Country Music’s Greatest Concept Albums of All Time
In the music world, some consider country as a creative lightweight. I guess they think you can’t get much imagination out of three chords and the truth. That was on display recently when the once mighty Rolling Stone could only find one true country record to include in their supposed best concept albums of all time.
But concept albums have been an integral part of country music history, with the release of certain projects completely reshaping the country music paradigm, including in recent memory. And with the way cohesive story lines are often used in concept albums—and the way story is so important to country songs—one could put country right up there with prog rock when it comes to the perfect genre for releasing a captivating song cycle.
So just in case you need an illustration of the breadth and importance of concept albums in country music, or want to complete your record collection with some of the best of them, find the Top 11 country concept albums below, along with a more detailed compendium of country concept records through the years below that.
PLEASE NOTE: Like every list, the intent is to fill in the gaps in your body of knowledge. If you think there is an album missing or you want to share top country concept albums, by all means, please pipe up in the comments section. But whiners saying “This list sucks because so and so is not included” or “This list sucks because so and so is included” can go kiss a duck. This is a list on the internet compiled and posted for free, not a “Where’s Waldo” exercise.
11. Slackeye Slim – El Santo Grial: La Pistola Piadosa (2011)
El Santo Grial is about a man, and a gun. It is a concept or theme-based album that follows Drake Savage, a man torn by religion, told since he was a boy that he was “The Chosen One,” but conflicted by his desire to see proof of a higher power. That proof is eventually bestowed one day in the form of a legendary gun for which the album is named. El Santo Grial is a masterpiece, exquisitely produced, arranged, and performed. This is a patient, uncompromising album. You can tell time was never introduced into this project as a goal. The goal was to flesh out Slackeye’s vision without ever settling for second best, and that goal was accomplished.
The music is a wild mix of Western, old-school Spanish, and cowboy narratives. In some spots it probably is better described as simply poetry with a music bed. Think of the score from the film The Good, The Bad, & The Ugly, with some Dick Dale flair and Johnny Cash imagery. This album is full of textures and layers, yet conveys a tremendous amount of space at the same time. Many of the sounds of this album are harsh and biting—lots of percussion, gong bangs, horse braying—but it is a well-mixed mixed and mastered album to the point where the recording concepts become as important of an asset to the music as the words and instrumentation. The sharp sounds, the contrast, and the space is what transports you to the setting where the album transpires: in dusty, gritty, wide open spaces. You get completely immersed into the landscapes this album inspires in the human imagination. (read full review)
10. Paul Kennerley & Various Artists – White Mansions (1978)
Paul Kennerley wasn’t from the American South. He wasn’t even from North America. The North West England native was an advertising lackey living in London at the time he heard his first piece of country music at the age of 28. It was Waylon Jennings’ “Let’s All Help The Cowboys Sing The Blues,” and it changed his life. Two years later he would release one of country music’s most compelling, yet most overlooked concept albums with none other than Waylon Jennings himself in a lead role. Waylon’s wife Jessi Colter, along with Eric Clapton, and John Dillon and Steve Cash of the Ozark Mountain Daredevils also came along for the ride, telling the story of the South during the Civil War through the perspective of four white Southerners.
White Mansions isn’t Civil War music. There’s no field drums or fiddles or banjos. There’s a few moments that are inspired by the sounds of music from the mid 1800’s, including a choir of free slaves. But overall this is a late 70’s Outlaw country record at the height of that style and influence, especially in the style of Waylon Jennings. The bass guitar is extra loud on many tracks. There’s ample electric guitar. And the album has that warm feel of all those old school Outlaw country records from the period, including some songs set to half time beats.
Like all concept records, the songs together equal something greater than the sum of their parts. All of the tracks are entertaining, but some fulfill their role of forwarding the story thread first. The tracks in the center of the album are the ones that work best standing alone, from the up tempo and rowdy “Southern Boys” sung by Steve Cash, to the slow and droning “The Southland’s Bleeding,” which is a good example as any of Waylon’s classic sound from the period, enhanced by the presence of Eric Clapton on guitar who appears on numerous White Mansions tracks as part of the studio crew. (read full review)
9. Emmylou Harris – The Ballad of Sally Rose (1985)
The Ballad of Sally Rose is an important concept record for numerous reasons. First, it’s one of the few concept albums recorded by a woman in country music history. Second, it’s the only album in the career of Emmylou Harris where she wrote or co-wrote all of the songs. And third, the concept revolved around the character Sally Rose, who was a singer whose mentor and lover was a troubled, hard-living and alcoholic musician who died while on the road, mirroring Emmylou’s own experience with Gram Parsons.
The Ballad of Sally Rose came about when Emmylou Harris was married to British musician Paul Kennerley, who was also the mastermind of the critically-acclaimed concept record White Mansions from 1978, as well as the The Ballad of Jesse James from 1980. Kennerley once again was the visionary behind the project, both producing it, and co-writing all of the songs with Emmylou.
The album also featured an all-star cast of contributors that included fellow Trio members Dolly Parton and Linda Ronstadt on harmony vocals along with Gail Davies, and Vince Gill and Waylon Jennings on guitar. Yes, Vince Gill and Waylon did appear on a record together. Unfortunately for Emmylou, the album was considered a commercial flop, though the single “White Line” did decent at #14. It also received a Grammy nomination. But like so many concept records, time has considered The Ballad of Sally Rose more fondly than it was when it was released.
8. Willie Nelson – Phases and Stages (1974)
Many consider this the first definitive concept record of Willie Nelson’s career, and to some, it is Willie’s best. The album narrates the story of a divorce, with the first side telling the woman’s side, and the second side telling the man’s, with the “Phases and Stages (Theme)” mixed throughout the tracks, solidifying it as a truly conceptualized work.
The album came about after Willie Nelson was signed to Atlantic Records by producer Jerry Wexler, who was starting a country division for the label. Shotgun Willie was released right before Phases and Stages, and recorded in the same year as Atlantic’s first foray into country. Leaving RCA and the Chet Atkins Universe on Music Row is what allowed Willie Nelson the latitude to make Phases and Stages like he wanted to.
Phases and Stages was a commercial flop, despite “Bloody Mary Morning” becoming a signature song for Willie, and hitting #17 in the charts—his biggest hit up to that point in his career. After the album, Atlantic Records closed its country music division, and Willie signed with Columbia. But the album was the prototype to Red Headed Stranger, which would become Willie Nelson’s opus.
7. Hank Williams III – Straight To Hell (2006)
There are albums that are a hoot to listen to, and there are albums that sell lots of copies. And then there are albums that help completely reshape music into something different than what it was before they were released. Whether these records are recognized by the wide population or not, they’re the projects that change music as we know it, broaden possibilities, and become so influential that the music can be heard in the bones of countless other albums and songs spanning well into the future. Hank3’s Straight To Hell was one of those albums.
We talk today about how technology has put the power of music back in the hands of artists. Hank3’s Straight to Hell was arguably the first record to illustrate this truth in country music at large. Recorded on a piece of consumer electronics—a Korg D-1600 digital workstation—it put the power of budget and production into the hands of Hank3. Along with being the first truly DIY album to be released in the country music industry proper, it was also the first album released under the CMA umbrella to include a parental advisory sticker.
But the most lasting legacy of Straight to Hell is the music itself. Angry, raw, explicit, but also erudite in its own way, Straight to Hell set a creative high watermark that arguably has yet to be attained again in country. Many fans only focus on the candid and raw lyricism about drug use and other explicit themes. But Straight to Hell was a concept record through and through. The songs of hard living, while making an excellent gateway for escapism and character creation, lead to the last song on the first album, the 6-minute “Angel of Sin” that resolves in the wisdom of how the lives of it’s characters lead to a dead end. (read full review)
6. Marty Stuart – The Pilgrim (1999)
In 1999, Marty Stuart was at a crossroads. He still had his signature black hair and some semblance of a mainstream career, but the gray was filling in and he was quickly being forgotten by radio. He still was using The Rock & Roll Cowboys as his backing band. It wouldn’t be until his next album that Stuart would saddle up with his long-standing and current outfit The Fabulous Superlatives. The album was his last with MCA Nashville and an opportunity for Marty to do what he wanted, free of the commercial worry of a major label breathing down his neck about delivering on their investment. This brew of circumstances resulted in arguably the Philadelphia, Mississippi native’s crowning opus.
