On Taylor Swift’s “Betty” Coming to Country Radio

From Taylor Swift’s recent surprise album Folklore, the most folkish or “country” song from the collection called “Betty” is being sent to country radio as a proper radio single. It was sent officially to many radio affiliates on Thursday (7-30) after numerous stations were already playing the track, resulting in multiple “adds” for the song on the mainstream country radio format. An official impact date on country radio of an edited version of the song (removing a very prominent F-bomb) is August 17th.
From all indications, “Betty” will not be just a perfunctory single that they send out hoping some stations will play. Though Taylor Swift’s current label is Republic, they are partnering with fellow Universal Records-owned imprint MCA Nashville to promote the single to country radio specifically. In other words, there’s a good chance Taylor Swift is coming back to country radio, and in a big way.
The last Taylor Swift single to have a significant impact on country radio was “Red” in 2013 which settled at #5, and was the title track to Taylor’s transitional record before she made the full move to pop. In 2014 when she released her first full pop record 1989, Big Machine Records owner Scott Borchetta wanted to send singles to country radio stations as well, but Taylor Swift resisted, insisting she wanted a clean break from country to remove the conflict that had roiled around the categorizing of her music, and to help keep her bridge to the format in tact.
But some also forget that another Taylor Swift single was sent to country radio in 2017. The sedate and piano-driven “New Year’s Day” that concluded her 2017 record Reputation wasn’t just sent to country radio stations right before the actual New Year’s Day in 2017, it was accompanied by a massive push by Big Machine, including a full page ad in the Country Aircheck trade periodical, with four additional pages featuring huge Taylor Swift images embossing the left margin—way more real estate than you would see for a regular single.
But strangely, after the initial push for “New Year’s Day,” Big Machine pulled their promotion of the single entirely. The song never registered more than a whimper on the country format before being summarily forgotten. Even if you are Taylor Swift, to have a successful song on country radio requires commitment, and follow through.
So what might make the story for “Betty” a different one? Well first off, it’s actually a bit more country than “New Year’s Day,” or really most of the singles Swift has released to country radio aside from the singles from her first self-titled record, which some are quick to forget were pretty country too compared to what you hear on the country format today. With prominent harmonica, and acoustic guitar comprising the heart of the song, “Betty” is more respectful to the country format than most of the singles currently being programmed there.
While some were quick to characterize Folklore as a folk or Americana record when it was first released, this is mostly fantasy based off the title and more lyric-driven recordings. The prevailing presence of electronic beats and drum loops throughout the record exclude most Folklore material from consideration in the roots realm, but “Betty” is the exception, with little drumming at all aside from what sounds like brushes on toms.
Though some may be reluctant to welcome a Taylor Swift song back to the country format, they shouldn’t be so wary of “Betty.” It’s a far better-written, and more country option than most of the tracks Maren Morris, Avenue Beat, or whatever other nauseating monstrosity is currently being pushed to the format by pop artists claiming country affiliation.
Besides, it’s names like Miranda Lambert whose song “Bluebird” is #1 right now, Maddie & Tae’s “Die From a Broken Heart” which has entered the Top 5, and Ashley McBryde’s “One Night Standards” finding traction in the Top 20 that are helping change the landscape. As long as Swift doesn’t take any important slots from these ladies, she should be welcome. If she sent a more patently pop-oriented song to the format, that is when it would be warranted to cry foul, no matter the genre she calls home.
But be mindful for the gaming of the country music mind when it comes to “Betty.” We’ve already seen multiple media outlets misgendering the song on their way to declaring it a “gay anthem.” Instead, it’s Taylor Swift writing with co-writer William Bowery from the perspective of a 17-year-old boy named James. “Betty” is part of a song trilogy that also includes the tracks “Cardigan” (which is referenced in “Betty”), and another song called “August.” It’s basically three separate perspectives on a love affair, and helps define one of the themes of the record.
Some have surmised that “James” is actually a girl, and who knows, maybe the song does have a hidden message or meaning. But let’s let people interpret the song however they wish out of respect for the songwriting as opposed to assigning wishful notions to it to align with someone’s ideologies. Let’s also not make this into another “Girl Crush” scenario, where Little Big Town admitted to hoping that a gender misunderstanding of the lyrics would lead to conversation and controversy, resulting in an otherwise fine, but average song becoming a #1 hit and the CMA Song of the Year in 2015. Make no mistake, enterprising journalists are waiting in the wings for some redneck on Facebook to claim they’re offended by who is kissing who in “Betty,” and maybe that’s part of the calculus of releasing it to country radio.
But “Betty” coming to country is fine. Many of the staunch traditionalists who will gripe about it don’t listen to mainstream country anyway, and if they did, they would know it’s actually an improvement to what you normally hear. It’s much more troubling and offensive to hear much of the pop music passed off as country that’s native to the format at the moment. Taylor Swift left country for pop with a greater level of respect from country fans for being honest about her music instead of sowing endless conflict by pushing pop through the country genre like we see with Sam Hunt, Maren Morris, and so many others.
“Betty” to country radio? It’s hard to hear it becoming a big hit, but who knows. Bring it on I guess. It will be interesting to see where it goes.
July 30, 2020 @ 6:45 pm
Country radio
July 30, 2020 @ 7:49 pm
Aaron Watson did it best!!!
July 31, 2020 @ 7:04 am
Who still listens to radio in 2020? Spotify premium is like $10 a month and every modern car has Bluetooth. I’d rather not listen to 10 minutes of luke Bryan/kane brown then 20 minutes of commercials
July 30, 2020 @ 6:52 pm
I don’t have a problem with this on country radio but it is kinda bizarre. Also I’m hype that Bluebird hit number one. If die from a broken heart gets there too that would be awesome.
July 30, 2020 @ 10:37 pm
Die From a Broken Heart is one of the best mainstream singles of the last 5 years.
July 31, 2020 @ 12:29 pm
What’s crazy is that Die From A Broken Heart was released in May — May 2019. It’s a song that just didn’t die. I would love to see Maddie and Tae get a couple other singles to radio.
July 30, 2020 @ 7:00 pm
I wonder if at 30 if she getting a little too old for songs like this? And as someone who has a wife that forces them to listen to country radio periodically is it better than most of the stuff you hear.
On another note has anyone heard anything about a Jinks acoustic album or the release date of the Red Rocks show?
August 2, 2020 @ 4:41 pm
I didn’t know Cody was playing at Red Rocks. Hot damn that’s gonna be a hell of a show and I may have to check it out. I’ve been to several shows there. Best one was Widespread Panic. That’s probably my favorite venue in the continental United States.
