Lydia Loveless Claims Bloodshot Records “Covered Up” Harassment – Co-Owner Steps Away

This story is developing.
Alt-country singer and songwriter Lydia Loveless has come out with a statement saying that independent, Chicago-based insurgent country label Bloodshot Records did not properly address the behavior of an individual associated with the company who regularly sexually harassed and groped her during label functions over multiple years.
Bloodshot Records was founded by Rob Miller and Nan Warshaw in 1993, and Lydia Loveless claims it was Warshaw’s life partner Mark Panick who would commonly grope her and make sexually explicit remarks at label events at SXSW, at shows in Chicago, and other functions. After the revelations over the weekend, Nan Warshaw has announced she is stepping away from the company.
The claims of Loveless come in the wake of revelations from multiple women that Ryan Adams sexually harassed them. Adams has been accused of sending sexually explicit texts to a 15-year-old in a matter the FBI has opened a probe into. Ryan Adam’s first solo album, 2000’s Heartbreaker was released on Bloodshot Records.
Lydia Loveless, who won Saving Country Music’s Song of the Year in 2014, first addressed the Ryan Adams revelations in a series of tweets.
A lot of people are confiding in me that they are gutted and hurt by the Ryan Adams news. Please know the people who should be gutted and hurt are his victims, not people who are going to miss his overrated songs. There are a million ways to support good music and good people. There are few ways to support shitty people who already have it all—buy their dull records and tell them they’re geniuses.
Tell an artist you love them today. Spread some joy that can’t come from a phony ass motherfucker with too much power. AND you know what? Keep writing those fucking records that no one hears a hit or your “usual” style on. That is the spice of life, and we need it, not another bland fucking known commodity.
I’m gutted and hurt by an industry that claims to be creative and here for us and that only proves more and more every day to be just like everything fucking else. Not really at all surprising that a label who allowed a man to grope, paw at and mentally disturb me for over five years still touts Ryan Adams as a fucking genius.
Following the initial tweets, Lydia Loveless posted a much more lengthy statement about her experience on Bloodshot Records via Instagram. It can be found in full below.
I began my relationship with Bloodshot Records when I was 19. They are a fun and creative group of mostly good people—in fact many of them I consider to be friends more than business colleagues. However Nan Warshaw’s domestic partner Mark Panick has long been a source of strife for me. From the day I started a relationship with the label, he was part of all social events, including taking my band and I out for drinks at SXSW the first time I ever went.
He was, for years, as much a face of the label as anyone. I do not think I am along experiencing his casual predation, but this is only my story to tell. For years he would greet me with a rub to the ass and a close whisper to the ear—“They hoooney.” He friended me on Facebook and left comments on my page that would elicit texts from friends—Who is this person? Are you OK?
In one instance, he approached me at the Bloodshot 20th Anniversary party, and while resting his hand between my buttcheeks, told me he loved my messy hairdo because it reminded him of the way girls’ hair in high school would look after they blew him. I didn’t know who to tell about these behaviors because I felt afraid, as for me, shows are work events and Mark was part of the label from my eyes—my label.
I continued to put up with it, dread label events, and endure anxious stomach … knew he would be day drinking with the rest of us. I personally find this day to day harassment to be the most insidious thing women have to put up with, because it leads to a slow erosion of confidence and instills guilt—what do I do? Should I dress more modestly?
After one groping event at SXSW one year, I was told by Rob Miller to come to him if I was ever made to feel uncomfortable again. He relayed to Nan some of Mark’s actions he’d witnessed, and was told by Nan that, “She couldn’t help if people threw themselves at Mark.” This was maybe five years ago. It’s hard to remember specifics. After that, I felt completely betrayed by Nan but I didn’t want to cease my relationship with the label.
A couple of years ago I decide to instill a nobody-backstage-in-Chicago rule, in order to avoid seeing Mark at all, but two people at the label called me and asked if they wanted to have Mark permanently banned from events. I agreed that yes, though it would strain Nan’s relationship to me, that would make me feel more comfortable at my own shows. I have not seen him since except for once on accident after a Cubs game. He did not speak to me.
I don’t think Bloodshot has maliciously encouraged this behavior but instead quieted it to protect their brand, and it has indeed been covered up in my eyes, as the behavior only ceased when I was informed they wanted to begin signing more women.
Bloodshot Records addressed their relationship with Ryan Adams on February 16th.
The Ryan Adams we met in the late nineties was a sweet, manic, disheveled whirlwind of a talent. After the release of ‘Heartbreaker’ on our label in 2000, he signed a major label deal and thereafter our paths rarely crossed.
The Ryan Adams we have been hearing about over the past few days bears no resemblance to the one we knew back then. To be emphatically clear, we never saw or heard a hint of the appalling behavior now coming to light. We are as shocked and disappointed as every one else.
