Album Review – Wynonna & The Big Noise
50-year-old country stars aren’t supposed to make records like these. They’re supposed to be trying to hold onto their glory days or make good use of the last dying gasps of somehow getting on the radio. Or they’re supposed to just give up the ghost and make sure they’re investing their money smartly. But nobody told Wynonna Judd that, or her husband, producer, drummer and songwriter Cactus Moser. Or if someone did, they didn’t listen, and made the record they wanted to any damn way. And the result is one of the most unusual, interesting, and texture rich albums we’ve heard from an established name in country in some time.
It’s hard to even know what to make of the Wynonna Judd legacy. The Judds were half part country soul with some really killer songs that have since become country standards, and then there was plenty of more country pop material. The duo amassed fourteen #1 hits and is one of the most successful duos in country music history, but it only lasted for six years and then it was over. Wynonna’s solo career started out with a flash, but in recent years she’s been yet another victim of the Curb Records Talent Retention Program which has no problem waiting seven years between releases like they’ve done here so that artists can’t fulfill their contracts and move on.
But the most important thing to understand when approaching this album is that whatever you know or think about Wynonna, just scrap it, because this new album is an animal all to itself.
Wynonna & The Big Noise starts off with a really solid foundation of building blocks, including songs from people like Julie Miller, Chris Stapleton, and Travis Meadows, and collaborations with people like Jason Isbell, Derek Trucks, Susan Tedeschi, and Timothy B. Schmit. Then you build the entire record around recording live with a basic five-piece band. Just looking at the liner notes, you know this is going to be something unique. And the noise they make together isn’t just “big,” it is raw, in the flesh, meaty, full, and leaping out of your speakers.
The magic ingredient here is Wynonna. She’s had to face many of her demons over the years in public. Personal tragedy has helped define her career. And being a celebrity doesn’t help to insulate you from adversity as some people surmise, it exacerbates it. So there’s a lot of weight hanging on the shoulders of Wynonna, and when she starts to sway back and forth, and taps into that real world emotion, she can have as much soul as the Staple Sisters.
The difficulty is how to get that out of Wynonna, and that’s what Cactus Moser does here. Moser has his own adversity to fight through. He lost one of his legs in a motorcycle accident in 2012 shortly after he and Wynonna were married. But taking the oath of “in sickness and in health” to heart, the accident made the couple stronger, and one can’t help but hear that living and breathing entity that is the relationship between these two artists embedded in this record. There’s some anger to it, and honesty. The album works like a big exhalation, like their blowing out all these pent up emotions and feelings that have been caged in them for these last few years.
It’s hard to describe Wynonna & The Big Noise because the sound is so hard to pin down. “Country” is probably the last thing that comes to mind, though it’s still there lurking in the background. Wynonna & The Big Noise is more of a blues, rock, and gospel record at heart, but encapsulating everything is the very advanced approach to composition and writing that makes it more than any one genre or subgenre. With the use of composition and chording, this album is strange to the ears … in a good way. Forced into a corner, one may call it progressive Americana or something, and it does remind you of Buddy Miller’s blues albums perhaps, but with more bravado.
This will not be an album for everyone. Who will love it is other musicians. Cactus Moser knew what he had with Wynonna. He knows what she’s capable of more than anyone else. And he put together the perfect environment and songs to allow her to shine. To sing it, you have to live it. And few if any know Wynonna’s innermost feelings like Cactus.
This is one of those records you have to hear to judge for yourself, and you’re going to have to open your heart and mind to it a little bit to take in the full breadth of its message. Some songs are stronger than others. There’s loud moments, and more intimate ones like the collaboration with Jason Isbell, “Things That I Lean On.” There’s a song on the album called “Something You Can’t Live Without” that may encapsulate the album better than most. It has a true-to-life message, but it’s such a sonic journey, with a vision and imagination that’s missing from most modern music, especially from country artists. A different version of the song was released as a single a couple of years ago, and listening to the old version speaks to the unique vision that was brought to this new project to make it something special.
