Jelly Roll Could “F*ck A Goat” and Still Not Be Country

As a true country music fan, you almost want to like Jelly Roll. You almost want to accept him into the country music fold, despite his history with rap, despite the face tattoos and being a convicted felon and all of that, and even though his music remains much more rap, rock, and pop as opposed to country. Because at the heart of Jelly Roll’s story is a message of redemption, and it’s one that’s told in part through the vehicle of country music helping to facilitate his redemption story.
And Jelly Roll’s songs—despite still not being especially country—are so much better than what have come before him in the space where country and hip-hop collide. “Son of a Sinner” on the otherwise rap rock album Ballads of the Broken (2021) is the song that opened Jelly Roll up to the country market, and it’s not a bad song at all. Neither is “Need a Favor” and a few other songs from Jelly Roll’s “country” (in quotations) debut, Whitsitt Chapel.
But make no mistake about it. Jelly Roll is not a country artist. The music he makes is not country music, with some minor exceptions. And not to be pedantic or arrogant about it, but this is pretty inarguable, and empirically true from a technical, sonic standpoint. And it doesn’t matter how much you want Jelly Roll to be country, or how much you want the music he makes to be considered country. It’s just not.
Country rap is nothing new, despite its proponents perpetually characterizing it as being on the cutting edge of country’s evolution. Rap celebrated it’s 50-year anniversary in August of this year. Country artists have been experimenting with integrating rap elements into the music for over 40 years. Jason Aldean had the biggest song in popular country music a dozen years ago with the country rap track “Dirt Road Anthem.” You’re constantly being gaslighted about how this is something new, creative, innovative, and boundary pushing in the country space. It’s not. In 2023, it’s passé.
The trouble with country rap is not necessarily that it’s always terrible on its face. It’s that the end results are almost always trite and derivative because the point of country rap is commonly to cast the widest net of appeal. Country rap was one of the elemental building blocks of Bro-Country. And though nobody advocating for country rap will ever acknowledge this, country rap is also where you will find the most open and overt elements of racism anywhere in the country music sphere—however ironic that might be.
But that doesn’t mean creativity can’t reside in the country rap space. For years, performers like Yelawolf, Struggle Jennings, and yes, Jelly Roll to some extent, have proven country rap can be creatively lucrative, at least at times. What they do is far beyond Florida Georgia Line or Jason Aldean’s “Dirt Road Anthem,” which found their popularity through appealing to the widest possible audience and the least common denominator. Those versions of country rap were pure commercial product, and derivative tripe.
But now Jelly Roll wants to be part of mainstream country, and that changes the rules of engagement. Yelawolf appears on Jelly Roll’s new album Whitsitt Chapel, and Yelawolf said it best in 2015 when he derided the mixing of mainstream country with arena rap. Yelawolf said in part,
“I feel somewhat responsible to be in Nashville because I know that arena rap, and the little bits of meshing up country music with hip-hop has now made its way up to mainstream country. Country music artists talking about, ‘I’m in VIP. Shake it for me.’ Shit like that, it’s bad man.”
When Jelly Roll first started making his move into country, Saving Country Music didn’t put up a stop sign and protest. In fact in March of this year, an article titled “How Country Beat Back Hip-Hop in Mainstream Country” was published, highlighting the career track of former country rap artist Ernest, as well as quotes from Jelly Roll ahead of what was supposed to be his “country” album debut where he spoke about how he was using his move to country as a reformative aspect in his life, while promising the debut would be a “super country record.”
Here’s the quote in full from an Apple Radio interview,
The evolution that’s happened with my music was only a reflection of the evolution that happened as a man. Right? The music just evolved because the man evolved. This was just the music just followed my heart. It followed my spirit. I’m not that kid anymore. I was tearing my community apart and making CDs bragging about it. Ignorantly. In my defense, I didn’t have knowledge that I have now, you know. But there was no glory in that. I started singing more and getting more soulful and more in touch with the kind of music that I knew was important, which was the music that helped people. Like music had helped me whenever I was young. It just kind of followed that way.
Now, I still got hip hop elements in everything I do. I have a hip-hop element on my debut country album that’s coming out this summer and I have a hip-hop feature on it, but it’s still super country record. But my heart is different, man. My heart is to help. It’s not even about rap itself, it’s about the culture that I came from in the streets and just how misguided they are. Just how obstructive of a view we have when we were in that situation. It’s sad. I only see it now, because I’m out of it. You never see it when you’re in it. I only got above, got the 30,000 foot view and seen it. It’s like, “Man, I just want to make music that helps, the music that heals. I just want to try to do things to help the community that I’m from.”
But the problem is that when Whitsitt Chapel arrived in June, it didn’t have just one “hip-hop element” on it, and another “hip-hop feature.” If anything, it had only one or two country elements, and one or two country features. More than anything, it’s a pop record, which just like Yelawolf said back in 2015, is what you get when you try and mix mainstream country with commercial hip-hop.
But even then, Whitsitt Chapel wasn’t seen as problematic enough to openly criticize. There is music that is way worse than whatever Jelly Roll is doing in country, and so much better stuff to focus on than wasting breath about Whitsitt Chapel.
Even when Jelly Roll walked away recently with the CMA’s New Artist of the Year award over two very important artists in Zach Bryan and Parker McCollum, as well as two very important women surging in the mainstream space in Megan Moroney and Hailey Whitters, not a discouraging word was said about Jelly Roll. There were bigger fish to fry.
But in a recent extended interview on The New York Times‘ “Popcast” with Jon Caramanica, Jelly Roll decided to twist off on the folks that dare to say he’s not country while making some rather absurd statements about what country is, with the most quotable portion of the interview capturing Jelly Roll saying about trying to prove his country bona fides, “What do y’all want me to do, fuck a goat?”
Jelly Roll says later in the interview, “I don’t know how more country I could be … They said that about Garth Brooks and George Strait.”
For the record, nobody has ever said George Strait isn’t country. Ever. And by asserting such, you’re proving just how uninformed you are about what country music actually is.
As the interview continues, Jelly Roll commences naming off distinctly non-country performers and songs that were released into the country space, and then using them to justify how “country” he is. Jelly Roll states,
Let’s talk about country for a second … my love for country music. It’s my unbelievable favorite. And I can tell you little markers that have happened in the last 20 years that have let me know that I might be here one day. Obviously, all the early Aldean stuff, especially ‘Dirt Road Anthem.’ When there was a guy full blown rapping on country radio, I remember being like, ‘This has really got a chance.’ But when I heard the 808 (drum machine) from [Sam Hunt’s] “Break Up in a Small Town” on the Big 98 in Nashville at the time, and that was an undeniable Three 6 Mafia-esque 808. And that whole Sam Hunt project…
For context, Sam Hunt’s two albums Montevallo (2014) and Southside (2020) were both produced by Zach Crowell. Zach Crowell also one of the producers on Jelly Roll’s Whisitt Chapel. Jason Aldean is signed to BBR Records, which is the same label Jelly Roll is signed to.
When Jelly Roll said ahead of the release of Whitsitt Chapel that the album was going to be a “super country record,” his frame of reference for “super country” was Sam Hunt, “Dirt Road Anthem,” and Three 6 Mafia’s 808s, all of which are empirically more related to hip-hop than country. Jelly Roll didn’t cite George Strait or Garth Brooks, or even Luke Bryan or Tim McGraw. This speaks to Jelly Roll’s entirely misguided and patently incorrect concept of what country music is. And he’s not alone.