What some don’t know about The Pilgrim, even some of its apostles, is that the linear narrative of the album is based on a true story from Marty Stuart’s hometown. It begins with a man named Norman, characterized as “cross-eyed” but still able to land the town’s most beautiful woman by the name of Rita. When Norman becomes jealous and protective of Rita, she takes to the arms of “The Pilgrim,” who doesn’t know that Rita is married. When Norman finds out about the relationship, he commits suicide, and filled with guilt, The Pilgrim takes to traveling, ending up on the West Coast before returning eventually to be with Rita once more.
Along this journey, Marty Stuart takes the role of Norman, and other characters as he narrates the theme. Helping Marty unfurl the story of The Pilgrim is one of the most impressive collection of legendary country music names this side of the Nitty Gritty Dirt Band’s “Will The Circle Be Unbroken” session. The indelible voice of Emmylou Harris greets listeners early in the album, assuring that The Pilgrim will be full of surprises, turns, and towering contributions. Pam Tillis, George Jones, Ralph Stanley, Earl Scruggs, and Marty’s former boss and father-in-law Johnny Cash also contribute, with Cash helping to conclude the album with a haunting performance. (read full review)
5. Johnny Cash – Bitter Tears: Ballads of the American Indian (1964)
Johnny Cash spent his career speaking out against injustices, and specifically when it came to the Americana Indian. There is no better example of this than his 1964 concept record that was ahead of its time, and highly influential in drawing attention to the plight of America’s native people. Many of the songs were written by folk singer Peter LaFarge, but Johnny Cash contributed a few of his own, along with a song he co-wrote with Johnny Horton.
Bitter Tears dealt directly with issues facing Native Americans such as the loss of Seneca nation land in Pennsylvania and New York State. Most popular from the album was the song “The Ballad of Ira Hayes,” which became a hit, despite the initial reluctance of radio stations to play it. Johnny Cash took the ignoring of the song personally, reaching into his own pocket to pay for promotional records to be sent out to radio stations, and placing a print ad calling into question the credibility of radio for not playing it. The song eventually went to #3. Ira Hayes was a Marine of Pima descent that participated in the famous flag raising on Iwo Jima during World War II.
The album set a precedent in country music for concept records, and was one of numerous conceptualized efforts Johnny Cash released.
4. Sturgill Simpson – Metamodern Sounds in Country Music (2014)
With Metamodern Sounds in Country Music, Sturgill Simpson didn’t just capture our ears, he captured our imaginations. However misguided the notion may be, most every disenfranchised country music fan harbors the idea that at some point a country artist is going to come along that is so good and so important, they will tip tip the country music scales back in the right direction. This is exactly what Metamodern Sounds did. It gave the true country music listener hope beyond the happiness the music conveyed, and it resolved that ever-present conflict between sticking to the traditional sound of country music, but progressing it forward.
Metamodern Sounds was the greatest, and most influential record released in the last 10 years in country music—mainstream, independent, or otherwise. It had Keith Urban wearing a Sturgill Simpson shirt on American Idol. It very directly influenced Chris Stapleton to record Traveller, and the way he wanted. It launched Dave Cobb into the stratosphere as a producer. It shattered the ceiling for non radio-supported artists such as Tyler Childers, Cody Jinks, and Zach Bryan to come later and compete with their mainstream counterparts.
Sturgill Simpson defined the pinnacle and what was relevant in the here and now of independent country music for decades to come. And he did it from the sheer strength of this album. Metamodern Sounds also inspired a new generation of country music concept albums that would be recorded and released in greater frequency in the coming years. (read full review)
3. Marty Robbins – Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs (1959)
People take for granted that when Marty Robbins commenced his signing career, he was mostly known for his teeny bopper crossover material like “A White Sport Coat” and “She Was Only Seventeen.” But by the end of the 50s, Robbins had found enough success to be able to flex his creative muscles and do what he wanted, which was write and record songs in the Western traditions he grew up with in Arizona. So in a single eight-hour session on April 7th, 1959, Marty Robbins recorded Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs, and not only delivered a country concept record for the ages, but one of the greatest country and Western albums of all time.
Unlike some other song cycles, Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs had hits, especially “El Paso,” which became a #1 song in both country and pop, and ultimately, Marty’s signature song. “Big Iron” was also a big hit, and a song that is still widely covered today. So many of the songs of the album eventually became standards in the Western music canon, with the Western Writers of America including six of the songs in their Top 100 Western Songs of all time, including ones that Marty wrote himself like “El Paso” and “Big Iron.”
The album was so successful, More Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs was released as a followup the next year, which unfortunately failed to find the same traction or reception. Nonetheless, the original has gone down in history, and has almost single-handedly kept the Western influence in country music alive for generations.
2. Nitty Gritty Dirt Band – Will The Circle Be Unbroken (1972)
The cultural and generational divide running right through the middle of country music has always been the ever-present point of hostilities between traditionalists and innovators for going on a century. In 1972, the progressive country rock outfit with a hippie look known as the Nitty Gritty Dirt Band devised a way to bridge this generational divide, and the result was one of the most important albums in country music history.
The Nitty Gritty Dirt Band took a bunch of old standard country songs, and invited some of the most traditionally-minded oldtimers in country music still around to collaborate with them. This included Roy Acuff, Jimmy Martin, “Mother” Maybelle Carter, Doc Watson, Earl Scruggs, Randy Scruggs, Merle Travis, Pete “Oswald” Kirby, and Norman Blake. Roy Acuff originally wanted no part of it, calling them “a bunch of long-haired West Coast boys,” but later relented and was happy for it. Bill Monroe held his ground, and refused to participate.
The result was a cross generational masterpiece that bridged the old with the new at a time when the Countrypolitan sound was all the rage in country music. In some respects, it was country music’s first “neotraditional” record. And since everything was recorded live with either the first or second takes with the studio banter left on the tracks, it came with a live feel that put the audience right in the room. Along with being an enjoyable listen, Will The Circle Be Unbroken is also the template of how to preserve country music tradition, while also pushing it forward.
Volume Two was released in 1989 and won the CMA’s Album of the Year and three Grammy Awards. Volume Three was released in 2002.
1. Willie Nelson – Red Headed Stranger (1975)
This is not only the greatest country music concept record of all time, it is the greatest country record of all time, period—at least according to many accounts and assessments over the years. Similar to many of the other most important country music albums, the magic of Red Headed Stranger was not just relegated to the music itself, but the impact it had on country music at large. Recorded on a shoestring budget at Autumn Sound Studios in Garland, Texas, Willie’s label Columbia Records initially regarded it as a demo. But since Willie had earned creative control over his music, he was able to release it as he wanted. It made Willie Nelson a superstar at the age of 42, and changed country music forever.
A cinematic tale about a red headed preacher who kills his wife and her lover before going on the run, Willie Nelson wrote it to be like a movie, which wouldn’t come about until 11 years later. But Red Headed Stranger also made Willie Nelson so popular, he was able to launch an acting career as part of its success. It also earned Willie Nelson his first ever #1 single in “Blue Eyes Crying in the Rain,” written by Fred Rose. Willie had never even had a Top 10 single before. But it was the entire album that the public consumed in its cohesive story line, and fell in love with Willie.
Not only has Red Headed Stranger inspired scores of other concept albums in country music and beyond, it’s also inspired concept albums based upon Red Headed Stranger specifically—albums like Sturgill Simpson’s The Ballad of Dood and Juanita.
