Ke$ha & Pitbull Blend A Country Vibe Into “Timber” Hit
Back in July of 2012, I placed my chips on the square that said that sometime in the future pop star Ke$ha would be a big player in the country music realm, and that when she did, she would be huge. Ke$ha’s mom is country songwriter Pebe Sebert that wrote the #1 hit “Old Flames (Can’t Hold a Candle To You)” for Dolly Parton amongst other notable compositions, and Ke$ha has professed her love for country music, and specifically Dolly Parton, Johnny Cash, and Townes Van Zandt.
It’s hard to call “Timber”—her current collaboration with Latin rapper Pitbull—a country song, but it’s just as hard to ignore that this song is trying to capture a country/Americana vibe through its production. In many respects, “Timber” is the perfect mono-genre specimen. Take a Latin hip-hop artist, an LA pop star via Nashville, inject elements of American country culture like harmonica, the line “swing your partner, ’round and ’round,” reinforce it in the video with choreographed line dancers wearing cutoffs carousing in a honky tonk with a jug band playing in the background, and you’ve got yourself a bona fide mono-genre master work.
And the results of their attempt to touch on every element of popular American culture without pigeonholing the song into any specific genre speak for themselves. “Timber” is now the #1 song in all of music, and it’s video has received 61 million+ hits at the the time of this posting. This is the kind of results that can be garnered when your music has no limits based on traditional lines of genre, culture, race, or even geography.
The video for “Timber” was shot in two primary locales. Pitbull’s portion of the was mostly filmed in The Bahamas, while Ke$ha caught a more country vibe by filming in a honky tonk in Miami and a ranch outside of the city limits. Horses, chickens, and bikini’ed Ke$ha chopping wood (a day’s work is never done, apparently) are all featured in the video, and so is, of all things, a relatively-obscure, but worthy-of-your-ear band from Orlando called The Bloody Jug Band.
The Bloody Jug Band is a true jug band (yes, they have a jug player) that features very traditional instrumentation around an otherwise very progressive Americana sound with a dark, macabre approach. At first glance one might think this is a gimmick band, but their compositions reveal great depth in both theme and structure, constituting their debut album Coffin Up Blood to be nominated for Saving Country Music’s Album of the Year in 2012.
“It was just one of those opportunities that fall in your lap,” says Bloody Jug Band frontman Cragmire Peace. “I got a call on a random weekday, and one of the producers of the video got me on the phone and said, ‘This is going to be a weird conversation.’ She went on to say they were looking for a jug band type of sensibility in the video—instrumentation of some of that old-timey music—because that’s what they considered fit well with the kind of Americana vibe of the song. And when they looked up jug bands, not only did we come up, but we’re also in Florida. So they pretty much loved the ready-made package.
“Everything in the video that we wore and played, down to the stickers on the washboard, that was all us and they had no problem with us being us in the video, which was one of our stipulations up front. If we were going to show up and do this, we were going to be ourselves, and they had no problem with that. They knew what they were getting.”
The inclusion of The Bloody Jug Band in the Ke$ha/Pitbull video speaks to just how far the video’s producers were willing to go to capture a country/Americana vibe in the shoot. “They could have easily cast four assholes to be extras in this video, and it wouldn’t have been The Bloody Jug Band and it wouldn’t have meant anything,” Cragmire Peace says. But they didn’t. Though you would definitely have to categorize “Timber” as hip-hop or hip-pop first, producers were trying to be inclusive to the rising popularity of country music, and even bands like Mumford & Sons. At the same time, the use of The Bloody Jug Band speaks to another trend in music that is helping out many independent bands.
“You hear a lot about this in TV and the licensing of music,” Cragmire explains. “They figured out it was way cheaper and way more mutually beneficial to instead of having composers you hire for the music, to actually co-opt independent bands and put them in the credits. I think it is more typical in TV right now than it is in music, or popular music, but I think it opens the door for people. It’s a window into another type of music. “Timber” has sort of the Americana vibe to it, and that’s probably a little different for Ke$ha and Pittbull to have done. So the fact that they introduced into the listener’s ear, for people to realize that there’s dynamic music in this genre going on, I think it’s a great door opener for people to hopefully step through, and they can be turned on to this other type of music. And hopefully pop culture realizes that to take a chance on an independent band, and feature them in your video, or to use these bands in some other way, it helps the band out, it opens people’s eyes, and ultimately I think it’s not bad business.”