The host of The New York Times Popcast Jon Caramanica is a pop journalist who many times in the past has made it patently clear that he believes country music should sound more like performers such as Sam Hunt and Kidd G to “open up” the music. Being a pop writer, Caramanica believes country should sound more like the pop that appeals to him. In the interview, Caramanica gives credit to Hunt and “all the work that Sam Hunt was doing” in the 2010s for opening the door for a performer such as Jelly Roll in country music.
The co-host of this particular Popcast episode, Joe Coscarelli, is a hip-hop journalist and writer, and also offers no scrutiny to Jelly Roll, let alone devil’s advocacy to Jelly Roll’s “country” claims. And all of this happens under the auspices of the “paper of record,” The New York Times, which doesn’t see the need to employ an actual country music writer who can lend to this discussion with knowledge, authority, expertise, and proper context.
Why does any of this matter? Because Jelly Roll now has a CMA Award for Best New Artist, and two important country women that country needs more of in Hailey Whitters and Megan Moroney don’t. Neither do Zach Bryan and Parker McCollum who both came up through the grassroots of country. Meanwhile, Jelly Roll was a rapper who migrated into country, and very well might migrate back out when greener pastures present themselves. And if he does, country music will never get that CMA trophy back.
Country music has been burned too often in near history by awarding artists with the CMA New Artist of the Year that end up either jumping ship from country, or turn out to be creeps. Maren Morris, Jimmie Allen, Kacey Musgraves, and The Band Perry come to mind as recent New Artist of the Year recipients that are no longer active participants in the country genre.
Jelly Roll comes from a long line of great American hustlers, whose hustle has brought him to the financially lucrative space of mainstream major label country music. He talks about sobriety, but openly admits he doesn’t really practice it. He speaks about God and Jesus, but at times seems to only practice Christianity in a performative fashion, and sings about this specifically. He claims he’s country, but is really a rap/pop/rock artist. These are all classic American hustles.
And the biggest American hustle of them all is to constantly have your name associated with charity. Make no mistake, Jelly Roll’s giving back to the Nashville community that he’s a native of appears sincere, as well as prolific. This is not to question his ethics or the authenticity of these efforts.
But the constant, effervescent, daily and dutiful human interest reporting about Jelly Roll by Whiskey Riff, American Songwriter, Taste of Country, and others without any scrutiny has gone from over-the-top to outright nauseating while never acknowledging the clear marketing angle behind these charitable efforts.
Meanwhile, country artists like Chris Stapleton, Tyler Childers, and many others do many acts of charity each year without any public acknowledgement of them whatsoever, by the artists or the press, and on purpose.
Jelly Roll sheds more alligator tears than Garth Brooks—which is saying a lot—while holding back more skeleton’s in the closet that the rest of Nashville’s performer class combined. While he’s giving back, perhaps Jelly Roll could look into helping to compensate the mothers of the dead workers of his former country rap associate Mikel Knight who won a $20 million wrongful death lawsuit against Knight, and have yet to be paid out.
– – – – – – – – – –
Again, you want to like Jelly Roll. His story and career arc are compelling. He can write a good song. But that doesn’t make him country. Being country is not simply a declaration you make. It’s born out through your music, or it’s not.
I’d come to peace with Jelly Roll in the country space because he was the exception, not the rule. Similar to Bro-Country, country rap is compartmentalized as a concern in mainstream country, and on the wane. What’s on the march is actual country music, illustrated by the major success of artists like Lainey Wilson who just won the CMA Entertainer of the Year, and the aforementioned Megan Moroney. What is also on the march is more quality songs, including some cut by Jelly Roll.
Country music is succeeding right now in popular music like never before, and it’s because country music is leaning into its roots, and shirking the advice of Jon Caramanica and others who’ve been claiming country music needs to incorporate more pop and hip-hop elements to evolve and survive in the future. On the contrary, country music needs to be itself, assert what makes it unique in popular music, and not try to pander to anyone.
Country fans should not allow a pop writer, a hip-hop writer, and a rap performer to lecture them on what country music is, and what it should be. That is for country fans, country artists, and country writers embedded within this community and working in it on a daily basis to decide.
Go ahead and fuck a goat, Jelly Roll. That still won’t make you country. If you want to be considered country, if you want to stop fielding criticism about how you aren’t, then make actual country music instead of just claiming you are for marketing purposes.
December 21, 2023 @ 10:08 am
Fairly certain goats don’t support this option.
December 21, 2023 @ 10:44 am
Bhahahaa
December 21, 2023 @ 10:45 am
Save the goats!
No need to tenderize them that way.
December 21, 2023 @ 11:28 am
It’s fuck a sheep not a goat u ain’t even country BOY
December 21, 2023 @ 4:47 pm
Didn’t AC/DC sing “Dirty Deeds Done With Sheep”?
December 22, 2023 @ 8:36 am
Ray Wylie Hubbard should rewrite line to following for Jelly.” He’s got a gun rack, goat fuckers need love too, sticker.”
December 21, 2023 @ 5:08 pm
Preach!
May 4, 2024 @ 2:40 pm
Right get your farm animal right son !
December 21, 2023 @ 2:55 pm
Save a goat, ride a plowboy!!!
December 21, 2023 @ 10:13 am
You can be a convicted felon and still write and make country music idiot. Good rest of the article though lol
December 21, 2023 @ 10:36 am
I’m not saying you can’t be a convicted felon and make country music. On the contrary, this has been a common theme and redemption story in country music for many decades, told through artists like Merle Haggard, David Allan Coe, Jesse Daniel, and many others. It’s the underlying message of Johnny Cash’s prison albums.
People “seeing the light” through country music and finding their way on the straight and narrow is a compelling narrative, and in many respects, Jelly Roll is exploiting this through his move into country. But at the same time, just like country, he’s only got one foot in. He only wants to do some of the work, but to reap all of the rewards.
December 22, 2023 @ 6:32 am
Perhaps a look into why the CMA insists on giving these awards to people who aren’t quite deserving of them yet would be in order?
There was a time when the CMA awards show was appointment viewing in this house. We’d gather around to see what scandelous dress Reba was wearing, Brooks and Dunn pick up another Duo of the Year award, and Garth Brooks pick up another Entertainer of the Year award. But not anymore. I probably haven’t seen a CMA show in over 20 years now.
And I’d really like JR to answer the question of WHO said George Strait wasn’t country when he first arrived.
March 31, 2024 @ 10:55 am
Jelly Roll can sing if he wants, he can win awards if he wants. Don’t call him COUNTRY, don’t give him COUNTRY AWARDS. Pop or some other music can have him. I don’t want to hear him on my COUNTRY radio stations. Thank you
December 21, 2023 @ 10:17 am
The boys over at risky whiff love starting a headline with “Jelly Roll Tears Up” and “Jelly Roll Holds Back Tears” its so fuckin annoying lol. Like how retarded do you have to be to fall for all this shit. Sorry for saying retarded. This unabashed marketing and cheap emotional pleas are just so irritating, and more so when people fall for it.
