Album Review – “The Guadalupe Breakdown” by Ryan Scott Travis
Most country music fans are general music fans first, and then their loyalties revolve around country. If you’re a country fan, you’re likely to also have leanings toward many of country’s offshoots like Southern rock, country rock from folks like The Flying Burrito Brothers or early Steve Earle, and alt-country, bluegrass, and Americana.
But the sector of music that has much in common with country but doesn’t always get its proper due from country fans is the era of country-flavored folk rock that hit a high water mark in the 70’s with artists like America, Jim Croce, Gordon Lightfoot, and David Gates of Bread. Often this music is either overlooked for country folk superstars like John Denver, or diminished because many of the standards from the era went on to become the foundations of “soft rock.” For every “Horse With No Name” there’s a “You Can Do Magic.” But the texturing, the songwriting, and some of the arrangements were just as country as anything else outside of the genre proper. And put together, the 70’s folk rock era in music is a treasure trove of song and emotion.
The Guadalupe Breakdown by Ryan Scott Travis is not a 70’s era folk album. It is a country album with fiddle, steel guitar, some banjo, and songs of heartbreak. But it has just enough of the textures of the country folk era—the melancholic chords, the mild volume, tasteful percussion treatments, and swooning melodies that re-imagine human memory in song. It’s this treatment of country that allows certain emotions to be stirred up in a manner that traditional country just can’t.
Not much information can be found about Ryan Scott Travis when poking around the internet. Apparently he’s originally from Borne, TX—a river town in the Texas Hill Country where like many Hill Country towns, country music is a part of life. Boerne is a town that symbolizes what Texas once used to be, while at the same time being a haven for the affluent of the San Antonio area. According to the music of The Guadalupe Breakdown, Ryan Scott Travis finds his inspiration and much of his life story drifting between central Texas and the commercial country epicenter of Tennessee.
The Guadalupe Breakdown is lost between towns, lost between loves, and told in a musical language lost in time. Excellent songwriting is combined with tasteful, well-crafted arrangements that bring rise to the nostalgic sentiments of acoustic folk, while also delivering essential country ingredients like twangy steel guitar and choruses set in half time. It is the best of both of worlds conjoined together with reverence.
This album’s strength is also its weakness. It gets a little sleepy, especially in the later tracks from a lack of up-tempo songs or sharp edges. Aside from the title track, most everything on this record is a tick slower. It could have used just one more song with a faster beat, or a boot stomper with some more meat on the bones, and then the other songs would have all felt that much slower and sentimental in a good way. But Ryan Scott Travis stays true to himself and his sound, and that deserves respect as well, even if it makes listening cover to cover a little tedious by the end. For the right mood—whether it’s a sleepy Sunday afternoon or a bout of melancholy or nostalgia—The Guadalupe Breakdown fits about right.
Often the lines between what is country, and what is folk is only a matter of perspective, opinion, or what the artist decides to call it. What makes Mickey Newbury country, but Neil Young’s Harvest a folk record? Both folk and country share many of the same foundations, ideas, themes, and instrumentation. The Guadalupe Breakdown illustrates this while delivering songs that can and should be enjoyed by most all fans of roots music.
1 3/4 of 2 Guns Up (8.5)
– – – – – – – – – – – –
ElectricOutcast
February 21, 2016 @ 12:09 pm
Pretty good voice. We got Jason Isbell, Sturgill Simpson and Chris Stapleton and I think this guy’s next on the list (hopefully I’m right).
RobertS
February 21, 2016 @ 1:33 pm
I’m not somewhere that I can listen to this yet, but the description looks interesting. I’ve been to Boerne a few times & it’s a cool town – caves (at least one of which hosts concerts), dinosaur footprints, etc. The album cover looks very much like Guadalupe State Park.