July 30, 2020 @ 7:06 pm
I second the die from a broken heart vote! Taylor Dye is the only Taylor on Country radio I support at the moment. Talented and gorgeous.
July 30, 2020 @ 7:13 pm
Folklore is her best album to date. It flows well, it’s more grown up, and it might be her best songwriting yet. If this is her slowly coming back to country I don’t think that would be the worst thing. However, it’s awesome to see Miranda, Ashley, and Maddie&Tae on the charts so I agree that it would be a shame if that was overshadowed. It would be great to have all of these women on country radio more often instead of the pop stuff that is currently on it.
July 30, 2020 @ 7:35 pm
Taylor Swift is way over hyped….
I hope “Betty” takes 12 months to peak… I hope it doesn’t have that Luke Combs power behind it. Too many good songs struggling to make it into the Top 25 .. We don’t need this clogging the system. We already have “Happy Anywhere” ( a rejected “Minions” movie soundtrack song) debuting extremely high on the charts this week based only on the namesake of the artists involved..
July 30, 2020 @ 8:24 pm
But it has acoustic guitar and harmonica so GTFO.
July 30, 2020 @ 9:29 pm
Dude. Do you really not understand why Happy Anywhere resonates with people? How many people whose lives have gone to shit because 2020 go to sleep next to their beloved thinking, it’s okay because I have you. All of those people fucking love that song. And Blake and Gwen being so joyfully, unabashedly in love in the middle of all the hate and disease and death today.
We went to their car concert. In Vegas it was at an actual working drive in movie theater and they had to show it on 2 screens cause they oversold tix and the car distancing thing wasn’t happening. People were full on tailgating and having the best time. You SO don’t get it.
July 30, 2020 @ 10:29 pm
Entertainment Weekly Gang Is gonna Entertainment Weekly.
July 30, 2020 @ 10:42 pm
Reused snark is not helping you one bit, Sparky. You lack a clue.
July 30, 2020 @ 10:47 pm
Hey, how about we keep it on the subject at hand as opposed to back and forths about Blake Shelton songs?
August 1, 2020 @ 4:40 am
The song isn’t only debuting high because of the artists. People love the song. It’s happy and fun. People need that right now. Why even bring up this song in particular when discussing Betty anyway?
August 27, 2020 @ 11:32 pm
Yeah, I don’t care for it. Every time I’ve listened to Taylor Swift I have never been impressed by the song she is singing. She is pretty and has a nice voice but that’s about it.
July 30, 2020 @ 8:19 pm
I personally like this song. if she does more country. I will welcome it.
July 30, 2020 @ 8:39 pm
I really liked her song “Lover” last fall, a rare modern pop song I actually liked. And it sounded more country than most stuff on “country radio” these days.
July 30, 2020 @ 10:22 pm
Basically almost all acoustic pop songs from Taylor is more country than the mainstream lmao
July 31, 2020 @ 4:34 am
Sad the genre has fallen so far that this can be a truthful statement.
July 30, 2020 @ 10:42 pm
I feel this is her return to country music and an FU to her shitty pop autotune production team that screwed her out of a ton of money. Am I wrong in thinking this is a response to her song Teardrops On My Guitar?
September 17, 2020 @ 10:27 am
I totally felt like this song was a reminisce of Teardops
On My Guitar.
July 30, 2020 @ 10:43 pm
Betty is just a really, really good song, and it’s a sight better than most of what’s on the radio.
I still don’t think she’s ever matched the heights of Speak Now (Ours and Sparks Fly are perfect pop country songs), but Folklore is very much the direction I wished she’d chosen, when she decided to go “Full Pop.”
Like her or hate her, she’s very smart and an extraordinary talent.
July 31, 2020 @ 9:53 am
The fuck you say. Shes been the product of huge hype, and a team picked by daddy. I didnt think you were a teenage girl, Lester.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:42 am
Lots of teenage girls with rich daddies want to be pop stars.
Lots of them manage to buy hype.
Only Taylor Swift is Taylor Swift.
The kid won a national poetry contest in elementary school, and has been selling millions of records for 14 years, across 8 albums and two genres – she’s also known for the exacting control she exercises over her image and marketing.
Since I’m a grown man, rather than a preteen boy, I have zero issues recognizing that someone is talented, even if I’m not the target audience.
Do you know the term for a smart, well-written song about the feelings of a teenage girl?
A smart, well-written song.
July 31, 2020 @ 11:57 am
Sounds like her talent peaked in elementary school. Her songs are tripe. The excuse used to be her age, but they haven’t progressed beyond teeny tunes
July 31, 2020 @ 12:11 pm
Do you know what you call a vivid, specific “teeny tune” with a great hook?
A good song.
The last several albums have been a step down from her best stuff, and I’d actually argue it’s because she’s been relying more on cowrites than she was earlier in her career.
Like her music or hate it. Pretending she’s anything other than extremely talented is nonsense.
August 1, 2020 @ 10:15 am
Age was never an “excuse” for Taylor Swift. It was a point of shock that someone so young could write better songs – and share more resonant stories and feelings – than successful professional songwriters in their 30s and 40s.
The youthful aspect of her content was also viewed as a breath of fresh air – she was writing songs that spoke to things someone her age would actually be going through. Unlike 11-year-old Mason Ramsey singing about how he hopes to be with his girl for “another five years.”
July 31, 2020 @ 1:08 pm
Jousting for her honor all you want; she still isn’t sleeping with her white knights.
July 31, 2020 @ 1:34 pm
…lol.
This isn’t Incel Reddit, champ.
August 1, 2020 @ 7:33 am
This isn’t the Taylor Swift Kool-Aid site either, White Knight.
August 1, 2020 @ 9:41 pm
Cracks me up that you’re doubling down on calling me a “White Knight,” kiddo.
Like I said…that line only works on other incels.
August 1, 2020 @ 9:45 pm
One day, long in the future, when you’ve managed to even have a conversation with a live, human woman…you’ll understand that it’s possible to view women as human for reasons other than wanting to sleep with them.
It’ll probably be another few years before a woman does willingly sleep with you…but you’ll be on your way, sport!
August 5, 2020 @ 12:12 pm
You just unironically called CountryKnight an incel lmao. I think you spend more time on Reddit than you care to admit.
August 5, 2020 @ 6:27 pm
I only got a Reddit account to buy my fake ID in high school, haha – only reason I go on these days is for MLBStreams
I learned about all that incel nonsense on sites that are very aggressively not Reddit – places where I’m very firmly on the right wing of the general commentariat, and they unironically have threads labeled as “Safe Spaces,” where you have to spoiler-text anything that might be “triggering.”
