Ending National Anthem in Sports Ends a Stepping Stone in Music

Billionaire owner of the NBA’s Dallas Mavericks basketball franchise Mark Cuban caused quite the stir this week when he announced the team would no longer include recitations of the National Anthem before home games. At the 16 home games The Mavericks have played so far in the current season, the anthem hasn’t been played, and on February 9th the team made the policy official, with reports saying the team initially cleared the decision with the NBA.
The implications of this were major. Eliminating the National Anthem at sporting events would be a major paradigm shift in American culture, with the Dallas Mavericks potentially setting off a domino effect for all games in all leagues at all levels having an excuse now to not include the song in the presentation. The mere idea sent major reverberations throughout the sports world.
Of course many will focus on the political implications of this effort by Mark Cuban and and others to eliminate the National Anthem, and it will be argued about ad nauseum back and forth without any ultimate gain, goal, or resolution, just like many social issues that roil the public. But if public sentiment turns and it sets off a domino effect where the National Anthem is eliminated at sporting events at large, it could have major implications in the music world that many are not calculating for at the moment.
Though Mark Cuban has not specifically cited the National Anthem as socially problematic, that is most certainly the stance some have been taking. But opponents of playing the anthem are also taking other stances that just don’t make any sense. One of the prevailing opinions is “Hey, they don’t play the National Anthem at my office every morning before we start work, so why would they do it at a sports game?” This sentiment has been shared over and over on social media amid the debate, and by prominent commentators such as Kevin Williams at the Chicago Tribune.
But the reason they don’t play the National Anthem at your work is because it’s not a community function. 50,000-100,000 people don’t regularly congregate to watch a cubicle farm go through the motions 9 to 5 on a Tuesday. Commentators don’t broadcast play by plays from your office to radio, TV, and online audiences. Many sports venues were paid for in part by government dollars and/or tax incentives. Same goes for many of the smaller ballparks, hockey rinks, football stadiums, and gymnasiums throughout the country. Sports events are commonly civic gatherings, which is the reason for performing the “Star Spangled Banner.”
Others complain the National Anthem is simply a waste of time, which seems like a strange complaint about a 2-minute song being performed at the beginning of a 2 to 3-hour match where grown men fight over a rubber or pigskin ball. That seems like a loss of perspective.
Ultimately though, the NBA overruled Mark Cuban and The Mavericks, saying in a statement on 2-10, “With NBA teams now in the process of welcoming fans back into their arenas, all teams will play the national anthem in keeping with longstanding league policy.”
Mark Cuban later responded to the NBA’s statement with, “We are good with it,” meaning they will begin including the National Anthem in game presentations after all. At least for now.
But the eliminating the National Anthem could have major implications on the music world that need to be discussed in the debate. Performing the National Anthem is often one of the most important stepping stones in an amateur or professional musician’s career, and may be one of the few opportunities to be able to perform in front of a large crowd. It’s a rite of passage. This may seem superfluous to some, but many singers will cite the performing of the National Anthem at sporting events as one of the most pivotal moments of their career. From minor league baseball games in smaller communities, to packed NFL stadiums, these performances can make an artist, and help break a career when other opportunities don’t present themselves.
The National Anthem is just as much a part of the musical farm system in America as local radio, open mics, dive bars, and county fairs. And with the evaporation of locally-programmed radio, an opportunity to sing the National Anthem may be the only opportunity an up-and-coming artist has to perform for a large local crowd, and receive recognition.
This is not a hypothetical. In 1974 while a sophomore in college at Southeastern Oklahoma State University, Reba McEntire performed the National Anthem at the National Finals Rodeo in Oklahoma City (see video below). In the crowd that day was Red Steagall. Red was so impressed with Reba’s performance, he eventually brought her to Nashville where she was signed to Mercury Records. The rest is history.
“After the rodeo, we all went up to the Justin [boots] suite at the Hilton and we were all in this big suite and the guys were passing the guitar around, and somebody asked me to sing ‘Jolene,’ no ‘Joshua,'” Reba later recalled.
