How Wal-Mart Is Helping The Spread Of Hick-Hop
On July 4th, The Wall Street Journal posted a rather lengthy, in-depth look into The Unlikely Rise of Hick Hop. Focusing in tighter than the more broad country rap phenomenon that is gripping mainstream country music in 2013, the Journal draws parallels between the rural recreational sport of “muddin'” and the emergence of artists that use a rapping style set to country lyrical themes in a tight knit underground that doesn’t rely on traditional radio play for support. Saving Country Music has talked about many of these bands in the past like the Jawga Boys and Moonshine Bandits, and how they are able to garner tremendous loyalty from fans by using YouTube and other easily-accessible outlets, and whose fan bases have ballooned to astounding numbers in the last few years.
One of the principle purveyors of this underground hick hop is the record label Average Joe’s, which is home to artists like Colt Ford and Brantley Gilbert, but also has a large barn of underground country rappers like the LoCash Cowboys and Bubba Sparxxx. Average Joe’s is on the cutting edge of marketing country rap to consumers, and doing so in an unconventional way that side steps country radio and traditional album distribution. What The Wall Street Journal piece explains is how Average Joe’s has been working very intimately with Wal-Mart to market country rap to certain areas seen as favorable to the emerging sub-genre. While physical CD sales are falling overall, Average Joe’s has been able to keep the CD alive with the help of Wal-Mart, and country rap.
It started in country’s traditional stronghold of the Southeast.
Wal-Mart started getting calls from stores across the Southeast from customers complaining that mud-themed music was only available online, said Tiffany Couch, sales director of Select-O-Hits, a division of closely held Anderson Merchandisers that Wal-Mart hires to supply its 4,000 Supercenter stores with CDs. Cautiously, she said, they began stocking several hundred Wal-Mart stores in the region with the music, waiting to make sure it sold before expanding to other locations.
But once hick hop began to take off, Average Joe’s expanded their reach across the country.
To assure Wal-Mart about its prospects for selling more mud music outside the Southeast, Average Joe’s last year showed the retailer “heat maps” drawn up by Pandora. The maps showed where Pandora users were listening to the new genre most frequently, landing the records in nearly half of Wal-Mart’s Supercenters nationwide. Average Joe’s also began using Pandora’s heat maps to route artists’ tours through unlikely areas with high fan concentrations, like Ohio, Indiana and the Pacific Northwest.
The parallel the Wall Street Journal piece does not draw is how hick hop and Wal-Mart tend to have the same demographics of poor, sometimes disadvantaged, and sometimes culturally disenfranchised white people from rural areas. For many of these consumers, whether it is because Wal-Mart is the only store in town, or because they offer cheap prices, the big box retailer has become the only retail outlet they have access to, and in turn becomes their primary interface and outlet for culture, including music. And while Wal-Mart has ceased to carry the wide swath of music that consumers used to see at traditional music stores, or at stores like Circuit City and Best Buy during the height of the CD era, the retailer has zeroed in on the hick hop market as a specialty and focus of many of their stores. Wal-Mart also tends to stock the same type of clothing and other consumables seen in hick hop videos, becoming a one stop shop for the country rap culture.
The most important takeaway from the Wall Street Journal piece might be that the emergence of country rap is multi-pronged, and highly profitable. This is not just Blake Shelton releasing one song to a mainstream audience. Hick hop, or country rap is a widespread, nationwide phenomenon spanning mainstream and underground channels alike, and now being disseminated through the world’s largest retailer to American consumers en masse.
Keith L.
July 10, 2013 @ 8:21 am
Something I know a little about. I worked for Wallyworld for 19 and 1/2 years. Busted my ass day in and day out, worked my way up from an hourly associate to “District” level management, only to be called in one day and told they no longer needed my services. It’s the money hungriest entity in the United States. They don’t care about their associates, their reputation, their community. The only thing they care about is “bottom line”. No fear, once the popularity of “hick hop” wavers the least little bit, they will get dropped like a hot rock.
emfrank
July 12, 2013 @ 11:34 am
Perhaps you might appreciate a song from Steve Earle’s most recent album… https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jebt9OnHh6A
Shastacatfish
July 10, 2013 @ 8:23 am
I think the time has come to stop referring to this as country rap. There is nothing country about it, musically speaking (obviously). The themes in the songs are certainly rural, southern, redneck or whatever you want to call them, but they are in no way limited to country music’s thematic domain. It is more helpful and appropriate to refer to it as hickhop, as that implies a severing of the connection with country music.