It’s hard to see how Wynonna & The Big Noise makes a big noise outside of Wynonna fans and people who may stumble upon it accidentally, or listen to it for the contributions from Americana folks. It has some dull moments too. But this album feels like a real victory from Wynonna and husband Cactus Moser. They had purpose with this record, saw it through, executed it near flawlessly, and the outcome is a very interesting, and sonically rich listening experience.
1 3/4 of 2 Guns Up (7.5/10)
– – – – – – – – – – – –
Purchase “Wynonna & The Big Noise”
ElectricOutcast
February 18, 2016 @ 10:42 am
One thing I’m taking notice is that I think Wynonna is taking a similar approach to what Marty Stuart did awhile back and that is create a personal backing band similar to Buck Owens and His Buckaroos or Hank Williams and The Drifting Cowboys.
Just an observation.
Fuzzy TwoShirts
February 18, 2016 @ 11:14 am
Hate HATE hate HATE the Judds… Mostly because they were a soft Country pop band with no soul, like DeBarge without the talent.
Wynonna Judd’s facial expressions are painful to watch…
Pool
February 18, 2016 @ 11:31 am
For some reason I read “softcore” instead of “soft Country” hahaha
I’d already sampled this. It sucks.
Trigger
February 18, 2016 @ 11:41 am
What does that have to do with anything Fuzzy? The last Judds album was released 26 years ago. Sometimes you give really insightful commentary, and sometimes you paint the readers of this site as moronic assholes who can’t see past their own noses. What makes it worse is you always try to get the first comment in so YOUR opinion starts off the conversation, or nosedives it more accurately.
“But the most important thing to understand when approaching this album is that whatever you know or think about Wynonna, just scrap it, because this new album is an animal all to itself.”
But of course you didn’t read it. All you did was give your opinion about the Judds. Well I don’t give a shit what you think about The Judds. Why don’t you actually read the article, maybe at least watch the videos above, and contribute to the conversation, critically if you choose, but about the actual material being discussed?
I don’t mean to jump down your throat but you’ve slowly morphed into the resident troll when you used to be one of the most insightful commenters. And it’s lame.
Gumslasher
February 18, 2016 @ 3:28 pm
I never really listened to the Judds. Doesn’t matter. What I heard on the two clips Trigger posted does. Great music by musicans. Will check out full album, love the drummer, hate the queen bee act of the queen bee. Video will ruin this band, but it is good music.
Toby in AK
February 18, 2016 @ 3:34 pm
The Judds… no soul?! Wynonna get’s no respect. They should get just as much credit as Randy Travis and George Strait for bringing traditional sounds back to country music. I’m tempted to drop a list of songs to refute that point but I think I’ll just listen to a playlist of them in protest instead.
As for this album, this is about as perfect an album as you can expect from an established country artist. Oh, it’s country. Not boilerplate country, sure, but the themes, the lyrics, the emotion in the music. If this album isn’t country I’ll kiss Wynonna’s ass.
Mule
February 19, 2016 @ 12:41 am
Agreed. I don’t care if it fits in that sometimes limiting box called “Country”. As long as it knows its roots, I dig it, and this album does!
Wynonna has always loved blues and soul. At worst she comes off as a Bonnie Raitt wannabe, but she’s always had quality material and has never really embarrassed herself musically. Loved her cover of Dire Straits’ “Water of Love” back in the Judds days. She’s got great taste and this new album proves that again. Kudos to Cactus for helping her take this leap. It fits her perfectly.
As for the Judds? Great songs but … Other than being the vessel for Ashley and Wynonna, I’ve never understood the purpose of Naomi.
FLYINGBURRITO2486
February 19, 2016 @ 7:02 am
I don’t understand what you mean. Ashley wasn’t a part of The Judds.
Mule
February 19, 2016 @ 7:06 am
Sorry. To clarify, I meant vessel as in she gave birth to Ashley and Wynonna.
murtry
February 19, 2016 @ 6:00 pm
The purpose of Naomi is the same as the purpose of Phil Everly to the Everly Brothers. To provide family harmony that’s an essential part of the band.
Marky Mark
February 19, 2016 @ 3:06 pm
Fuzzy never has anything nice to say.