Jeremy pinnell for CMA Artist Most Likely To Rip In a Manner Which Many Will Find Enjoyable 2024
December 21, 2023 @ 10:17 am
His music sucks. Never was and never is going to be country. I think I speak for many, Trig, when I say that we are perfectly fine if the Jelly Roll content stops with this write-up.
December 21, 2023 @ 10:39 am
There are many stories that could be written about Jelly Roll and I’ve been biting my tongue for months. But when he’s on a “New York Times” podcast lecturing folks about how he’s super country because of Sam Hunt, I have a sworn duty as the proprietor of Saving Country Music to speak up.
December 21, 2023 @ 10:24 am
Yeah, I was a little surprised to see you seeming to advocate for him earlier this year, or at least including his music on the release radar. The music isn’t terrible, almost compelling AT TIMES. (perhaps I think that only compared to the bro-country stuff) But definitely not country.
December 21, 2023 @ 5:10 pm
Not to dive too deep here on defending Trigger, but he’s always covered southern rock and other roots music.
He talked about Aaron Lewis, who I think is a very comparable artist.
December 21, 2023 @ 5:51 pm
I wanted to give Jelly Roll a chance. I took him at his word when he said his album was going to be “super country.” Little did I know his frame of reference was Sam Hunt. Now it all makes sense.
December 21, 2023 @ 10:35 am
Shallow I may be, but I just can’t. Face tattoos? I ain’t listening. If his song is playing and I don’t know it’s him and I’m diggin’ it then he might convert me, otherwise it’s a no.
That happened with Orville peck. Didn’t know it was face fringe dude and was really liking a song, was shocked when I found out it was him. Now I like him.
December 21, 2023 @ 10:45 am
FACT 1: “Rap” is NOT music.
FACT 2: Anyone with face or neck tattoos is a felon or shall soon become one.
December 21, 2023 @ 1:10 pm
You have a strange understanding of what the word “FACT” means. If it’s in all caps does the definition change to “my shitty opinion”?
December 21, 2023 @ 3:27 pm
No. This has nothing to do with my opinion of you.
December 26, 2023 @ 12:30 pm
Right, it’s about your shitty opinions on rap music and face tattoos.
December 21, 2023 @ 4:59 pm
Rap is not music. It’s spoken word with rhyme and beat. It started with DJ’s mc’ing over sampled tracks. The biggest rap songs of the 90’s literally stole the music from popular rock artists.
December 22, 2023 @ 9:34 am
Correct. “Rap” does NOT have melody, which is a necessary component of music.
December 22, 2023 @ 10:02 am
Not into “Rap” as a genre, but Bone Thugs-N Harmony “E. 1999 Eternal” is one of my favorite albums of all time. All melody and hooks. Typical 90’s gangster rap approach lyrically, but par for the course in 95. Highly recommend everyone at least check it out, if unfamiliar.
December 21, 2023 @ 7:29 pm
According to the nerds at Merriam-Webster, music is:
a
: vocal, instrumental, or mechanical sounds having rhythm, melody, or harmony
b
: the science or art of ordering tones or sounds in succession, in combination, and in temporal relationships to produce a composition having unity and continuity
As far as I can tell, rap/hip-hop fit these criteria, so I’m having trouble figuring out why you’d be under the impression that it’s not music.
December 22, 2023 @ 5:19 am
Trust me, I know from experience arguing this exact same topic: bigtex doesn’t give a shit about facts. They just throw that word out to try and make their very subjective feelings seem objective, whilst also using CAPS to be more DRAMATIC because apparently that’ll help make the POINT. If you argue this, bigtex will immediately start with the ad hominem attacks and invoke Godwin’s law.
December 22, 2023 @ 9:36 am
Who is “they?” What did I post that is factually untrue? Provide that information. (Watch this, folks.)
December 22, 2023 @ 11:13 am
“They” is you, and you know that. I get that being willfully obtuse is kinda your thing, but that particular bit was just wasteful of everybody’s time. Despite our disagreements, I was trying not to assume your gender, as I really don’t know based on the few comments you leave that I’ve read. Not trying to be disrespectful, I’m just trying not to assume. Also, starting out your counter argument with a quibble about pronouns is about as weak as the sauce gets in a music debate.
As far as what’s factually incorrect, Trainwreck provided you with two different Merriam-Webster definitions that support the claim that rap is, in fact, music. You just ignored them. You hang on to that singular criteria, melody, as well as your verifiably false notion that rap has none, like a man hanging on to a tree limb in a hurricane. Coat provided you with an album recommendation, E. 1999 Eternal by Bone Thugs-N Harmony, which has plenty of melody. Even if that were the singular example of a rap album with melody in recorded history, by its very existence you would be factually wrong, never mind the fact that it’s not the only rap album with melody.
Again, you don’t care about facts, you just care about trying to use the notion of a fact to support your opinion. You do realize that nobody, and I mean not one single soul, would care that you dislike rap if you just expressed that opinion? What people take issue with is your smug assertion that your opinions are “facts.” It’s okay to just state your opinion without trying to compensate for disagreement. Even though you’re verifiably incorrect, let’s just say for a moment that you weren’t: rap isn’t going to disappear just because bigtex is ranting about it in the comments section of a country music website. I’ve had people tell me that country music “isn’t music” and they were no more correct than you are.
I don’t mean any of this maliciously, but I’m sure that won’t stop you from pulling out the ad hominems in response.
December 22, 2023 @ 3:45 pm
FACT: Rap is NOT music. That is a FACT. Anyone who doesn’t know that FACT has never studied music; and, no, “Merriam-Webster” is not a source of music knowledge nor theory. Do you, by chance, somehow get paid by the word for your posts? Is that the reason for the rambling screed?
December 23, 2023 @ 9:59 am
Merry Christmas, bigtex. I hope it’s a good one for you.
December 23, 2023 @ 3:46 pm
Merry Christmas, Acca Dacca. I hope it’s a good one for you as well.
December 22, 2023 @ 9:35 am
“Rap” does NOT have melody, which is a necessary component of music.
December 22, 2023 @ 1:16 pm
almost every rap song has a hook.
December 22, 2023 @ 3:35 pm
And . . . ?
December 22, 2023 @ 3:49 pm
A jackhammer has rhythm.
Is that MUSIC?
December 23, 2023 @ 11:33 am
Less irritating than Mr. Roll.
December 22, 2023 @ 7:17 am
FACT 1: ALL people with the handle “bigtex” have a significantly limited worldview
FACT 2: that is NOT something worth championing
December 22, 2023 @ 9:37 am
Your envy of bigtex is showing.
December 22, 2023 @ 1:17 pm
no one envies someone who has to call themselves ‘big’
December 22, 2023 @ 3:47 pm
You’re wrong, BIG time.
December 22, 2023 @ 4:12 pm
No more comments on this thread.
December 24, 2023 @ 12:47 pm
Totally agree with you.
January 10, 2024 @ 2:54 am
The definition for Music is “vocal or instrumental sounds (or both) combined in such a way as to produce beauty of form, harmony, and expression of emotion”. Just because it doesn’t get your cowboy boots tappin’ doesn’t give you the power to dictate what is or what isn’t “Music”.