There was country music before Red Headed Stranger, and country music after Red Headed Stranger. And country music after Red Headed Stranger was better, more loose, more open, and it was all thanks to Willie.
More Country Concept Records
Ashley McBryde – Ashley McBryde Presents: Lindeville (2022) – You could consider Lindeville just as much like a stage production as you could a studio album, with the cast of characters unfolding before you as the songs transpire. Composed around the characters of a fictional town named after the influential songwriter Dennis Linde, Ashley McBryde is joined by songwriters Aaron Raitiere, Brandy Clark, Caylee Hammack, Connie Harrington, Benjy Davis, Pillbox Patti (Nicolette Hayford), and Brothers Osborne.
Brandy Clark – 12 Stories (2013) – Though not as overt of a concept record as many, Brandy Clark builds the album out via 12 vignettes of characters all trying to escape their lives. This is the album that codified Brandy Clark as a premier songwriter in mainstream country. (read review)
Corb Lund – Horse Soldier! Horse Soldier! (2007) – Alberta, Canada’s Corb Lund is one of the artists helping to keep the Western influence of country music alive, and in this concept record paying tribute to cavalry men throughout history, his bridges his love for horses and heroes into an immersive experience.
Dave Cobb (& Friends) – Southern Family (2016) – Partly inspired by the 1978 Civil War concept album White Mansions, Dave Cobb took the burgeoning stable of artists he was working with, and created an album that featured Morgane Stapleton (with Chris Stapleton), Holly Williams, Jamey Johnson, Miranda Lambert, Rich Robinson (The Black Crowes), Zac Brown, Jason Isbell, Anderson East, and Brent Cobb. The release of the album helped establish Dave Cobb as independent country and Americana’s premier producer.
Drive-By Truckers – Southern Rock Opera (2000) – Though more Southern rock than country, it nonetheless is considered the definitive work by many from the Drive-By Truckers. Tackling the duality of the Southern identity by both being proud of the heritage and conflicted by the history, this double album put the Drive-By Truckers on the map.
Hank Williams III – Ghost to a Ghost / Guttertown (2011) – Hank Williams III tried to revitalize the creative song cycle he achieved with Straight to Hell with mixed results. Centered around “Guttertown” and a voodoo lady named “Musha,” this 30-song album that also featuring Hank3’s dog Trooper and Ray Lawrence Jr. at times felt more like a hard drive dump than an album. But a few gems can be found from digging through.
Hellbound Glory – Streets of Aberdeen (2018) – Aberdeen, Washington is where Kurt Cobain is originally from, as is Leroy Virgil of Hellbound Glory. Also from Aberdeen was Billy Grohl—an alleged serial killer. Taking inspiration from the ghosts that lurk in his hometown, Leroy Virgil created this concept record showcasing his stellar songwriting.
Jason Boland and the Stragglers – The Light Saw Me (2021) – Made of three distinctive interlocking parts, the album follows a cowboy living in Texas in the 1890s who is abducted by aliens and ends up back in Texas in the 1990s. It’s partially inspired by the story of a rumored UFO crash in Aurora, Texas on April 17, 1897 before most folks even knew what a UFO was. (read more)
Johnny Cash – Songs of Our Soil (1959) – Considered by some as Johnny Cash’s first concept record of many, the premature death of his brother had Cash pondering the meaning of death, and weaving it into all of the songs of the album.
Johnny Cash – Ride This Train (1960) – Johnny Cash’s eight studio album became one of the first fully recognized country concept records, with spoken dialog before the tracks that featured different locations and people from around the United States in a travelogue narrative. Though these locations were all hypothetically visited by train, train songs aren’t what the album is about.
Johnny Cash – The Rambler (1977) – Another traveling concept album by Johnny Cash, but this one goes by car, including dialogue with hitchhikers picked up along the way. The Rambler is also significant because it was the last Johnny Cash album where he wrote every track.
Joshua Ray Walker – Wish You Were Here (2019), Glad You Made It (2020), See You Next Time (2021) – Though not exactly conceptualized individually, this three album concept revealed itself to be about the various characters one may encounter in a bar, and was an auspicious opening for this critically-acclaimed songwriter.
Kathy Mattea – Coal (2008) – Though all the songs on the album were covers, the West Virginia native decided to find the best songs about coal, and put them all into a concept album that won high critical praise. Recorded in tribute to her grandfathers who were both coal miners, and inspired by the Sago Mine disaster in 2006, Coal has come to be known as a defining piece of country music, produced by Marty Stuart.
Kenny Rogers and the First Edition – The Ballad of Calico (1972) – Based around the real-life town of Calico, California, all members of The First Edition took turns singing songs, portraying various characters from the town through songs written by Michael Martin Murphey and Larry Cansler. The album came with a 15-page booklet, with all the band members dressed in period, and a map of the town. It was recorded at Glaser Studios in Nashville, which later became known as Hillbilly Central, aka the home of Outlaw country.
Kenny Rogers – Giddeon (1980) – Some people strangely regard Kenny Rogers as a creative lightweight since he so successfully crossed over into pop. But an album like Giddeon turns that assessment on its head. Starting with the revelation that the main characters Giddeon is dead, it looks back on the life of a Texas cowboy in retrospect. It also includes the hit song “Don’t Fall in Love with a Dreamer,” sung with the co-writer of the album, Kim Carnes.
Kris Kristofferson – Spooky Lady’s Sideshow (1974) – Though there has been some dispute over the years of whether to consider this a concept album or not, Kristofferson’s songs on the album were all about the decline brought about by drug and alcohol abuse. The album also saw a decline in Kristofferson’s commercial appeal, which often happens with concept albums.
Kyle Nix – Lightning on the Mountain (2020) – The fiddle player from the Turnpike Troubadours made an auspicious solo debut during the band’s hiatus with this ambitious concept record with interludes and elements inspired by the Spaghetti Western sounds of Ennio Morricone. It is an adventurous, varied, and diverse effort that keeps you on your toes for 17 tracks. (read review)
Lindi Ortega – Liberty (2018) – It isn’t just about Western scoundrels and bloodthirsty revenge. It’s about the struggles we all go through to arrest control of our own destinies, to face down demons sometimes of which exist just as much within ourselves as apparitions of the outside world, and ultimately prevail through the perseverance of our efforts, just as Lindi Ortega did in this sweeping epic. (read review)
Maddie & Tae – The Way It Feels (2020) – Though more of a “soft” concept record than a true song cycle, it follows the arc of a romantic relationship, from meeting, to falling in love, and eventually breaking up. Unfortunately, label Mercury Nashville broke the project up into two EPs first, but the duo finally got it to market the way they envisioned it.
Mamma Coal – Raven Haired Vixen (2016) – Singer and songwriter Carra Stasney previously of the duo Copper and Coal re-imagines Willie Nelson’s Red Headed Stranger into an epic of her own, inspired by her true life love for her son, and the maternal bond that holds creation together and ensures that life moves forward. (read review)
Paul Kennerly – The Legend of Jesse James (1980) – Known best for his White Mansions concept album, Kennerly followed it up with this study into America’s most notorious bank and train robber. It features songs sung by Johnny Cash, Charlie Daniels, Emmylou Harris, Rosanne Cash, Albert Lee, Rodney Crowell, and Levon Helm of The Band.
Porter Wagoner – Confessions of a Broken Man (1966) – The Bottom of a Bottle (1968) – Skid Row Joe Down in the Alley (1970) – This was a series of records all portraying the otherwise dapper Porter Wagoner in the persona of Skid Row Joe, with songs about the downtrodden side of life. Though some of the songs on the albums were covers of previous country songs, they still deserve the concept distinction with the way Porter brought an entire character to life through them. Also interesting to note, Porter portrayed Skid Row Joe on the album covers himself. The fictional Skid Row Joe lived in the famous alley between the Ryman Auditorium, and the Lower Broadway honky tonks like Tootsie’s in Nashville.