Summer Jam
February 20, 2016 @ 2:31 am
I don’t like throwing insults, but Fuzzy, d00d, man, bro…..you are an idiot. Don’t talk shit about the Judds. I’m not even a fan of them and actually do not like their music AT ALL. But i was forced to grow up listening to them by my family….and calling them soul-less and “pop country” is absolutely absurd, ignorant, and not true in any way, shape, or form..
Banjo
February 18, 2016 @ 12:07 pm
Thank you for finally saying it Trigger!!! I wanted to for so long, but didn’t want to detract from any real conversation going on. Keep writing these articles for people who actually like to read them first, and then comment if they so choose.
Razor X
February 18, 2016 @ 12:08 pm
Is “Wynonna and The Big Noise” a new band or is this a one-off collaboration for this album?
Trigger
February 18, 2016 @ 12:22 pm
I’m not sure. It may be yet to be determined depending on how good this album does.
Judd
February 18, 2016 @ 1:27 pm
At fan fair last year I think they introduced it as wynonna and the big noise.
Bigfoot is Real (and is back from the mountain)
February 18, 2016 @ 12:19 pm
Jumpin’ Jeebus, I was absolutely floored at how good this is! I was thinkin’ “as much soul as the Staple Sisters”? No freakin’ way but the proof is in the tracks. And the production has just enough grit in all the right places. Cactus Moser, hmmm. Maybe like Dave Cobb, Moser will become another “go to” kinda guy.
Razor X
February 18, 2016 @ 12:27 pm
I haven’t bought a Wynonna Judd album since 1993’s Tell Me Why. Nothing she’s done since then has been very country or very interesting. This album isn’t very country, either — at least not what I’ve heard so far (I’m about about half way through) — but it is quite good. Whereas I found most of her music from the past 20 years to be rather bland, she sounds refreshed and engaged on this album. I really didn’t expect to like it very much; I’m pleasantly surprised.
Gena R.
February 18, 2016 @ 1:37 pm
I absolutely loved ‘Tell Me Why’! 🙂 I bought ‘Revelations’ when it came out about three years later, but I ended up not liking it nearly as much…
But yeah, I streamed this on First Listen a couple weeks ago and thought it was pretty good; I especially got a kick out of the cover of Julie Miller’s “You Make My Heart Beat Too Fast.”
Enjoy Every Sandwich
February 18, 2016 @ 12:32 pm
Thanks for the review. I wasn’t planning to check this out (at least not anytime soon) but now I think I will.
Tom Smith
February 18, 2016 @ 12:56 pm
That’s good stuff.
JW
February 18, 2016 @ 1:16 pm
I loved Cactus Moser and Highway 101 back in the day.
Jackie Treehorn
February 20, 2016 @ 11:11 am
Highway 101 had some good shit back in the day.
Smokey J.
February 18, 2016 @ 1:58 pm
She’s got a great voice, so when the material is up to par, I really enjoy her. I’m digging “Things that I lean on” and “Jesus and a Jukebox”.
Razor X
February 18, 2016 @ 2:22 pm
Those are my two favorites as well.
PETE MARSHALL
February 18, 2016 @ 2:10 pm
Great Review, Trig. I will buy this cd in the next few weeks.
Acca Dacca
February 18, 2016 @ 2:50 pm
My sister is a big Judds/Wynonna fan, so I might pick this up for her. I myself was intrigued enough to pay attention based on Trigger’s interesting review until he let it drop that this one isn’t really country. I’ll probably still give it a listen, but I like enough real country and non-country music to give a country artist that isn’t making country music too much of my time. However, if I end up liking it enough, I’ll eat my words.
——–
Side note, and I don’t wish to incur the wrath of Trigger as Fuzzy has (understandably so), but isn’t Wynonna something of a… well, bitch? The only reason I ask is because I have trouble stomaching “personal” music from artists that are a little less than admirable in character, as it casts a shadow over any genuine sentiment that might be there (at least for me). She played a show here at the University of Central Arkansas and my best friend worked the show. She pretty much treated the team like dirt, didn’t sign any autographs, and told them that they had to get people out of her way whenever she went to or from the venue. I’ll give anyone the benefit of the doubt for the first few offenses; she might have been having a bad day or not felt well. However, it was both irritating and hilarious that she was acting like she was something so special while playing at a public school basketball court. I’ve heard stories of similar behavior from her at CMA fest and the like as well, so I’m inclined to not think this was an isolated incident.