And we resolutely stand by his accusers in their search for vindication and resolution. There is absolutely no room in the entertainment world for this behavior. That it would happen in our corner of it—the underground, independent music scene—a place where many of us turn to as a refuge, makes it profoundly disheartening.
We like to think of it as a space of inclusion and respect, and thus when “one among us” defiles it, the hurt is especially keen. We hope that Ryan quickly and fully atones for his actions and that the voices and experiences of those he has traumatized are heard and respected. And that we all move towards eradicating such unacceptable actions in our creative community.
Bloodshot Records co-founder and co-owner Rob Miller then addressed the Lydia Loveless accusations in a statement.
Subsequently, co-owner Nan Warshaw released a statement late Sunday evening (2-17) declaring she is stepping away from the company for the moment.
Originally from the Columbus, Ohio area, Lydia Loveless released five total records with Bloodshot going back to her 2011 debut on the label, Indestructible Machine. Her last album on the record was 2017’s Boy Crazy and Single(s), which was a repackaging of a previous EP and select songs from her career.
Nan Warshaw met Rob Miller in Chicago in 1992, and the two started Bloodshot Records with Eric Babcock the following year. Under the charge of giving a home to “insurgent country,” Bloodshot Records is a seminal record label of the independent country and alt-rock world, helping to launch the careers of Ryan Adams, Neko Case, Justin Townes Earle, The Old 97’s, Whitey Morgan and the 78’s, Scott H. Biram, Wayne “The Train” Hancock, and many others. Bloodshot Records was the label for Saving Country Music’s 2018 Album of the Year, Years by Sarah Shook and the Disarmers.
February 18, 2019 @ 9:03 am
Can’t express the importance Bloodshot Records has played over the years as one of the foundations of the underground/independent country and roots music movement. The label was one of the direct inspirations for starting Saving Country Music, and they have a vital role in the careers of so many artists, including Lydia Loveless and Sarah Shook, who both have turned in year-defining efforts that may have not made it to the public without the label. That said, if the company was somehow facilitating a culture of harassment against Lydia and anyone else, that is troubling. It also appears they have worked to actively address the situation, and I hope Lydia feels she made the right decision to come forward, and that the label holds to their commitment of creating an environment that can be safer than some of the mainstream alternatives many artists are faced with.
February 18, 2019 @ 9:52 am
I was wondering if you were going to address this, and I’m very glad you did. I’ve never heard of any sexual harassment or misconduct in the underground/independent/alternative country realm until last week. If there are more instances of this kind if behavior going on, I hope Lydia Loveless coming forward and the allegations against Ryan Adams lead to more of this coming to light.
It’s bad enough these behaviors exist in the mainstream. If we present our little corner of the music world as the alternative to the mainstream, only to have the same problems persist, that’s not right and something needs to be done.
February 18, 2019 @ 10:48 am
I won’t be surprised if we hear more of these allegations in the close future. So many people knew and experienced Ryan Adams terrible behavior but kept quiet about it out of fear. The floodgates have been opened now.
February 19, 2019 @ 8:36 am
Kinda boggles my mind that the rest of the world is just now finding out that Ryan Adams is no good. All anyone would’ve had to to is walk into a bar in Raleigh and ask folks what they thought about him.
February 18, 2019 @ 11:01 am
Waiting years to come out and tell about these things does nothing but make it seem more doubtful.
February 18, 2019 @ 11:48 am
What would be her incentive to make this up?
February 18, 2019 @ 12:17 pm
Not saying she made it up. Just saying it’s more believable when you tell about it when it happened. Why wait so long? Is having a career more important than stopping a sexual predator? If it’s happening to you, it’s more than likely happened or is happening to someone else. So speak up now and save anyone else from going through it
February 18, 2019 @ 1:18 pm
I think that Lydia’s story is 100% believable because Rob Miller and Nan Warshaw basically admitted in their statements they were aware of the behavior previously, and that they even worked to address it, and wanted Lydia to address it publicly as well on her terms.
I agree that it takes women coming forward when the behavior occurs to make sure it doesn’t happen again, and as we’ve seen with so many cases, if a guy’s a creep, he’s likely creeping on all kinds of people over years. But if you’re an artists such as Lydia Loveless, Bloodshot Records may be your only shot at a legitimate career in the music business. That’s what makes it so cool, and why this issue is so serious. I can only imagine the conflict Loveless went through in trying to decide the right thing to do. The Ryan Adams stuff probably just hit too close to home, and she felt she couldn’t keep it bottled up any more.
February 18, 2019 @ 9:57 pm
You should study up on the subject of victims of sexual abuse. It’s extremely common for victims to not tell anyone about abuse for many reasons including shame about the event, slut shaming, fear of reprisal, feelings of helplessness due to the perpetrator being in a position of power (being the husband of the owner of the company is a powerful position), etc.