Cragmire Peace says he’s no fan of pop music, Ke$ha, Pitbull, or “Timber” specifically. “It’s easy to beat them up. But if it means more exposure for The Bloody Jug Band or Americana music, I don’t care what door they came through. The end result is what matters, not how they got there. Even if people don’t know who they’re looking at, if they’re somehow captivated for the 5 to 8 seconds that we’re actually in the video, then that’s cool. To be exposed this way but have people respond to it like they have, I think that’s very powerful and validating for any artist, but certainly what we’re trying to do with The Blood Jug Band.”
Meanwhile the resounding success of “Timber” likely means we can expect more blending of country/roots/Americana elements into pop and hip-hop music, while rap elements in country music are now a mainstay of the genre, and Jerrod Niemann’s recent single “Drink To That All Night” adds the world of EDM and dance music into the mix. The autonomy of American music genres remains in full retreat in mainstream music, and 2014 promises to be the most brave year yet for breaking rules, blending genres, and toppling borders.
(The Bloody Jug Band have a new EP out, Murder of Crows, and a new album planned for later this year.)
Synthetic Paper
January 11, 2014 @ 11:51 am
I really like Bloody Jug Band, but I gotta work up to watching this ”¦ i mean, Pitbull?
Noah Eaton
January 11, 2014 @ 2:39 pm
As someone who listens to most types of music but considers country music most dear to me………..I’ll confess: “Timber” is one of my guilty all-genre pleasures this season.
Pitbull can be absolutely insufferable as a narcissistic tycoon, yet I can’t help but admire how he genuinely always looks like he is having the time of his life. And sometimes provided the right material, that goes a long way to making a listening experience enjoyable.
And it doesn’t try to make itself anything more than a silly genre-blending dance song. It’s lyrically minimalist and is obviously driven by a stomping chorus intended for Zumba classes and karaoke bars.
“Timber” may be devoid of any nutritional quality whatsoever, but it’s damn delectable skull candy to me.
Hank
January 11, 2014 @ 12:16 pm
I absolutely despise this song but I think Kesha is capable of some good things in the future. I actually don’t mind her cover of Bob Dylan’s “Don’t Think Twice, It’s All Right” from the tribute album.
She also has unreleased song called “Innocence and Pills” with Patrick Carney of The Black Keys that shows promise.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sb7IFCGE-8E
triggman
January 11, 2014 @ 12:28 pm
i didnt know a kazoo made you country. yo 2pac you beez country too dawg
Trigger
January 11, 2014 @ 1:16 pm
I wrote this article fully knowing it would be misread or skimmed through by some. Nonetheless I would encourage everyone to read the story and attempt to understand the wisdom and perspective it attempts to convey.
J
January 11, 2014 @ 1:23 pm
No joke I would ten times rather listen to this song than anything by FGL
Noah Eaton
January 11, 2014 @ 2:30 pm
Again, I have to say I’m surprised you haven’t fathomed Swedish DJ Avicii’s game-changing role in this meshing of country/”country” and EDM.
As far back as this past spring, Avicii has been both praised and reviled by the EDM constituency for devoting a large part of his set at the Ultra Music Festival (an annual outdoor EDM music festival in Miami) to his new instrumentally-driven scope of sound. Later in June, Peter Tong (a famous BBC radio DJ and personality) premiered his hit single “Wake Me Up!” which features American singer Aloe Blacc and Incubus guitarist Mike Einziger: which both EDM listeners and professional critics have called “Nashville meets EDM” and anywhere from “Mumford and Sons on Red Bull” to line-dancing meets four on the floor.
Avicii has went hook, line and sinker now: releasing “Hey Brother” as the follow-up which features Alison Krauss & Union Station member and the famed “O’ Brother Where Art Thou” vocalist Dan Tyminski. Again, everyone is boasting about how country has finally surrendered to the pulse of EDM.