Those folks…aren’t all that sympathetic to Incels, haha.
July 31, 2020 @ 6:02 pm
I truly honestly don’t think she’s talented and never understand that argument and the need for it to be so aggressively asserted when arguing for her. If talented is simply being able to sing and play guitar, I guess? But lots of people can do that and no one goes on and on defending how talented *they* are, so why the need to do so with her? There is zero, and I mean zero, soul or depth in her music. I think people want to get along, they want to fit in, they want to see and “get” what everyone else does, what’s popular. So, they convince themselves “Fine. I can like Taylor Swift too! I’m not an old fuddy duddy!” But I am thoroughly convinced that if, years from now, an alien life form found remnants of the music from our world and played Taylor Swift back to back against say, I don’t know, a classic like Dolly Parton, with NO access to what they looked like, the image surrounding them, the media hype that occurred when they were stars, just void of any other background other than the sheer merits of the melody and lyrical structure and vocal tone and talent… Taylor Swift wouldn’t even be in the running to be taken seriously. Her music is that bland. And yeah, it sucks to feel like you’re just cynical, but goddammit it’s so depressing because you know you’re not. It really is just that bad, but that’s what culture has come to and we’re in the Twilight Zone lol.
July 31, 2020 @ 8:01 pm
It’s almost like different people can have different opinions about the same music. Just because you say something sucks, doesn’t make it true, and saying someone likes something just to “fit in” is incredibly arrogant.
July 31, 2020 @ 11:05 pm
This is a very nice wall of text…but millions of sales across 14 years, 8 albums and 2 genres (plus 2 labels) speak a bit louder.
If you were unaware…her “talent” lies in writing both vivid lyrics and catchy melodies, while having an acceptable voice and being able to handle herself instrumentally.
With that skillset, you can succeed in legitimately any genre you pick.
She generally doesn’t play the genres I prefer…but I’d have to be a deluded child to pretend she wasn’t talented.
August 1, 2020 @ 7:56 am
”It really is just that bad, but that’s what culture has come to and we’re in the Twilight Zone lol. ”
great points M…..and indeed there has always been pressure on the youth to ‘ fit in’ . TS has been a rallying point for the young , mostly , and perhaps not even as positive a role model , IMO as many would argue , in terms of her music . much of it is angry and vindictive and simply trite . enough said there.
talent ? wow ….if those aliens listened to TS’ efforts and the songs and writers responsible for the treasure that is the great american songbook, they would question whether this stuff all came from the same species.
yes ..I agree culturally we are living in a ‘ twilight zone”. we’ve relinquished common sense , we communicate a growing and dangerous sense of entitlement and worship celebrities and politicians who demonstrate the same . mass entertainment is watered down beyond recognition , funding cuts to the arts , and hype abounds no matter what is being sold ..and EVERYTHING is being sold . In the case of TS , that hype has been successful in marketing an inferior product to the most impressionable …youth . and the collateral damage to the more mature , ‘thinking’ audience , has been , for me , astounding . Its the pop music version of ‘The Bachelor ” or any other ridiculously exploitative dumb and dangerous ‘reality show’ . It pacifies and panders to our ‘ don’t -wanna- have- to- think ” basic instincts, at best ,when there is simply so much more inspiration , creativity , thoughtfulness , and sheer musical TALENT in 99.9% of the unknowns and singing show contestants out there than in a thousand TS’s. There are more interesting and inspiring songs and lyrics in an episode of Sesame Street which , at least , attempts to challenge its young listeners with its approach rather than simply marketing to the LCD.
I’d say ‘ don’t get me started ‘ but obviously that ship has sailed .
July 30, 2020 @ 10:48 pm
Hmm. Maybe Betty = Country Radio, and James = Taylor (“James Taylor”!!), and James is tiring of his summer fling and just wants to go back to the good times of hanging with Betty. Not sure who Inez is; maybe Scooter?
Oh well, it’s all too Seventeen for me.
I’m more interested in seeing how the other half of Ashley Ray’s new album unfolds. I think Pauline could pop Betty like a zit.
July 31, 2020 @ 1:39 am
Picking up on a comment I have seen eveywhere about Folklore. It is not a folk or Americana record and that assumption has been made by many people due to its title.
What it is instead is a tasteful singer-songwriter record that lands itself in the alternative/pop realm. It’s a return to form in terms or Taylor’s songwriting which she started to regain in Lover.
I really appreciate Trigger taking the time to look at Betty though. It is a brillaint, well written narrative song that I think should have a shot at country radio.
The whole album is fantastic but I wouldn’t expect Trigger to cover it here as it’s not a country/folk/americana record but if he does it will be an added bonus. I would love to hear his thoughts on the songwriting!
Thanks Trigger!
July 31, 2020 @ 3:55 am
I was tired of Taylor Swift long ago.
I was tired of ‘better than what’s on country radio’ long ago.
I’m getting tired of the discussion about the above two items.
I think it’s time for me to start shutting the hell on up about it, and anything else having to do with Music Row. it’s really not worth the time and effort, folks. Don’t protest it, just boycott it y’all.
July 31, 2020 @ 9:38 am
I’m right there with you, Charles. I gave up on this entitled little brat when she voiced her opinions on how horrible the United States is to women. She lives in the greatest country on the planet, who treat women better than any country on the planet, so I don’t know what her complaints are about. She is a 30 year old spoiled brat feminist that leans towards socialism, when it has been Capitalism that has made her millions. Her song writing comes from the perspective of a 12 year old. Her voice is not even above average. Her looks and lots of money have gotten her where she is today, certainly not her talent. At best, she would make a great poet.
July 31, 2020 @ 9:57 am
I completely understand if some people don’t want to busy their minds with what’s going on in the mainstream and on Music Row. It’s not a fight for everyone. But it happens to be one of the founding charges of this website, and the reason it was important to broach the subject of this song. You can’t save country music while ignoring the mainstream. Arguably, it’s the realm that needs the most attention. And as we’ve seen in recent years, things are improving there, and it’s because more an more the concerns and criticisms of fans are affecting decision making. If Taylor Swift’s “Betty” is an improvement over much of what’s being played (which it is), let’s celebrate it, and continue to try and inch country radio further in the right direction.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:27 am
What about this is the right direction for you? The harmonica? Lack of drum machine? Obviously the term country isn’t 100% rigid, but I would have never guessed people would say this was the right direction for country. Is it possible that most of us know it, only some of us are pretending not to?