Bottom line: it’s never easy to speak up about these kinds of things
February 19, 2019 @ 5:29 am
Not saying it’s easy but that’s the only way to put an end to it.
February 19, 2019 @ 6:19 am
Of course reporting is the only way to put an end to it, but your original comment says that her claims are more open to doubt the longer she waits to speak up. I agree it complicates the situation, but I don’t think it should be seen as a disqualifier of truth.
February 18, 2019 @ 4:56 pm
She did speak out. Years ago. They took action, banned him from attending label events and/or speaking to Lydia. She just didn’t come forward to the public until now. Which, given some of the things people have been saying, nobody can blame her for. (These are all verified facts contained in Bloodshot, Lydia, and Nan’s statements.
February 18, 2019 @ 11:03 am
Interesting- and troubling? IMO, it’s fairly well documented that jerks come in all shapes and sizes- that the (a/ Bloodshot in this case) player in the music industry is now in focus isn’t surprising- not sure how I’d handle it if I were a girl- but if my personality was the same there’s going to be more than a bruised ego involved- ala Miranda Lambert- this is much deeper than is being discussed- it’s a lack of self respect by a perpetrator who was never taught respect has to be given in order to receive- or, that it’s important in life- or that at some point chickens come home to roost, often in the arena of public humiliation at least and a law suit at best-
If the allegations are indeed true- this is where (IMO) a reckoning/personal retribution beckons- but, the perp probably doesn’t have the balls to stand up to someone willing to defend their honor, physically or verbally- and anyone involved in the ‘cover up’ (the lady co-owner particularly) needs to be taught a lesson or two about “publicity’ being a double edged sword that is pretty sharp-
As for the comment “something needs to be done”- that’s the mentality that allows “legislation” that ultimately punishes the many for the actions of a few-(no offense intended Warthog) but that’s what happens and why there are so many laws we can’t keep count or know when we’ve committed a real crime- harming another person or someone else’s property is a crime- this type crap needs to be addressed, face to face, up close and personal- if there are existing statutes or laws they can be applied AFTER the wrong has been corrected by the one harmed-
BTW, the court of public opinion rarely shares both sides of any story-
February 18, 2019 @ 6:40 pm
Wasn’t a coverup…Ms Warshaw addressed it when it was brought to her attention 3 years ago. She just didn’t out Ms loveless. Which is Ms Warshaw respecting Mr Loveless’s privacy.
February 18, 2019 @ 11:11 am
Terrible.
I guess I’ve been around for awhile. I remember the Clarence Thomas hearings, the president’s behavior in the ’90’s and a plethora of other situations. I am not sure how anyone can possibly think that this is acceptable behavior in the workplace or anywhere else and how people in authority think it’s OK not to address it when it is identified to them.
So many women, when I talk to them about it say, “Oh yeah, happens all the time.” It’s happened to my wife on multiple occasions (and her management didn’t address). Too bad we’re not more litigious. Her situation, which was a heavy psychological strain on her, would have probably netted her a couple hundred thousand dollars, if not more.
It’s like people think, “Oh those rules aren’t for me.”
February 18, 2019 @ 1:22 pm
I think it’s important to note here that Mark Panick likely knew he was in a position of power over Lydia, even if he didn’t work at the label, and that’s when some men (and women, occasionally) feel like they can leverage that authority into being insulated from retribution.
February 18, 2019 @ 1:48 pm
The same kind of power that Lambert has had when hiring and firing back-up performers.
February 18, 2019 @ 2:17 pm
Boy you celebrity gossip addicts just can’t resist any kind of opening. This article is about Lydia Loveless and Bloodshot Records.
February 18, 2019 @ 5:31 pm
Mr. Panick was not well known by the public until now, but he was (is) a talented songwriter / guitarist, and his significant other is someone very special, so there was absolutely no logical reason for him to engage in this behavior against Ms. Loveless. It really is infuriating and maddening that he messed with her and her career in this despicable way; hopefully he gets help, and hopefully Ms. Loveless can recover emotionally, mentally, psychologically, and financially from this.
February 18, 2019 @ 11:24 am
Is that a Graycliff G2?
February 18, 2019 @ 11:43 am
Cohiba Cubans (yellow label) or supposedly Cubans.
February 18, 2019 @ 1:02 pm
You’re correct.
February 18, 2019 @ 11:34 am
If this somehow gets Ryan Adams off Twitter and shuts his stupid pie hole, then maybe some good will come of it.
February 18, 2019 @ 1:24 pm
Luckily he blocked me years ago so I don’t have to see his stuff. Not sure if it was when I called him out for saying he hated country music, or when I ripped apart his cover of Taylor Swift’s “1989.”
