Molly Tuttle Announces New Album, New Direction

Molly Tuttle, who has Alopecia (hair loss)


Molly Tuttle will no longer be a bluegrass performer, at least not for this next season of her career.

Her new album called So Long Little Miss Sunshine will be released on August 15th. It is being sold as a departure from her bluegrass past, and an exploration of more pop, rock, and country influences. Tuttle also covers Icona Pop and Charli XCX’s “I Love It” on the album. It’s produced by Jay Joyce, who also performs on the album, while Molly Tuttle love interest Ketch Secor of Old Crow Medicine Show co-writes many of the songs.

We all pretty much knew where Molly Tuttle was headed when she announced a few weeks ago that she was dissolving her Grammy-winning bluegrass band Golden Highway, and retooling with a band that included electric guitar and drums. Though Molly Tuttle might be one of the most important bluegrass flatpickers of our era—and has the IBMA Awards to prove it—she’s always seemed a little bored with bluegrass, which can happen when you master the genre at such a young age like Molly did.

Some might forget (or never knew) that when Tuttle started her solo career, it wasn’t in bluegrass, but in more moody, indie folk music that was mostly centered around songwriting. This sound comprised her first three albums on Compass Records from 2017 to 2020. And she was really good at it, earning critical acclaim, even if her output went mostly under-the-radar. Even at that time there was some frustration that Molly just wouldn’t pursue bluegrass.

That is what was so great about Tuttle’s Golden Highway era. It was bluegrass, but it was young and cool. And most importantly, the Golden Highway era was both commercially successful and critically-acclaimed. Tuttle released two albums Crooked Tree (2022) and City of Gold (2023), and both won Grammy Awards in the bluegrass realm. She also was nominated for the Grammy’s all-genre New Artist of the Year in 2023, which was an incredible feat for someone from bluegrass.

Everyone had a sense that “Golden Highway” would be an era for Molly, not her forever endeavor. But what’s disappointing for many is how short-lived that era was, especially seeing how successful and resonant it ended up being. Just a few weeks ago, Billboard published an article proclaiming how bluegrass was in a boom and going mainstream thanks to Billy Strings, Molly Tuttle, and Zach Top. Molly leaves bluegrass right as interest in the genre is surging.

Imposing our desires upon Molly Tuttle’s music and career does feel unfair. Molly Tuttle should make whatever music is in her heart, and follow her own path wherever it leads. But leaving when she’s in the midst of dominating bluegrass and a roots resurgence is taking place means this decision carries significant risk. Tuttle could very quickly become a small fish in a big sea.

We also need to wait and see what exactly we get with her new album So Long Little Miss Sunshine. According to the publicity copy, there is significant flatpicking on the album, it includes some country influences, and Molly plays banjo on recorded tracks for the first time. Tuttle has earned the right for us to try and keep an open mind.


And even though Molly Tuttle has been wildly successful compared to most bluegrass artists, it’s hard not to notice how performers like Sarah Jarosz, Watchhouse, and others who started in bluegrass eventually branched out to more indie rock and pop influences, and garnered much bigger followings. Molly and Golden Highway were great. But they were still performing in opening slots on tours and trying to get greater traction.

Molly Tuttle says, “Part of me was scared to do such a big departure, and that went into the album title.” But ultimately she overcame her fear and said, “‘You know what? I’m just not going to care what people think. I’m going to do what I want.’”

But as a fan, it’s also okay to be heartbroken when you fall in love with a style or approach from an artist, and then they completely switch things up on you. Artists have a right to pursue their creative muse. But music fans have the right to not like it if it doesn’t fit their sensibilities.

Of all the news and information coming out of the Molly Tuttle camp about the new direction, the new song “That’s Gonna Leave a Mark” is probably one of the least concerning things, despite the super cringey and cliché line, “Ooh you got a certain je ne sais quoi,” and the fact that it’s basic fluff pop. But Tuttle’s guitar is in there, and if they’d embedded this song into one of her bluegrass albums, it would be a departure, but not entirely unusual.


But seeing that Molly Tuttle is working with Jay Joyce as producer is perhaps the most bitter pill to swallow. Jay Joyce is the new Country Music Antichrist. He’s the destroyer of country music worlds, with all the dubious distinctions thereof.

After Joyce wrecked the recent album of Lainey Wilson, eviscerated neotraditionalist Jon Pardi, and whatever the hell Eric Church just turned in via Evangeline vs. The Machine, you couldn’t have a more stomach churning experience than seeing that he’s now working with Molly Tuttle. How and why this guy has become the producer du jour is beyond perplexing, and even the assessment that he can confer commercial success is extremely circumspect.

All of this might be what Molly wants for Molly Tuttle. But will this be what the public wants from her? Time will tell. And again, we all owe it to Molly to be a little patient and see what she comes up with. But at a time when everything is heading towards country and bluegrass, Molly Tuttle is going in a more pop direction, and with that guy.


© 2025 Saving Country Music