On a side note, I wonder what effect trying to gatekeep actually has on the mainstream. If anything, people don’t like to be told what to do and most often rebel against it. Highlighting the awesome music that you do is probably way more impactful, in my humble opinion.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:58 am
Saying “This is a better direction than Thomas Rhett and Kane Brown” is a damn sight from saying “This is my preferred direction for the format, in a perfect world.”
betty is the sort of Lumineers-adjacent stuff that would ideally form the pop fringe of country radio.
July 31, 2020 @ 12:04 pm
Listen to Cool Lester Smooth.
July 31, 2020 @ 12:28 pm
The “I’d rather have” argument is short sighted. You can make all these justifications you want to, and I’d rather listen to certain songs than Luke Bryan myself, but you’re eroding the definition of country music in the process.
Whatever, I haven’t listened to country radio in years, so in the end I don’t personally care. It’s just hilarious to watch you guys rally behind this song with a straight face.
July 31, 2020 @ 1:06 pm
Better direction than More Boring Than My Wife Rhett or Kane Clown doesn’t mean much.
Once again, the only argument the apologists have is comparing this song to the worst of the mainstream. How persuasive.
July 31, 2020 @ 1:23 pm
At the end of the day…I would love for the current mainstream of the country genre to be “eroded” by well-written singer-songwriter stuff played on real instruments.
That’s I listen to, regardless of where on the genre spectrum an individual song might fall under – only stuff I listen to that doesn’t fall under that purview is highly lyrics-focused rap.
I’ve never pretended to be a country purist, so there’s no hypocrisy here, haha.
July 31, 2020 @ 4:10 pm
Fair enough CLS and like I said I don’t give a shit personally. I just laugh at this stuff mostly. There will still be good country music made, outside of this bullshit fake “country” in name only landscape. A little caught off guard by the logic here though, and by the guy whose “charge” or “charter” it is to care. Genre names mean less to me personally, but if you’re going to try to “save” one, I’m not sure that pretending this is country is going to help save jack shit.
July 31, 2020 @ 4:23 pm
Jake,
I never called “Betty” a country song. I said it was more country than much of what you find on mainstream country radio. I’m not advocating for the track. This is not a review. This isn’t even a think piece. This was an article published in the “radio” category of the site explaining the mechanics of how the single is coming to radio, and couching it in the context of similar singles like “New Years Day” and “Girl Crush.” I also wanted to go on record of how controversy might be used to sell the track, which we should all be on the lookout for. Since I knew there would be a lot of curiosity, I also gave a brief opinion on the song as well, which is that it is written better and more country than much of what is on country radio. Neither of those statements say that the song is country, or imply that I’m advocating people support it or Taylor Swift. It’s simply my judgement call based off of my professional perspective on country radio. Perhaps if this was a review, I would go more in-depth about how I feel about the song itself. But judging the song and the general style of songs that are currently being played on country radio, I don’t see any reason to be alarmed over it being released as a single. This really isn’t complicated.
July 31, 2020 @ 4:34 pm
Once again you didn’t say it verbatim, but half your article is providing some context and backstory, and the rest of it is excusing the song as being better or somehow more country than the others. While we could debate that all day, the bottom line is that you think this song is acceptable for “country” radio. How hard would it be to say something like “ironically the quality of the songwriting and the use of acoustic instruments might in some ways stand in stark contrast to what country radio passes as country these days, but make no mistake, this song ALSO ISN’T COUNTRY” You’re right, it isn’t really complicated.
August 1, 2020 @ 9:19 am
…the bottom line is that you think this song is acceptable for “country” radio.How hard would it be to say something like “ironically the quality of the songwriting and the use of acoustic instruments might in some ways stand in stark contrast to what country radio passes as country these days, but make no mistake, this song ALSO ISN’T COUNTRY” You’re right, it isn’t really complicated.
Speaking for myself, I didn’t need him to explicitly say that. Unless Trigger was to clearly communicate that a new Taylor Swift song was indeed a real country song, my assumption would be that he doesn’t think it is. Maybe that’s because I’ve read a lot of TS articles here over the years and I’m pretty sure the title at least one of one them was something like “Taylor Swift Is Not Country!”
August 1, 2020 @ 10:05 am
Neither do I, which is why I NEVER SAID he thinks it’s a real country song nor that he “needs” to do anything. Reading this site for years and watching great country music supported and introduced to me, I would have to be thicker than molasses not to understand that. I take that as a given, but thanks for pointing it out. What I DID do, is give one EXAMPLE of a way he COULD say something other than defending this song being on country radio…if that was how he felt…which he doesn’t seem to…which is the point of my comment, Jack.
August 1, 2020 @ 10:14 am
Ironically the quality of the songwriting and the use of acoustic instruments might in some ways stand in stark contrast to what country radio passes as country these days, but make no mistake, this song ALSO ISN’T COUNTRY.
There, I said it. Does that past your litmus test? Jack is right. I shouldn’t have to explain how I feel about country music some 13 years, and 6,000+ articles in. Maybe I don’t want to come across as trite and redundant.
Man are we splitting hairs here.
August 3, 2020 @ 10:04 am
In the context of what has happened to the industry, and the fact that you’re pretty much usually the ONLY voice of sanity against the onslaught of cultish journalists and industry folk who would gladly swallow this pill and more….I would have to say it makes me feel better to hear you say that, yes. If I’m going to get “trounced” or mocked for it, then so be it.
July 31, 2020 @ 5:50 am
I’m with Betty. She needs to tell Taylor Swoft to go fuck herself
July 31, 2020 @ 5:53 am
I like this place better when it wasn’t filled with Swift apologist pieces and was filled with epic take downs of her.
Go away Taylor. You did the decent (aka financially lucrative) thing and departed in the first place. Stay far away from country music. We don’t need or want you.
So much for her picking a line, Trigger? So much praise wasted on a charlatan move.
And it is more country than Morris? That is not a point in its favor. 99% of music is more country than Morris. Man, have our standards fallen. The bar is two inches off the ground.
July 31, 2020 @ 6:38 am
“Man, have our standards fallen. The bar is two inches off the ground.”
Couldn’t agree more. I used to think the idea of country music was being chiseled away, but it seems it’s fast becoming a race to the bottom.
July 31, 2020 @ 9:26 am
It is depressing as hell.
“Taylor Swift’s new stuff is country because it is more country than Maren Morris!”
If we take that stance, the war is already over. We lost.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:08 am
““Taylor Swift’s new stuff is country because it is more country than Maren Morris!”