Kurt
February 21, 2016 @ 12:42 pm
original and honest – definitely worth a listen
Jim Bob
February 21, 2016 @ 1:19 pm
That’s not bad, but..am I the only one thinking that sounded like a slightly-less-good version of ryan bingham on the first one? I’ve had a few today, so I could be way off base, but that sounded like bingham’s melody off his last album. Which is not necessarily a bad thing, I’m just saying
Kevin Davis
February 21, 2016 @ 1:22 pm
This is why I love sites like SCM — introducing me to quality music that I would have otherwise never heard. I just listened to the album on Spotify and thoroughly enjoyed it. I agree about the need for a few more uptempo numbers, but there’s an uplifting quality to the whole album and, as a result, it doesn’t feel too weighty or too self-absorbed.
Don
February 21, 2016 @ 2:08 pm
This is great stuff, but then again I’m always a sucker for that 70’s easy going sound.
kevin
February 21, 2016 @ 5:25 pm
My fear, with some reviews (and no offense to Trigger, of course) is that we get steered away from the rock in side of country for fear that it’ll put us in league with a bunch of douche bags. I love the folksy stuff…for sure…but I hold put hope that there are bands out there (other than the CDB) that Chanel good old redneck, God loving, kickass country. Where is country’s Ted Nugent?
Trigger
February 21, 2016 @ 6:58 pm
I don’t exactly understand this comment.
” Where is country”™s Ted Nugent?”
His name is Hank Williams Jr., and he’s sucked for the last 20 years.
This is just one review, of one album people.
kevin
February 21, 2016 @ 7:30 pm
Hey, thanks for responding to something you don’t understand. I’m just saying that PC folksy stuff is awesome but it does get tiring…there has to be a bunch of non-pussy stuff out there….you hear way more than I do…turn me on to it Trig! Don’t get me wrong, I can listen to Charlie Daniels for a loooong time…and, that’s simply my opinion. I feel flattered that you addressed it “people” but maybe it’s just me.
Charlie
February 22, 2016 @ 8:19 am
You sound like a potential Hank III fan.
For me, Blackberry Smoke is about as far as I would want to go for a band that rocks, but is still country.
Check out Little Piece of Dixie, track: Up In Smoke.
Check out Whitey Morgan, too. Call him a pussy and see how that goes!
wayne hancock…..dale watson…….lot’s of badasses out there.
Just don’t wish Terrible Ted on us.
RD
February 21, 2016 @ 6:25 pm
“What makes Mickey Newbury country, but Neil Young”™s Harvest a folk record?”
Neil Young is from Canada, and no foreign artist has ever misunderstood American culture and history more than him. His shallow typecast of the South would be laughable if so many people didn’t find it “deep.” I think that folk music can be culture-less, while country music is rooted in a specific culture. That is what would distinguish Newbury from Young…
Trigger
February 21, 2016 @ 7:02 pm
Who said anything about Neil Young’s nationality or politics? I was making a distinction about sonic similarities, and I stand behind it. If you don’t like Neil Young’s name, replace it with a dozen others. The point remains, and nothing here has to do with politics.
” I think that folk music can be culture-less.”
If it wasn’t for folk music, country music doesn’t exist. I would say that gives folk music some cultural value.
RD
February 21, 2016 @ 7:19 pm
Where in my comment did I say anything about politics? You seem trigger happy. An uninformed American writing a song about the Quebec Front de libération would be just as silly as Neil Young writing about a people, place, and time he knows nothing about. Folk music can be culture-less in that it can be without roots in any specific place or culture and still be good. I really like Gordon Lightfoot. To the casual listener, his music doesn’t scream “I’m a Canadian.” He could just as easily be from Oak Park Illinois, Columbus Ohio, or some other bland setting.
RD
February 22, 2016 @ 7:44 am
“If it wasn”™t for folk music, country music doesn”™t exist.”
No.
What are you calling “folk” music? Do you mean Pete Seeger, Woody Guthrie, etc.? Or do you mean all traditional European music lumped into one big category?
