On Tyler Childers Performing “All Your’n” with Olivia Rodrigo

I get it. As a country music fan these days, it almost feels like the entire music world is caving in on you as everyone wants a piece of the country genre. First it was Beyoncé and her supposed country album, which ended up being a dud. Now it’s Post Malone out there making country music news every other day, and giving all indications his upcoming country project will be anything but a dud. In fact, it might be dominant over the country genre for the foreseeable future.
But that doesn’t mean we can’t allow for one-off cross-genre collaborations, or even conclude they’re kind of cool upon occasion. Olivia Rodrigo isn’t going country, and Tyler Childers isn’t going pop. They just happened to collaborate on a song that clearly felt personal to Rodrigo on what’s basically Tyler Childers’ turf.
On Wednesday, July 24th, pop star Olivia Rodrigo appeared at the Rupp Arena in Lexington as part of her “Guts” world tour, and the 21-year-old invited Tyler Childers to come out and sing his song “All Your’n” with her. Rodrigo has also brought out Noah Kahan and other artists on stops on the tour. The Rupp Arena holds special significance to the Appalachian/independent country resurgence because it is one of the first arenas that artists like Tyler Childers played and sold out.
Clearly the crowd in attendance thought the duet was killer. Most of the reception has been positive. But there has also been quite a few criticizing Tyler Childers for agreeing to the collaboration.
One of the reasons that country has become so hot all of a sudden is because it’s sounding more country than it has in years, and because the regional roots of the music are coming through once again. Regardless if you’re from the region where the music originates, hearing someone’s personal and authentic expressions conveying universal sentiments gives the music a distinct character that creates a unique appeal.
This is the whole reason Tyler Childers has blown up into an international arena star by playing distinctly Appalachia music. He’s said in interviews in the past that the reason he never moved to Nashville or outside of Kentucky is because he wants to be embedded within the regional dialects that influence his music. “All Your’n” is a perfect example of this. The song is full of Appalachia vernacular, including the title. Maybe some see it as sacrilege that a Filipino American pop star would sing a song like this, but it’s not like she is releasing this as a radio single.
It is important that the traditions and influences of American country music are preserved and respected. But it’s also important that we aren’t so rigid as to disallow the opportunity that music has to bring people together, bridge perspectives, and broaden appeal.
Remember, in large part it was a collaboration with another Kentucky country artist, Chris Stapleton, with a pop star, Justin Timberlake, that set off country music’s move away from the whole Bro-Country era in the first place. Will the collaboration between Olivia Rodrigo and Tyler Childers have a similar effect? Of course not. It was a simple, one-off thing. But that’s all the more reason to not be uptight about it.
If you’re true in your conviction about preserving country music’s roots, you have to pick your battles wisely. Otherwise you come across as the boy who cried wolf, or pretentious, or overly uptight. Tyler Childers singing “All Your’n” at the Rupp Arena with Olivia Rodrigo? This isn’t a war worth waging. As you hear from the folks in the crowd, it was a fun and enjoyable. Many will remember when one of their favorite pop stars brought out one of their local heroes in Kentucky, and a memorable moment ensued.
July 28, 2024 @ 6:04 pm
I’m a die hard 33 year old country music fan who also happens to love Olivia Rodrigo. She’s the real deal. I was at this show and the crowd went crazy when Childers came out. In Kentucky, we love our own. It was simply a one off fun collab of a great song. Nothing more nothing less.
July 28, 2024 @ 6:20 pm
There should be no one complaing about this. It was well done and the crowd appreciated it and knew the words. Im not a fan of either so its all good. If we cant bond by music then maybe all hope is lost.
July 28, 2024 @ 6:35 pm
Anyone complaining about this needs to get a grip. Two great artists who clearly have respect for each other collaborating at a show for the fans. What’s better?
July 28, 2024 @ 6:46 pm
Trig, We gonna get a red clay strays review? I know it’s not really country but it’s a borderline masterpiece of southern rock salvation.
July 28, 2024 @ 6:57 pm
There will probably be a Red Clay Strays review soon. I didn’t get the benefit of a review copy of this one (often happens as soon as an artists signs with a major), so I’ve been listening in real time and want to make sure I get it right. Thanks for the interest.
July 29, 2024 @ 6:44 am
I know Trig’s on it because I freaked out after listening to it on my drive to work Friday morning and the first person I had to tell was him so I sent him a note. And as busy as he is, he took the time to reply directly with the same message he gave you. I know there’s a bunch of us feeling like little kids on Christmas morning wanting to get his take and jump into the comments section but we gotta respect that Trigger is not your typical “one listen” critic. That’s why we love him.
July 28, 2024 @ 6:57 pm
Very well said.
Who was criticizing it? I thought all the comments on social media were overwhelmingly and shockingly positive. The one that cracked me up was “didn’t even know this was an option.” Maybe I’ve blocked all the Negative Nancy’s throughout the years and insulated myself from these kind of naysayers.
I’ve only ever seen Olivia Rodrigo printed in Grammy nominations and I didn’t know she was this popular. It was cool hearing all her fans singing along, but Travis Scott could play Lexington and his Kentucky fans would know the words to Tyler Childers’ songs. He’s the most popular man in Appalachia right now.
July 28, 2024 @ 7:14 pm
Yeah, I’m seeing some folks pushing back that there was no negativity and I’m making it up out of whole cloth for clicks or something. Where I saw the performance first was the massive “Tyler Childers Fans” Instagram account with 323,000 followers. Far and away the most popular comment is, “Tyler ur better than that come on now.”