This is just one of many instances of the National Anthem being a critically-important stepping stone in music. The National Anthem is also often an important cross-pollination event between genres and cultures, like we saw at the 2021 Super Bowl with Eric Church and Jazmine Sullivan turning their respective fan bases onto new music through the collaboration. Since it’s recited at community gatherings, music fans are exposed to artists they otherwise might not be. This is why major labels and booking agents actively work their clients to the sports world to perform National Anthems if they desire to in an effort to increase their name recognition.
And none of this is to mention the iconic recitations of the song, from Whitney Houston’s 1991 performance at the Super Bowl, to Marvin Gaye’s magical rendition at the 1983 NBA All-Star Game, to Jennifer Hudson’s at the 2009 Super Bowl, to Jimi Hendrix playing the Star Spangled Banner at Woodstock in 1969 … well, not exactly a sporting event, but one we all remember for sure. These are iconic moments in music and American history, and should not be sacrificed for silly concerns over time constraints, or some other misnomer about the National Anthem’s relevancy.
Performing the National Anthem is not just a sports issue. It’s a music issue. And eliminating its recitation as a matter of course would mean the elimination of thousands of opportunities for local, regional, and national performers to sing in front of crowds, and shine, inspire, uplift, and perhaps even make their career, or inspire a young person in the crowd to to pursue music or singing themselves.
Perhaps the era of the “Star Spangled Banner” before all sports games is fleeting. But the musical quotient should definitely be considered in that calculus.
February 11, 2021 @ 9:54 am
Half of the time the anthem isn’t even shown on TV anymore anyway. I’d say keep it for major events (Super Bowl, championship games, special occasions) and eliminate for the rest. Canada and the US are pretty much the only countries who do it anyway, and half the time people just complain about the anthems being butchered
February 12, 2021 @ 3:18 pm
I believe that the National anthem should continue it an important part of the game and we have to be silent to listen to the person singing and i have my own office and i play it everyday before i start my day so let me just say let it play !
February 13, 2021 @ 10:34 am
There is nothing wrong with the anthem. It is part of the game experience. This is the only time most Americans even realize they are Americans. All you have to do is stand there for two minutes or so. No one is asking you to storm the beaches of Iowa Jima.
Also, if singers would sing it the way it was originally written, it would last under one minute.
February 15, 2021 @ 6:20 pm
Long past time to end the National Anthem at sporting events. Concentrate on the game and not the nationalistic, militaristic, faux patriotic BS which the song and the attendant military aspects of playing it with the large flags, soldiers on the field, and the fly overs of military aircraft. The US is the most violent and terrorist nation in the world, about time that people recognize this and deal with it rather than continue to go along to get along…. Play the game and don’t endorse millions spent on military recruiting efforts….
February 11, 2021 @ 9:56 am
The anthem before games is an incredibly weird thing that Americans just accept as not weird because it’s just been done that way for as long as most people can remember. There’s no good reason for it. It’s also absurd how many taxpayer dollars the Pentagon spends to encourage the practice and use sports leagues as a promotional too.
February 11, 2021 @ 10:13 am
Yeah, this is another misnomer about the National Anthem that’s just not true. Canada plays their anthem before all sporting events, as do many South American and Asian countries. Basically what people should say is that British Premier League Soccer (football) doesn’t play the National Anthem before games—except finals matches, where they do. Sure, it’s adoption is spotty across the world. But the US isn’t alone in playing it before sporting events.
But again, I’m just wanting to enter the musical quotient into the conversation. There are multiple artists, especially women in country, who’ve relied on Nashville Sounds games and other National Anthem performances to get name recognition and experience when nobody else would let them in.
February 11, 2021 @ 12:57 pm
“It’s also absurd how many taxpayer dollars the Pentagon spends to encourage the practice and use sports leagues as a promotional too[l].” I have never heard of the Pentagon spending any money to promote the singing of the anthem. The only time the military is involved is when there is a flyover of some form during/after the anthem is sung.