Trigger
July 10, 2013 @ 10:37 am
My running theory is that there is no country rap. There is country, and hip-hop. Hip hop has always borrowed from other genres, and as soon as it takes whatever it takes from another genre, it ceases to be from the parent genre and simply becomes hip-hop.
Mattwrotethis
July 10, 2013 @ 10:44 am
That is, and always has been what rap is and does. Why rap using country samples, or even written using country as a backdrop is getting treated any differently is beyond me. The actual direct cross-genre work doesn’t bother me, it can be quite good at times, and the experimentation with sound is what music is all about. Unfortunately, for every “Walk This Way” (Aerosmith/RunDMC) and “Over and Over Again” (Nelly/Tim McGraw) we get a hundred bad cross-genre examples.
Rob Williams
November 9, 2015 @ 1:51 am
“experimentation with sound is what music is all about” this is incorrect music is about taking the time to learn an instrument and the theory to make music. Experimentation with sound. is cacophony.
Mattwrotethis
November 9, 2015 @ 4:54 am
Jimi Hendrix, Chuck Berry, Jerry Reed, JJ Cale, Beck, and a whole host of others would disagree.
Davey Smith
July 11, 2013 @ 7:54 am
There are Horses and then there are Donkeys; Mules are Hick Hop… I think we know who Donkeys are…
Gunner
July 10, 2013 @ 8:24 am
“Hick Hop” ain’t bad,its not country,but it’s interesting to listen too. I wouldn’t even bother classifying it under the Country Music label. I’d wouldn’t even bother writing about it. It doesn’t really have much to do with country music. It’s not bein put on radio, leave it alone.
I listen to a bit of it(very little) and i enjoy it when i’m not crankin Real Country music. It’s not really somethin to worry about,leave it be.
Trigger
July 10, 2013 @ 10:41 am
Okay, so should we not worry about independent country and roots music because it is not on the radio either?
The point the Wall Street Journal was making is that they don’t need radio to have massive support and impact, both culturally and financially.
Gunner
July 10, 2013 @ 12:54 pm
Not necessarily, i was thinkin more along the lines that you seem to think that Hick Hop is a threat to traditional country,when it is not. its a different genre that shouldn’t be connected to country music. But people seem to connect the two with out a single similarity, I say leave em sing(rap) whatever they want too,they’re not affecting anything that has to do with country music.
Zac Schaneman
July 11, 2013 @ 7:56 am
how can you say “they”™re not affecting anything that has to do with country music,” when artists who create this music (jason aldean, colt ford, the moonshine bandits, blake shelton, etc., etc.) receive and have for years received major airplay on country radio and television outlets such as cmt and gac? does this not take opportunities from more traditional artists to have their music heard by a wider audience? granted, if people like it and are buying it, I can’t blame radio/tv for playing it. but saying that country rap, hick-hop, or whatever you want to call it is not affecting country music is ridiculous.
Gunner
July 11, 2013 @ 8:12 am
Out of the names you mentioned the only two i have heard on the radio are jason Aldean and Blake Shelton. Very little of “Hick Hop” if any, is bein played on country radio. It has their own fans,country music has theirs. Do some of the fans enjoy both? Yes. I happen to be one of em. You’re right CMT and GAC have given airtime to these acts,but if that’s what the consumers want to watch that’s what get. They’ve given the fans what they want. Acts like the Jawga Boys,Moonshine Bandits,and Colt Ford have yet to make it to radio(They don’t belong there obviously). I just think that till those acts make it to radio,we should leave em alone. Because they do no harm. They’re out there having fun and making money. That’s not a problem. The fact that this is even compared to country is beyond me,yeah they name drop some country singers,but shouldn’t be a big deal.