That’s your quote, not mine.
My quote is, “While some were quick to characterize Folklore as a folk or Americana record when it was first released, this is mostly fantasy based off the title and more lyric-driven recordings. The prevailing presence of electronic beats and drum loops throughout the record exclude most Folklore material from consideration in the roots realm.
Let’s quit being so fatalistic. I did not praise this song. I simply said it’s more country and better written than most Maren Morris songs, which it is. The reason I chose to cover it is because it’s very relevant to country music that Taylor Swift is releasing a song to country radio, and I felt it was important for someone to spell out in detail the mechanisms behind how that’s happening, and what the impact could be. This isn’t a seismic shift in what Saving Country Music is doing. This is what I’ve been doing for over a decade. I continue to remain perplexed why so many take this as some sort of new development. I have always covered the mainstream and rooted for improvement—however incremental—and highlighting this song falls very much into that category.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:25 am
C’mon Trigger. Saying it is more country than the worst of the mainstream isn’t saying much and shouldn’t count as a point in the song’s favor. That is the point. It is like someone saying this player should be inducted into the HOF because they are better than a player whose induction is universally considered to be a mistake.
“Betty” is more country than the worst offenders. Great. And we wonder why we lose ground every year. How about is it country by a higher standard?
July 31, 2020 @ 11:02 am
Well, Taylor does write songs for durls!
And durls are GROSS!
The LAST thing that country radio needs is quality songs, sung by the writer, that only feature organic instrumentation!!!
July 31, 2020 @ 11:16 am
CLS: I know many female Jazz singers who write great music with organic instrumentation. I’m never going to call their music country, and it has nothing to do with anything other than the music.
I got no issue with pop or TS. She’s good at what she does. Unlike some here, I respect what she’s done and like some of her songs to a degree. None of this means I’m going to pretend this is country music.
July 31, 2020 @ 11:38 am
She’s definitely not country, and neither is this song…but if I have to have pop songs on country radio, I want ones in this vein.
If George Ezra got all of Luke Bryan’s country radio airtime, I’d cheer!
July 31, 2020 @ 10:37 am
I’m don’t really have the morale to fight a war, if this is what we’re fighting for.
July 31, 2020 @ 8:22 am
I was looking at the Billboard Country Airplay chart this week, and Maren Morris’s current single doesn’t seem to be doing too well. Any take on this Trigger?
July 31, 2020 @ 6:20 am
James is a girl – or at least it wouldn’t be a stretch to say that that’s the case. She is good friends with Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds and their 3 daughters are named: James, Inez, and (as revealed in this song) Betty.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:12 am
Well, if James and Betty are sisters, then it could also be a song about incest. 🙂
My only point here is that Taylor Swift purposely wrote this song so that it could be interpreted differently by different people depending on their perspective and life experience, and that’s the mark of a quality song. Let’s not impinge on the ability for “Betty” to resonate with listeners, and in different ways, by assigning certitudes to it, or presenting it as a Trojan horse to push an ideological agenda. Let the song live on its own.
July 31, 2020 @ 1:32 pm
I didn’t hear anything other than the singer pining for the girl he loves but cheated on. It’s clear to me that even though the singer is a girl, the person telling the story is a boy.
August 1, 2020 @ 7:23 am
My final piece of evidence on this topic would be that James is admitting fault. Which is usually to blame in a TS song – a boy or a girl? 😉
August 1, 2020 @ 10:03 pm
Reminds me of people grasping at the straws for the “This is how we roll” song from FGL somehow being a gay anthem because of “love who we love” line.
August 7, 2020 @ 9:47 am
I stand corrected. Per her new interview, “I think we all have these situations in our lives where we learn to really, really give a heartfelt apology for the first time. Everybody makes mistakes, everybody really messes up sometimes and this is a song that I wrote from the perspective of a 17-year-old boy,” she said. “I’ve always loved that in music you can kind of slip into different identities, and you can sing from other people’s perspectives. So that’s what I did on this one.”
July 31, 2020 @ 6:28 am
FOH with that ignorant BS
July 31, 2020 @ 6:44 am
Wtf is this shit? Among other things, not even close to a good comparison.
July 31, 2020 @ 7:00 am
Fuck off, punk.
July 31, 2020 @ 7:09 am
Either my perspective has shifted or this comment section has really gone sour. I think Taylor Swift is a better country writer than most country writers. She’s a brilliant lyricist and knows what an actual melody is. I like this song and would love to see it go to #1
July 31, 2020 @ 7:19 am
I actually liked the first few seconds.
Then I heard the word “homeroom”
I’m a grown ass man with bills, a job, and taxes to pay.
I’m sick of hearing high schoolers and grown adults pretending to be High schoolers and college age dumbasses on the radio.
I don’t wanna hear about the kids and their 420s and their TikTok and their Fortnite.
I want to hear big people music because I’m a big person.
And big people have big things to sing about.
I don’t care who kissed whom on the playground, I don’t care whose homework k is overdue. And I especially don’t care what a bunch of chihuahua voiced pipsqueaks think.
This isn’t kidz bop
Is it too much to ask to hear some actual adult stuff, like about landlords and bosses and debt collectors?
July 31, 2020 @ 8:10 am
absolutely nailed it F2S…..NAILED it IMO,
this is trite ‘homeroom” pop for kids , as her music has always been . nothing mature or consequential or COUNTRY about it . she’s trying on a new pair of shoes …and that’s all . same person wearing a new pair of shoes . and not really all that new .
I wonder when she’ll cover ” The Gambler ” ?
July 31, 2020 @ 8:55 am
Yeah, the sexy adult Taylor of “Style” and “Lover” and especially the bitchy, edgy Taylor of “Look What You Made Me Do” are way preferable. Ditto “You Need to Calm Down.”
July 31, 2020 @ 9:11 am
George strait has a #1 song about a school bus and playground
July 31, 2020 @ 9:28 am
I assume you are referring to Check Yes or No?
To be fair, that song is written from the perspective of a man looking back on his relationship with his wife. As a fellow “grown ass man” and one whose marriage will hit 20y in February, I can relate to Check Yes or No. I have a harder time relating to songs about homeroom. Not saying there isn’t a place for those songs on the radio, but I’m with Fuzzy in wanting more songs with adult themes on the radio. Especially country radio.
If you are not referring to CYN, then apologies.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:15 am
Not really understanding the criticisms of the song as being immature. I think it’s a mature perspective presented in a reminiscent moment. We all look back on things we did when we were younger with remorse and wisdom. This isn’t an instance of “glory days syndrome” like so much of country today.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:41 am
I was not clear – my comment is not specific to the Taylor Swift song.