I’m from Lancaster, KY. And that as country as can be and I’ve never been a big fan of country, in fact, it usually gives me Diherreah! Lol, but it’s still Music! Jason is a godsend to many, including me, and his lyrics are relatable, unlike thinking someone’s tractor is sexy or doing the watermelon crawl while cutting your bangs with a rusty pair of scissors! Well honestly being a girl, I like that song by Miranda, but honestly, I found this whole thread searching if Jelly was quitting with rapping, now that he considered “country”!
I’m actually sad, I dont want him to quit rapping! So as much as y’all ain’t really trying to welcome him to the square dance; Us Rap/hip-hop lovers don’t want to lose him to it! ????
Besides our opinions or factual definitions, numbers don’t lie and every type of genre he does, it’s very much well liked and the votes cast for the CMA’s, is proving yall opinions are not favorable, but lmk if yall take a vote to cast him out the holler, I’ll definitely be an Allie and vote in y’alls favor, just so I can keep my fav artist. #RantOver
January 10, 2024 @ 7:32 pm
Sorry, but I cannot save you from yourself. I cannot do the impossible.
January 16, 2024 @ 4:16 pm
Your all idiots
January 17, 2024 @ 9:40 am
But idiots who, unlike you, know the difference between “your” and “you’re.”
December 21, 2023 @ 10:55 am
I’m not certain why the convicted felon thing keeps coming up as a sticking point for Jelly Roll? Granted I don’t care much for his music but I don’t think the conviction should be a calling card.
Every time it is brought up it draws a direct comparison to Merle Haggard,
“I’d like to hold my head up and be proud of who I am
But they won’t let my secret go untold
I paid the debt I owed them, but they’re still not satisfied
Now I’m a branded man out in the cold”
Willie Nelson also has been convicted of crimes, these are never constantly brought up when speaking of him either.
Stop beating that horse to a pulp.
December 21, 2023 @ 12:05 pm
I’ve sen this comment numerous times now, and it’s misunderstanding the opinion. What I’m saying is that country fans want to overlook that he’s a felon BECAUSE he’s using country music to find redemption similar to Merle Haggard. This makes people more forgiving and open to Jelly Roll than less.
Ultimately though, the problem is he’s still not country.
December 22, 2023 @ 5:44 am
It would go a long way to not be misunderstood if it’s not constantly mentioned. Words cannot be mistaken for what they’re not if they are never said/written in the first place.
December 22, 2023 @ 7:47 am
Look, maybe I could have worded that better to convey the opinion more understandably. But that doesn’t mean that I said that convicted felons can’t or shouldn’t make country music, because I didn’t. And I’m more than happy to address an clarify that point if need be.
December 21, 2023 @ 11:05 am
Country music is straying from the path that was laid out many years ago. Rock, and all the new stiles have infiltrated. Big companies only care about the bottom dollar, and care less what type music it is. I no longer even turn a radio on, unless it is to listen to old country stations, and those are hard to find. Who declared RAP as music?
December 21, 2023 @ 11:08 am
I’m glad somebody said something about this dude. I haven’t been following much of new country. But when I heard people raving about jelly roll and heard one song I knew it was all just more of the pop shit.
December 21, 2023 @ 11:26 am
This is really well written. Mainstream country music is just so desperate to be accepted by the cool kids that they’ll sell their soul to anyone. What Stryper was to 80’s Christian Rock, Jellyroll is to country.
December 21, 2023 @ 5:00 pm
Reminds me of the King of the Hill episode about this. “you arent making Christianity better, you are making rock n roll worse.”
December 21, 2023 @ 11:29 am
Good commentary, and props for shouting out T6M, easily one of the most ripped off artists in modern music.
IMO, JR doesn’t know how he could be more country because JR doesn’t know how to make country music. He knows how to make “Nashville Country” music because he has a personal relationship with Ernest, who came onto the scene via the same hip hop to pop country door JR walked through.
In his mind, I believe he thinks he’s assimilating because of the people he’s surrounded by. If you’re hanging out in the Broken Bow offices and making records with Dustin Lynch’s producer, it’s not a stretch that a white trash guy from the area would feel just as part of the culture as any man in the room.
JR and Ernest did Theo Von’s pod this past month and shined a little light on their approach to making music and their backgrounds. It’s really interesting context that connects a lot of dots between very mediocre hip hop and the bro country era. They weren’t writing songs, they were writing bars and making the accompaniment fit a “sound”. Once you had a dynamite hook, you had a hit. Really simple formula, but that light never came on for me until I heard them discuss it.
December 21, 2023 @ 12:43 pm
“Need a Favor” did have a fiddle on it. And its meaning connected with folks.
I don’t know his other songs — but the 3 singles he sent to radio so far have been decent enough. Def better than Aldean, Dustin, FGL & Sam Hunt
December 21, 2023 @ 12:58 pm
Don’t disagree.
December 21, 2023 @ 12:56 pm
As the self-appointed legal representation for all the goats, I hereby serve this restraining order to the Jelly Belly.
December 21, 2023 @ 1:08 pm
Maybe Jelly and Garth can get to gether and have a cry-fest and show us all how to be authentic.
Jelly Belly lectures us like Maren Moris, but is less offensive than her so there’s that.
Not against him and not for him. I don’t begrudge him either. I just kinda ingore most of him, and that is a lot of ignoring!!
December 21, 2023 @ 3:44 pm
I personally prefer Jellyroll as a rap artist. That being said even in rap, his music sampled and used old country songs and artist like Waylon Jennings. In fact if you’d researched any of his previous works you would come across the Waylon and Willie albums ( yes multiple) The fact that he now introduces urban kids to county they would not normally be exposed to also benefits country music sales and artist.
December 21, 2023 @ 5:17 pm
this makes me hate that lazy fat f*** even more.
September 19, 2024 @ 11:46 pm
Are you stupid? The Waylon and Willie albums are because Struggle Jennings is the step grandson of Waylon Jennings and the nephew of Shooter Jennings. His name isn’t a gimmick. Dumbass.
Ya. Jelly Roll started in Rap and for that reason it doesn’t matter how country he gets, your ignorant ears won’t lose their bias. (Hip
Hop is music btw to all the idiots saying it isn’t just cause it’s not their thing) and he’s keeping his roots into his new endeavour. He’s not being fake and just writing country songs to cater to the country fans, which would be too easy. He’s writing music that comes from his heart and roots.
I’ve listened to him since he started in hip hop, and he’s always been himself, never hiding anything, transparent and genuine. Never losing himself like so many of the CMA artist of the year winners you worship have. Writing whatever makes you hicks happy. Hip hop haters are too easy to spot. Ignorant.
I could write an article about it just as long as this ridiculously ignorant garbage but I’ll spare you simple minded folks. This article screams for attention and validity. It’ll always be one of the outliers in the mass amount of music opinions out there.
Jelly Rolls music comes from a place of empowerment. Over coming adversity and now speaking from a better place but never forgetting the lessons learned. I have never related to an artist as much as Jelly Roll. Most songs relate word for word with my experiences and it helps me through tough times knowing it’s not impossible to battle demons and win fights life throws at you.
If you guys want him we will gladly take him back. The man has more talent than 90% of the country artists out there anyways. Deal with it. Cry about it more.
