1:13 pm
It’s not his best album but I still really like it. Agree with most that the production isn’t very good, not terrible but definitely not good, especially compared to his last 2 records. I mean just listen to “What Else is New” for an example of great production.
I think it’s a really good album overall though, “Head Case” is definitely some of his best work.
Dane
July 27, 2018 @ 1:23 pm
You know Jinks is about to bust wide open when all the haters come out with their ready review after needle dropping one time. Triggers review is very fair & nuanced. Some sweet f these other knuckleheads are just spouing off. Whiskey didn’t hit me as special at first, I love it now. I can say Somewhere Between, Lifers, Colorado, Head Case & Stranger are gonna live in my head.
Big Cat
July 27, 2018 @ 5:53 pm
Not sure how much people are “hating”….I’m a huge fan and have been for a long time. I like the record but was disappointed after the progression of the last few albums. Referencing Sturgill in these debates can be too easy but Cody fails here (in my opinion) to separate himself the way elite artist do. I thought this was his time. Won’t keep me out of his shows.
Truth5
July 27, 2018 @ 9:23 pm
Sturgill hasn’t released anything as good as I’m not the devil, and each sturgill album has gotten worse. High top mountain was excellent, metamodern was a step back but decent, and then sailors guide idk what it is, but it damn sure ain’t country
Big Cat
July 28, 2018 @ 3:09 am
I’m not stepping in that trap. The Recording Academy didn’t see Sturgill’s record progression that way but we will leave it at your opinion. I’m Not the Devil is a great album, which is why I’m a little disappointed here.
Thebugman10
July 28, 2018 @ 9:08 am
Sailors Guide to Earth was my first exposure to Sturgill. Completely turned me off to him.
Truth5
July 28, 2018 @ 10:43 am
If you like real country music, avoid sailors guide and start with high top mountain. High top is excellent. Sailors guide isn’t country, no matter what anyone tells you.
Colter
July 27, 2018 @ 2:10 pm
Is it as good as I’m not the devil?
Nope.
Will that stop me from listening to it over and over?
Nope.
63Guild
July 27, 2018 @ 2:14 pm
It’s a good album and like others have said Desert wind is one of the better tracks. I still rank lucero new album above this though
North Woods Country
July 29, 2018 @ 9:30 pm
Did the Lucero album drop on the 27th, too?
63Guild
July 30, 2018 @ 4:58 am
Nope but you can stream it on NPR right now
North Woods Country
July 30, 2018 @ 4:08 pm
Thanks for the heads up! I’m listening now and love it so far. I think if I had to pick a favorite songwriter on the drop of a dime, Ben Nichols might very well be who I’d pick. Of course, I tend to say the same about Jinks or Isbell when they release new albums.
akus1985
July 27, 2018 @ 2:15 pm
I read a lot of these comments before I had the chance to listen to the album today, and I was getting worried. But Lifers definitely isn’t a “grow on you” album for me. I enjoyed every single song immensely on my first playthough. The 2 bookend tracks have a different vibe opposed to the rest of the album, but that’s just a nitpick. Lifers is a fantastic album from start to finish.
Barry Cheevers
July 27, 2018 @ 2:58 pm
I don’t know what it is, but I just can’t get into Cody Jinks. I listened to this album and I will say that Desert Wind was very enjoyable. Glad so many others enjoy Jinks, and I won’t say he is bad, just not for me.
wrs
July 27, 2018 @ 3:21 pm
I really enjoyed the album. Is it the best album he has released? Probably not but it’s one the best albums released this year in my opinion. He has sat the bar very high and I’m not disappointed in this album at all.
Bad One
July 27, 2018 @ 3:22 pm
I think that Adobe Sessions is an A+, while I’m not the Devil is a C at best. I give Lifers a C-.
DJ
July 27, 2018 @ 3:33 pm
LOL- I’ve not heard the album- but so what- It’s Cody effing Jinks by god!