Even if the flyover is what you were referring to, that isn’t an extra cost. The pilots have to have so many hours of practice/flight time to keep their certification. They would be up in the air in the aircraft either way. They just are flying over a stadium instead of out over nothingness or transiting between two points.
February 11, 2021 @ 2:48 pm
He’s referring to Paid Patriotism. The Pentagon paid the NFL and other entities to play the National Anthem, spotlight soldier homecomings on the field between quarters and roll out those large flags. They were using sports teams as a recruiting tool. The late Senator McCain ended this terrible practice.
https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/11/05/454834662/pentagon-paid-sports-teams-millions-for-paid-patriotism-events
It’s also when I soured on the National Anthem.
February 11, 2021 @ 10:25 am
Didn’t the NBA just now come out and overrule Cuban?
February 11, 2021 @ 10:33 am
Yes, Mark Cuban came out late Tuesday and confirmed they would no longer be including the National Anthem, and it appeared they had told the league about it, and the league was okay with it. Then on Wednesday the NBA came out with a statement saying it was league policy to play the National Anthem.
Full disclosure: I first wrote this article when it appeared the Dallas Mavericks were not going to be including the National Anthem anymore in home games, and the NBA wasn’t going to put up a fight. Then Richie Albright died, and I didn’t get it posted. So I updated it with the new info, and posted it today. With the NBA’s decision, I’m not sure this is as big of a concern. But I felt there were still some important points that needed to be made.
February 11, 2021 @ 10:39 am
Roger that.
Full disclosure: I commented before reading the whole article.
February 11, 2021 @ 10:26 am
i have never heard a rendition of the anthem that caused me to check out the performer.
and please, no politics in the comment section. this is a music website that didn’t start talking about the musical aspect of this story until halfway through the article.
February 11, 2021 @ 11:17 am
So are you whining about the article or the comments?
February 11, 2021 @ 12:30 pm
I understand that to some people’s world view, the National Anthem means nothing to them. Reba McEntire and others would disagree. I’m not presenting a hypothetical here. Another artist named Mary Sarah created a lot of interest in her career singing National Anthems when Music Row had basically shut her out. This is a real thing.
February 11, 2021 @ 12:42 pm
i didn’t say the national anthem doesn’t mean anything to me. i said “i have never heard a rendition of the anthem that caused me to check out the performer.”
February 11, 2021 @ 3:01 pm
You know what, dude? Screw you. Trigger posts so many different articles that cover the broader spectrum of music and I read every single one of them. The only time I EVER see you comment is when there’s a perceived political bent that you can come on here waving your self-righteous flag of how much better you are than people who dare disagree with you. We lost so many uncelebrated titans of music in the last few years, and from you? Not a peep. This guy (one of the few remaining TRUE journalists) writes a story about the impact of potentially lost exposure to artists, and you come trolling along. Just. Freaking. Stop. And, no. I’m not some simpleton who worshipped at the altar of the Sentient Cheeto. I’m a person who loves music and believes in its healing power. Matt Woods LITERALLY saved my life with the power of a song. So don’t try baiting me into some virtue-signaling argument. Just…stop.
February 11, 2021 @ 4:06 pm
i didn’t make a political comment. can anyone around here read?
and
APRIL 7, 2020 @ 7:41 PM
rip. enjoy that cocktail and nine mile cigarette.
https://savingcountrymusic.com/john-prine-leaves-us-with-the-wisdom-from-another-world-rip/#comments
(so screw you)
February 11, 2021 @ 5:25 pm
Gentile,
You are regularly and purposely disruptive, veering conversations unnecessarily into politics, and degrading fellow commenters. There are others that do this as well, but you know better, and choose to veer off topic as opposed to contributing constructively to it. If I didn’t appreciate or value your opinion, I would not keep allowing your comments. But if you actually want to contribute to the discussions as oppose to just troll them, you would make a better spokesperson for your perspective.
February 11, 2021 @ 5:43 pm
i didn’t say anything political or disruptive, stuck to the topic at hand, and i’m getting a reprimand. meanwhile di is talking about sucking dick and big tex is calling for secession from the union…
lol.