Avicii’s success, unmistakably, paved the way for Pitbull, Ke$ha, acclaimed harmonica player Paul Harrington, American music producer Dr. Luke, Canadian producer Cirkut and English producer Sermstyle to make a #1 hit off of “Timber”. And while I will shamelessly admit “Timber” is one of my guilty pleasures of the moment (Pitbull can be absolutely insufferable, yet he always sounds like he is having the time of his life and I can’t help but dig this catchy treat) and I find Avicii hit-or-miss…………..what I fear will be the end result of Avicii’s massive success is that we’ll begin to see numerous Nashville labels follow the decline of bro-country with the desire to milk this EDM-country hybrid trend for all its worth…………..and that will mean much more songs in the vein of “Drink To That All Night” and “Country Girl (Shake It For Me)” replete with weak-sauce EDM beat-drops and synthetic elements replacing percussion across the board! =/
And I can’t even blame Avicii for this inevitable result, frankly. Avicii has been wise to stay clear of the country music establishment in itself. But you can bet Republic Nashville, Big Machine and most other labels are going to pounce on his winning formula template.
Trigger
January 11, 2014 @ 3:00 pm
Well if Avicii had put The Bloody Jug band in one of his videos, maybe I would have written about him by now, which speaks again to the benefits of mainstream artists being inclusive to independent bands.
I haven’t been ignoring Avicii, it’s just up to this point I don’t feel like I have studied the topic enough to feel like I have opinions or insight to share. And honestly, the only place I am hearing about it is in comments sections. Overall I’m seeing very little chatter about what he’s doing. However I do think the EDM frontier is the next road to be traveled as popular country continues to try to make excuses for itself and prove how cool and hip it is. Country rap may die off with “bro-country” (still hate that term), but there will still be plenty of bean counters feeling like boundaries need to be pushed.
Blackwater
January 11, 2014 @ 3:41 pm
I think BJB is selling a little on high in the value of being in that video. 5 to 8 seconds – seemed more like .5 to .8 seconds. I can’t imagine even one person saying, “hey who was that blip that probably wasn’t actors but a real band, I’ll have to check them out.” I hope they got paid good, I definitely want the BJB to succeed, they are a refreshing take on a virtually non-existent genre.
Trigger
January 11, 2014 @ 6:02 pm
Having talked to Cragmire of the Bloody Jug Band, I think they are realistic about the exposure the video will create for them specifically. It’s not going to change their world, but when you’ve had 61 million people see you, especially at the very start of the video, it may have a subconscious impact that will be hard to measure in the short term. Out of 61 million pairs of eyeballs and counting, some of those people will wonder who that band is and take to Google to find out. That is part of the point of this article. I think Cragmire was talking just as much about how things like this and the exposure television shows using independent music and such are giving to artists could have a greater impact of opening a door to fans to expose them to the idea that there’s a whole other world of music out there.
Paul
January 11, 2014 @ 3:43 pm
This is no less country than what is on my local country station (in New England). The video is weird, having two completely different locations and nothing to tie them together feels strange. Looks nice and warm there though!
Chevy3
January 11, 2014 @ 5:22 pm
Maybe its just me but the first thing that popped into my mind when she started singing that first line was Joseph Huber’s Broken Paddles.
Phil
January 11, 2014 @ 5:55 pm
Ug. This is the skank that drank her own pee and gives stage performances with people in giant Penis costumes dancing around her.
You know this Timber song came out a few months after Blake Shelton had Daniel Bradbury sing “Timber I’m Falling in Love” by Patty Loveless on the voice. The timing is too close – they became aware of the song because of this and mutilated it (thats my assumption anyway). My point is it could become a trend for pop artists to chew on the bones of country if I’m right and considering the success of this song.
blue demon
January 11, 2014 @ 6:09 pm
I’ve always liked her voice even when its auto tuned so Id be interested in hearing her record some country songs. to me this particular song is just as annoying as all her other pop songs.
BwareDWare94
January 11, 2014 @ 6:55 pm
Holy airbrushed picture, batman. Talk about caveman selling points, eh?
Just put an ass on there. We’ll touch it up, make it look unrealistic. People will eat it up.
Chris
January 11, 2014 @ 8:55 pm
Welcome to the monogenre. Bloody Jug Band is in this but if you blink you’ll miss them. Other than the harmonica the song sucks unless you like crappy pop and rap. This is the kind of song bro country songs like That’s My Kind Of Night try to be but fail to be good at.