Sturgill Simpson – A Sailor’s Guide to Earth (2016) – A Sailor’s Guide to Earth is a record Sturgill Simpson wrote for his young son who was born right as Metamodern Sounds in Country Music was being released. He uses the record to directly impart wisdom and knowledge to his young son, as well as delve into a bit of his own history as a former member of the Navy, and his perils with drugs. (read review)
Sturgill Simpson – The Ballad of Dood and Juanita (2021) – The culmination of Sturgill Simpson’s five album career was a return to his traditional country roots. Dood is a half breed whose father was a mountain man and mother was Shawnee. Juanita is the apple of Dood’s eye. Based loosely around Sturgill’s grandparents, it was Sturgill’s Red Headed Stranger in a career of concept records. (read review)
Terry Allen – Juarez (1975) – Few carried the creative spark of Lubbock, TX farther into a conceptualized version of country music than Juarez by Terry Allen. Just as akin to a Cormac McCarthy trilogy novel as Red Headed Stranger, it evoked the strange brew of the Texas border and all the intrigue that the region encompasses.
Waylon Jennings – A Man Called Hoss (1987) – A concept record that came together like an autobiography of Waylon’s life, it consisted of ten chapters (songs): “Childhood,” “Texas,” “First Love,” “Lost Love,” “Nashville,” “Crazies,” “Drugs,” “Jessi,” “Reflections,” and “The Beginning.” Though you do get glimmers of the Waylon Jennings backstory, his 1996 actual autobiography is much more complete.
Willie Nelson – Texas In My Soul (1968) – In a career full of concept records, this was officially Willie Nelson’s first. Built around paying tribute to Texas, it was part of his effort with producer Chet Atkins to draw attention to Willie’s recording career, which despite of his success as a songwriter for others, meandered in obscurity in the late 60s.
Willie Nelson – Yesterday’s Wine (1971) – Written and recorded during a tumultuous time in Willie Nelson’s life after a divorce and a move back to Texas, he showed up In Nashville with no material written, and no real plan. Over two day he wrote the album, and combined it with older songs of his like “Family Bible” to make the story of an imperfect man from birth to death. Willie had been reading a lot of religious and spiritual material at the time that inspired the album, including The Bible.
Woody Guthrie – Dust Bowl Ballads (1940) – Considered one of the first concept albums ever in any genre, and released at a time when singles an 78s dominated music, Woody centers all of the songs around the Dust Bowl period in the United States, and its effect on the country and its people. Though mostly considered a folk record, it’s influence on country was also significant.
Other Country Concept Albums:
Ben Nichols – Last Pale Light in the West
David Allan Coe – Requiem for a Harlequin
Drew Kennedy – Marathon (2022) and Fresh Water in the Salton Sea (2011)
The Heavy Horses – Murder Ballads and Other Love Songs (2012)
James Steinle – What I Came Here For (2020)
Merle Travis – Folk Songs of the Hills (1947)
Other Pseudo Country Concept Albums:
Willie Nelson’s Tougher Than Leather (1983) and Charley Crockett’s The Man From Waco (2022) were both sold as concept albums, but listeners have generally failed to recognize what the concept is, so their distinction as concept records are in dispute.
Marty Stuart‘s Way Out West (2017) was not sold as a concept album, but some consider it as one.
Rosanne Cash‘s 3-time Grammy winner The River and the Thread (2013) has been called a concept album by some.
Jamey Johnson‘s double album The Guitar Song dealt with darkness on the first disc, and light on the second, making it semi-conceptualized.
Though perhaps more rock than country, Desperado by The Eagles deserves honorary mention.
Black Ribbons by Shooter Jennings was definitely a concept album built around conspiracy theories, as was Sturgill Simpson’s Sound & Fury, but neither is exactly country.
Joseph J
October 19, 2022 @ 8:22 am
Another worth mentioning, Corb Lund’s “Horse Soldier! Horse Soldier!”
The album highlights horses (obviously) and their use as calvary steed throughout the history of war.
Trigger
October 19, 2022 @ 9:26 am
Gross oversight that’s been added.
bigcityhick
October 31, 2022 @ 9:31 am
I’ve always thought of Jean Shepherd’s album, Songs of a Love Affair, from 1956 to be one of the first concept albums and it’s a great one IMHO.
Cody
October 19, 2022 @ 8:38 am
Always loved Bobby Bare’s oft overlooked “Hard Time Hungrys,” heavy again on Silverstein songs that all chronicle the down and out…
Trigger
October 19, 2022 @ 8:45 am
Yeah, I kind of struggled on whether that should be considered a “concept” album, though I wouldn’t necessarily argue against it. I’ve always regarded it as one of Bare’s tributes to Shel Silverstein more than a true song cycle.
Red Barrons
October 19, 2022 @ 11:36 am
Came here to say exactly this! I would consider it absolutely a concept album as the entire thing is related to the “down and out” of the early 80s recession. My all time favorite, and, I believe, most underrated Bobby Bare album of all time.
As much as I love Charley Pride, Bobby’s version of Able Bodied Man hits the soul way harder. Especially compared to the “jangly”, happy take tried by Charley.
Red Barrons
October 19, 2022 @ 11:45 am
Early/mid 70s recession. Damn phone…
Makar
October 20, 2022 @ 12:00 am
I quite like porter wagoner’s “the cold hard facts of life”
Also, I presume you didn’t think of it to not even give it an honourable mention, but I adore Johnny cash’s “Ride this Train”.
Trigger
October 20, 2022 @ 7:04 am
Johnny Cash’s “Ride This Train” is on there.
RyanPD
October 19, 2022 @ 8:38 am
Bra on, bra on
Country Charley Crockett's Butter
October 21, 2022 @ 5:34 am
Haus, we’ll need a bigger boat.
And remember, Tex is in the oil business.
Country Charley Crockett's Butter
October 21, 2022 @ 8:04 pm
Oops. I replied to the wrong comment. Sorry @RyanPD
WKU Grad
October 19, 2022 @ 8:45 am
Love “Juarez” & “Lubbock On Everything”. Would’ve put Juarez at #2. Personal preference though.
brz
October 20, 2022 @ 5:01 pm
Terry Allen is phenomenal. Juarez definitely deserves a mention here. And Lubbock, and Salivation… I guess almost everything he’s released has a pretty cohesive theme that could earn it a place on a “best concept albums” list
Howard
October 19, 2022 @ 8:46 am
Another “pseudo-concept” album by Rosanne Cash was her 1991 “Interiors,” songs all tied — closely or loosely — to her crumbling marriage to Rodney Crowell. I assume you’re using the “pseudo” prefix to distinguish purely self-focused albums like that and Carly Pearce’s “29” from the sweeping sagas and topical song collections that populate your main list and not in a derogatory “this is fake and pretentious” way. I think the ultra-personal song collection is just as much a concept as those others.
Also must put in a good word for “Another Country,” the Chieftains’ collaboration with the Dirt Band, Ricky Skaggs, Don Williams, Willie Nelson and many others, illustrating and expanding on country music’s Celtic roots.
Trigger
October 19, 2022 @ 8:59 am
There are albums that are clearly concept albums, and then albums that it’s in the eye of the beholder. I tried to keep this as pure in the clearly conceptualized album as possible, but still knowing I would miss a few.
To me, Carly Pearce’s “29” is more a traditional breakup album as opposed to a concept album. And if you include breakup albums here, you’d have to add hundreds more because they’re so prevalent in country music. If fact, the “Greatest Breakup Records of All Time” might make for another good dive, and “29” would definitely be on there.
Euro South
October 19, 2022 @ 4:02 pm
Another album called “29” that I would consider a concept album (in this case it’s definitely in the eye of the beholder, though I’m definitely not the only one who beholds it in that way) is the one by Ryan Adams.