Course I’m not a “professional critic”- just a listener, an old listener and he’s better than strangle simpson or jason is a whatever any day of the week and twice on Sunday-
Greg
July 27, 2018 @ 3:50 pm
I was listening to WSM the other day and they played one of Cody’s songs,but I don’t remember which one it was.
RedDirtCyclone
July 27, 2018 @ 3:53 pm
I get some mid 90s vibes out of the album, which I enjoyed. I really like it. It gets better on every listen. It is the first Jinks album with a real production record sound, but it works. It’s good. It’s not “I’m Not the Devil” but it is real good.
Big Cat
July 27, 2018 @ 4:00 pm
Haven’t read one other reply/post yet. As Trig knows I’m a long standing devoted fan. I was disappointed here. Couple of great songs (Colorado, Somewhere) but a lot of lazy fill here in my personal opinion.
Interested to go read what everyone thinks
Seth
July 27, 2018 @ 4:10 pm
My favorites are holy water and 7th floor
Kevin Davis
July 27, 2018 @ 4:44 pm
I’m late to the party. Some of the negative comments above are way overblown, and I highly doubt that such persons have spent enough time with the album to make such judgments. I’ve listened to the album once. There’s a lot I like, there’s some I’m not so sure about, and ultimately I won’t really know what I think so soon after its release. That should be a rule of thumb that we all abide by.
By the way, I listened to Kenny Chesney’s new album, which (as noted above) was also released today. I have to say that I was pleasantly surprised, for the most part. He has certainly made the whole beach/caribbean thing into a permanent identity, but he’s matured within it. There’s some quality songwriting on this album, and the production is measured and refreshing. For me, the highlight was his collaboration with Mindy Smith, who I’ve loved since her debut album.
Luiz Alexandre de Oliveira da Luz
July 27, 2018 @ 4:46 pm
“Head Case” is just amazing… the lyrics and feeling.
Must Be the Whiskey its a energetic song, should be played live every show.
and Somewhere Between i love you a im leavin remembers those sad old country songs.
Those are my favorites!
Hearing for the first time.
Great Review Trigger! Cheers from a friend from Brasil.
Mike2
July 27, 2018 @ 5:45 pm
Dang people are hard to please, apparently. I haven’t got my copy in the mail yet but I’m sure it can’t be that bad.
ScottG
July 27, 2018 @ 6:49 pm
Finally was able to listen enough times throughout the day, and concur that this album grew on me. I actually like the songwriting, instrumentation, and the arrangements a lot. The best words I can think of to describe them are ambitious and creative. Not the songs you might have expected and definitely not Adobe or Devil 2.0. But I like that. I can go listen to those anytime if I want. This is cool.
I still think the album overall would have benefited from better engineering / mix production but whatever, it’s not terrible and the songs come through. Some songs sound better than others, like Head Case, so I almost wonder if different people mixed that vs others. Speaking of, that song is stuck in my head. The guitar hook and that Cello are sick. Cool background vocals too. Again, pretty ambitious.
Anyway I’m enjoying listening to it and would agree with the 8.5 score. It’s a damn good album to me.
Mike Moore
July 27, 2018 @ 7:27 pm
Now you can all get back to Garth and company’s next bowel movement …..and the rest of your dumbass opinions
Justin S
July 27, 2018 @ 10:44 pm
Wut?
ScottG
July 28, 2018 @ 7:17 am
Yeah I’m like, with you man! Screw all you people with your bowel movements and Garth Brookses. Wait, who are we talking about again?
jvnyk
July 27, 2018 @ 8:01 pm
I only listened to the album 3 times so far today, but as of now I would have to consider this a disappointment compared to his last two offerings. This really is not very good.
The Dot
July 27, 2018 @ 8:52 pm
Head Case is stunning. I must have hit repeat 4 times on that song today. It’s up there with David on my favorite Jinks songs.
Production is “murky”. Might have been on purpose, but with a voice like Cody’s, it didn’t do him any favors. His vocal that should be clear, not buried. His voice burst through about the 2:20 mark on 7th floor and it totally changed the song.
