My Letter to Capitol Records Nashville
Dear Capitol Records Nashville,
When firefighters came to protest at your building in support of Ronnie Milsap and Bleve Music, you forced them away. My guess is they would have not met the same reception if the building was on fire, and you or your family were inside. Yet your actions are precluding dollars from the firefighter’s families if they died trying to save you or your family. And these aren’t hypotheticals. The reason these funds are needed is because 343 firefighters lost their lives on 9/11 trying and succeeding to save thousands of lives of people just like you, people going to work everyday in a high rise building. And even then, even in the face of this cutting irony, I have no doubt that if Capitol Records Nashville went ablaze, those firefighters wouldn’t blink once risking their lives like they do every day to come pull your greedy bacon out of the fire.
What kind of disease of the soul would make someone take this stance, make someone so grossly overlook their sense of decency, community, and family? How do you live like this? And if you draw the moral line somewhere past withholding money from the families of fallen firefighters and police officers, what kind of other malevolent deeds can your lawyers help you justify?
This isn’t about music anymore, it is way beyond that. It isn’t even about freedom of speech. This reaches beyond all of these trappings of culture and country to the moral fabric that joins every single last person on our planet together and that expresses itself in compassion and empathy. If you came upon somebody who really needed help, would you help them? And if someone helped you, would you say “Thank you”?
I do not have any firefighters or police in my immediate or extended family, or any that are friends or neighbors. But what I do have is this: About 11 years ago I was in a major car accident. Luckily I didn’t have a passenger or they would have died. My truck was crumpled all around me, so much so that my knees were touching my chest, and my teeth had bit clean through the bottom of my lower lip. They had to cut me out with the jaws of life, and use a dust buster to vacuum the windshield glass out of the flesh wounds in my arms. I still have the scars to this day. And even though they delivered me to the hospital fully strapped down to a gurney as a precaution, before I left that ambulance, with the little I could move my hand, I grabbed the wrist of that first responder with a serious enough grip that he looked me straight in the eyes, and I simply said “Thank You.”
I told myself as I was being wheeled into the hospital that I would write a personal “Thank You” letter to each of the people on that first responder crew, but life goes on and it never happened. We rarely get opportunities to sit back and give thanks for the essential things in life, like the people who serve and protect. But luckily Bleve Records and Ronnie Milsap have given all of us this opportunity through something we all can enjoy guilt free: music. So please Capitol Records Nashville, take a moment and think about it, and take advantage of this opportunity to just simply say “Thank You” to the people who risk their lives every day.
And if you don’t, then I pray for your sake that you lose this fight. Not just because I personally want to see Bleve Records prevail, but because as one human feeling compassion and empathy for another, I would hate for you to have to look back years later after this event and feel the guilt that your decision regarding this case will undoubtedly create.
Sincerely,
Kyle Coroneos
October 5, 2009 @ 12:16 pm
AMEN. Good letter !
October 5, 2009 @ 12:40 pm
Thanks Nick. I found myself getting all worked up over this whole thing last night, pacing back and forth. I just kind of blurbed my thoughts out in letter form. In the sober light of day this morning I thought it came across as awkward, but I wrote it when I was feeling passionate about the subject, so I decided to go ahead and run with it.
October 5, 2009 @ 12:50 pm
Profound stuff. It’s very personal and articulate. Thanks for sharing this with us. I look forward to their response …
October 5, 2009 @ 2:51 pm
I’m not expecting them to read the letter. I’m hoping for a over-generalized form letter (those are always fun to point and laugh at), and maybe a nice Capitol Records bumper sticker, balloon, or if I’m really lucky, maybe a mug. My jackpot would be a Keith Urban sippie cup.
October 5, 2009 @ 3:12 pm
Excellent letter, Kyle. If anyone wants to write Capitol Nashville directly, here is the contact information:
Capitol Records
3322 W End Ave # 1100
Nashville, TN 37203-1000
(615) 269-2000
Mike Dungan (Capitol Nashville)
(615)-269-2020 (Direct Line)
mike.dungan@emicap.com
October 5, 2009 @ 7:15 pm
You hit the nail right on the head! I feel so strongly for Ronnie and Bleve records, I just can’t stand it. My father had an industrial accident and the first responder literally brought my dad back to life and stayed with him doing CPR all the way to the hospital. Ever since that accident, I have been a local supporter of the local fire departments because they really DO save peoples lives and put others before their own safety.
Great letter!
October 6, 2009 @ 9:33 am
What if Capital is telling the truth? What if Trace got permission to record the song for the CD, but not to release it as a single? What if the fault lies with Trace or his management team (which was supposed to have gotten permission before he recorded it)?
And why doesn’t Ronnie just re-record it as a solo? Wouldn’t that be the easiest solution?
October 6, 2009 @ 10:10 am
Hey James,
Thanks a good point, but …
First off, all we can do is ask “what if?” because Capitol will not man up and make any statements regarding this case to help clear up the facts, or what their specific position is. Trace is saying ‘no comment’ as well, so if the mistakes were by his people, they’re not willing to say so.
What we do know is Capitol DID give Bleve permission to use the song on their compilation. According to Bleve, Capitol did not have an issue with the song as a single until it started climbing the charts, and competing for attention with Trace songs Capitol was releasing.