December 21, 2023 @ 1:11 pm
The writer has obviously never heard of Colt Ford
December 21, 2023 @ 1:45 pm
The only person I’ve seen who pulls off a face tattoo and actually looks good with it is Mike Tyson. Probably, because it’s actually tastefully done and is not all that obtrusive when you look at him head on. That and the “fact” that you don’t tug on Superman’s cape, spit into the wind, or tell Mike Tyson that you have a problem with the way he looks.
It’s like the only artist who didn’t look like a dork and actually looked like a boss when wearing a Nudie suit was Porter Wagoner. I guess thats’ why he kept wearing ’em when all the other singers, from Ray Price to Faron to Marty to Webb switched to business suits.
December 22, 2023 @ 5:14 am
Marty Stuart could rock a Nudie suit. Granted, he always had a bit of a smirk or twinkle in his eye, like he understood how out of time he looked when he did it.
December 21, 2023 @ 2:07 pm
He’s from the country. My opinion will be the one everyone attacks and that’s ok. Country music is evolving and there is a place for him. Hick hop is a sub genre and good for him. I could care less about his face tattoos and all that stuff. In his music the country twang has been there. He found his niche. Good for him. Love his music.
December 21, 2023 @ 2:45 pm
No specific comment on jelly roll other that when his songs pop up in a playlist and I’m driving, it’s easy to to sing along. But I would like to say how much I enjoy your writing. It makes me laugh. It makes me find new artists on Spotify. It occasionally baffles me. happy holidays and thank you for what you do Trig. Looking forward to your 2024 pieces.
December 21, 2023 @ 3:48 pm
He’s the white version of DJ Khaled.
December 21, 2023 @ 6:02 pm
Damn. Now that I’ve read this comparison I can’t unsee it. Just need him to say “and another one”
December 21, 2023 @ 3:55 pm
If anything your post is too generous. I can grit my teeth and listen to tractor rap if forced to but Jelly Roll? Simply awful. His sudden “popularity” is entirely forced and contrived.
December 21, 2023 @ 4:55 pm
I can’t fully blame Jelly Roll for not understanding what country music is since the entire industry has pushed bullshit for the past 20 years. However Jelly Roll is attracted to the country music genre because he sees it as the easiest path to engratiate himself to more fans, success and money, not for any deep appreciation for country music history. The industry brought this upon itself. (ex. Luke Bryan and Jason Aldean)
December 21, 2023 @ 5:49 pm
If I was a country rap fan, I would take what Jelly Roll is doing as selling out to the man. For years he was a grassroots hip-hop artist. Now he’s out there fake crying at the CMT Awards over meaningless awards.
December 21, 2023 @ 6:26 pm
I don’t think country rap fans are that nuanced with their music opinions. I could see where fans of Upchurch would be mad at Luke Combs for pretending that he ever appeared on video with Upchurch or that he ever associated with him. I view Jelly Roll as a mainstream accepted version of Upchurch.
I know that ‘Hick Hop’ artists get millions of views on Youtube but no one has ever said to me “Hey have you listened to…?” or “You should check out..” It reminds me of high school in Indiana where there was all these kids wearing ICP (Insane Clown Posse) clothing but no one ever recommended me their music. Even people I was friends with. And this was a time when it was big to share burned CD’s and that’s when I discovered so much music.
I think deep down even they know that Jelly Roll and country rap music is shit.
December 21, 2023 @ 4:57 pm
Y’all are jerks in this comment section. Took me two hours to comment this since my phone died and my charger was up 2 1/2 flights of stairs.
December 21, 2023 @ 5:16 pm
Jelly Roll declaring himself country is like Michael Scott yelling ” I DECLARE BANCRUPCY” in the office.
Also I don’t know that it’s fair to label Kacey Musgraves as some kind of turncoat. Her first album was incredible and very much country, and she didn’t shit on the genre on her way out to making a pop album. She hasnt done anything (that I am aware of) that should prevent her from coming back and making a country album if she chose to. Maybe I am missing the point that was made, but her music is far better than everyone else’s listed there and country acts have drifted into Pop, including Crystal Gayle. (I found a cassette of hers from the 80’s that I played in the car and it was straight up 80’s pop.)
December 21, 2023 @ 6:22 pm
This site reviews a rolling stones album and then gripes jelly roll isn’t country.make your mind up already.
December 21, 2023 @ 6:44 pm
This site did not call The Rolling Stones country, nor was Mick Jagger on a podcast from The New York Times claiming he couldn’t be more country, and everyone claiming he wasn’t country is wrong.
As was said in that Rolling Stones review, the band has had a major influence on country musicians. But nobody is claiming they’re country.
December 24, 2023 @ 2:25 pm
We agree the stones aren’t country. I think we agree this site is about country music.yet their album review is on here.of course it’s your site.and I do frequent it often so kudos for allowing a different view point.
December 24, 2023 @ 3:00 pm
I understand what you’re saying, but I don’t think we should be so uptight over genre that we can’t allow to go off script every once and a while and talk about an album all of music is talking about.
December 21, 2023 @ 11:51 pm
Never thought I would see 3 6 mafia get brought up on here. That’s wild. I was obsessed with them back in the day.
December 22, 2023 @ 1:05 am
Probably my favourite SCM article of this year.
December 22, 2023 @ 1:59 am
…remind me please, where did conway come from into country music? or charlie rich, ronnie milsap – or even waylon for that matter? jelly roll grew up in nashville, chances are that he has been influenced by country music one way or another thereby. he may not be the real deal – but he’s a pretty good deal for many – fans, nashville, his label and mostly for himself. sounds not all that bad to me. and when ms wilson helps to save him, it even sounds pretty great.
December 22, 2023 @ 7:39 am
Nobody said that artists from other genres could not make country music. We don’t have to assume if Jelly Roll was “influenced by country music.” He told us expressly that he was. And that “country music” was Sam Hut and “Dirt Road Anthem,” which is distinctly NOT country music.
Jelly Roll has some good songs. That doesn’t mean that he’s “super country” as he claims.
December 22, 2023 @ 2:15 am
I agree with the sentiment. Jelly Roll is not a country artist, but “Save Me” is a country song and a darn good one at that.
December 22, 2023 @ 3:26 am
Thank you for writing what I have been saying all this time- jelly roll: what a clown.
December 22, 2023 @ 4:04 am
Watch the ‘it’s’ that should be ‘its’ in para 4.
December 22, 2023 @ 5:14 am
I think this a well written, fair overview of the whole jelly roll paradox. His music is not country in a classic sense – nor is that of his apparent muse, Sam Hunt. Let’s face it, you take the east tn twang and the steel guitar out of Morgan Wallen songs, it’s not much different. That being said, the topical material and context of songs; even the life experience of a guy like jelly roll is as country as Cornbread. I don’t prefer rap but there are a lot of millennials and gen x-ers who do and I love the fact that they get exposed to a variety of other country music when jelly roll and hunt bring them to the tent.
On a cynical note, the real villians as always remain the suits at labels who could care less about what is or isn’t country music. Their choices, their marketing and their allegiance is and will always be to profit. If they thought that jelly roll could advance their bottom line with goat bestiality, they would have him mounting Billies at every meet and greet with press coverage. They will milk the jelly rolls from the fringes as long the sub genre generates sales and profit. Then they’ll stand up and proclaim – that’s not country!