A few sounded like classic Jinks, and the extended jams on some songs didn’t work for me.
Is it “Adobe” or “Devil”? Nope, but it’s something I’ll push on my friends as music they need to listen to.
Bill
July 27, 2018 @ 9:06 pm
Looks like I’m in the minority here but I think this record is amazing and on par with I’m Not the Devil. I really dig “Holy Water” and “Desert Wind”, and “Head Case” is bone chilling. Still waiting for new records from Colter Wall, Ward Davis, and Whitey Morgan this year…c’mon folks times are exciting and Lifers is pretty damn stellar.
Thoroughbred
July 28, 2018 @ 3:50 am
Cody needs to use more harmony vox on his choruses, when he does, it really stands out.
King Honky Of Crackershire
July 28, 2018 @ 4:57 am
Another perfect example of an act this website and its readers go crazy about, but when I listen I just hear some average dude with an average voice and writes average songs. Who gives a crap?
I don’t understand why anyone would pay for this.
Bill
July 28, 2018 @ 9:00 am
“Somewhere Between I Love You and I’m Leavin'” and “Head Case,” average lyrics? Ok bud…not convinced you aren’t Sturgill Simpson in disguise and just fucking with SCM.
“You’re the Only one that you are screwin’, when you put down what you don’t understand…”
Aggc
July 29, 2018 @ 7:29 pm
Ok, I’ll bite. Who in your opinion has an exceptional voice?
Ryan
July 28, 2018 @ 5:17 am
I’m surprised by the reaction to this album. I think it’s outstanding and one of the best releases of the year. All of the tracks (with the exception of Big Last Name) are very strong. I agree with Trig and others for Head Case being a Song of the Year contender. I’ll be playing this one for a long time to come!
Don
July 28, 2018 @ 5:34 am
It’s funny how we hear things differently. I love this album. Didn’t hear one song that disappointed me, but maybe it’s our experiences in life that define what sounds good to us.
James O
July 28, 2018 @ 8:45 am
I think it’s his best album
Thebugman10
July 28, 2018 @ 8:55 am
Just started listening to it. Jinks and Turnpike should be the two biggest acts in country music. There’s not many artists that debuted with 3 albums as strong as Jinks (Turnpike is one of them). I’m not as high on I’m Not the Devil as SCM and others here, but I still like it.
Thebugman10
July 28, 2018 @ 9:05 am
By first 3, I guess I should say I meant 30, Less Wise, and Adobe Sessions. I’m not familiar with the first two (were they not wide releases?) and I just found out about Blacksheep today.
JB-Chicago
July 28, 2018 @ 11:43 am
Just curious Trig did they ever even “send” Must Be The Whiskey to terrestrial Country radio to try and be added? I hear it occasionally on Sirius Outlaw. Just wondering……. or maybe another song?
OlaR
July 28, 2018 @ 11:56 am
Very good album. Not great & not my album of the year.
Still trying to find a song & reason to buy the album or a song or two.
The album i bought today:
Adam Harvey – The Nashville Tapes – 12 Tracks – Released 07/27
Australian country star Adam Harvey returns with a great traditional/classic country album.
The album starts with “Less Of A Thinking Man” in Waylon Jennings style followed by the first single “I’d Rather Be A Highwayman”. The ballad is #2 (19 last week) on the Austrailan Country Tracks Chart.
Helping out are Troy Cassar-Daley (who wrote “We’ll Have To Drink Our Way Out Of This” for the album), Mickey Raphael (Harmonica player for Willie Nelson) & living legend Lee Kernaghan on the duet “Three Rivers Hotel”. Nash Chambers (brother of Kasey Chambers) produced the project.
altaltcountry
July 28, 2018 @ 8:01 pm
A good review provides just enough perspective and background to make sure that our preconceptions don’t stand between us and the music. This is a damn good review of a great album.
I’m Not the Devil had one foot firmly planted in outlaw (reminiscent especially of Billy Joe Shavers) territory. Lifers forges its own path (without abandoning the tradition). That’s a risky gambit, but it provides unique rewards.
