Devarati Ghosh, A.K.A. “Windmills Country,” Has Died
Devarati Ghosh, also known to many as Windmills Country, who among many other much more important contributions to the cultural and educational community was a Saving Country Music contributor, regular commenter, and behind-the-scenes counselor and compass for years, died on September 2nd, 2016 at JFK Medical Center of a massive coronary. She was 38-years-old.
Working under the pen name Deb B for the reality TV competition site Mjsbigblog, and Windmills Country on Twitter and Saving Country Music among other places, Ghosh was a tireless champion for women in country and American music, as well as the authenticity and accuracy in reporting and charting of music. Her lengthy, dedicated, and detailed work into subjects such as Billboard‘s 2012 chart changes that boosted country songs played on pop formats, and her signature “deep dives” against the systemic inequality female artists face on country radio resulted in palpable and verifiable change in the music marketplace that would have never occurred without her contributions.
Unlike much of the writing on Saving Country Music, Ghosh did not just post what she believed or what she felt about a certain artist or a certain subject. Through detailed research and analysis, she would present certifiable facts behind her assertions that were not just brilliant and enlightening in how they opened up esoteric subjects to common understanding, but that were bulletproof in their conclusions. She did not take up every cause, but the ones she did, she won the argument, and always had the final word, bolstered by hard facts and detailed statistics. Though dogged and determined, she was also incredibly patient and willing to explain even the most minute detail to both major music power players, to the most common fly-by-night fans in order to create a common understanding, while also being willing to acquiesce that taste and appeal were things that numbers could not always refute or explain.
She was an important contributor to the Change The Conversation movement founded by CMT senior VP music strategy Leslie Fram, artist manager and Rounder Records VP Tracy Gershon, and Middle Tennessee State University recording industry department chair and The Tennessean columnist Beverly Keel in the aftermath of 2015’s Tomatogate controversy.
Devarati Ghosh made the hardest elements of the music industry easy to understand, was a chart wonk inhabiting her own echelon of expertise, but moreover, she was a music fan who brought her passion for research to the medium to challenge norms and dug-in perspectives in a way mere commentary could never equate to in effectiveness. What Windmills Country did was irreplaceable, because nobody had ever taken such an analytical approach to music commentary and criticism before, and nobody possesses her unique skill set, disposition, and passion to ever do it again.
Beyond the music realm, Devarati Ghosh was arguably much more accomplished, though her music comrades knew little about her personal or professional life. Though an obituary says she she was an Associate Director for Carnegie Council for Ethic Affair in New York City for 8 years, according to Carnegie Council Vice President of Finance Eva Becker who Saving Country Music spoke to Tuesday morning (9-20), Ghosh never worked at the organization. Instead, this was likely a cover to pursue her country music efforts. Ghosh was from a very traditional family.
According to a Billboard article from July of 2015 highlighting one of Ghosh’s numerous studies into the issue of women on country radio, she is listed as a political economist and Stanford University Ph.D. candidate, which can be confirmed from numerous sources. She is quoted as saying she “fell into blogging about the country music charts due to an intersection of passion for the music and a curiosity about chart outcomes.”
Saving Country Music and much of the country music blogsphere that relied on the analysis and perspective of Windmills Country is devastated by this news. Specific to Saving Country Music, Devarati Ghosh contributed to dozens of articles via behind-the-scenes guidance, fact checking, and topic discovery. If any article or idea had statistics or charts at the crux of the matter, it was always important to first double check facts and assertions with Windmills—a service she offered to Saving Country Music and others pro bono, while contributing lengthy commentary in the comments section, sometimes vehemently disagreeing with this site’s opinions. She was a natural mentor working hours on country music problems from passion, not for payment. Her efforts significantly and irrevocably contributed to the movement to save country music.
Devarati Ghosh was born on September 22, 1977 in Flushing, New York. Thursday would have been her 39th birthday. According to the funeral home obituary, she is survived by her parents, several cousins, uncles and aunts, and many close and dear friends.
– – – – – – –
Vickye Fisher of For The Country Record, and journalist Grady Smith helped confirm some of the information in this article.
September 20, 2016 @ 8:25 am
Way too young, she’ll be missed. Thoughts to her family and friends.
September 20, 2016 @ 8:27 am
Speechless.
September 20, 2016 @ 8:30 am
How incredibly sad. I remember when I got into a twitter fight with Travis Tritt, of all people, over his comments about Billy Currington & Tim McGraw performing at a Sandy Hook benefit. He kept retweeting me and his fans were threatening me and she was quietly screenshotting all of it. She compiled it all and sent Tritt a tweet of his fans threats with a sharply worded, yet very intelligent statement about celebrity power on twitter. That was her ?. Smart, educated about her topics, fair and reasonable in her arguements, but always ready to support her statements with a multitude of statiatics and facts. She is irreplaceable and will be missed greatly.
September 20, 2016 @ 8:31 am
Deeply saddened by this news. Dev and I follow each other on twitter, and has had several convos via tweets and DM. As you said she’s a natural mentor, always patiently explaining and simplifying things for anyone interested in the music business. I will miss her.