Kevin
July 10, 2013 @ 8:34 am
Man, I cannot stand Wal-Mart. Cheap, “Made in China” crap, bad customer service, horribly long lines, not to mention what they do to the economy of the towns that they go to. Also how they don’t pay a decent living wage and pretty much encourage people to use government assistance instead. If there’s one thing I hate more than country rap, it’s Wal-Mart. I haven’t stepped foot in one in at least two years. I avoid it like the plague.
Kev
July 10, 2013 @ 8:46 am
Yeah, I know what you mean. I live in the UK but everytime I’ve been in the States on a package holiday we end up being taken to a WalMart. Glad I’m doing my own thing this year!!
Phineas
July 12, 2013 @ 9:15 am
Totally forgot about this song but you just reminded me about it check it out I think you’ll get a kick out of it! (Matt the Electrician – Dear Angela)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XagsXc0MqR4
There’s also some good versions with a band out there too I think….
“Now, normally I avoid your store like it like a plague –
like a virus, or miley cyrus, in a teen magazine”
I think it’s also called “dear customer complaint department” …this is related (to the article) right? either way its fucking awesome.
And made in the USA.
Will
July 10, 2013 @ 8:41 am
These articles >>>>>> Shooter articles
SyntheticPaper
July 10, 2013 @ 10:43 am
People call up Walmart to complain about not being able to buy enough cds with “mud themed” songs at their stores.
There are just some things in this world that I will never ”¦ ever understand.
TX Music Jim
July 10, 2013 @ 11:00 am
walmart sales whatever will sale. not suprising. I agree with you country is country hip hop is hap hop etc. Not suprising you have 2 generations of rural white kids that grew up with both rap/hip hop and country. So something that in their minds combines the too is unfortunately appealing. The monogenere is alive and well. Thre is a large club about 35 east of Dallas in a semi rural area they book country tracy lawerence mark chesnett etc but also TExas/Red Dirt RRB/ Fowler/ Boland etc. In the last year and a half they have added guys like Colt Ford and PJ Sparxx to the mix as part of the regular revolving cycle of bands so it must draw.Again rural white kids who dig all three of the kinds of music that the club books. Sad but your comments about the monogenere are down right prophetic. Thankfully neither the Dallas or the Fort Worth Texas music station will play the colt Fords of the world at least yet.
TX Music Jim
July 10, 2013 @ 11:31 am
PJ Sparxx my bad I meant Bubba Sparxx !
Jon
July 10, 2013 @ 12:13 pm
Brantley Gilbert is on Big Machine not Average Joes. Just an FYI.
Trigger
July 10, 2013 @ 5:31 pm
He was on Average Joe’s. That may be the better way of putting it.The point is, they have/had big, recognized names, as well as smaller “mudd” acts.
Jesse David
July 10, 2013 @ 7:29 pm
They do, however, have Montgomery Gentry on their roster.
TX Music Jim
July 11, 2013 @ 9:13 am
Kevin Fowler is on the roster too.Lord I hope he doesn’t go to the “hick hop” darkside.
Acca Dacca
July 10, 2013 @ 12:28 pm
I’m suddenly rather concerned that Montgomery Gentry will go hick hop. Sure, they’ve collaborated on a few songs with Colt Ford, but bringing someone else in to rap is a far cry from doing it yourself. Being a part of Average Joe’s and not having had a hit record in a while, I think they might feel the call of country rap. 🙁
Chris
July 10, 2013 @ 11:07 pm
Dreams really do come true (sarcasm)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txjrVXONBVE
Chris
July 11, 2013 @ 10:01 am
I went to the itunes country section and they have a big ad for the Mud Digger 4 album mentioned in the The Wall Street Journal. The MG song is on it so hopefully it was just a label favor. Where I Come From hit #8 about a year ago so not too long ago. FGL might be MG’s biggest obstacle at radio.
https://itunes.apple.com/us/album/mud-digger-4/id656842332
Check out the many 1 star reviews. I listened to the samples and agree with them. Where’s the country because all I heard is rapping to rap beats and rock in most songs? They should call it rock rap.