February 11, 2021 @ 7:19 pm
Gentile,
Stop worrying about di. Not worth your concern.
Try to find ways to be happy.
And btw, i wish you happiness.
February 11, 2021 @ 10:31 am
As far as Cuban goes, this is nothing more, than another billionaire, out of touch with most of America, trying to show solidarity with 37 year-old Pasty-Whites™️.
February 11, 2021 @ 10:41 am
It’s always the people who benefited the most from America who are now the most anti-american
February 12, 2021 @ 12:59 pm
……”It’s always the people who benefited the most from America who are now the most anti-american”…..
2016 Lily-Millies: “Kneeling for The National Anthem is good, because it shows that America can be better, and isn’t yet living up to its values.”
2021 Lily-Millies: “The National Anthem doesn’t represent me.”
February 11, 2021 @ 11:05 am
It’s also worth noting that Mark Cuban is neck-deep with China in terms of his business dealings, and “external pressures” not only from BLM but his foreign handlers could be playing a role in his decision-making. He just so happened to let the mask slip during a recent podcast:
https://variety.com/2020/politics/news/mark-cuban-nba-china-megyn-kelly-1234803523/
https://thetexan.news/dallas-mavericks-owner-mark-cuban-defends-nbas-business-with-china/
https://www.foxbusiness.com/business-leaders/mark-cuban-condemns-human-rights-violations-but-is-ok-doing-business-with-china
February 11, 2021 @ 2:24 pm
We all knew Mark Cuban was sucking itty bitty dick the moment this happened.
February 11, 2021 @ 3:47 pm
How are things going for you, Di? You and your neighbor’s family are still in my prayers!
February 11, 2021 @ 5:45 pm
Hi NPC,
Doing great, thank you. : D
Your prayers are very much appreciated, especially for T.J.’s family.
Hope you, your friends and loved ones are doing well!
Moving in March. When T.J. was murdered knew that i wouldn’t stay in the area.
Moving to a town of ~ 200 Artisans. Great energy & vibe.
Possibly get a horse. Friends have a cabin close by and said i was welcome to put a horse there.
Have a good evening, and thank you again
February 12, 2021 @ 5:21 am
If people are willing to connect the dots, everything is right there out in the open.
Cuban and the NBA are owned by the CCP and act accordingly, just like Hollywood. But oh my, they are SO concerned with social justice. The biggest bunch of hypocrites walking this earth.
On topic: this stuff never stops once you let it happen. First the national anthem, then the flag etc.
February 14, 2021 @ 6:03 am
Mr Cuban isn’t really Mr Cuban. His real last name is Chabenisky. Yes it is a jewish name but no one is persecuting jews in the US. I’ve always found it odd that there are a number of people in the entertainment industry that feel they have to hide their last names. In fact it’s disturbing. What else are they hiding? This is America. You shouldn’t have to hide your last name and it seems very disingenuous by the people who do it and to me it comes across as fake and shady. Mark above all people should appreciate this country for what it is and for taking in his family and giving them refuge and opportunity. Instead he turns around and takes a dump on it. Creepy guy.
February 19, 2021 @ 2:19 pm
Personally I love our national anthem and believe it should be played at the start of any events, heck I think my place of work should play it before every shift. It promotes nationalism in our country. While I think all should stand, I find focusing on the ones who don’t, whether they be fans or players, just draws too much attention to them. These players especially have plenty of avenues to get their opinions out far as professional athletes go. If reporters and people just basically ignore their kneeling or whatever, then things would be fine.
February 12, 2021 @ 7:38 am
When I first read your comment, I thought it said “Patsy-Whites.” That works as well.
February 12, 2021 @ 12:54 pm
“Pasty-Whites”, “Lily-Millies”, I’m referring to the generation of urban, firmly middle to upper-middle-class Americans, born between 1983 and 1999, who complain about how horrible America is on their IPhone 11s while sipping on $7 dollar cups of coffee.