Razor X
February 18, 2016 @ 3:01 pm
I met her once at a charity benefit in Philadelphia where The Judds were part of the entertainment. It was in 1990 and right after Naomi had announced her retirement. All I can say is, they were both very nice and willing to sign autographs. Granted, it was a long time ago ….
Trigger
February 18, 2016 @ 3:12 pm
I think there’s all kinds of stories out there about Wynonna Judd. She was arrested for DUI, and has come out on record many times about her personal struggles in life. If that’s something that keeps you from her music, so be it. But I think she addresses some of those issues in the music of this record. There’s a lot of subject matter about the fallible nature of man here. If she’s a “bitch” now or in the past, I can’t really speak to that because I’ve never met her.
Acca Dacca
February 18, 2016 @ 3:39 pm
I know, I know: we build up pedestals and rip them down unceremoniously for each and every public figure, fair or not. And I’m well aware of your principle of judging the art first and leaving a person’s personal life to them alone. But as I said in your previous article about fans supporting artists before art, it’s kind of hard to separate the man from the myth (or woman, as it were). I know that I personally become invested in these people when I spend my time and money on them; who doesn’t? They become like extended family. When I figure out that my family isn’t who I thought they were, it kind of bothers me. And I try not to welcome in those that I already know are at odds for what I consider my personal principles.
But I’m not telling you anything you don’t already know. And if that point-of-view is immature or silly, so be it. Obviously I don’t and never will know or meet 99% of the artists whose work I enjoy on a daily basis, it’s merely my perception that they become like family and friends to fans. In this particular case and many others, I hate to pair it down to something as inconsequential to the art as whether someone is friendly or not, it’s just my sheepish way of asking whether I should invest myself in these people at all to begin with. That’s dumb, I know; no one should invest too much of themselves into people they don’t know, and I’m working on adopting your art first, personality second approach (thanks for introducing me to it). But at the moment it’s still a consideration, and it probably doesn’t help that my best friend was given the cold shoulder by her as I’m inclined to have my good friend’s back.
To be fair, though, nobody is perfect. I also already own two Judds records so it’s not like I’m boycotting Wynonna. Sorry about my train of thought coming off the rails or from left field so often. I might need to check and see if Ozzy Osbourne is the conductor.
Doug
February 19, 2016 @ 5:56 am
Thanks for this review and for posting the two videos — great stuff. I never listened to the Judds so have no baggage there, though you couldn’t escape the stories in the press. From a distance that all seemed like outtakes from the movie “Nashville” (which I hated). Re Wynonna’s past, the prominent mention of the 12 steps in the great song “Things I Lean On” suggests she’s dealing with her demons now (as is her co-writer, Jason Isbell, judging from various comments he’s made in interviews regarding his days in Drive By Truckers, etc.), so good for her. One thing that predisposes me to like this albumis the cover. Also appreciated the backstory provided in the review re Wynonna’s relationship with her husband.
Steve Reynolds
February 24, 2016 @ 7:46 pm
Saw Bono pull Wynonna up on stage at a U2 show in Murfreesboro, TN many years ago. Then saw her the next day at the local mall. Walked right up and asked her how that felt and she spent 10 minutes talking to a total stranger about the greatest thrill of her life. She’s no “diva”.
Toby in AK
February 18, 2016 @ 3:43 pm
I don’t usually make accusations like this but people are judging Wynonna on her looks and they have for a long time. I won’t make any fans, women or men by saying this and might even piss off Wynonna if she read it. Sorry for what I’m about to say, you’re voice makes you a glowing orange angel as far as I’m concerned. It ain’t cool to like an aging spray tanned try-hard “diva” who looked masculine even when she was young. It doesn’t help that she went into Celine Dion adult contemporary land as soon as she was out from under her mom’s direction. However, Wynonna’s singing ability and the SOUL in her voice are up there with Dolly Parton’s…. who can get away with looking trashy because she makes trashy look good.