Troy
October 19, 2022 @ 8:48 am
Some great albums! Nice to see Hellbound Glory’s ” Streets of Aberdeen” mentioned. Great album, a departure from the more edgy stuff most of Leon/ Leroy’s fans seem to like, but couldn’t agree more that it’s an album that highlights his great songwriting ability and style. Lovin that he expanded on that on his newest release also. Great to hear you continue to give shout outs to his stuff. He deserves much more recognition than he receives.
Matt F.
October 20, 2022 @ 6:21 pm
Of all of the gifts Trig has given me, HBG may be the greatest.
RamblinWreck
October 19, 2022 @ 9:07 am
1. Second the Corb Lund Horse Soldier! record.
2. Patty Loveless – Mountain Soul
Travis
October 19, 2022 @ 9:11 am
If anyone’s looking for something bizarre but fun, The Pine Box Boys (horror bluegrass) have some fun concept records. The most recent is the Feast of Three Arms, but I liked the predecessor a little more, Tales from the Emancipated Head.
Huge fan of Straight to Hell but never really considered that a concept record.
Yo
October 19, 2022 @ 9:19 am
I would have put Willie Nelson’s Spirit in there as a concept album as well. It’s one of my faves and as the first part of a two-part series with the follow-up, Teatro was as good as Willie albums got in the 90s.
I’m curious how you are defining concept album here though. Everything fits on your list until we get to Metamodern. That doesn’t seem to me to be a concept album unless the concept is awesome country songs? Did I miss it?
Anyway, this is a great list Trig and there were several albums I can’t wait to hear for the first time.
Trigger
October 19, 2022 @ 9:33 am
How to define a “concept” album is definitely in the eye of the beholder. One of the requisites I used when putting this together is whether the artist themselves have called it a concept album, and Sturgill definitely considers “Metamodern Sounds” a concept album. It also has elements of a concept, like Sturgill’s Grandpa giving an introduction, the tape feedback on “It Ain’t All Flowers,” etc, and does include a cohesive theme, even if it’s a little more loosely defined than others.
Wayne
October 19, 2022 @ 9:24 am
Great article, I would had Phases and Stages as #1 for me but it is hard to argue with any of your choices here. Surprised Yesterday’s Wine album by Willie is not included somewhere here. I always have considered it to be a great concept album. Again, great read! Thanks.
Euro South
October 19, 2022 @ 4:12 pm
Yesterday’s Wine is my favorite W. Nelson record and one of my favorite albums of all time, and I second that it should be included in the list of great country concept albums. It compresses the whole ark of human existence in its variety of sacred and profane aspects into 30 minutes of brilliant country music.
Trigger
October 19, 2022 @ 4:37 pm
And entry for Yesterday’s Win has been added. It was another initial oversight.
Ells Eastwood
October 19, 2022 @ 9:29 am
Obviously Red Headed Stranger is the GOAT, but when it comes to the finer details of “what is a concept record” wouldn’t it be safe to assume that the artist would have to write ALL of the songs? I mean one or two co-writes, sure; but less than half? I’m thinking about records like Tommy, The Wall, Sound & Fury, Welcome to The Black Parade, that came directly from the head of artist that released it.
Would love to have someone let me know where I’m going wrong here.
Trigger
October 19, 2022 @ 10:02 am
I would say that it might be a preference that the majority of the songs were written by the performer. But if we started tossing out albums with cover songs on them, this list would be whittled down to virtually nothing. Country music has a long history of diving into the genre’s catalog for songs, and sometimes someone else’s composition tells you story better than one you could write. That’s one of the beautiful thing about country music and its universal themes.
Kevin
October 19, 2022 @ 9:30 am
You filled in lots of knowledge gaps for me. Headed to the iTunes Store now.
No duck-kissing here.
Cap'n B
October 19, 2022 @ 9:31 am
I suppose it could be debated if it’s truly a concept album or not, but Mike and the Moonpies’ “One to Grow On” is another great album for consideration for the topic at hand. Concept album or not, I would still consider this to be one of the best albums of recent memory and is still in my constant rotation.
Also, was able to see both Mike and the Moonpies and Vandoliers last Friday in Macon, GA (first time seeing either band), and I would recommend everyone do themselves a favor and see both of these bands live if you can.
jt
October 19, 2022 @ 10:50 am
They’re playing near me on the 25th. An 8:00 show, 2 hours away, on a work night. Ugh! I would so like to go. My brain says no, my heart says yes. It remains to be seen if the brain can hold on while tickets last.
Cap'n B
October 19, 2022 @ 12:41 pm
Yeah, I feel your pain there… I was actually closer to the Charlotte, Athens, and Atlanta shows, but opted driving 4 hours to Macon just because it was a Friday night, rather than a work night.
Ben Gretenhart
October 19, 2022 @ 2:08 pm
Worth the drive and the subsequent hangover. Go!
Jbird
October 19, 2022 @ 11:38 am
Hell yeah Cap’n, they put on one hell of a show!
Jamie Lake
October 19, 2022 @ 9:41 am
Great list, but no mention of Jamey Johnson’s Guitar Song black and white concept album?
Trigger
October 19, 2022 @ 10:27 am
That’s a good suggestion and an interesting one. In some respects, most all albums are “conceptualized” to some extent. Jamey definitely wanted to highlight darkness on the first disc and light on the second one. It doesn’t cross me as fully conceptualized with since there isn’t a cohesive thread tying all the songs together, or the interludes or recurring theme song that usually accompany a concept album. But it definitely sits on the bubble.
Di Harris
October 19, 2022 @ 9:43 am
Conrad Fisher – Homemade
Matt
October 19, 2022 @ 9:51 am
I consider Calico Jim by Pony Bradshaw to be concept, and it’s been one of my favorite albums in the last two years.
Euro South
October 19, 2022 @ 4:18 pm
Love that album, great, great music, songwriting, atmosphere. How’d you describe the concept?
Matt
October 25, 2022 @ 1:47 pm
It’s main concept is about life in Appalachia. It’s a loose concept, for sure, but the album definitely focuses on life in that area. I like to think that most of the album is from Calico Jim’s perspective.
Euro South
October 26, 2022 @ 1:46 pm
Yeah, I can buy that. Thanks for replying.
WuK
October 19, 2022 @ 9:54 am
Enjoyed the article and am fortunate to have many of the albums listened. Some great music. I do like White Mansons and the Ballad of Sally Rose. Mattea’s Coal is very good. Patty Loveless Mountain Soul, I think superb. Still not so sure about Sturgill’s albums. His latest ‘Jaunita’ I also found disappointingly contrived. The new Ashley McBryde album is also a really good album.
glendel
October 19, 2022 @ 9:56 am
“And then I woke up”
— Marty Stuart ending the greatest concept album of all time.
Tom
October 19, 2022 @ 9:58 am
Thanks for the list. Much listening to do.
Would you consider “Hail Mary” by Shane Smith & the Saints to be a concept album? To me it felt as if it needed to be listened to in track order for the album and its themes to be fully appreciated.
Tom
October 19, 2022 @ 9:59 am
On a different note, “Desperado” by the Eagles is one of my all-time favorite albums. Though I suppose it’s not a country or concept album as much of a western album.
JF
October 19, 2022 @ 10:02 am
I would include Brian Burns The Eagle and the Snake: Songs of the Texians. Several of his other albums while not concept records are centered around a same theme as well.
JF
October 19, 2022 @ 10:11 am
Also stumbled on 2 albums at a used record store by Bobby Barnett that are very cool. Heroes, History and Heritage of Oklahoma and Heroes, History and Heritage Vol 2.
Jake
October 19, 2022 @ 10:03 am
Does “Turmoil and Tinfoil” count as a concept album? I also thought Billy Strings was trying to capture the magic of “Metamodern” with his own spin on it.