Eli Locke
January 11, 2014 @ 10:08 pm
I don’t quite know how to feel about this, I could see her doing something pretty cool with her career, because I pretty much listen to everything Trigger has to say, and the song has some pretty great harmonica, not a bad rhythm..can’t see myself listening to it regularly, but still.
Trigger
January 11, 2014 @ 11:06 pm
I’m definitely not endorsing Ke$ha, and I’m DEFINITELY not endorsing this song. I do think at some point that Ke$ha will do something in country, but if it will be good or bad remains to be seen. Ke$ha and this video are simply discussion points about what is going on in popular music right now and how it effects country music. As Cragmire said above, they could have cast four people to be a jug band in this video, but they wanted something authentic. They wanted to capture a country/Americana vibe for what they believe is a song with country/Americana elements. And as the #1 song in all of music, by definition this song is setting what is relevant right now. I don’t necessarily have any answers or important salient points. I just think it’s important that we study what this song says about where popular music is, where it’s headed, and how it could effect the perception of country music in the greater population.
Sonas
January 14, 2014 @ 8:30 pm
Hey I hear you Trigger. I like it that you keep up with these country trends. I never even heard of Keisha and now I know that she exist.. or rather, Kei$ha. Hey what’s the dollar sign for? Is she rich? OK, I digress. Personally Trigger, the only thing I enjoy about these people is your coverage of them. I was prepared for you to shred her, or the video or Pit Bull, or any and all on the video, the a?# shaking, the song, the songwriter/writing, producer…anything, but surprisingly disappointingly, you didn’t. I got no shredding!!!
Travis
January 11, 2014 @ 10:31 pm
I grew up in South FL and have managed to avoid Pitbull until now. Goddamn you trig! I didn’t see much, if any real exposure to Americana or roots music in this. I’m sure their fans won’t notice anything anyway. I’ve done work on dozens of construction sites in Miami and the folks down there who love stuff like Pitbull talk down on country music like its the stupidest thing in the world. I don’t think this will result in one search for the Bloody Jug Band. Maybe I’m wrong. Also, I’m quite surprised at some of the positive responses above. Now I’ve got to listed to some god ol florida death metal to re-represent my state. Just finished a 7-hr drive full of Roy Acuff, Delmore Brothers, Pokey Lafarge, Sturgill, Good Luck Thrift Store Outfit, etc – all ruined with this damn video.
Applejack
January 11, 2014 @ 11:38 pm
Eh, I prefer “Cotton Eye Joe” by Rednex for this sort of thing.*
Only, I think that was seen as a novelty song and not the potential future direction of American popular music.
*I am being facetious. That song is horrible too.
Applejack
January 11, 2014 @ 11:43 pm
That confused me as well.
What does the beach have to do with anything?
Applejack
January 11, 2014 @ 11:59 pm
That was meant as a reply to Paul.
Strait Country 81
January 12, 2014 @ 3:26 am
Can Hank Jr be waiting with his shotgun at the studio?
Tom Smith
January 12, 2014 @ 6:45 am
Man. That is just plain god-awful.
Cragmire
January 12, 2014 @ 8:43 am
Yes…they Paid us Well 😉
I should have told everyone not to Blink. LOL. But, we are now in the annals of Wikipedia, forever linked to the Video. So, love it or hate it…it is what it is.
Sonas
January 14, 2014 @ 8:12 pm
Sorry, I did blink, and halfway through it, it was all I could take. I will try again when my tolerance level is a little better. But just so we’re on the same page, you do agree this sucks?
Rachel
January 12, 2014 @ 9:57 am
Pitbull is only 32 years old. Wow, Rapping must be hard on the body. I thought he was about 52.
Flynn
January 12, 2014 @ 10:38 am
Wow. I just ain’t sure what to say about this. It’s a catchy and infectious pop song. The harmonica is a nice touch. All in all if I walk into my local dive and this is playing instead of Luke Bryan i’ll be somewhat happier.
Wez
January 12, 2014 @ 10:24 pm
This article presents an interesting angle. It almost falls under the ‘if you cant bet em, join em’ mantra’. While you don’t want to stoop to their level and abandon your principles, using your enemy for your own benefit is a smart move.