December 22, 2023 @ 5:46 am
I come to this as a fan of his wife’s podcast before I ever heard Jelly sing. It’s odd that a genre that calls Kenny Rodgers, Vince Gill, and even Cody Jinks(the best country musician performing today), country despite their work prior to joining “us. Jelly sings about very real topics and while not a great singer, sings them with so much heart it’s it hard to not listen. On one hand Trigger bashes, rightfully, the awards shows, then on the other gives them importance.
His frame of reference is based on what’s played on the radio, so of course he will cite it.
December 22, 2023 @ 7:50 am
Nobody is saying that artists who previously made music in other genres are disqualified from making country music. But when your music sounds more like other genres than it does country, and the country influences you cite are Sam Hunt and a country rap song, you probably don’t fit. Even then, myself and others were letting Jelly Roll by because ultimately he’s got some good songs and there are bigger fish to fry, including artists that are more country-sounding, and more native to the genre. See Dustin Lynch.
But I’m not going to sit here and be lectured by a hip-hop artist and a writer for The New York Times about how Jelly Roll is “super country.” Because he’s not.
December 24, 2023 @ 8:21 pm
Is Cody Jinks country when he’s making a metal album?
3 chords and the truth.
The truth being in short supply with the image of country, not the soul
December 22, 2023 @ 6:36 am
So…wait. In JR’s opinion you have to pound a goat’s backside to be country? My opinion has been neutral on him up until this point. But if he thinks country folk bang goats, I have moved to strongly dislike.
Could JR have just dixie chicked himself?
December 22, 2023 @ 6:38 am
this dude is a poster child of bad decisions. from the food he consumes, the tattoos on his face, the terrible music he makes, and the laws he has broken in the past. let me say this in no uncertain terms, the f@t POS won’t ever be normalized in my house.
December 24, 2023 @ 8:23 pm
We’ll just assume you weren’t a Merle Haggard, Waylon Jennings, or George Jones fan. Enough drugs/drink and laws broken for a lifetime
December 22, 2023 @ 6:52 am
The Band Perry might have drifted away from country before they split up, but Kimberley has drifted back, even if her brothers haven’t. Check out her new EP. And Maren Morris has walked back on her “farewell” to country. As for what Lacey does next, will have to wait and see.
December 22, 2023 @ 7:53 am
Yes, Kimberly came back after a decade of going away and making terrible music.
And yes, Maren Morris is now out there lying saying she never left country … and then releases a pop song with thrice accused sexual assault suspect Diplo. Morris is next in line to get her ass handed to her for blatant lies.
December 23, 2023 @ 7:36 am
Out of interest do you consider The Chicks to be country? Because like Maren, they’ve had well-publicised political spats with other artists, and have declared that they were “leaving country”, but – again like Maren – all their albums have been country. Even if she’s done a couple of pop singles with other artists.
Similarly, do you consider Maren’s work with The Highwaywomen to be country?
Will admit I’ve never heard of Diplo. Has he(?) been convicted, or just accused?
December 22, 2023 @ 7:16 am
Trigg you have been waiting for him to slip forever – you never wanted to accept him and like you said “bit your tongue” for a while now – you jumped on him the first opportunity you had with those stupid goat comments- sorry that this genre is shifting away from your idea of country but you got work those feelings out. Not every new artist is going to be a young George strait- you never wanted this dude in country and his goat remark gave you the lane to blast him. Go fuck a goat dude
December 22, 2023 @ 7:57 am
According to Jelly Roll, people said George Strait wasn’t country either.
You can go back and read my articles on Jelly Roll from the past. I wanted to like this guy. I wanted to take him at his word that “Witsitt Chapel” was going to be “super country.” Even now, I’m giving the guy credit for releasing good songs, and am praising him for being one of the few good ones in the country rap space. This is not a take down. I do not hate this guy. I see the value in him and his music. But he’s gaslighting people by saying he’s “super country” and there’s no other way he could be more country other than “fucking a goat.”
I think I’m being very fair and nuanced with Jelly Roll here. I understand why people like him. But he’s not “super country.” I’m sorry.
December 22, 2023 @ 10:48 am
Gaslighting… bc he made a stupid comment about a goat while he was with people like Cher and Olivia Rodrigo at the jingle ball concerts – compared to them jelly roll is country as fuck. Can we discuss the context of which he said it? Honestly going back to your previous comments you seem more like you tolerated a ex felon with face tats coming onto the scene instead of embracing him.
December 22, 2023 @ 8:51 am
We survived Cowboy Troy. We’ll survive Jelly Roll.
December 22, 2023 @ 9:22 am
Maybe if he moved to Austin…
December 22, 2023 @ 11:50 am
The dude may be a nice guy, but he’s phony as hell. Great point on his charity stuff Trigger, if you do some charity work but make sure all the press is there to report on it, you’re doing it for yourself. One of my students didn’t have a winter coat, so I got one for her. I didn’t get on the PA system and announce to the school that I had went and got a coat for a student and that everyone should then praise me.
Here’s my biggest issue with him. He’s nothing more than a heat sponge. He finds someone that’s hot, leeches onto them to steal as much of their heat as he can and moves on. Do you think Jelly Roll would’ve had anything at all to do with Lainey Wilson if it were 2017? Oh and wow look he’s always saying quotes about how much he admires and wants to work with Zach Bryan, the hottest thing in country music. Well shit, who wouldn’t? He ain’t said a thing about anyone that wouldn’t help his career. There are no “Damn, I love Jason Boland” or “I’d love to work with Tracy Byrd” or “Lee Roy Parnell was a big influence on me growing up,” no, it is always whoever is hot and can give him a leg up. You can be a nice guy and still be an asshole.
December 22, 2023 @ 1:26 pm
Jelly Roll recently did a collab of ‘Almost Home’ with Craig Morgan. Craig Morgan’s career had been essentially dormant prior to this. I agree with your point that he is trying to attach himself to whoever is hot. And maybe his collaboration with Craig Morgan is similar to “what’s his nuts” pulling in Joe Diffie on that awful country rap song.
December 22, 2023 @ 7:47 pm
I’m facebook friends with Wade Hayes and he had nice things to say about him too and was wary about him going in but to me, that’s all to try and throw people off the scent. Same with the Post Malone Joe Diffie stuff. They’re just happy to get their name out there again with someone modern fans are into. No different from a politician going to meet with some elder statesman to get a rub from their credibility.
By all accounts, Jelly Roll is a nice guy. He does charity work but always makes sure you know about. He has great things to say about people that can help his career. He’ll make a small fortune and roll out of Nashville as soon as people cool on him and there’s no more easy money to be made
December 22, 2023 @ 11:07 pm
If someone has to tell people about what charity work they did, that cancels out the “karma” of the good deed.
December 24, 2023 @ 7:02 am
No.
You just told SCM about buying a coat for your student.
December 22, 2023 @ 1:28 pm
I’m trying to find a song of his that doesn’t reek of country and I can’t. Any examples?
December 22, 2023 @ 2:56 pm
While reading the article and comments I found myself think of Dale Watson’s song, “Country My Ass.” That’s not to say I can’t see why some find him appealing. There’s a directness and simplicity that’s nice.