If white privilege where real, these folks are the whitest of the white. They’re so white, that they harbor luxury political beliefs; these are political beliefs that make them feel and appear virtuous to themselves and other members of their class, while simultaneously creating poor living conditions for people of all races who aren’t as “Pasty-White” as they are.
Let this soak in:
Mark Cuban wants to ban the anthem to appease China, and to appease Pasty-Whites who Tweet about hating America on IPhones manufactured in China.
February 12, 2021 @ 5:14 pm
“Mark Cuban wants to ban the anthem to appease China, and to appease Pasty-Whites who Tweet about hating America on IPhones manufactured in China.”
Nailed it.
But you already knew that. : D
February 11, 2021 @ 10:37 am
Play the damn song. It’s not about bowing to the government. I just like living in the USA. I hear Rocky Top, being a Tennessean, I feel the same thing. It’s home. Some of you all need to get off the intellectual high horses.
February 11, 2021 @ 10:41 am
Yeah, the national anthem is a bizarrely American thing. It makes no sense to play it before a sports contest. Just a strange custom, and I am happy to see it start to end. No one else does this.
February 11, 2021 @ 12:17 pm
Not true, I am Canadian; the anthem is played before every hockey game – big league/lower league etc, and I believe for other sports as well, although I don’t follow other sports. I think it’s perfectly fitting – it’s our national anthem, sung before we play our national game, people feel a sense of community/patriotism, it takes 2 minutes. Why not play it.
February 11, 2021 @ 10:57 am
What’s it going to be replaced with, the Black National anthem and maybe a Gay/Trans National Anthem? As a Libertarian I don’t really care if they stop singing the national anthem. Maybe I’m a jerk, but I’m not interested in seeing charities and social causes intertwined in sports.
February 11, 2021 @ 11:03 am
Sounds corny but certain renditions of the National Anthem still give me chills. Something about being at a gathering full of people, yet they all pause and come together to honor this country and it’s citizens.
February 11, 2021 @ 11:20 am
All of these comments about how only the US does this, who cares? It’s a point of civic pride and something unique. Besides what other counties have four massive major professional sports leagues not to mention the college and minor league franchises we have. Not comparable.
February 11, 2021 @ 12:38 pm
Saying the US is the only one that does this is also just not true. I’d almost rather hear the arguments that it’s jingoistic propaganda blah blah blah, because at least that’s rooted in some sort of foundational opinion as opposed to unfactual mealy mouthed frap.
February 11, 2021 @ 11:21 am
I personally, wish they would get rid of it. the song use to mean something, but all it is now is a political fighting point. Liberal singers sing it. the conservatives loose their minds and vice versa. people kneeling. people flipping out.
when a conservative singer does sing it all conservatives do is say take that liberals! I am so sick of the left and the right making this a fighting point. I wish they would get rid of it. so we could just get on with watching the sport and could enjoy a little bit of escapism without making it a left vs right war.
February 11, 2021 @ 3:10 pm
Get rid of it, it’s weird and would solve a lot of the issues people have in sports on both sides
February 11, 2021 @ 5:53 pm
Let’s just get rid of the United States altogether. We aren’t united. It’s ridiculous that every 2 years we all get so excited about the chance to force our will upon the other 49%.
February 12, 2021 @ 2:48 pm
I was at a game once and stood up took my cap off and all that. Some people in front of me stayed seated, their right I don’t really care. The guy behind me proceeds to spend the whole anthem yelling at the people in front of me to stand up. I am here literally one row from each person. I have never felt the anthem was so disrespected as in that moment of the guy behind me yelling. Sadly I agree with you, get rid of the anthem at games. People can’t get along over the stupidest shit and don’t deserve the anthem.
February 11, 2021 @ 11:26 am
I love the Star Spangled Banner. I love it even when it’s butchered. I love making sporting events civic events. I don’t know when the basic idea was lost, but in public sports competitions, we all come together to enjoy ourselves and to be grateful for the excellence on offer. That gratitude extends to those who have given their lives on our behalf.