Acca Dacca
July 11, 2013 @ 11:42 am
I was referring to the fact that MG’s albums used to consistently go Platinum, but they haven’t even had a Gold record since 2006. Sure, some of that is the current state of the industry, but the rest seems like a lack of interest. They’ve had a few decently successful singles, but singles don’t mean much if they don’t translate to record sales. They had a whole record to be titled “Freedom” canned at Columbia and a compilation as well, which caused them to elope to Average Joe’s. Despite “Titty’s Beer,” I still have hope for them and hope that they don’t decide to revamp their sound to sell a few more CDs.
And on the duo note, I think that FGL is an obstacle for ANY country artist on radio, but especially those like Montgomery Gentry. They’ve always had their own neo-traditionalist/southern rock blended sound, but their music tends to lack the drive of Jason Aldean or Eric Church, and doesn’t even come close to that boy band crap or (until the aforementioned abomination, anyway) objectifying women.
Acca Dacca
July 11, 2013 @ 11:33 am
I listened to that on Spotify and I literally couldn’t believe my ears. It wasn’t really hick hop, but the lyrics were so sexist and banal that my jaw hit the floor and I had to turn it off. Montgomery Gentry always struck me as a pair of decent guys and after “Some People Change” I began to respect them a lot. “Titty’s Beer” almost killed that respect in about 15 seconds. I can handle the musical side, as mediocre as it is, but come on, guys! “TITTY’S Beer”? Did Colt Ford threaten to fire you if you didn’t cut THIS song? Tell me you didn’t WANT to.
SyntheticPaper
July 11, 2013 @ 12:16 pm
That’s how I felt about it too, when I clicked the link, then I saw all the positive comments on youtube and was afraid I was just taking it all too seriously or something. I’m glad I’m not the only one who found that song to be more than a bit over the line.
RD
July 10, 2013 @ 12:41 pm
I reject hip-hop, ghetto culture and all of its evil works and empty promises.
Trainwreck92
July 13, 2013 @ 3:08 pm
Dude, you say something like this on every article that mentions rap. What has a genre of music done to you to make you hate it so vehemently?
RD
July 14, 2013 @ 3:44 am
Why do you care?
Ghetto “culture,” hip-hop “culture,” whatever you want to call it, is the lowest, basest, most destructive force in popular culture. It elevates, the dumb, the violent, the illiterate, the criminal, the misogynist, the lazy, the drug-addled, the welfare loafer, etc. as admirable. As it is pushed by the popular media, it permeates every element of society in order to destroy traditional American culture and make us dumb, illiterate, and servile.
Trainwreck92
July 16, 2013 @ 7:41 pm
I care because hip-hop is a form of music that I enjoy. If someone who’s only exposure to country music was through mainstream radio said that country was a horrible genre because of lazy songwriting, bland instrumentals, perpetuation of southern stereotypes, and promotion of ignorance as their reasons, that would bother me. As a lifelong country music fan, I know that the genre is far deeper, and more creative than mainstream radio portrays it. The same can be said of hip-hop/rap.
Mike
July 10, 2013 @ 1:08 pm
Based on what you quote, it appears that Wal Mart was not forcing this garbage down their customers throats, they were responding to their customers demanding they stock the music.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying Wal Mart does not have a negative impact on Southern Culture. However, at least here, I think Wal Mart is simply reflecting the problem rather than causing it.
Nnels
July 11, 2013 @ 2:09 am
I think the point is that WalMart is doing more than “reflecting the problem” – they are feeding the problem for profit with no regard for the social impact of this mindset. Or lack of mindset.
“Wal-Mart also tends to stock the same type of clothing and other consumables seen in hick hop videos, becoming a one stop shop for the country rap culture.”
WalMart, as a mega-corp, has a unique opportunity to make a real difference in promoting core American values. Hick-Hop is not one of them.
Mike
July 13, 2013 @ 11:57 am
Wal Mart does not really create many cultural trends. They are a cheap store that sells second rate stuff. For example, if some designer makes some type of popular shirt, they will eventually sell knock offs, or else try to license it to make cheaper versions. Either way, the fashion was already popular before wal mart got to it.