I’ve thought and written a lot about this story, and it has occurred to me that at some point Bleve MIGHT have not been as legally thorough as they should have been at one point or another, but they did get permission from Capitol, and I think that the fact that this song is being used to benefit charity organizations should be taken into account.
There is gray area in every legal matter, so do you want to side with the side that is a foreign owned mega-corporation that is trying to squeeze freedom of speech, or a charitable organization trying to do the right thing?
I don’t care if Capitol has some legal stepping stones they’ve assembled to make their stance right “legally”, it is not right in my mind, or the mind of many others.
October 6, 2009 @ 10:10 am
Good point, James. Its not hurting anyone at Capitol. Its only helping these public servants who need it now. Even if it was Trace’s fault, especially in a case like this, is beside the point. I think the adage “It’s easier to ask forgiveness, than permission” comes into play.
October 6, 2009 @ 10:21 am
Kyle your letter was very well written and expressed. Like Aaron Tippin would say “You’ve got to stand for something or you’ll fall for anything”. It does real courage standing up for what you truly believe in and not backing down. Capitol Records seems to have forgotten, that consumers who purchase records made by their company, determine the success or lack thereof that they enjoy. What Bleve Records is doing is very noble and honorable in seeking to help the families of the police and firefighters replenish their funds so the families can survive day to day. Capitol Records should take an example from Bleve Records and make a major donation to the funds benefitting the families of the police and firefighters who lost loved ones on that fateday 9-11-01, a day many of us will never forget.
October 6, 2009 @ 11:24 am
But one problem is your average joe consumers don’t pay attention to who they’re giving their money to, and what it is going to support. Aside from the obvious bad parts about this story, one good thing is that is is raising awareness about how most Nashville major label operate, and how they manipulate their artists. If you ask me, Capitol Records Nashville has done plenty wrong before this case to render a boycott of their products by American consumers. They just finally crossed a line where no kind of explanation will make it go away.
October 6, 2009 @ 11:40 am
Triggerman: I am not siding with anyone. I’m just saying they might not have ever given permission for this to be used as a single, and we have no proof either way. The fact that they are foreign-owned has no bearing on whether they are telling the truth or not.
As a huge Ronnie Milsap fan, I want to take a side, but as much as I hate to admit it, this is looking like a bit of a publicity stunt.
October 6, 2009 @ 1:47 pm
These are good points James. I guess I’m just confused why if Capitol didn’t give them the right to use it as a single, why they don’t come out and say so. Maybe they’re afraid any public comment will just fan the flames, or maybe this just isn’t the truth. They could “leak” that info if they wanted.
No question Bleve is using this incident for publicity, for the record, the single, and the label. But if Capitol is strong arming radio stations to stop playing the song and getting it yanked off iTunes and such, then I don’t blame them for doing whatever they can to fight back, including silly protest bits to draw attention to themselves.
One thing I was thinking of when responding to your first comment is that Bleve said that Capitol did not start opposing the song until it started rising on the charts. I’m not sure if that is true if I understand the timeline right. My guess is Bleve’s nose is not completely clean in this, but I have complete confidence Capitol’s is dirtier. If Capitol had any reservations about this, they should have never given permission in the first place, or been explicit about the limitations. And even then, if there is a dispute, then side for what is right.
And for some reason, though I have no trust in Capitol and Bleve is a new unknown quantity, I trust the integrity of Ronnie Milsap.
October 6, 2009 @ 2:17 pm
It’s true, we really dont have enough information to know who’s legally right or wrong in this situation. i think, however, that Capitol is taking a stance that is (possibly) correct to the letter of the law, but not to the spirit of it.
Capitol is not making money off the single, but no one (except a charity, which is by definition not a for-profit company) is gaining by it.
October 6, 2009 @ 9:14 pm
Triggerman, i agree with what you say in comment #13. Capitol has a great chance to look like the good guy here, and they are dropping the ball.
October 7, 2009 @ 5:27 am
That’s the real rub here. Capitol is courting a PR disaster if this story really goes mainstream. Take away the charity aspect in raising money for the police and firefighters and this story would have gotten very little traction.
I’m not a lawyer and I have no way of knowing the timeline of events, but I do know that Capitol looks like the “bad guy” in all of this. I haven’t conducted focus groups or looked at key demographics, but I can’t see how having Trace Adkins played on radio in a charity single that raises money for America’s first responders “diminishes” his commercial value, as Capitol contends in its cease-and-desist order. It seems to me it would do just the opposite, because it is such a feel-good story.
And even though I admit I am a Milsap loyalist, I’m not enough of a Polyanna to think there are not other factors at work here, too, mainly a chance to get Ronnie back on the radio. Legal wrangling aside, I hope Ronnie and BLEVE succeed on all counts.
October 19, 2009 @ 3:33 pm
What you all seem to forget is no one (when Giving permission for a song ), can guess what it will do or not.(accept when being specific at the start of the deal) so Capitol is now wanting a larger piece of a [charity pie,] no matter who it hurts. So lets hope this gets hashed out soon. It Is causing undo stress for all concerned! Thank You For Listening, ThePaladin
April 30, 2010 @ 8:53 am
I hope this has an impact on the right person, so something good comes out of it all. What goes around comes around.