Trigger
February 22, 2016 @ 10:19 am
Honestly I’m not even interested in having this discussion. As I said in my review, this is a country album. It’s a country album that takes some of the cool elements from 70’s folk rock and combines that into country. Talking about what Neil Young thinks about the South or the cultural value of folk seems to resign to the fact that this is a folk album, which it isn’t. Though it does have some folk inspirations.
Jake W.
February 21, 2016 @ 9:36 pm
Folk music has a lot of truth in it, and has helped bring about social awareness on a variety of issues from civil rights to war and poverty. They also really stayed true to the roots, old folk songs, appalachia music, blues, and gospel. Arlo Guthrie, Woody Guthrie, Bob Dylan, and others of the same spoke out against racism, war, goverment control, economic inequality, standing up for others and what you believe in is not pussy. Lead belly would be considered folk blues a lot of his songs were rendentions of older folk songs. Most of Led Zeppelin’s source material was celtic folk songs and blues, all is derived from the first melting pot of immigrants spreading out and mixing different types of folk music.
Back to the point this guy is really good, some were meant to sing sad songs, even when they sing a happy one. I am definitely gonna check out the whole album, another awesome find SCM. Excellent song writing and tone on that first video. Earning your spurs everyday haha. By the way if Hank Jr sucked for another 20 years it couldnt erase the mark he has left behind. Hopefully, he will turn his song choice around soon, as the heroes are dying he is drifting farther from his own legacy. Sundown you better take care if i find you been creeping round my back stairs.
ElectricOutcast
February 22, 2016 @ 5:12 am
“Folk music has a lot of truth in it, and has helped bring about social awareness on a variety of issues from civil rights to war and poverty. They also really stayed true to the roots, old folk songs, appalachia music, blues, and gospel. Arlo Guthrie, Woody Guthrie, Bob Dylan, and others of the same spoke out against racism, war, goverment control, economic inequality, standing up for others and what you believe in is not pussy.”
THANK YOU!!! I would also like to add in Pete Seeger and Johnny Cash to the mix.
Hayley
February 22, 2016 @ 4:34 am
Trigger what a great find! I’m digging it. I love that he leaves room to let talented musicians jam out a bit, without making it a tug of war lol. Good stuff!
Hayley
February 22, 2016 @ 4:40 am
Forgot to ask, who was on harmony? She sounded great
ElectricOutcast
February 22, 2016 @ 5:09 am
Glad I’m not the only one who caught that, their harmonies blended as beautifully as Jason Isbell and Amanda Shires and also Chris Stapleton and his wife Morgane.
Trigger
February 22, 2016 @ 10:22 am
I believe it is a girl named Emily Kozacek who is a performer herself, but I don’t have the liner notes or much information about this. They’ve performed together live.
Buzzed Aldrin
February 22, 2016 @ 10:33 am
Man, “Someday” has a weird chord change at :55.
Nice music, good review. But his voice sounds so much like solo Paul Simon in the 70s I can’t get over it!
Urban Cowpuncher
February 22, 2016 @ 11:21 pm
Buzzed, “But his voice sounds so much like solo Paul Simon in the 70s…”
So glad somebody else said that. I kept hearing the same thing; thought maybe my ears were broken ’cause no one else picked it up. Thanks for pointing it out!
ElectricOutcast
February 23, 2016 @ 4:57 pm
“Man, “Someday” has a weird chord change at :55.”
Right? It kept flashing me back to a different song I heard on a Metal Gear Solid video game.
Taylor
February 22, 2016 @ 9:13 pm
Just have listened to a little bit of it and it is really good! Love the folk side of country too. The simplicity and closeness to nature it has is relaxing.
CAH
February 23, 2016 @ 11:25 am
I don’t truly know, or even care, where country ends and folk music begins, although I have wondered about the issue.
I like both, along with rock, blues, metal, Broadway, opera and probably something which doesn’t come to mind.
Just not pop music.
What makes Robert Earl Keen, Jr. folk and not country?
I don’t know.