Josh Killian
October 19, 2022 @ 10:05 am
Dwight Yoakam’s “Buenas Noches From a Lonely Room” could be considered a concept “side A”. It follows a man who is in crazy in love, begins to suspect cheating, confirms the cheating, loses his mind and ends with him murdering his love interest and her lover. “I Sang Dixie” and “Streets of Bakersfield” on the B side is the cherry on top. Also, even though he doesn’t like the label of “concept album”, Jason Eady’s “Daylight and Dark” is a fantastic album following a man struggling with alcoholism, its effects on his relationship with the woman he loves, hitting rock bottom and the hopefulness of coming out on the other side.
Jack W
October 19, 2022 @ 10:09 am
Great idea for an article and well done.
Bluegrass great and West Virginian Tim O’Brien released two albums that I consider concept albums. They were The Crossing in 1999 and Two Journeys in 2001. Just to save some time (back to work and all), here’s an excerpt from Thom Jurek’s review of the latter that I think accurately sums them up at a high level:
…The Crossing in 1999, which offered a rootsy musician’s ear-view of how Irish music informed the folk traditions of the American South and found a home in a mutated yet no less soulful form. Two Journeys is The Crossing’s mirror image. This album shows O’Brien — and a company of the British Isles and American South’s finest musicians — looking toward the coastlines of Ireland to express those traditions as they prepared to leave the homeland for the “new world.”
Grievous Angel
October 19, 2022 @ 10:39 am
No Chris Gaines? List is poop.
Trigger
October 19, 2022 @ 10:48 am
Not sure if you’re being real or sarcastic, but Chris Gaines was considered. The issue is that it’s not country, not that it isn’t a concept album. It’s similar to “Black Ribbons’ by Shooter Jennings.
Redneck_rainman
October 20, 2022 @ 10:48 am
Yeah the Chris Gaines album was unapologetically pop. That being said, it’s actually a pretty damn good pop album. Seriously, all jokes aside, it’s unironicly a solid album on its own.
RD
October 19, 2022 @ 10:57 am
White Mansions is my favorite on the list. Looks Like Rain by Mickey Newbury should be right up there. I have also seen some say that American Trilogy should be viewed essentially as one concept record.
Nicolas
October 19, 2022 @ 11:11 am
Great list! I’ll have several albums to listen to, thanks to this post. I also think about Jenny Tolman’s “There Goes The Neighborhood”, released in 2019. It was an excellent concept album, something similar to the album released by Ashley McBryde, with the concept of a small town, Jennyville.
Rob Lee
October 19, 2022 @ 11:11 am
“Desperado” by the Eagles I’d have to put down, even if it delves into rock at times. Great list though.
Big Tex
October 19, 2022 @ 11:24 am
Does anyone consider Tom T. Hall’s “Songs of Fox Hollow” a concept album?
Big Red
October 19, 2022 @ 11:25 am
Is Marty Stuart’s “Badlands” a concept album?
Strait86
October 19, 2022 @ 11:33 am
idk if this counts but that Bakersfield album by Vince Gill and Paul Franklin is talked about a lot amongst players.
Jimmie Hughes
October 19, 2022 @ 11:49 am
Really enjoyed the list. Was introduced to a couple albums I wasn’t aware of before. One of those albums was the one you have listed as Paul Kennerley’s The Ballad of Jesse James. I immediately started looking for it online on vinyl, and couldn’t find it to save my life. Finally found out why. FYI, the album is actually titled “The LEGEND of Jesse James.” I have a copy on the way. Thanks, Trigger!
Ian
October 19, 2022 @ 7:20 pm
I found a copy in a thrift store years ago. Autographed.
“Dear Addy, wish I had stayed on in Cincinnati!”
My friend was convinced it was a gift following a one night stand!
Happy Dan
October 19, 2022 @ 11:59 am
James Steinle – Mac from the Mountain
Love this album, should be on this list too
wayne
October 19, 2022 @ 12:14 pm
I do think Marty Stuart sets the standard in many ways. I don’t think Porter Waggoner’s last album, “Wagonmaster” probably fits the bill of a concept album, but it dances around the edges and is a classic. Of course, also produced by the Renaisance man.
Di Harris
October 19, 2022 @ 12:24 pm
For Trig’s Eyes …
: D Thank goodness know how to work in the cold.
This time, will not have to wrestle a 2,000 + lb. horse to get him “dressed” and tethered to a carriage. Lawsy, although showered and dressed, ready to go to work, by the time you got knocked off the bucket, pleading with your horse to open his mouth “just a little” so you could get the bit in there – Was about the time He’d had enough of Your crap.
Next thing you know, you’d be flat on your back, waiting for the stars to clear, & your vision and balance to come back to equilibrium.
Well, helping direct traffic for 2 & 1/2 hours tonight is going to be a cakewalk!
And, NO Percheron Wrestling Match, beforehand.
Life Is Good.
Go Ahead – ask if i’m excited about tonight’s concert ????
Colter
October 19, 2022 @ 12:25 pm
Ballad of the Lakota by Marty Stuart. I actually like it better than the Pilgrim.
Mark
October 19, 2022 @ 1:10 pm
I would add DAC’s “David Allan Coe Rides Again”.
Jbird
October 20, 2022 @ 4:20 am
Maybe his best album.
Countryfan68
October 19, 2022 @ 1:51 pm
THANK YOU BEYOND SO MANY WORDS, TRIGGER , for putting Johnny Cash’s Bitter Tears on this great list, I have this great album, and just goes to show he was not the poster boy for the conservatives in country music, Rosanne Cash even said her dad WAS NOT, A REPUBLICAN, HE WAS NOT A DEMOCRAT, he was his own man, with songs like ALL GOD’S CHILDREN AINT FREE, and THE MAN IN BLACK, Johnny always sung songs about the poor, the prisoners, and those who were done wrong, so yeah, Johnny was his own man, and thanks again for picking this album. He was not a conservative, he was not a liberal, I don’t know what he was, I don’t care, I just know Johnny Cash does not belong to the gop, he does not belong to the democrats, he belongs to everybody , he represented no political ideology, he is still one of my favorite singers, so again, thank you for including this album, if any of you have not heard it, I suggest you buy it and give it a listen.
Corncaster
October 19, 2022 @ 2:17 pm
Merle Travis, “Folk Songs of the Hills,” is one of the greatest. Massive influence on every country guitarist.
Kevin Smith
October 20, 2022 @ 4:27 am
Cornman,
Spot on! Merle Travis made a great concept album indeed. For some reason, he gets overlooked frequently. Most people don’t realize he wrote Sixteen Tons. His instrumental guitar albums are epic. There’s one album of him and Joe Maphis, and listening to it makes me want to swear off guitar forever. FYI, Deke Dickerson is releasing a biography on Travis this coming month. Way time someone documents his legacy.
brz
October 20, 2022 @ 4:54 pm
Merle is top notch. Guitar playing aside, he wrote some amazing songs. Dark as a Dungeon, I am Pilgrim, Nine Pound Hammer, Divorce Me COD.
Corncaster
October 21, 2022 @ 9:03 am
He’s right there alongside Doc Watson in my book. A bedrock player and a great songwriter. He’s overlooked maybe because he became the norm, which tends to be invisible. Plus, now people seem to believe that other qualities (origins, politics, etc) are also (or more) important. For musicians, Merle’s place is assured.
RLT
October 19, 2022 @ 2:28 pm
Gah, what a great list. Really — got me thinking and looking and re-thinking all over again. Saw “SRO” made the “honourable mentions” and figured I’d point out that “The Dirty South” is also pretty heavily concept — but it’s also my favorite album of all time, and when I saw your comment about “eye of the beholder” I realized that your criteria there is spot-on. DBTs have a few albums that *might* fit, but SRO is only pure-concept of them.