I don’t think you can honestly expect Wal Mart or any corporation to not stock music that their customers are demanding because they don’t approve of its values. The only time Wal Mart won’t stock something is because there is some outrage–usually either self righteous Christians or Leftists– who threaten a boycott.
Again, I’m not defending Wal Mart. I think they destroy downtowns and mom and pop stores, so I’d rather there be a lot less of them. However, once they are here, I can’t get upset at them for selling what their customers want–no matter how bad it is.
Trigger
July 11, 2013 @ 8:35 am
I hope I didn’t imply that Wal-Mart was “forcing it down people’s throats.” At the same time, like people have been complaining for years, if Wal-Mart runs all the other locally-owned busines and competitors out of town and you have only one place to shop, you’re giving consumers very few options and all of a sudden America dresses the same, and listens to the same music, which sounds the same no matter what genre it is being marketed in.
It Is Hot Outside Tiddy Bits
July 10, 2013 @ 2:55 pm
[…] WALMART IS THE DEVIL […]
Nellie
July 10, 2013 @ 3:35 pm
“And while Wal-Mart has ceased to carry the wide swath of music that consumers used to see at traditional music stores, or at stores like Circuit City and Best Buy during the height of the CD era, the retailer has zeroed in on the hick hop market as a specialty and focus of many of their stores.”
I have to say that it really annoys me that this music is becoming more widely available across the country (although still localized) but when I walk in to either of my nearby South Texas Walmarts I can’t find a Stragglers album or a Cody Johnson Band CD.
I do think it’s interesting that we’re at a point where CDs are still typical enough to even make this article possible. The increased presence of these CDs in stores must generate enough of a profit to keep from going exclusively digital. Would it be giving CDs too much credit to assume that they do a fair amount to keep these artists in business when we consider the prevalence of illegal downloading and the meager payments provided by online streaming services? The target demographic of hick-hop music seems to be a generation that is more technologically inclined, although the way that economic conditions determine access to that technology is complicated.
On a related note, it was kind of weird seeing Joe Diffie promoting an iTunes ringtone of “Girl Ridin’ Shotgun.”
Charlie
July 11, 2013 @ 11:45 am
“I have to say that it really annoys me that this music is becoming more widely available across the country (although still localized) but when I walk in to either of my nearby South Texas Walmarts I can”™t find a Stragglers album or a Cody Johnson Band CD.”
Sounds like you Texans need to get together and organize a phone-in campaign to Texas Wal-marts and complain. I hear that can work 😉
Chris
July 10, 2013 @ 11:36 pm
I saw a survey stating that half of country fans don’t have internet at home, so those people plus many with internet buy CDs from Walmart, Best Buy, Target etc. There’s been articles about Walmart removing CD rack space from stores so it’s interesting that a new unknown and unproven genre can get in there. This could be a way for more indie labels and country artists to get CDs in Walmart. Mainstream artists’ CDs can be hard to find there unless they are the ones labels promote to Walmart with exclusive bonus tracks and shows. Even when Kellie Pickler was getting halfway decent (top 15) airplay, fans had a hard time finding her CDs at Walmart and wanted exclusive bonus tracks but apparently Sony/19 reserved that for artists they promoted more, even a few with lower sales they dropped soon after their first albums released.
Pandora heat map is interesting
http://www.billboard.com/biz/articles/news/1561471/exclusive-pandoras-plan-to-share-more-streaming-data-with-artists
http://blog.omusicawards.com/2012/09/pandora-plots-tool-to-help-bands-plan-better-tours/
Clear Channel plays some of this hickhop type stuff online weekend nights on the Nashville Channel
http://www.iheart.com/live/The-Nashville-Channel-4623/
Check out Ziggy Pockets, he sounds better than most hick hop, rap or country rap I’ve heard. Some of his songs are funny too, especially Country Is
http://www.reverbnation.com/ziggypockets
Hickhop lyrics are better than rap but like pop it’s not country so I don’t want to hear it on country radio. That said I don’t mind listening to it occasionally online when I want. Most of what I’ve heard isn’t good music though.