July 31, 2020 @ 9:50 pm
I was referring to cyon. Fuzzy said he liked the first few seconds and then he heard “homeroom”. By the same standard, listen to cyon for a few seconds and you’ll hear “third grade”
July 31, 2020 @ 12:39 pm
Yeah and there’s also “I’m Already Taken” by Steve Warner, considered a 90s country classic. And Billy Currington’s first single “Walk A Little Straighter”, which if I recall he started writing at 14 years old.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:32 am
helluva comment looks like u still got it thats wut we came here to reed
July 31, 2020 @ 11:09 am
“I want to hear big music because I’m a big person” sounds like a direct quote from Vincent Adultman.
The speaker of Yvette, off Southeastern, mentions seeing the title character “in class” – clearly, that’s a song for kids!
Do you also hate the Steve Earle song Someday? Hell – half the tracks off Rose Queen are from the perspective of an adolescent treading water.
July 31, 2020 @ 2:08 pm
Someday is written from the perspective of an adolescent who is thinking about his future and considering making some adult decisions about what he will do with his life. Maybe he will leave the town, maybe he won’t. He works at the “fillin station” – he clearly has responsibilities. Does he seem to be in the same spot in his life as the narrator of Taylor Swift’s song? Maybe, we only have partial information. I’m guessing no.
BTW Guitar Town is a great album through and through.
July 31, 2020 @ 5:13 pm
Despite her talent as a songwriter (and she is talented when’s she’s not writing with the brain of a 12 year-old), Swift’s tuned vocals do nothing for me. She comes across as 30 going on 12, mentally. Her music seems so contrived.
Bringing up Steve Earle in a Taylor Swift post, though, is sacrilege. Sales figures be damned (which don’t necessarily = great music), Swift isn’t even the beginning of a pimple on the legendary Earle’s ass. (To borrow a quote from the movie Crossroads — not the Britney Spears one!)
August 1, 2020 @ 9:51 pm
As someone who owns a pair of Steve Earle’s guitar strings…if I called either Steve or Swift a talented, genre-spanning songwriter who can’t really sing, would you disagree?
July 31, 2020 @ 4:50 pm
FuzzyTwoShirts, you couldn’t have nailed it any more accurately. It seems that people have forgotten there actual adults in the world that have adult problems and do adult things. I don’t want to hear Taylor singing about high school crushes. I don’t want to hear Luke Bryan singing about hitting on college girls at spring break. It was fun back in the day, but people like me have outgrown it and moved on with our lives!!
July 31, 2020 @ 7:29 am
Musiccityman,
Racism is a bad ideology. It’s immoral, dawg.
Having said that, I’m not someone who believes that words are racist in and of themselves. You have to be a racist for your words to be racist. The great thing about your comment, is all the pasty-white leftists it will offend. Their tears give me life, and for that I thank you.
Let me say, if you really do hate blacks and Jews, I think you should reconsider.
As for this song: I’ve hated Swift since day one. Her inclusion in “Country” radio was always a mistake. I actually hate everything about her and always have, which I won’t waste my time elaborating on here. But why does it matter which radio format plays a song that I’ll never hear?
When most of us on this site gripe about “Country” radio, we’re griping about something we don’t even listen to anymore.
July 31, 2020 @ 7:36 am
Musiccityman,
I also think you misunderstood Trigger’s use of the word “redneck” in the article.
He’s saying that’s how mainstream journalists view “Country” fans, or at least that’s my understanding.
July 31, 2020 @ 7:37 am
I don’t mind Taylor and I don’t mind “Betty” but god she shouldn’t get to pick and choose when to make a buck in “Country”. There are women in the format who are struggling but choose to stay in there lane. If this song does well it takes away from the women who are fighting tooth and claw to be successful on Country Radio.
I just don’t think it is fair she taps into the format when it is convenient for her or she wants to stick it to Borchetta. Not to mention when is she going to start writing grown up songs, she is almost 30 and singing about high school triangles. Although I guess her fan base is middle schooler’s as no one I know listens to her music.
August 4, 2020 @ 9:16 am
”I don’t mind Taylor and I don’t mind “Betty” but god she shouldn’t get to pick and choose when to make a buck in “Country”.”
agreed . WE should pick and choose and realize when we are being scammed , pandered to and disrespected . it all comes down to educating the listener in these exploitative times.
July 31, 2020 @ 7:42 am
For the record, a comment using an offense word was deleted here, which subsequently deleted responses to that comment. Feel free to repost comments that were not directly related to the use of that word that might have been inadvertently deleted.
Also for the record, I did not use the term “redneck” in this article to be offensive to anyone. I was using it to characterize how much of the media views country fans as inferior and stupid. Obviously, I don’t hold that view myself.
July 31, 2020 @ 7:49 am
It was more than obvious.
July 31, 2020 @ 11:10 am
Racists gonna racist.
July 31, 2020 @ 12:45 pm
I see what you did there.
July 31, 2020 @ 8:03 am
All she’s doing is picking a song with a controversial subject to try to get attention. Another “look at me” moment where she can claim to do a country song but keep her pop street cred since it’s not like those other country songs that those country people listen too. Probably hoping country music won’t play it so she can get more headlines. Everything is click-bait driven for dollars. Sick times people. Sick times.
Giant Meteor 2020!
In ancient times the Romans looked at actors as nothing more than prostitutes. The more things change the more they stay the same. We are modern Rome.
July 31, 2020 @ 8:25 am
The song is less offensive than a lot of other stuff being played on mainstream country radio these days.
For me, her music is stuck in an adolescent perspective. She should have outgrown that by now, but so should have Luke Bryan.
Her coming back to country now only bothers me because we are finally getting some airplay success for Miranda Lambert, Maddie & Tae, Ashley McBryde, etc. I would hate for one of them to get dropped to make room for Swift – especially when there are so many other more worthy female acts that can’t seem to break through the radio barrier at all.
July 31, 2020 @ 8:36 am
I’m glad I listened to the first half of the song before I started to rip it up on-the-air.
Surely she will release an edit without “fuck me” in there to the radio stations that would even consider her crap as country.
July 31, 2020 @ 9:00 am
The follow-up to Taylor’s Betty is a song called….Karen, and I need to see the manager.
July 31, 2020 @ 9:03 am
Perusing social media comments from her Stans, this is the “worst album” she’s ever done.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:16 am
Huh. The critics are loving it.