February 18, 2019 @ 11:44 am
It’s a real shame if Bloodshot tried to just sweep that shit under the rug. As one of my favorite record labels, I’d hope for them to be completely on the level, but Lydia Loveless has no reason to lie as far as I can tell.
February 18, 2019 @ 12:09 pm
“A lot of people are confiding in me that they are gutted and hurt by the Ryan Adams news. Please know the people who should be gutted and hurt are his victims, not people who are going to miss his overrated songs.” I totally understand her frustration, but I also sympathize with folks whose favorite singer/songwriter gets exposed as a total piece of shit. Luckily for me, I’ve never cared much for post- Whiskeytown Ryan Adam’s and knew he was a douche, but if, say, Ben Nichols from Lucero turned out to be an abusive asshole, I’d be gutted. Lucero’s music was more or less my intro to alt country and I even have a Lucero based tattoo. If the person responsible for the soundtrack of my young adulthood turned out to be an abuser, I’d have to rethink how I feel about all of the songs that are so near and dear to me.
February 18, 2019 @ 1:17 pm
I have forehead tat of Frankie Yankovic playing the accordion. Good thing he died before the pound me too movement…..
February 18, 2019 @ 1:57 pm
I agree that the victims of any such abuse have every right to feel what they do and act on it (or not act on it) in whatever way they wish. I really do see Lydia’s point because any disappointment fans may feel certainly pales in comparison to being let down by your favorite artist.
BUT I also agree on your Ben Nichols example. I would cry real tears if this kind of news emerged about him. Some artists/bands find their way into our hearts and make such an impact that it would be like ending a friendship with someone you really value.
Be it Ryan Adams or, hypothetically of course, Ben Nichols or (god help us) Thomas Rhett, fans can be disappointed in their favorite artist without taking anything away from the pain and suffering these artists inflict on their victims. I don’t see it that it has to be an either/or situation.
February 18, 2019 @ 3:52 pm
i know it’s petty and not the focus of the article but, hearing Lydia describe RA’s music as overrated and dull makes me love her even more than i already did.
February 18, 2019 @ 4:03 pm
The time of sheltering sexual predators and addictive drug use has come to an end. We can no longer pretend these things do not happen nor make excuses for sexual predators and active addicts. No matter what their status or power level is this must end now. The purging of such people will continue forward and nothing will stop it. Hopefully many of these individuals will be wise enough to remove themselves and seek the professional help that is available for them. If not they will be found out and their denial will be crushed along with their careers leaving their innocent family members broken as well. Our society and especially the music industry will grow even stronger as a result. Please pray for the abusers and the abused.
February 18, 2019 @ 8:02 pm
Rachel Ray Zill = Trumper. Oh the hypocrisy!
February 18, 2019 @ 9:42 pm
Let’s not veer into partisan politics here please. Thanks!
February 18, 2019 @ 5:31 pm
It would be nice to have gentlemen and ladies in country music genre again. Both on the entertainment and management side.
February 18, 2019 @ 8:33 pm
Honestly, I doubt there was ever a time in country music when there was a higher percentage of ladies and gentlemen. It’s more likely that the bad behavior of the “good old days” simply didn’t make headlines.
February 19, 2019 @ 10:54 am
Guaranteed. I’m sure Loretta Lynn could tell some bad stories if she was so inclined.
February 19, 2019 @ 7:30 am
This isn’t a comment about Lydia but a comment about folks with an admiration of certain artists (I saw Lucero mentioned a couple times). I’m afraid at times we put certain folks on a pedestal because we love their art. I personally have to separate the art from the person because if I didn’t, I’d probably have to pitch 80% of my music collection. No one is perfect including those of us who enjoy any kind of art. If a guy or gal is a turd in real life, it can be a complete turn off, but the music is what drew me to them, not their personality.
If I found out Cody Jinks was a complete ass hat, a drunk, harassed women, etc. I would not look at his art any differently and still enjoy his albums. Johnny Cash, Waylon Jennings, and many others were womanizers. Would we think any differently if they were artists in this environment?
February 19, 2019 @ 10:51 am
And anyone who is a fan of any Rock music especially from the 60’s and 70’s is nearly guaranteed to be listening to someone who treated young women (and possibly underage) like crap.
February 21, 2019 @ 7:40 am
Two words – Mick Jagger
Although, at this point, it appears that all of his relationships were consensual, but damn, I don’t think they would survive today’s scrutiny. I wonder if there will be anything brought up during their upcoming tour or if they get grandfathered, so to speak, in.
February 19, 2019 @ 10:37 am
It’s not the label’s job to deal with such issues – either work it out person to person or call the cops.
February 20, 2019 @ 4:37 am
Sorry to hear about this.