Gumslasher
February 18, 2016 @ 3:46 pm
She comes of as a bellend, but the music is good. Enough said:) fuck em and feed em fruit loops.
Jen
February 18, 2016 @ 3:47 pm
No…just no. Those are awful!
Gumslasher
February 18, 2016 @ 3:59 pm
Nah, lazy shit Jen. You did not really listen to that first link did you. You might possibly not like it, but awful?
Smokey J.
February 18, 2016 @ 4:15 pm
Jen and Fuzzy have overdosed on Haterade.
Jen
February 18, 2016 @ 6:33 pm
Trigger, I did not sign on to be spoken to that way. I did not like the fucking songs. GTF over it!
Trigger
February 18, 2016 @ 7:03 pm
What do you want me to do? I already edited Gumslasher’s comment. You can’t come hear throwing shade and then complain when someone throws it back. Not sure why there’s this boiling hatred by some over this album. You don’t like it? Hey, that’s totally fair. But to act like there’s something unconscionable about this music is ridiculous.
Summer Jam
February 20, 2016 @ 7:08 pm
Jen if you don’t like what is being said on this site or you don’t like Kyle’s articles, THEN STAY OFF THE SITE! It’s that SIMPLE! I don’t always agree with what everyone says on here, but there is NO NEED to be DISRESPECTFUL. I’m not a fan of the Judds but you don’t see me leaving disrespectful comments do you?
Fuzzy TwoShirts
March 3, 2016 @ 3:05 pm
Yes
Summer Jam
March 3, 2016 @ 5:16 pm
You’re one to talk, buddy.
J Burke
February 18, 2016 @ 5:04 pm
Always thought it was nice of Wynonna to let her talentless mother on stage with her.
Tiffany
February 18, 2016 @ 5:27 pm
Love it, Trigg. Although, I like Ain’t No Thing better than Things that I Lean On. The Judds were one of the first country family acts that I literally was into. I love the fact that they were country, but middle of the road country. I was in high school at the time they came out, so that probably had something to do with it. And, it wasn’t because I didn’t like traditional country music, because I do like traditional country music. They just filled a need in my musical taste at the time.
Then when Wy went solo, I still liked her, but her solo stuff was a little bit popish. But, in conclusion, out the two tracks that I heard so far that you have provided I like the direction she is taking now with her music.
kevin
February 18, 2016 @ 5:56 pm
I think it’s really good (sorry no witty or edgy critique).
albert
February 18, 2016 @ 6:29 pm
Trigger…..your review of this record could not be more accurate , more explanatory or more RIGHT IMHO. This is a collection of songs and performances greater than the sum of their parts and will surprise some while baffling or just plain frustrating others . Bottom line is that I think this is a great record ….honest on all fronts …decidedly un-trendy , adventurous -but just enough-and , for me, unexpected , coming from Wy at this stage. Your guns -up rating says it all .
Robert S
February 19, 2016 @ 7:16 am
I can’t think of much to add to that opinion, because I am fully in agreement. I really like this.
Trigger
February 18, 2016 @ 7:06 pm
Look, in this album review I addressed how The Judds released a lot of pop country material. I addressed Wynonna’s personal demons and how they’ve played out in public. I said this album wasn’t very country. And I said how it wasn’t for everyone. So I’m not surprised that some people don’t like it for a host of reasons, but is this really music to get aggressively angry over?
Jen
February 18, 2016 @ 7:09 pm
Ok, first…I don’t like something, post my opinion, and I’m throwing shade? Second, to be told something with the word cut in it is ridiculous. I come here to read the articles and comment my opinions. I thought that was whatbtjis mother fucking site was for! My apologies if I was wrong. I guess I’ve stumbled on to another liberal site, where the only opinion that matters is the popular one. Fuck you! I will simply stop following your site. Pretty fucking sad, because I did like it. Now, you, along with the rest of the morons that can’t appreciate that I don’t like something, can all kiss my ass! Nkw, THAT was throwing shade!