Our national anthem challenges us to ask whether we can still “see” this, unlike other national anthems that sing about the motherland or fatherland, etc.
We certainly can see it, even if contemptible egoists like Mark Cuban can’t.
February 11, 2021 @ 6:14 pm
Excellent comment.
February 11, 2021 @ 11:26 am
It’s not just an american thing. Here in Italy the national anthem gets played during major (exspecially international) soccer matches, though most of the times players don’t know the lyrics and just lip sync them.
February 11, 2021 @ 11:38 am
Just replace the National Anthem with “America the Beautiful”. Boom, problem solved, everyone’s happy. ????
February 11, 2021 @ 1:15 pm
I think the stadium collectively singing the national anthem, a song set to the melody of an old British drinking song, before binge drinking with friends and cheering on a team is perfect.
Although untrue, even if it was something only we in the US do, all the better.
February 11, 2021 @ 3:16 pm
All major sports leagues that caved to blm have suffered tremendously, yet they just can’t stop doing stupid shit to push fans away. It’s pathological, a sickness deep in the bones of the ‘woke’ dildos who, as I’ve said previously, if they were anymore asleep would be dead.
Music will be fine. It’s the major league sports that will be shrinking, not just revenue wise, but support wise. It’s more entertaining watching billionaires and millions fall all over each other to destroy their brands with political correctness and group think than the actual sports themselves.
February 11, 2021 @ 6:17 pm
In my opinion major league sports in the US suffering more so because it’s a corrupt and rigged big business. The games are not fun to watch anymore when you know the refs have been paid off and all you get are the same pile on teams in sports like the NBA.
February 12, 2021 @ 2:51 pm
What major sports caved to BLM? And which didn’t? I am under the impression ratings are down in all sports. You got any data to back your claims up or are you just shooting from the hip?
February 13, 2021 @ 11:16 pm
The information is out there, Ian. Don’t be so fucking lazy; do your own research.
February 14, 2021 @ 10:51 am
That is what I am saying. I have looked into it. Hockey is down, PGA is down, NASCAR is down, MLB is down… those are the major sports that have mostly avoided the controversy. NFL is down but looks like one of the better ones rating wise relative to other sports. NBA is similar. TV viewing habits have changed.
February 14, 2021 @ 10:53 am
https://www.forbes.com/sites/alexreimer/2020/12/16/why-sports-tv-ratings-will-likely-still-suffer-in-2021/?sh=4dfc0d4c2acf
See this link.
February 11, 2021 @ 3:20 pm
I envision, sooner rather than later, a great – and long overdue – cleavage of this nation into at least two separate ones.
Let the great, patriotic people of the Red States form their own nation, and let the left-wingers, all of whom hate the USA, form their own Blue State nation.
Problem solved.
Oh, one more thing.
We will send Cuban and all other Texans like him to the Blue States.
February 11, 2021 @ 4:36 pm
With both sides weaponizing the song, artists are going to stop volunteering to sing it at events? It’s toxic. Forced nationalism and paid patriotism isn’t the foundation of a true democracy.
February 11, 2021 @ 5:07 pm
A “true democracy” usually starts with a guillotine and ends with dispossession. 50 years ago, even the most ignorant victims of public schools would never have argued that this country was or should be a “democracy.”
February 12, 2021 @ 10:46 am
I said that because I know past elected officials and Presidents have validated invading countries under the guise of spreading democracy and freedom when we ourselves aren’t a democracy – a constitutional republic.
February 12, 2021 @ 10:29 am
Thank God we are a republic.
February 12, 2021 @ 10:51 am
If we can keep it.
As Ben warned us.
February 11, 2021 @ 6:07 pm
This is a good thing
Musicians have better things to do that be reduced to awkward spectacle before a bunch of muscle bound cavemen run back and forth
Roy Clark did the anthem before a game once
Why is Roy Clark reduces to a sideshow in front of a bunch of people who might not know who he is?