Oddly enough, it’s not one I care for that much…but they are one band where I just know that if I listen to it a few more times, I’ll start to see it in new light. And dig it.
Love the list, man. I’ll be thinking on it all some more. My wife, when I mentioned the impetus was Rolling Stone’s snub, sat quiet for a while and then was like “…but that’s BULLSHIT! I can name a dozen country concept albums, and that’s without stopping to look for the GOOD ones!!!”
She’s a keeper, and so is this list!
RLT
RJ
October 19, 2022 @ 2:45 pm
That is the best Clickbait I have ever seen. You also included horse soldier, spooky lady sideshow, and Terry Allen. It is so incredibly rare to find any organized list with these things on it and it makes me feel far from alone!
Bear
October 19, 2022 @ 3:09 pm
“Coal” is one of my favorite album ever tied with the follow up “Calling Me Home”. Those two records are superb.
Howard
October 19, 2022 @ 3:28 pm
Not only were Kathy Mattea’s grandfathers in the coal industry, but her father was a longtime Monsanto worker, a foreman.That’s some heavy baggage for someone so passionate about her state and its amazing natural beauty to carry. It took not a small amount of courage for her to record “Coal” and “Calling Me Home,” with songs that tell of coal mining and its many facets frankly and sometimes painfully, not through a maudlin nostalgic filter.
Bear
October 19, 2022 @ 4:01 pm
God, I LOVE those albums.
They feature so many fabulous songs. That Laurie Lewis cut is a favorite. If you haven’t heard the original Wood-Thrushes Song sung by Laurie check it on youtube. Laurie sings it a cappela for even greater effect.
David: The Duke of Everything
October 19, 2022 @ 4:08 pm
I would have put will the circle number one but that’s just me. Never have been a big Willie fan so red headed stranger means little to me. I don’t listen to too many concept albums so I can’t really say too much.
Red Cloud
October 19, 2022 @ 4:27 pm
Sturgill’s Dood and Juanita is one of my all time favorites and certainly my favorite album in the last few years.
Euro South
October 19, 2022 @ 4:40 pm
I see in your review at the time that you don’t consider it a concept record, but I’d still argue that The Weight of These Wings, with its “Nerve” and “Heart” sides, should be considered loosely conceptualized along the lines of The Guitar Song.
Dane
October 19, 2022 @ 4:42 pm
Very very good list but no concept best of list could be complete without the Statler Bros masterpiece turn as Lester “Roadhog” Moran & The Cadillac Cowboys with Alive at the Johnny Mack Brown High School!
Trigger
October 19, 2022 @ 8:45 pm
I struggled with if we should consider albums of alter egos as “concepts.” I was considering Dierks Bentley and his “Hot Country Knights” side project, but I think that’s something different than a true “concept.” But again, in the eye of the beholder.
Corncaster
October 21, 2022 @ 9:05 am
It’s also hard because, in this day and age, the concept of an “album” is itself a “concept.”
Oregon Outlaw
October 19, 2022 @ 4:48 pm
Might be more folk than country but Tom Russell – Man From God Knows Where is one of my favorites.
JF
October 19, 2022 @ 5:47 pm
Check out Tom Russell’s The Rose of Roscrae. It’s a massive two and a half hour story that is fantastic.
MPLS by way of DC
October 20, 2022 @ 2:12 pm
Been scrolling through the comments just to see if Rose of Roscrae was here. I always liked how he used snippets of older songs to fit the storyline
James
October 20, 2022 @ 7:47 pm
I have several Tom Russel albums downloaded but not this one. I like him a lot, so thanks for the suggestion. Also a good reminder to try to see him in person before it’s too late.
The Unrighteous Gemstone
October 19, 2022 @ 5:38 pm
Do not any number of the brilliant Willy Vlautin inspirited Richmond Fontaine/The Delines recordings measure up as ‘Concept Albums’? Or are they clearly not ‘Country’ enough? #blurredlines
hoptowntiger94
October 19, 2022 @ 5:45 pm
I think everyone is playing loose and dangerous with the definition of a “concept album,” but I will use this great list by Trig to revisit some of these albums. In the streaming and playlist age, concept albums get overlooked (the parts alone don’t play as well as the sum).
Jimmy
October 19, 2022 @ 7:37 pm
I would add Steve Earle’s Ghosts of West Virginia to the list.
njoseph
October 19, 2022 @ 8:23 pm
Hey Trigger, I’m not sure this fits with your (admittedly loose) definition of a concept album, but I’d include Bill Monroe’s “Master of Bluegrass.” It’s an all instrumental album of original music that is really unlike almost anything else Bill Monroe recorded, with the tunes having 4 and 4 parts and really hearkening back to the “ancient tones” in a unique way. Wait- hold up- it’s not all original music, “Evening Prayer Blues” is an old DeFord Bailey tune from the earliest Opry days but everything else is, and some the tunes are downright weird, especially the cross-tuned “My Last Days On Earth, which features the first and possibly only use of bluegrass seagulls.
If I had to say what the concept WAS, I’d say, it’s Bill Monroe showing that bluegrass can be stretched furthest by going back to its gnarliest roots.
Norman Blake, Jesse McReynolds, and Kenny Baker played on it, among others.
Really y’all, if you think you know bluegrass but haven’t heard this album, check it out. It blew my mind the first time I heard it many decades ago.
njoseph
October 19, 2022 @ 8:39 pm
Whoops, I obviously meant the tunes on this album (some of them) have 3 and 4 parts, not 4 and 4. Alas for an edit function.
RyanPD
October 19, 2022 @ 8:29 pm
I’ve always wanted to see a movie based on the plot of Big Iron.
Andy
October 19, 2022 @ 8:34 pm
Ween – 12 Golden Country Greats. Unbelievably amassing album with some truly talented session musicians from the country scene. Ween is def not a traditional country band, but man alive, each track is amazing.
BigHig
October 27, 2022 @ 12:38 pm
Read the article and comment section specifically to see if this album would get a mention from anyone. Thanks!
Di Harris
October 19, 2022 @ 8:41 pm
Holy Cow,
Jeff Beck is a GUITAR. PLAYING. MONSTER.
Depp – What a Terrific Night, seeing both of these men onstage.
U N R E A L
????
Di Harris
October 20, 2022 @ 1:39 pm
One last tidbit from the Beck/Depp concert last night.
Beck played a solo that blew Black Velvet out of the water.
And i think that Black Velvet is one of the sexiest songs, E V E R.
Beck’s playing is, Effortlessly P H E N O M E N A L.
Have an adorable profile picture of him, smiling at the band, with a dimple showing. The guy is like, 78. He looks like he’s in his 40’s in this pic.
Ok, that’s my concept comment.
Really sexy songs.
Joe
October 19, 2022 @ 9:09 pm
What would you think about The Last Pale Light of the West by Ben Nichols?
JD
October 20, 2022 @ 7:43 pm
Perfect album and should be on the list.
James
October 20, 2022 @ 7:52 pm
That’s a good reminder that the Walking Dead’s first few seasons were great TV.
Yevsey
October 20, 2022 @ 12:10 am
Corb Lund said of “Horse Soldier! Horse Soldier!” that when he putting together songs he had written for an album, that he wasn’t intending to make a concept album, which explains the odd ducks on the album that absolutely don’t fit the concept at all. But he also said in the same breath that it” kinda came out that way”, which was obviously embraced by the time it was given a name and art. This info was off his art artist site, before it was completely bombed and replaced by the shitty modern standard where all the site does is advertise the most recent album, and not the artists body of work. That old site had some really nice paragraphs about each album and what Corb was thinking when they were released.
kapam
October 20, 2022 @ 12:25 am
Fantastic list, Trigger!
I confess I have not listened to any of them, except the Sturgil Simpson works; but rest assured I will start in on the list as soon as possible.