While Ke$ha and Pit Bull are not the enemy of SCM they are similar to the pop-country being produced today. The Bloody Jug Band agreeing to appear in this video, as opposed to shutting it down completely because they don’t like the song or the artists, is a smart play for themselves and certainly couldn’t be considered selling out in my opinion. Anything that gives independent artists exposure should be utilized. This similar tactic can be used by independent country artists with respect to their mainstream counterparts.
Shastacatfish
January 13, 2014 @ 1:53 am
All music aside, I am pretty sure this is the first video I have ever seen with a swimming pig.
Chris
January 13, 2014 @ 10:44 am
I just think they should have showed the band for at least a few seconds. A split second is like an insult to them and country music. Why bother to cast a band and barely show them? These pop stars would have demanded a lot more face time to be in anything.
CAH
January 14, 2014 @ 11:27 am
This is awful.
It combines Brittney Spears video dancing with hip hop vocals and lyrics and cowboy hats.
I made it half-way through.
If it weren’t for the abundance of young female flesh, I could not have made it that far.
This isn’t the kind of music I want to save, and I like multiple genres (excluding pop music).
Cragmire
January 14, 2014 @ 6:02 pm
I will say that the BJB was originally supposed to be featured in several other scenes/parts of the Video…but much of what ended up being captured was based on the artists mood or energy level at the time. So, needless to say, some things didn’t make it…
Trainwreck92
January 14, 2014 @ 7:48 pm
I actually love this song. The Kesha parts at least, I’m not too keen on Pitbull. It’s pure sugary pop, devoid of any substance, but I’d be lying if i said I didn’t hum along to it when it comes on.
Mattwrotethis
January 14, 2014 @ 9:48 pm
I actually kind of like the song. Ke$ha, who I’d never seen/heard before is pretty easy on the eyes other than that damned nose piercing, and she’s obviously got some pipes (though I’d really love to hear what she can do on her own without digital assistance, she’s obviously got power and range, but can she control it on her own?).
LOVED getting to see Bloody Jug Band in the vid, even if it was for just a second or two, can’t wait for yalls next album, hope fate someday brings you guys through Texas so I can see you live!
I think it’s sad that this song, and several by Bubba Sparxxx are on hip-hop stations/charts where they belong, and stuff that sounds less country (and this ain’t country) than this is on country radio right now.
Maybe we need a petition to get Blake Shelton, Luke Bryan and the rest over to the hip-hop stations where they can be mocked by those they’re trying to emulate?
Bo Darville
January 16, 2014 @ 12:14 pm
Quick! Get these guys a CMA award!
Jarrett
February 11, 2014 @ 5:31 pm
I’m I the only one who feels like this is a revival of the same argument that the Genre went through with the Nashville Sound? It was sparked by the desire to attract mainstream artists, after pop stars were dipping their toes in country. Those songs are classics today, and saved the genre financially. EDM will become the Nashville Sound of today. Also, I’m surprised it took the industry so long to pick up on the hip-hop aspects, growing up in the South in the 1990’s they seemed to be the only choices and we listened to them interchangeably.
CeCe
March 27, 2014 @ 9:09 pm
While it has a little bit of a bluegrass feel to it (a teeny bit from the jug band), it is not at all country, but still a wonderful song with a great beat.
Joanne
April 4, 2014 @ 2:55 pm
Kesha has done some recent country songs. Wonderland is a country rock ballad on her Warrior album and she covered Old Flames Can’t Hold a Candle to You for her Deconstructed EP. She also has unreleased country songs from her teens. Sunday Morning and I’m the One are the best. On all these songs you get to hear her voice without any alterations. I’m sure she’ll do even more in the future since she’s been fighting to get dropped by her record label because they were forcing her to sing songs like Die Young that she didn’t want to do.
yankeedoodledandy
May 24, 2014 @ 11:32 am
Pit bull isn’t real hip hop like this isn’t country it’s funny because country and hip hop fans have a lot in common unfortunately pop has ruined every genre of music and this is the result. It’s an interesting song but definitely not a classic but the mixing of rap and country is inevitable remember Nelly and Garth brooks
Phillip
June 13, 2015 @ 11:26 am
Ya haters better get real….ya have no idea what real musicianship is….. I thought the song was great….listen to it all the time….js ….