Merle Haggard used elements of Tejano; no one thinks of him as a Tejano musician. Similarly Flaco Jimenez dipped his toes into country (mostly famously perhaps on Dwight Yoakam’s version of “Streets of Bakersfield”; no one thinks of as a country musician.
Jelly Roll makes decent pop music because he is a pop musician.
December 22, 2023 @ 3:32 pm
I quite enjoyed some of the songs on Jelly Rolls last album whether country or not. It’s not a bad album. If it is country, it is stretching the genre but he is not the only one that has stretched the country genre in recent times. Maybe his is less of a stretch than some others. I would rather listen to his music than look at him! I do not like his look at all George and Garth have always been country and still are. His saying otherwise is plain wrong,
December 23, 2023 @ 4:47 am
What is it with Country music that makes so compelling for non-country artists that they’re willing to loose their marbles over association with it?
Does singing about living in the city, drugs, decance and other shallow cliches make you a rapper? Apparently, because rapping about red dirt roads, pickup trunks and honky tonks makes you Country singer. This larping really needs to stop.
God, i almost wish Alan Jackson would make a horrible song about offensive hiphop cliches and then demand it to be rotated on urban radio because it references smoking weed and hittin’ up them hoes, complete with an awfull club remix featuring Nelly.
December 23, 2023 @ 6:00 am
This Jelly Roll fella is someone I will never listen to. Have yet to hear him, and prefer it that way.
December 23, 2023 @ 10:05 am
Nice to see Yelawolf referenced in this article. Perfect example of a rapper from the South whose music is imbued with lower “C” country themes and perspective.
December 23, 2023 @ 1:24 pm
I never would have guessed that Jelly Roll Morton had 2023 stage name borrowers,but…Dude likely ISN’T Country,as I don’t recall many good ol’ boys being jelly roll lovers.
December 23, 2023 @ 1:26 pm
Ironic that Jason Aldean experimented with rap on “Dirt Road Anthem,” given his 2023 mega-hit about less than racially progressive ideas.
December 23, 2023 @ 2:31 pm
I haven’t listened to the NY Times “popcast,” but as a longtime reader of the Times, I can say that for me Jon Caramanica doesn’t have much of interest to say about any of the genres of music he writes about.
December 23, 2023 @ 7:40 pm
Country music is the only genre that hates itself.
The Nashville folks badly want to be accepted by the mainstream even though the mainstream is soulless.
March 1, 2025 @ 1:29 am
But God forbid anybody speaks with soul and credits the source that inspired them to do so.
Buncha fxkn morons on here for sure.
December 24, 2023 @ 2:21 pm
Good article. The best part about it is that you can replace the word “rap” with “crap” and then replace Jelly Roll with any number of the “artists” featured on this site and just reprint it over and over again. It would work for Garth Brooks, The Chicks, Jason Isabel, et al.
December 25, 2023 @ 5:53 pm
God bless you for speaking the truth!! Every word of this story about Jelly Roll is absolutely perfect!!
December 30, 2023 @ 9:37 am
The article may be true, I didn’t read it.
I couldn’t get past the title ????
December 30, 2023 @ 5:22 pm
I thought we learned long ago that Country & Rap = Crap!!!
Unless you’re talking about Neil McCoys version of the “Beverly Hillbilly’s theme.
January 1, 2024 @ 3:47 am
Jelly Roll has always been told he isn’t hip-hop, rock, or country enough. In Trigger’s world, he isn’t allowed in any space because those spaces require him to be one thing or the other, but he never has been one or the other and never will be. I’ve been listening to him for 13 or so years, and he has been making country-influenced music the whole time. He’s always been and has always represented the outcast. He spent most of his career being told no and that he isn’t marketable because he isn’t enough of one thing or the other but he kept going, which is why he has so inspired me. I’d be lying to say he hasn’t recorded some songs over those 13 years that weren’t that great, but his heart and soul have always been there. The messages of regret, remorse, redemption, faith, and so on are not new – they’re not some new shtick he started to become marketable recently. I’m not surprised he cries as much as he does – his success is so unlikely, and he is overwhelmed by it. He isn’t 100% country but he’s not 100% hip-hop, rock, blues, or pop either – should he be excluded from all of those spaces and be left with no place to call home because he doesn’t fit a mold?
In the interview, I believe Jelly Roll was referring to whether or not he is country, but you are questioning whether his music is country. He’s as country as it gets. His music will always be part country and part hip-hop, rock, blues, and pop. I grew up country in the 90s and only the geeks listened to mainstream country music because it is some corny ass shit – the rest of us listened to a lot of 36 Mafia, Wu-Tang Clan, Tupac, Notorious BIG, Outkast, Nas, UGK, Goodie Mob, Geto Boys, and so on. I grew up on a farm, and my friends grew up on farms, but the one GEEK in our high school who wore a cowboy hat, boots, and ridiculous belt buckle who line danced at high school dances didn’t even grow up on a farm. Mainstream country is for geeks. My parents took me to all the concerts – Garth Brooks, Trisha Yearwood, Vince Gill, Alan Jackson, John Michael Montgomery, Toby Keith, Travis Tritt, and many more – the epitome of corny. Toby Keith has not released a single good song in his life and if you cannot agree with that, you have no business blogging about music – Toby Keith is the definition of cringe and taking advantage of easily marketable trash.
One thing your post did succeed at is bringing out the racists – they are on your side, so take pride in that. “Hip-hop is not music” also translates to: “I hate black people.” People who say they won’t even give Jelly Roll a chance because of his face tattoos = your ignorant scumbag followers.
Country music used to be cool and worth listening to, before 1980 – I could never get tired of listening to Johnny Cash or Waylon Jennings, but all of the mainstream country that followed incorporating pop music was trash. I was born in 1982 and don’t believe much music of value has been created under the umbrella of country in my lifetime – I don’t care for any of the artists you mentioned and most definitely don’t believe any of them are the “pure” country artists you are advocating for.
While you try to “save country music” I think you are trying to save something that isn’t worth saving. The pure country music that is worth listening to has already been made and the only thing that will follow is artists that are not “100% country,” which you have a problem with, because the pop influence has been there for a solid 40+ years. Country music has never been a pure genre, just like every genre ever – all music in history was influenced by the music that came before it.
So get over yourself and stop wasting time and effort on the idea that you are making a net positive contribution to the world. If you stop blogging about trash mainstream country music tomorrow I promise no one will notice. But if this is what helps you get your anger off of your chest keep hating on people more talented than you, more successful than you, and more relevant than you, but that won’t change the fact that you are you.
January 1, 2024 @ 8:29 am
This is a common misconception/straw man that Saving Country Music only wants country music to be 100% country. This has never been the case, and if you look at the music featured here, that is completely invalid. Purists hate this site because I will talk about an artist like Jelly Roll at all.
Jelly Roll said “Whitsitt Chapel” was going to be a “super country record.” That’s just not true. It doesn’t matter what anyone’s definition of “country” is, as you said, his music is an amalgam of pop, hip-hop, rock, and country. That makes it something that is not “super country.” That’s my only point. Irrespective of genre, he has some good songs. But that doesn’t make him country.
