Amish Couple Ben & Rose Become One of 2025’s New Breakouts

Reviews 27 Comments


One of the biggest breakout performers in country music in 2025 is perhaps one of the most unlikely in the genre’s history. Nobody could have predicted that an Old Order Amish couple could become a viral sensation. But that’s what Pennsylvania’s Ben & Rose have done.

The rise of Ben & Rose is counterintuitive to everything we think we know about virality, social media algorithms, and the other modes of success in the modern era of music. Ben & Rose only appear in the online world thanks to their producer and fellow musician Conrad Fisher. But that’s also what is so appealing about what Ben & Rose are doing. It’s wholesome, it’s authentic, it’s uncorrupted by the sticky residues of the modern music business. It’s simply a young married couple singing from the heart.

Record labels are pursuing them. Booking agents want to sign them up and put them on big tours. But they’re not really interested in all of that. Ben & Rose just want to sing, and people simply want to hear them.

“They stepped in front of a microphone and immediately had a career,” says Conrad Fisher. “But Ben doesn’t really want a career in music. He wants to be a stone mason. He does like singing, and he’ll do it on the weekends. That part of it is really beautiful and refreshing for me because they just want to make music, which is so rare.”

As a musician from Pennsylvania Amish country, Fisher would often interact with Amish teenagers going through “Rumspringa”—a time around the Amish 16th birthday where they’re allowed to bend the strict rules of Amish life before either committing to become part of the church, or being “shunned” by leaving it. The term translates to “running around” in Pennsylvania German.

Conrad Fisher runs a studio at Ragamuffin Hall in McCoysville, Pennsylvania, which is an old church built in 1871 where Fisher also holds performances. In 2024, Ben’s brother called Conrad up and paid for studio time for the duo. When they released the song and video for the old country standard “Slowly But Surely” on December 1st, 2024, it immediately started going viral. The video now has accrued over 3 million views.


But that is just the beginning. Ben & Rose’s cover of “If Teardrops Were Pennies” has 4.2 million views. “Lord I Don’t Need a Mansion” has 2.5 million views, and “When You Say Nothing At All” has 1.1 million.

And this is not just an internet phenomenon. Based off of this success, Ben & Rose booked shows at The Blue Gate in Shipshewana, IN, on May 14th, 2026, and the American Music Theater in Lancaster, PA on August 2nd. Both shows are nearly sold to capacity.

The success of Ben & Rose in undeniable, but the biggest question most outside observers have is how are they able to do all of this when Old Order Amish rules disallow the use of modern appliances, the Internet, etc.?

It turns out that the Amish Church in Lancaster county is going through a transition, with one group wanting to remain strictly conservative and follow all the Old Amish rules, and another that wants to relax the rules a little bit to allow things like the use of phones and vehicles in certain important work-related situations, and to allow things like what Ben & Rose are doing with their music.

In this restructuring, a grace period has opened up where members of the Amish community can join a more reformed church without being “shunned.” It’s within this transitional period that Ben & Rose have started releasing videos on a regular basis, and released the 12-song album Slowly But Surely in August.

The acceptance of what Ben & Rose are doing within the Amish community has been mixed for some according to Conrad Fisher, but they have also been very cautious and purposeful with how they are approaching their music. “For the most part, [their community] does embrace this,” Fisher says. “They’re just very careful. Their priority is their family, and they just don’t want to get themselves into something that they regret.”

That is one of the reasons Ben & Rose have only committed to two live shows in 2026 at this point. If they perform live and feel it’s something they want to do more of, perhaps it will be a regular occurrence for the married couple. But they don’t want to let anyone down by booking an entire tour they might not want to play—though they could, and likely would pack theaters in many markets.


Their producer Conrad Fisher is a big key to navigating this complicated, if not unprecedented moment for an Old Amish couple. Fisher’s parents grew up Amish themselves, eventually leaving the church, and joining a Mennonite congregation where Fisher grew up. Conrad still attends a Mennonite church, and though he might not follow all the rules on avoiding modern technology, he also lives a clean life where they don’t really have cause to kick him out.

“I’m a man of faith, so I’m going to go to church,” Fisher says.

In Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, Ben & Rose are outright stars, and get recognized at the grocery store, public events, etc. As successful as the Ben & Rose project has been over the last year, they’re still mostly singing cover songs at this point, even if they’re doing so at an elite level that is clearly resonating well beyond Pennsylvania, and even The United States.

Now the next goal for Conrad Fisher is to start co-writing with them to see what they can come up with. Fisher wrote “Lord I Don’t Need a Mansion” for Ben & Rose, and adapted “The Robin and the Eggs” from an old Amish folk tune to give their music some more originality. But it’s been his ability to navigate the complex rules and community surrounding the Old Amish Order, respect Ben & Rose’s wishes, but also get the music to the masses that has resulted in their unlikely success.

“At first, they didn’t want to release videos,” Fisher says.“I made the ‘Slowly But Surely’ video just for them to have. But after it did so well and the rules of the church started to loosen, by March they wanted to start releasing video on a more regular basis. This then led to wanting to release an album, and take the pursuit of music more seriously.”

Ben & Rose have no rock ‘n roll fantasy to live out. They never expected to do anything with music aside from singing for themselves and their family. It just turns out that Ben & Rose had something the world beyond their Amish community was yearning to hear.

– – – – – – –

If you found this article valuable, consider leaving Saving Country Music A TIP.


© 2025 Saving Country Music

,