July 31, 2020 @ 11:05 am
I would say that is untrue, from what I’ve seen its been a hit with fans and critics alike. The so called ‘stans’ who are having issue with it are those who followed her when she was doing straight up pop. This is noticeably different so it won’t be there cup of tea. But ‘worst album ever’ is a stretch, lots been getting a lot of buzz by fans and the numbers are showing that a true as the are doing better than Lover so far.
August 1, 2020 @ 10:15 am
Not true at all. Both critics and “stans” are probably overhyping it if anything, and in the process probably unfairly discrediting some of her past albums (this still isn’t as good as Fearless).
July 31, 2020 @ 9:25 am
Certainly better than anything on the new The Chicks album
July 31, 2020 @ 9:25 am
I’ve hated Swift since day one. I hate everything about her actually: her face, her smile, her personality, her voice, her writing…I can’t think of one redeemable quality she has.
Having said that, it really doesn’t matter which format embraces her at this point. Most of us don’t listen to “Country” radio anyway, so we won’t hear this get played. Me, and most of us here, griping about “Country” radio, is like a man who doesn’t go to McDonald’s griping about whether a salad should be on their menu or not.
In 2006, griping about Swift being on “Country” radio was a legitimate thing to do. In 2020, it doesn’t matter at all. In fact, it wouldn’t matter if they played all her music.
July 31, 2020 @ 9:32 am
This song is going to spark more conversations with friends who only know country music in passing. I’m really tired of those conversations…
This is an acoustic pop/singer-songwriter song targeted to teenage girls. It’s not country in instrumental style, melody, or narrative voice. Nothing about it is country. And sadly, it stills sounds more country than 95% of what’s on the radio these days…
As an acoustic pop/singer-songwriter song, I’d say it’s fine. A nice listen. Nothing wrong with it unless you categorize it as country.
August 1, 2020 @ 7:31 pm
The 90s are back so I’m gonna say she throwing it back to 1997 and Lilith Fair.
July 31, 2020 @ 9:56 am
As “reluctant” as I am to admit it, I actually like the song and think it has some redeeming qualities, from a quality perspective. Country, I don’t know… Was Guy Clark Country? More than most pop songs it has an interesting melody, it ISN’T just the same four chords repeated ad nauseam, and does tell a story. Sure, I’m a grow adult and interested in grow adult things, but I can also appreciate a good song when I hear it.
Thanks Trig, I never would have heard this song if not for you discussing it.
P.S. try to not to go too hard on the the words “guy” and “clark” in an article about Taylor Swift 😉
July 31, 2020 @ 10:06 am
If the consumers want TS on the radio, then so be it. I don’t have a problem with her. The people who complain aren’t her demographic anyway.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:07 am
I’ve only listened to the samples from the album, but good god is it horrible. The lack of beats and computer sounds usually included with her music only exposes her terrible singing.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:19 am
I am fan of Taylor. I do enjoy this album especially more than Reputation and Lover. Betty is cute. It is good song for teenagers. I wish she would stop trying to appeal to them so much.
July 31, 2020 @ 10:42 am
A little trivia:
James happens to be the name of Ryan Reynolds/Blake Lively’s first daughter, their second daughter is Inez and their last kid’s name wasn’t revealed till Taylor did… Betty
July 31, 2020 @ 11:26 am
Nah, I’m good. Once again, I have a sailors mouth, but F bombs aren’t always needed to make a good song. It is worse when an artist becomes ” enlightened.” They are offended over every other word, except F***. This song is decent pop, but. country radio doesn’t need this song. They need a country artist to ” save it.”
July 31, 2020 @ 11:33 am
Well Trigger, you did it. Thanks, thanks a lot.
July 31, 2020 @ 1:18 pm
Its nice. Its actually kind of different, a mix of adult and immature.
The arrangement is great, its how Taylor is best. Reminds me of “safe and sound” that she did with the civil wars.
I got to meet Taylor many years ago. She seemed nice. It was disapointing that she went pop, but its her choice.
Thanks for bringing my attention to it, i might get the album on the strength of the song.
I did get a feel she was copying the lumineer latest album with its themes of different sides of a family.
July 31, 2020 @ 1:34 pm
I really like the song. I don’t know why it would be a gay anthem or anything. I listened to it twice but I wasn’t looking for hidden meanings, just enjoying the song.
July 31, 2020 @ 4:10 pm
Well…
Taylor Swift is back. “Betty” will be a hit.
Is the track more “country” than the monogenre blabla Maren Morris is releasing?
It is. Sure. But…getting “better” (?) music out than MM is easy…the format is filled with half-baked pop-country tracks.
July 31, 2020 @ 9:05 pm
That harmonica really reminds of much better folk songs that this one’s modeled after.
August 1, 2020 @ 3:00 am
Fuckin homeroom and skateboards? Ok. If this is really an incest song then maybe il add it to my playlist of top incest songs to go along with my top face – sitting songs I’ve been working on for awhile now . If not, no add from me . Blockman, out.
August 1, 2020 @ 7:32 am
So much for Taylor picking a lane.
Lots of wasted praise on a decision that was never going to be final.
Can’t believe people actually fall for that line of bull.
August 1, 2020 @ 10:30 am
On the one hand, I agree with you that the praise felt misplaced. Too many people were discounting the strategic element of the pop move. For all the success she had over her first four albums, the one thing she didn’t really have was that big, ubiquitous, global pop hit (a few songs came close – but nothing suggesting she was the biggest artist in the world). By fully positioning herself as a pop star, she could A) make and promote music that was specifically designed for global ubiquity and B) eliminate the limitation/stigma of being a genre artist – particularly of a genre that isn’t as big around the world.
I Knew You Were Trouble was a full-fledged, undeniable pop song, and it was successful, but the market still looked at it in a different way than it would a big Rihanna or Adele hit. There was a ceiling in place because the market still saw it as a “country star releasing a pop song,” even if her music had actually long since left the country lane.
All that said, I don’t see this current move as betraying anything. I actually see this as being faithful to the idea of “picking a lane.” She’s not releasing her big pop single (“cardigan”) to country – and she didn’t release the pop singles from her last album to country. She’s releasing a song that, though not as country as people are saying, is faithful to the sound she had when she ruled the genre.
And that should be OK. The problem with “not picking a lane” is that pop stars and/or wannabe pop stars who call themselves country stars are releasing pop music to country radio. It was never that an artist, especially one who has proven she values country, couldn’t release pop songs to pop radio and country songs to country radio.
People aren’t (or at least shouldn’t be) upset that Kane Brown and Maren Morris have released pop singles to pop radio (Be Like That, One Thing Right, The Middle) yet still release songs at country radio. The anger is that the songs they release to country radio aren’t always country either.