May 21, 2024 @ 10:22 am
And? That’s because regular country music sucks. Jelly and Struggle were inspired by Waylon Jennings and Willie Nelson. Not fucking Luke Bryan lmao. This is real music about real struggles people go through. If all you want to do is listen to music about drinking beer and fucking your cousins then go ahead but don’t say Jelly isn’t country just because he actually talks about people’s struggles.
May 21, 2024 @ 10:37 am
Rio,
I would encourage you to take a beat and figure out where you’re at on the internet. If you think Saving Country Music is all up behind Luke Bryan or “regular country” as you call it, you’re sorely mistaken. As I said in the comment you responded to, Jelly Roll has some good songs. He also has some country songs. But that doesn’t mean his music isn’t also more pop, rock, and hip-hop.
January 15, 2024 @ 7:53 pm
You don’t have to fuck a goat dumbass what the hell has the goat done to you?? You just need to educate your fat ass what real country is belly roll your not country .Go listen to Murders been committed on music row by George Strait and Alan Jackson.It was written for goat Fulkerson like you
February 23, 2024 @ 12:05 pm
As a former smack freak (11 years clean), I am happy for the guy for bettering his lifestyle, at least as far as alcohol and drugs is concerned. Not a big fan of his tunes, though. the local country station plays him at least once per hour and we play country radio (traditional and new) at work all day. He has kind of turned into a one note artist for me. how many songs do we really need about how “broken” he is? it’s fantastic to overcome addiction but how many songs does a sober artist really need to write about sobriety? it gets old. even Morgan Wallen knows that probably won’t hit everyone if he talks about it relentlessly. Not a big Morgan Wallen fan but the opening track to his new record is an excellent song about quitting alcohol. The rest of the album is extremely long (30+ songs, I think?) and I would say I enjoy about 4 songs on the record, opening track “Born With A Beer In My Hand” being one of them. My point here is that Wallen hasn’t made his entire persona about sobriety the way Jellyroll has. Anyhoo, just my two cents on this topic! Great read.
April 14, 2024 @ 10:26 am
Equally sad and comical how rap has to have to be rough and ragged to be cool and authentic. Bunch of charlatans make-believing they chew glass and wash it down with diesel fuel. Was Bobby Bare rapping in ‘Numbers’, or way back in ‘I Love You’ with Skeeter Davis? Sounded damn good then, still does now. Majority of nowadays so-called country acts need to camp out wherever those Williams boys Hank and Don have been laid to rest and not leave either hallowed spot until having gathered inspiration and at least one good ole lesson from those 2 Super Spirits of Country Music.
May 4, 2024 @ 2:51 pm
I am as country as you can get boys. Grew up in Wynnewood OK and part kin by marriage to a well known country singer. Learned to two step in a living room, hunt, fish and raised in Baptist church. Have lived everywhere and the roots of country music have been slowly watering down since Garth and Keith Urban started the “new country”. There was a guy Luke Bell – who recently passed that was bringing back the classic country sound. There are a few more around the Austin area doing “roots” country like Charley Crockett that are not bad. The establishment needs to not call what Jellyroll is singing country.
May 21, 2024 @ 10:17 am
Jelly Rolls best friend is Struggle Jennings. Grandson of Jessi Colter. He spent a lot of time with his grandmother’s second husband Waylon Jennings. He later teamed up with Jelly Roll to make there first Waylon and Willie album paying tribute to Waylon Jennings and Willie Nelson. All this to say he’s more country then you or anyone else on this thread.
May 21, 2024 @ 10:04 am
This post is exactly why Jelly Roll is gonna take over country music. Country’s always been judgemental. Mainly because it’s main audience is republicans. Jellys changing the game by talking about stuff that actually matters. Not just “look at my pretty tractor, look at my pretty truck, watch me drink this beer.” Instead he makes songs about addiction, domestic abuse, inner demons, and finding yourself. And that’s why Jelly Roll has brought more people to country music then ever before. Also im tired of all these people from Nashville talking like they country. Your literally a city boy! Sorry but if there’s not a forest within 20 miles of where you are you ain’t country. If you ain’t never been on a farm you ain’t country. If you don’t have at least 2 acres between you and your neighbors you ain’t country.
May 31, 2024 @ 2:32 am
Jelly roll is just one more prong of the attack on white people and American culture by the Evilarchy running the world. The white male must be replaced with anything and everything that goes against what this country was built upon. It has nothing to do with music and everything to do with destroying the society built by white Christians. JR is a symbol that country music is compromised, just like Biden is a symbol of political destruction.
You’re not playing music. The music you are given is playing you.
May 31, 2024 @ 8:22 am
So this society was built by White Christians? Didn’t slave labor from West Africa build up the American economy and a lot of the infrastructure? Didn’t Chinese immigrants build the railroads? Weren’t Native Americans here before any of us, and probably have some indigenous right to the land? I agree that some would love to eradicate everything “White” and “Christian” from society as evil, and that’s probably a misguided notion. But that doesn’t mean nobody but Christian Whites have any agency in anything to do with America.
Jelly Roll is a charlatan with alligator tears. But that doesn’t mean he doesn’t have some good songs, or is part of an anti-White conspiracy, especially seeing that he’s both White, and Christian.
May 31, 2024 @ 8:48 am
Slave labor did nothing to build the economy or the infrastructure. That’s brainwashing in action to believe such BS. The slaves mainly picked cotton and farm work. The Chinese railroad workers were the same as any other immigrants. They wanted to be Americans, not destroy it. If you read REAL history you will know you have been lied to, and pretty severely, about most everything. The more recent the history book, the more lies are in it.
Yes, White Christians built America. Those TRUE Christians no longer exist in America, or are at least very rare. The average hard working European immigrant, and the ones from other places as well who wanted to become Americans, built this country. The key is they WANTED TO BE AMERICANS. They were not European Americans, or African Americans, or anything else but just plain old Americans.
The problem is that the system of “government” was hijacked right after the revolution and the bankers took over through THEIR constitution and that tree is bearing tyrannical fruit today. Part of that is the destruction of everything capable of rebuilding America once it is destroyed. It was built by White Christian men, so they must be eliminated. If blacks were so valuable in building society, why haven’t they ever built one in Africa? There is a reason blacks are a protected class, and it’s not because the Evilarchy fears them.
Jelly Roll is nothing but a big FU in the face of traditional country music and another step in the demoralization of White men. He should be rejected on that basis alone. Not to mention his voice makes me gag.
May 31, 2024 @ 8:53 am
You’re probably right.
July 18, 2024 @ 4:02 pm
In turn, f the goat fu@ked Jelly Roll, would the goat be considered country? Would the offspring be referred to as a “Billie Roll” or a “Jelly Goat?” Food for thought…
August 27, 2024 @ 2:43 pm
OK,but Mr. Roll is becoming accepted into the Country music family.
August 29, 2024 @ 7:53 pm
Bobby Bare rapping in “Numbers?” I don’t remember that at all.
December 8, 2024 @ 12:57 pm
A lot of time has passed since this article came out, and Jelly has definitely grown and changed as an artist. Has your opinion changed at all, Trig? Just wondering.
March 1, 2025 @ 1:24 am
Wow. Such a sad article written but a talentless person with no talent and no understanding of music trying to sound edgy.
Hope you find some form of real fulfillment other than trying to tear down your betters.