September 20, 2016 @ 8:32 am
I am absolutely devastated. I feel like my legs have been cut out from under me. Windmills Country was such a huge part of Saving Country Music behind the scenes, always patient, always available, and a trusted confidant and mentor. I can’t tell you how much I looked up to her and the passion and knowledge she brought to her work. SO MANY topics broached on this site started when Windmills Country sniffed out a topic, and usually one that had to do with an injustice or misnomer that was important to set straight. I feel lost, and intimidated to continue forward without her council. No different than when yet another important blog goes dark, I feel like I’m on an island in the void left by her.
I just want everybody to know how important Windmills Country was in the effort to save country music, and not just from the women in country issues she championed, but traditional country artists who also suffered from similar prejudices. How am I supposed to go on and pretend there’s not going to be a huge, gaping hole left where Windmills Country once was?
Thoughts and prayers to her family and friends.
September 20, 2016 @ 10:24 am
You got this. You are strong enough, and you are creative and determined enough to overcome this, the way you have overcome so much already.
I know you probably think of me as a maniacal kook who champions unpopular opinions and hates half of what you post,..
but to me, and I bet to a lot of people, you’re a friend who is always sharing music.
and I use the word “friend” sincerely.
keep on keeping on buddy.
September 20, 2016 @ 10:27 am
You got this buddy. You’re strong enough to overcome this.
And don’t ever feel down and out.
I know you just think that I’m some maniacal kook who hates half of what you post and disagrees with the rest…
but you’re my friend, as strange and alien as that sounds.
So much of who I am has been shaped by the music you introduced me to…
And I bet I’m not the only one.
Keep on keeping on buddy. You’ll make it.
September 20, 2016 @ 1:04 pm
I feel stinging sympathy and compassion for you! ; __ ; ; __ ; ; __ ;
September 20, 2016 @ 3:00 pm
Trig, I haven’t stopped crying since early this morning. We followed each other on twitter. As you said, anyone could ask her questions and she would respond and explain even if you didn’t like it. I had a heart attack 2 years ago and when I saw her last tweet was September 1, I kept thinking no, not her. I prayed and prayed. But somehow I knew – I just couldn’t bring myself to accept it as fact. I was lucky – extremely lucky – to have survived my heart attack with 3 stents. She was brilliant and I knew parts of her “job” but as you say, she was very private so you never knew for sure. I miss her so much but we must carry on as she would want us to. I hope her twitter timeline is left there because anyone remotely interested in music can learn so much from her and her brillance. She is truly one of a kind. There is no one like her. Now that everyone knows for sure and it is in writing, it is so very hard – but we must be kind and help people in anything we know how to do – we must do it for her. I miss you so very much. The Angels sang the most beautiful song ever for her. Love you Deb.
September 20, 2016 @ 5:47 pm
Wow. I’m really sorry Trig. I’m really gonna miss reading and learning from her. She was an industry expert and there is definitely going to be a huge void. But I think she would definitely want you to keep up the fight and be the voice country music deserves. You have what it takes.
September 27, 2016 @ 1:29 pm
I am incredibly sorry. I haven’t been in the reviewing world for very long, but even in my short experience, she was important to it. I know you feel, as you said, like your legs have been cut out from under you, but you are strong, and you inspire people like me to join the fight for country music. I am sure I’m speaking for the majority of your readers and commenters when I say that you have introduced me to music I would never have heard, given me perspective on issues, and entertained me with your satire. I think many people consider you as much of a mentor as you considered her. You can go on. She will be incredibly missed.
September 20, 2016 @ 8:43 am
Completely stunned. She always presented very thoughtful and numbers-driven information.
September 20, 2016 @ 8:51 am
I was so incredibly sad to see that news on twitter today. I loved her insight, her thought, and the use of statistics and research that she brought into the country music world.
Playing women country artists today, because not sure what else to do to best remember her. She will be missed.
September 20, 2016 @ 8:57 am
As someone who has read this blog for years, I’ve always recognized Windmills Country in the comments section. She always had great, well thought-out insight. I am so saddened to hear of her passing.
She left an impact not only on those she knew personally, but also those who came across her writings online. She will be missed.
September 20, 2016 @ 9:21 am
RIP Dev. 🙁
September 20, 2016 @ 9:21 am
Do you mind my asking how you unearthed the coronary detail?
Please keep on trucking, Trigger. With Windmills gone, we need you more than ever.
September 20, 2016 @ 9:29 am
The information on this story was difficult to track down because there were some inaccuracies in the obituary posted on September 2nd linked in the article. However, by speaking to the funeral home and Carnegie I was able to confirm all the information from reliable sources. Unfortunately, there is still much we don’t know about Deb because she was such a private person.
September 20, 2016 @ 10:36 am
That’s honestly makes it harder. To hear about her passing three weeks or so after the fact.