But as long as Taylor Swift releases country singles that are faithful to the format, then she hasn’t gone back on any word.
August 2, 2020 @ 10:08 am
You wasted a lot of words to deflect for her.
She went pop but she is releasing a non-country song to country radio. No amount of paragraphs can deflect that fact.
August 2, 2020 @ 11:30 pm
I would honestly LOVE if Maren Morris went full pop.
The Middle is really, really good. A solid step above most of her “country” releases (absent the Highwomen stuff) – you can tell how much more engaged she is.
Meanwhile…if Jade Bird’s next album trends more towards the country-rock sound of her live show, I won’t complain at all.
August 5, 2020 @ 10:57 pm
you make a great point here CLS. her first record is a fave of mine cuz it had SOUL and she delivered .
what ‘country’ calls R and B is absolutely soul-less …..the ‘singers’ can’t cut it …trite as it is lyrically .
MM NEEDS to find more interesting material than she released on her newest record . . and NOT ‘country’ or little big town ‘country ‘ drivel . she needs to call susan Tedeschi or bonnie raitt or Tami Neilson …..REAL singers who find and write GREAT material …..and she needs to stop trying to be all things to all genres . it falls through the cracks . I LOVE MM’s voice and passion and sheer talent . I want to hear it showcased on the right material regardless of genre .
August 1, 2020 @ 7:28 pm
I don’t care, but who cares. It sounds like every other Taylor Swift melody.
August 1, 2020 @ 7:36 pm
I listened but I always feel like when I hear her sing there something behind it all where she isn’t fully committed I can’t explain it but it’s not fake per se but as she doesn’t know who the hell she wants to be. Sometimes she’s middle finger sometimes, she’s forgive me, sometimes just she’s whatever, sometimes she la la I love you… And it has nothing to do with genre or age or even the music… It has to do with her knowing herself.
The only example I can think of i Madonna who in the 80s and 90s was fucking Madonna. It never felt like she was TRYING to be Madonna. Taylor Swift so often comes off as somebody who trying so damn hard to be liked or fit in and in the end is not sure who they are trying to be hence all the pseudo-chameleon changes throughout her career.
It has hurt her one bit but it’s just personally why I can’t get into the music.
August 2, 2020 @ 10:06 am
Like most young people, she is whatever the popular crowd is.
See the recent protests for example. They are a society of shape-shifters.
August 1, 2020 @ 7:37 pm
Also interesting that the album went #1 in the UK and AUS but hasn’t been released her yet. I wonder the reasoning behind that game plan?
August 1, 2020 @ 7:42 pm
After having a single run-through on “Betty”…well, I won’t say that I’ve been converted into a T-Swift fan (that ship has sailed). In comparison to a lot of the stuff she has done in her fourteen years in the business, however, it is one of her Top Three, alongside “Back To September” and “Begin Again”; and though hobbled by her tendency to write lyrics that are appropriate for someone in their teens but not someone who is 30 years old (as she is now), I think it is closer to what Taylor might have been, and maybe could still be, if she went in the folk/country direction of Linda Ronstadt or Joni Mitchell from the early 1970s.
Is this actually “country”? Only peripherally in my opinion; and clearly not to the minds of most on this dais (but then how much is played on country radio these days that actually is REALLY country?, he asked rhetorically). However, it does sound like Taylor took something of a hint and made a real attempt to project her voice better, as her voice has been her big Achilles heel for me. If she can keep up these improvements and move away from the teenage heartbreak themes she has been expounding on from the outset, just maybe she can be talked about as being one of this era’s equivalents of Joni or Linda.
August 2, 2020 @ 7:56 am
I’m surprised to say that I actually like this song. If I had to classify it, I’d call it something like Young Adult Americana. And as an adult, there are themes in this song that I relate to, like betrayal, regret and desperately wanting a second chance. And I don’t know that I’ve ever related to a Taylor Swift song before. I know that I’ve never wanted to listen to her music for pleasure before. It made me think a little of one of my favorite songs of 2013, which is “Happy” by Holly Williams, which is definitely for proper adults. But not everything in rootsy circles has to be for us.
And speaking of Holly Williams, I wonder if we’re ever going to hear that Dave Cobb produced album that is supposedly in the can.
(p.s. – I started streaming the TS album on my Echo while cleaning the kitchen yesterday to see if there was more that I might like, but stopped after three songs. Not awful, but I did nothing much for me and that was enough time spent on that particular curiosity. I’ll probably hear it played by my younger daughter eventually.)
August 3, 2020 @ 4:21 pm
Yeah, I had a drive the other day, so I popped it on…and it’s fine.
I quite like betty and exile, and the whole affair is definitely less “Empty Calories” than the last three albums…but it’s not gonna go into my rotation or anything. It’s a solid piano pop album.
Now, a new Holly Williams joint would DEFINITELY go into that rotation! She’s so freaking great.
August 4, 2020 @ 5:45 am
Being gay and thinking that one song in a million *might* be relatable to you isn’t part of any “ideology”. Especially when the writer is someone who openly embraces her non-straight fanbase.
August 4, 2020 @ 9:27 am
With all due respect, you missed the intent of that comment. It should be insisted upon by everyone that the meaning of songs be allowed to breathe and mean whatever they will to an audience, and have that fluidity preserved as opposed to hemmed in by assigning specific parameters or agendas to it. If someone who happens to be gay wants to take this song as being told from a gay perspective, awesome. If a straight person wants to see it as being a woman singing from a man’s perspective, that’s cool too. That is what will make the song personal to more people. The media shouldn’t assign it a meaning, just because they want to push their own personal agenda, which I’ve already witnessed happening with the song. They should let the songwriting speak for itself, and let every listener land on their own interpretation, which is the outcome Taylor Swift was hoping for when she wrote it.
August 5, 2020 @ 6:10 pm
It’s definitely not country, but I’ve still been pleasantly surprised by how good Folklore is.
August 6, 2020 @ 8:33 pm
This is the best song that Taylor has released in almost a decade, from a combined lyrical and musical viewpoint. I have been hoping for years now that she would go back to her roots musically. Now that she is out of Big Machine, that seems to be slowly coming true.
There are a couple of new things worth noting about this song. Firstly, it is clear that Taylor has mastered the art of writing abstract lyrics that feed the listener’s imagination. Secondly, I think that this is the first time she has ever used swear language in a song…
November 7, 2021 @ 11:01 am
If that’s the worst thing she ever did when she was 17, God bless her