Trigger
February 18, 2016 @ 7:17 pm
Jen,
Gumslasher’s comment was CENSORED. What he said is no longer there. As soon as the comment came in, I IMMEDIATELY censored it. I apologize for the rude language, but I didn’t use it, and I did my job as moderator by censoring it. And now I’m sure Gumslasher will get pissed because I censored his comment because that’s how these things go.
You left a very pointed, dismissive comment. I didn’t say you couldn’t leave the comment. Your comment is still up. Gumslasher’s got edited. You won. All I’m saying is if you’re going to be pointed and dismissive, don’t be surprised when someone fights back. I hope you continue to read Saving Country Music, but I fail to see what I’ve done wrong here, or how any of this is “liberal.”
Michael Cosner
February 19, 2016 @ 6:56 am
Im with you, Trigger. The most liberal thing you did was censor Gumslasher’s comment, which Jen wanted. Ironic, huh?
As far as Wynonna, I’ve never been a big fan of her or The Judds, but have always been a fan of Cactus’ playing and songwriting. His production here is solid.
baby wut did Lil Dale do? cuz u dont sound like u any mor
February 18, 2016 @ 9:22 pm
yea u tell em jen! an trigg u ole commie, thawt u wur in texas not russia
Banjo
February 19, 2016 @ 5:59 am
Damn – she mad. I hope she doesn’t stop following the site. I always loved trying to decode her comments. I have an easier time reading Lil Dale’s comments most of the time…
Jessie with the long hair
February 19, 2016 @ 9:07 am
Yes Jen, this liberal site always supports the popular opinions like how cool country radio is these days. We all jump on the liberal bandwagon to support “artists” like FGL, Luke Bryan, and Coke Swindell! Now you take your conservative Kacey Mushraves loving ass off this site. You probably like that tea party/right winger Steve Earl too!
Convict Charlie
February 18, 2016 @ 9:41 pm
Can’t say I’ve loved wy solo or even Naomi. I thought the Judds were a better sum of the two. “Things that I lean on” was so good and I’ll check out more of it. Good for her
Charlie
February 19, 2016 @ 5:17 am
Josey Wales: You have any food here?
Lone Watie: All I have is a piece of hard rock candy. But it’s not for eatin’. It’s just for lookin’ through.
Wynonna is not for lookin’ at. She’s just for listenin’ to. Sounds pretty good to me.
TheCheapSeats
February 19, 2016 @ 11:15 pm
I’ve been listening to the album while reading the article and the comments. About half way through. So, far it’s the best thing to come from Wynonna. Ever. Is it country in the traditional sense? Nah. Is it interesting musically? Yes. Is it good? Hell, yes.
Maybe the dull moments are at the end of the album. Haven’t found them personally, but I’m not done.
I wish more artists would make albums like this, with depth and texture. I can understand why this won’t be everyone’s cup of tea. But it’s right in my wheelhouse, I don’t the current song to end, but can’t wait to hear what the next one will bring.
Scott S.
February 20, 2016 @ 1:21 am
Never was a fan of the Judds, and not much for Wynnona either. What I have liked from her in the past has been her bluesy stuff because it fits her voice.
I like this album.
Bertox
February 20, 2016 @ 12:22 pm
News flash: If you don’t want to be insulted or “talked to like that,” it might be in your best interest to never post any opinion ANYWHERE on the internet. P.S. Wynona rocks!
Hayley
February 21, 2016 @ 5:36 am
“Things That I Lean On” is incredible. I love the approach they took with production, the lyrics are beautiful and simple, and I believed EVERY NOTE Wynonna sang. Awesome post Trigger! I’ll be downloading this one!
Collin
February 21, 2016 @ 9:17 pm
Is this not a music review? So tragic that people make this about themselves, their personal opinions, and speculation. Oh she’s a bitch, she’s masculine, blah, blah. Shameful behavior on any level…this is just SAD! She made an album that she likes and is “refreshed”…don’t like it, then piss off, seriously.
Tina
February 22, 2016 @ 5:09 am
I preordered it! It’s awesome and about time ! Whoop, whoop, can’t wait to see the show! Xo