“White Mansions” was the other one I knew of. As a huge Ozark Mountain Daredevils fan, I must seek it out for the Dillon/Cash involvement.
Blackh4t
October 20, 2022 @ 12:31 am
I like this article a lot.
I’d add Arkansas Traveller by Michelle Shocked. It was by no means as important as ‘Will the Circle be Unbroken’, but its a valuable interpretation of old folk song.
In a way, most good albums are kind of concept albums with a thread going through it making it more than the sum of its parts.
Which is why I don’t support playlists. Albums for the win
Michelle
October 20, 2022 @ 12:58 am
Merle Haggard – “Let Me Tell You About A Song”
Beau Bradlee
October 20, 2022 @ 1:09 am
A forgotten country singer, Skeeter Davis, had a concept album called “It’s Hard To Be A Woman.” Every song a winner.
Happy Dan
October 20, 2022 @ 1:05 pm
Skeeter is not forgotten, at least not forgotten in my house! Love her, and her “sister”
tunesmiff
October 20, 2022 @ 2:51 am
Perhaps not a true concept, but a definite theme, in Justin Townes Earle’s albums “Single Mothers” (2014), “Absent Fathers” (2015), and “Kids in the Street” (2017)…
Kevin Smith
October 20, 2022 @ 3:51 am
Johnny Horton Makes History.
One of the earliest true concept albums. All story songs based on history and most have a war theme. Of course The Battle of New Orleans is on it, as is Sink The Bismarck, Battle of Bull Run, Johnny Reb, Young Abe Lincoln and so on. Great album.
DJ
October 20, 2022 @ 5:15 am
1971 San Francisco Mabel Joy, Mickey Newbury- the first concept album I ever heard. And I might add, the best.
Matt D.
October 20, 2022 @ 7:23 am
How about Being There by Wilco? I get why Yankee Hotel Foxtrot is not here (not country). But Being There is country enough to make this list. I’m not sure what the concept IS exactly. But there’s a concept there. Just being there?
Matt D.
October 20, 2022 @ 7:34 am
Here’s a glaring omission: Son Volt’s Okemah and the Melody of Riot. One of the best war protest concept albums in the history of music.
Matt D.
October 20, 2022 @ 7:51 am
Just thought of another one. Begonias by Caitlin Cary and Thad Cockrell is a concept album, right? Listening in order, it builds up to the epic 7:00 story told in Track #9 Conversations About a Friend (Who’s in Love with Katie), followed by the heart-wrenching Waiting on June, and the perfectly timed and perfectly written closer – The Big House. Because these are not household names (Cary was always in Ryan Adams’ background in Whiskeytown), Begonias is often a forgotten classic in the alt-country genre.
Kevin Smith
October 20, 2022 @ 10:11 am
Can’t resist, nearly forgot David Allan Coes incredibly weird concept album Requiem For a Harlequin. It’s a mix of poetry, spoken word, blues, organ music, Star Trek sound effects, 70s funk and B movie, and a tripped out Coe describing his life as a gangster, hustler, con, pimp, biker etc etc…
I’ve not listened to the whole thing, it’s just too weird! But it is absolutely a CONCEPT album, and it’s even classed as such by music critics. I don’t recommend it unless you are truly bored and you love hearing Coe rap on about ” The asphalt jungle”, a phrase he uses throughout the album…
Kevin Carlson
October 20, 2022 @ 11:47 am
The Legend Of Jesse James has great performances by Johnny Cash, Kevin Helm, Charlie Daniels, and Emmylou Harris. Gideon by Kenny Rogers is another one of my all time favorites. Both released in 1980, my senior year of high school.
Jake
October 20, 2022 @ 11:58 am
Kris Kristofferson has an overlooked masterpiece concept album “To The Bone.”
SB77
October 20, 2022 @ 12:51 pm
Jeannie C. Riley – Harper Valley PTA. The whole album is about Harper Valley.
Ryan
October 20, 2022 @ 3:26 pm
Drew Kennedy – Marathon. From this year. Check it out if you haven’t! Jason Eady – AM Country Heaven – if in 2011 the concept would be a real country throwback album .. ? It actually was a fairly unique idea at the time.
Fuzzy TwoShirts
October 20, 2022 @ 4:51 pm
I’d have whined about Merle haggard’s ‘my love affair with trains’ being snubbed but red headed stranger is right where its supposed to be
I had that tape in my 1994 custom motor coach and the tape ran beginning to end in about the time I drove to work
I’d listen to it over and over again
I LOVE tougher than leather too
In fact I’d say tougher than leather (which is about reincarnation as a form of purgatory and I’m quite confused as to why this isn’t better understood) is BETTER than red headed stranger
Trey West
October 20, 2022 @ 5:53 pm
I would also like to recommend a concept album by Kris Kristofferson. The title of the album is “Moment of Forever”. It has many wonderful songs on it.
Some of his best and most meaningful to be honest.
I find it to be a “concept” album in a way because the tracks, although not telling a direct story, could easily be used to write out a full story with the ideas that are shared in each of the songs that are on it. Losing faith in your fellow man, losing faith in your government, losing faith in everything you believed in, but finding that love goes on forever.
The closing song is about a man who stood up to the government and paid a high (pun intended) price to the IRS for it. He went went down fighting with his first from the floor.
Yes, the song is about Kris’s best friend Willie. Not only did the take his money but property too, which included his songs.
I can’t recommend this over looked album enough.
It truly is one of my favorites of CW.
JD
October 20, 2022 @ 7:42 pm
Last Pale Light in the West by Ben Nichols is the best concept album since Red Headed Stranger.
James
October 20, 2022 @ 8:01 pm
Great post, Trigger. It looks like I’ll have plenty to occupy me until my next Audible credit arrives. I do wonder if any of those old pre-Nashville deal Chris Ledoux albums would qualify as a concept album? Along those lines, Michael Martin Murphey’s Cowboy Songs was one of my favorites when I was in high school (late 90s).
Also, although it doesn’t deserve to be on any “best of list,” somehow I feel the need to mention DAC had an interesting one that might have been called XXX. Getting a copy of that trashy cassette was like the holy grail for hillbilly high school kids back in the 90s.
Thanks for all you do on this website.
Bear
October 20, 2022 @ 11:16 pm
I want to add to this impressive list The Delta Sweetie by Bobbie Gentry. Well I want to add Bobbie Gentry to every list. She is so underrated.
Thom Jurek
October 21, 2022 @ 4:26 am
I’d argue for Mickey Newbury’s classic Frisco Mabel Joy to be included on this list.
SO too Kris Kristofferson’s 1981 divorce album, To The Bone (his final Monument release), and 1990’s Third World Warrior.
Finally, Lee Hazelwood’s Trouble Is A Lonesome Town.
Jbird
October 21, 2022 @ 4:30 am
Southern Rock Opera is excellent but Dirty South is the better concept album. DBT’s finest hour.
Mississippi Man
October 21, 2022 @ 5:46 pm
If you do this list in 10 years from now, I hope The Man From Waco is on there. Love the list and most of the albums on there. It’s also gave me some new stuff to check out.
Michael Martin
October 21, 2022 @ 8:12 pm
Drew Kennedy album “Fresh water in the Salton Sea”. He even wrote a novel that goes along with the album
Roscoe Brown
October 22, 2022 @ 6:10 pm
Yeah, ‘Legend of Jesse James’ is great, and Johnny Cash sounds wonderful! Cheap on Discogs if you’re into that whole vinyl thing…????
CRay
October 23, 2022 @ 3:50 pm
After Red Headed Stranger, I go White Mansions and Legend Of Jesse James 2A and B
jim bob
October 24, 2022 @ 1:05 pm
absolutely LOVE to see LIndi Ortega get some appreciation and attention.
her sound and voice are other worldly great to me.
Dale M
November 8, 2022 @ 10:55 am
I was surprised not to see Rodney Crowell’s The Houston Kid on this list.