Nnels
July 11, 2013 @ 2:00 am
“poor, sometimes disadvantaged, and sometimes culturally disenfranchised white people”
I get poor, I get disadvantaged, but what the heck do they mean by “culturally disenfranchised?”
Thanks for giving me another good reason to never set foot in WalMart again.
Ward
July 11, 2013 @ 8:49 am
Let me get this straight. Walmart drops Paula Deen, but they are selling and promoting this garbage called Hick-Hop? That tells me all I need to know about this disgrace of a retailer.
SyntheticPaper
July 11, 2013 @ 9:30 am
Walmart is highly hypocritical about their supposed corporate morals. They claim to not sell stickered CDs (though I have seen some on their shelves before), but yet they will have huge displays of “50 Shades of Grey” at the front of their stores. All they really care about is who and what they can get the most money from.
Phineas
July 12, 2013 @ 8:56 am
“omplaining that mud-themed music was only available online”
MUD THEMED??? lolol best laugh I’ve had in a while (even if it didn’t come off as an overtly racial metaphor / simile)’
Every day I feel more and more like that Idiocracy movie was actually dead on, and we’re headed there full fucking steam ahead lol
TX Music Jim
July 12, 2013 @ 9:31 am
Phineas, good point. We all maybe screwed.
Phineas
July 12, 2013 @ 9:05 am
I’m also quite surprised from all the comments (aside from the very first one) saying “NOW I really think Wal Mart is an evil giant corporation”
News flash folks – Most HUGE companies are most interested with their bottom line, regardless of what morals / ideas / etc they spread (unless the product placement / promotion somehow helps their bottom line, or endorses the owners / CEO’s views / beliefs). Buy local as much as possible, also buy shit that’s made in the USfuckingA.
Corporations are (apparently) people, albeit evil people. Never forget that shit.
One good point to take from this is that the record label is having some success with some alternative marketing / advertising methods, which is a huge factor in “our” music scene as well….imagine if any of the good artists we come here to read about were getting those kinds of numbers / views on youtube – it would be a game changer for sure
Of course this won’t be on a huge scale, but fuck look at 10 seconds of any of those artists’ videos and tell me that they’ll appeal to the “Mainstream” (although apparently enough to garners Wal Mart & the WSJ’s attention – I don’t think either of them would bat an eye at anything that is not going to make SOME MAJOR FUCKING MONEY
goldencountry
July 12, 2013 @ 10:20 am
Wal-mart’s bottom line is greed. I use to do in store demos. One Saturday they had to shut the store down because of a bomb threat. The was called in at Mid-night they were told it would go off at noon. The store didn’t shut down till 11:30 am.While we were outside the manger keep looking at his watch the whole time.
Phineas
July 12, 2013 @ 11:08 am
Trigger / Everyone, many of you have probably heard both of these songs, if not please check them out!!! One is clever / funny, and the second is like a song version of peopleofwalmart.com – let me know what you think! (assuming you haven’t heard it)
Matt the Electrician – Dear Angela (aka Dear Customer Complaint Dept)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XagsXc0MqR4
and…….drum roll………
Floyd Tolston – Wal Mart Lovers
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LqhN1CGRe4k
Please check’em out if you’re not familiar, both of these have much better sounding recorded / studio versions as well (fyi) but these were the quickest videos I could find of both…..
PS – Sorry to double post the Matt the Electrician song but I was afraid the one (up top) might be looked over since it’s up towards the beginning (of the comments section). Plus he’s a Texas guy.
Moose
July 12, 2013 @ 12:58 pm
Hey trigger this is totally off subject, but I just seen that Alan Jackson cut a bluegrass album, I’ve been looking but can’t find much, would you be able to let us know when it will be released and some more info on it
Gena R.
July 12, 2013 @ 1:17 pm
I found a link to this article, via Engine 145:
http://bluegrasstoday.com/the-bluegrass-album-from-alan-jackson/
Trigger
July 12, 2013 @ 1:48 pm
I have that story linked up in the news feed. That is all that is known at the moment, but when more info comes available, I’ll try to let folks know, either through the news feed, or by some other means.