I knew her as 43dudleyvillas over on the Pulse Board. Never knew they she and Windmills were the same. I didn’t always agree with her postings, but you could tell she was very passionate and intelligent and respected by all.
September 20, 2016 @ 1:14 pm
I left Pulse Music Board three and a half years ago because I felt like the community was getting increasingly thin-skinned about defending their favorite artists and was stifling a lot of genuine conversation in result.
Even so, she was easily one of my favorite contributors to the Country board. She always thoroughly backed up what she had to say and was very insightful and incisive regardless if you agreed with her overall point or not. She was naturally curious and inquisitive about everything and strove to get down to the heart of the matter. There are indeed other contributors to the group I respected, but few were as intelligent and intent on scratching beneath the surface as 43dudleyvillas.
She will be dearly missed! ; __ ;
September 20, 2016 @ 9:58 am
This is so sad. I used to tweet back and forth with her, and wondered where she had been the last couple of weeks. We wanted a team like the SABREmetrics crowd to tell us all about what was really going on in country music.
September 20, 2016 @ 10:28 am
Dev and I knew each other through Twitter. When I was working on a story earlier this year on country music, like so many people here I reached out to Windmills Country for some early advice and ideas for my story. What she wrote me back was an exhaustive, exquisitely written 1500 someodd word response that itself could have been published at any top publication. She was dedicated to helping others and setting the record straight in country music. I looked forward to having her as my colleague for decades to come. What a loss.
September 20, 2016 @ 11:28 am
So sorry for the gut punch you’re feeling, Kyle. You’re clearly shaken and stunned, but you’ll keep up the good fight. We need you.
September 20, 2016 @ 11:35 am
I don’t know what to say, but I’ll try:
Behind all the pseudonyms and gimmicks, we are a community. Even though we don’t necessarily know each other very well, I believe everyone who comes to this site at least every once in a while is family. To see a member of this family taken so abruptly is devastating. All we can do is pay our respects and do our best to carry the torch.
September 20, 2016 @ 12:01 pm
amen brother.
September 20, 2016 @ 11:36 am
I certainly recognize the name from the comments I’ve seen in the past but was unaware of her behind the scenes contribution to this website. Thank you for bringing this to our attention. I’m sorry to hear about it and condolences to her friends and family.
September 20, 2016 @ 12:31 pm
This is very, very sad.
Thanks for letting us know.
September 20, 2016 @ 1:47 pm
So sorry for your loss trigger…and for our loss. Don’t worry if you need to take some time off to process this.
September 20, 2016 @ 2:24 pm
I truly admired her and missed her these past few weeks. I’m just shocked. My condolences to all who knew and loved her.
September 20, 2016 @ 4:29 pm
sorry for the loss prayers for her family and friends through this difficult time
September 20, 2016 @ 8:04 pm
I’ll tell you this, I feel real bad for the parents, my opinion there’s nothing more sadder than having a live parent outlive their child.
September 21, 2016 @ 1:13 am
It’s amazing how much affection you can have for a person whom you’ve never even met. Reading through these comments here, and many others elsewhere, it’s clear how special Deb was and how much she contributed to the lives of those who knew her — whether in real life or on the internet. She was smart, incisive, caring, collaborative, funny. She was important.
She’s no longer with us but she won’t be forgotten. Like all writers who have found a rapt audience, she’ll live on through her work. And what a body of work it is. As Kyle pointed out there has never been a country music journalist who used analytical data in the way that Deb did. Her sober, measured point of view combined with her ability to drill down using numbers made her one of a kind. I hope others will follow in her footsteps, perhaps she has inspired at least a few to take up her mantle.
Goodbye Deb. Thank you for letting me get to know you, even if just a little. I’ll look forward to meeting you in the next life.
September 21, 2016 @ 2:00 am
This is sad indeed. Her contributions here were always a treat to read. To now have a name and backstory adds to the sadness.
I’m sorry for you, sorry for us.
September 21, 2016 @ 7:28 am
I’m a relatively new fan of country music, and this site has provided an accelerated path to understanding the genre and community. I appreciate all the contributors here. Many of you, in combination with Kyle’s writing, have guided me to such a love of wonderful music. Windmills’ contributions were impactful to me and my learning of the genre. May she rest in peace, and much love to this community.
September 21, 2016 @ 10:02 am
I kept meaning to ask her if she had any new information on Josh Turner’s single and album but like many things in my life, I kept putting it off. And now the opportunity is gone. There is a sad country song in there.
I didn’t always agree with her findings and views but she was a true champion of country music with incredible knowledge.
May God be with her family in their time of sorrow.
September 22, 2016 @ 11:58 pm
This is so shocking and saddening (especially given the age at which she passed away) that I don’t even have the appropriate words for it. Her combination of a razor-sharp analytical mind, a tireless work ethic, and a deep appreciation for music (especially country music) was extremely hard to match. It was truly valuable to the whole SCM community to have her as a contributor.
May she rest in peace and may her family find some comfort amid this sudden, unexpected yet still heartbreaking tragedy.