Jack Williams
July 29, 2018 @ 5:52 am
I’m about three listens in. I’d say this is a very nice album. And from my perspective, it is to I’m Not The Devil what John Hiatt’s Stolen Moments is to his classic Slow Turning. A quality followup to a great album.
scott
July 30, 2018 @ 5:34 am
Love that analogy! Of course, I rarely, if ever, disagree with your observations, Jack.
KGD
July 29, 2018 @ 10:38 am
I listened twice while I was working in the yard. Sandwiched around I’m Not the Devil. I like Lifers quite a bit. Really the only song I would skip over would be the first one, Holy Water. I even like Big Last Name and Desert Wind better than most.
I bet most if not all, will stand up pretty well in concert. We’ll find out in October. ????
Jimmy's Carhartt
July 30, 2018 @ 12:33 pm
Five listens in, I’m loving this.
Holy Water: good lyrics, but leaves me underwhelmed by the end. Would feel like filler if it wasn’t the lead track.
Must Be the Whiskey: A grower. In a just world, this is a mainstream smash.
Somewhere Between I Love You and I’m Leavin’: This hits my sweet spot of lonesome lyrics and cryin’ steel guitar. A clear highlight.
Lifers: I feel these lyrics deep.
Big Last Name: A good jam, but nothing special. The lyrics keep it unique enough to be interesting.
Desert Wind: I’m not feeling this one yet – I want to like it but I lose interest halfway though. We’ll see if it grows on me.
Colorado: Best song on the album. I get chills in the second verse: “I wonder if that tree’s still strong and standing despite the broken promises we made.” This is instantly one of my favorite Cody Jinks songs, second only to David.
Can’t Quit Enough: Chase That Song 2.0. It’s good, but I wish there were more growl in the vocals and more color in the solos.
7th Floor: This is a cool lyric and a great, dark vibe, till three minutes in when the choir comes in and ruins it for me.
Stranger: What a great lyric. I would have preferred more sparse production, and I’m just too used to the Billy Don Burns vocal. Big props to giving this song a greater audience, though.
Head Case: I never realized Cody Jinks singing about insanity, slathered in cello was what I was missing in my life.
Overall:
-Not as consistent as I’m Not the Devil, but the highlights (Colorado, Somewhere Between) are as good as anything he’s ever given us.
-I’m not hearing the production issues many of you complained about on the snares and guitars. It sounds good to me.
-The writing is strong all the way through. The production and the melodies are less consistent.
-I’m seeing him live on Friday night for the first time and I couldn’t be more excited.
Great review, Trigger. I totally agree – this is not the best album he’s made, but it’s still damn good, and a great intro to his sound. In a just world, he would be a mainstream superstar.
CountryRoads
July 31, 2018 @ 7:21 pm
I wonder if Colorado would win any awards for saying the word “think” as many times as any song in history, or for having the most poorly produced drum sound / most unnecessary drum fills for a “slow” song? Someone needs to research that!
On a more serious note, I have to say this album overall isn’t growing on me. A few high points, but overall, too much of the same old tempo Jinks rock songs with a hint of country, which I don’t think presents him in his best light. Does anyone else notice that he often tries to cram a few two many words into most of his songs? Feels like he writes the lyrics first and then makes them fit the song without modIfying them at all. He comes across as very rushed in his vocal delivery on a lot of these songs, which totally doesn’t do his voice or the vibe of the songs any favors.
John
August 2, 2018 @ 12:14 pm
Just finished up my first listen through of ‘Lifers’ and absolutely loved it. Although, as many have commented he has done better songs on other albums, this album is possibly the most accessible one to date. Every song is excellent and as a complete package is amazing.
Farina
August 4, 2018 @ 7:22 am
I’ve been playing “Lifers” at work this week to give an honest assessment. The verdict is, I like it a lot! It feels like a great country record, with nice variety. There’s nothing better when he goes “heavy”, as in Head Case, but Big Last Name is great too!