He’s Roy Clark he’s deserving of a proper audience who appreciates him not a bunch of people who couldn’t care less
And the same goes for every musician
They deserve to perform for themselves not be circus freaks at an unrelated event that reduces them to trivial two bit bearded ladies in front of a crowd that didn’t come to respect them but came for an unrelated reason
It’s very disrespectful especially to big names to treat them like disposable bit parts in another field
You don’t ask tom hanks to be a rodeo clown
You don’t ask Superman to be a commentator at the olympics
You don’t ask nikola Tesla to be on antiques roadshow
February 11, 2021 @ 7:08 pm
No one asks you to do anything, except sweep the floor and carry out the trash.
February 12, 2021 @ 1:16 pm
Superman may not commentate, but he’s not above being an umpire. https://www.si.com/si-kids/2016/03/25/batman-v-superman-sports-edition#&gid=ci025575c930082580&pid=batman-superman-sports-05jpg
February 11, 2021 @ 6:12 pm
I remember having to do the Pledge of Allegiance and then finding out the word God was added later. As a kid, I thought that was DUMB, so I stopped saying it. As to the National Anthem I always felt we had a lousy National Anthem it should’ve been Guthries’ This Land Is Your Land but any National Anthem would seem hollow with such a great economic, social, and political divide.
Is this day and age I think more people might willingly stand for Taylor Swift song (or some other pop anthem) than anything else. LOL!
February 11, 2021 @ 7:21 pm
It is a badass piece of literature that celebrated a great moment in American history.
Respect it. Period.
February 12, 2021 @ 7:40 am
Singing a national anthem is fine. But the Star Spangled Banner is a terrible “song”. It’s really hard to sing properly, well out vocal range of the almost everyone. It celebrates a military victory (fine) but that’s it. Way too jingoistic.
This Land is Your Land would be way better. Francis Scott Key was a colossal rabidly anti-abolitionist dick. Woody Guthrie, I’ve been told, was not.
February 12, 2021 @ 10:53 am
A national anthem being is jingoistic is fine. It is a national anthem, after all. Country pride is not a sin.
Guthrie was a communist hack. Give me Key any day. He loved this country and didn’t want to fundamentally transform it to follow the trend of a murderous doctrine (communism).
February 12, 2021 @ 6:11 pm
It’s a challenging song to sing, just like it’s a challenge in terms of the lyrics. I like it for just that reason. This country doesn’t say to people: “sorry, but you’ll never really be American because you weren’t born here.” It says: “you respect us and want to join us? Cool, but here are some expectations in return.”
By the way, you know that there are more verses than the one we sing, right?
February 12, 2021 @ 12:43 am
Most of the time, renditions of the National Anthem are horrible – vainglorious and selfish displays of unnecessary vocal acrobatics and ego with no idea of the significance of it. Quite disrespectful and annoying. Also can be a major liability to a musician if their performance deemed “awful” – they’ll die with that reputation, no matter how “profound” their work may or will be. If this issue is to be treated respectfully, it should be performed conservatively, traditionally with a tinge of nostalgia – or not at all. And as far as “politics”; perhaps maybe sideline this tradition since it does more harm than good. It forces athletes, fans and people in general in a compromising position in a venue where people are seeking relief from “politics” not engage in it. There are more important was of showing your loyalty to our country; like volunteering at the VA or consistently voting…..
February 12, 2021 @ 8:43 am
I learned about the great tenor Enrico Pallazzo from his rendition of the National Anthem in Naked Gun
February 12, 2021 @ 7:27 pm
Welcome to Biden’s America.
February 14, 2021 @ 1:46 pm
How about we keep singing the anthem but just get a better song, one everyone can follow along too and that celebrates more than war? I nominate “This Land Is Your Land” by Woody Guthrie. Any other suggestions
March 2, 2021 @ 4:19 pm
I think America the Beautiful would be a great replacement. I agree that instead of a song that is primarily focused on war, how about a song that is about the beauty of this great country that Americans were blessed to be born in. And let me add that just because we were “blessed” to be born in the USA doesn’t mean that we’re “exceptional” by birthright.