You can find the Instagram post here:
https://www.instagram.com/tylerchilders/reel/C92sL42p10l/
Though I would say most feedback was positive, and the negative was getting pushback, I decided to use the opportunity to highlight a deeper point, while also highlighting the moment for those that might have missed it. If you loved the collaboration, this article is probably not for you. I wrote it for the folks who are saying Childers crossed some line.
July 30, 2024 @ 7:53 pm
I mean, writing a story about what social media commenters on a fan account are saying is only about one step above inventing a controversy out of whole cloth. The internet is not real life.
July 30, 2024 @ 8:48 pm
I wrote a story about the collaboration between Tyler Childers and Olivia Rodrigo to highlight it for the folks who may not have seen it yet. I also used it as a moment to talk about how we shouldn’t be so rigid in country music that we somehow look sideways at a moment like this as problematic somehow.
When someone questioned whether there truly was anyone who was taking issue with it in the comments section, I responded with verification that there was. I didn’t include this information in the article itself because it was not a critical part of the story.
There has been some push back on this story, and I respect that. Perhaps it was a bit overwrought on my part. But I stand behind the opinion shared here, and that it was important to share. The target audience for this article were folks who had a problem with the collaboration, not the folks who didn’t.
July 28, 2024 @ 7:22 pm
If I had to chose a “problem” about this maybe it would be all the trying too hard to tell everyone what they should and shouldn’t think about it. Why can’t people be disappointed?
Personally I couldn’t give a shit, but if you do care and you’re surprised by Tyler doing anything “inauthentic” or in “betrayal” of “country folk” or something like that these days, you either don’t get it and / or haven’t been paying attention.
July 28, 2024 @ 7:54 pm
People have a right to be disappointed. And I have a right to be disappointed in those people for it. My job is to write commentary about country music. That is what I did here. But the jokes on me apparently. I’ll go back to my cage and continue to churn out boring album reviews that nobody wants to read, because apparently that is all I am ever allowed to do.
July 29, 2024 @ 3:21 pm
Well I just got my signed vinyl and sticker pack from Melissa Carper. Although I heard, and loved, the title track before your review was posted, it was your review and listening to the second embedded song you included that nudged me into purchasing from her. Im sure your reviews are still appreciated by the artists and your more regular readers, even if they don’t get the same attention as your articles with the bigger names or more controversial subjects.
July 29, 2024 @ 8:18 pm
Plus I got pretty ratioed so people seem to like this commentary anyway.
July 28, 2024 @ 7:44 pm
I think all those teenage Olivia fans singing along with Tyler Childers is cool as hell.
July 28, 2024 @ 8:56 pm
This is a positive thing for country music – having good songs break outside of the genre boundaries to where other genres appreciate it. Not sure how anyone could think that this is dilluting country in any way.
July 28, 2024 @ 10:09 pm
So cool! Feels like a win!
July 29, 2024 @ 1:15 am
…fact is, tyler childers’ “all your’ n” is a very beautiful love songs no matter which genre it originates from. olivia rodrigo – or any other music star – coming to the same conclusion does not surprise me for a second. if it creates such enjoyable and memorable moments, all the better.
July 29, 2024 @ 2:41 am
If he had come out dressed like a pop star or something like that, I could see someone saying “you are better than that”. It looks to me like he is dressed like a 90 year old farmer and I don’t think he is going to ever be “hip” and that makes me feel good
July 29, 2024 @ 4:59 am
In the end, most artists are in it for the money and fame.
July 29, 2024 @ 5:33 am
thanks for the post. i never would have otherwise bumped into this performance. it must have been an absolute blast to have been there.
July 29, 2024 @ 5:49 am
I took my wife to see J Timberlake at Rupp earlier this month (her birthday). I was hoping C Stapleton would make an appearance. Came away a little disappointed when he didn’t.
July 29, 2024 @ 7:23 am
Maybe next time, Jeff 😉
July 29, 2024 @ 6:42 am
Does it mean nothing to anybody that the crowd was belting every word?
At a pop show, of all places.
This is proof that one can like both things. There are plenty of great pop artists out there. I’m not familiar with Rodrigo beyond her name, but this collaboration was awesome in so many ways.
Chris Stapleton has had at least 2 killer live collabs with pop artists in Justin Timberlake and, more recently, Dua Lipa.
If done without nefarious intention, these can be really great for country music.
July 29, 2024 @ 7:25 am
This is too cool, I’m just grateful for Trig for writing the article so I could listen to the audio. Pretty awesome seeing a sold out arena of pop fans know every word to “All Your’n”, and really cool of Olivia to care enough to do it.
My favorite part was the quite audible “holy sh*t!” from a male fan when Tyler’s name was finally mentioned; that dude probably got dragged there by his girlfriend, thought he was gonna listen to nothing but pop music for 2.5 hours, and then TC walks out onstage. 😀
July 29, 2024 @ 7:47 am
I’m not sure this would have been on SCM and/or on my radar. “silver lining” that folks made a stink about it.
It is really wonderful and so good to see art unifying across genre & generations celebrating our shared human experience & humanity.😁
We have more in common than not. 🛐❤️☮️✝️
July 29, 2024 @ 8:00 am
I’m not saying “thumbs up” or “thumbs down.” All I’m saying: I hear syllable rhythm like “I Shall Be Released” and verse to chorus contrast like “I Shall Be Released”
yes I’m way out of the demographic and wouldn’t know Olivia Rodrigo from Dua Lipa 🙂
July 29, 2024 @ 10:37 am
People mad about those are going to be even madder when they realize their favorite artist listens to different genres of music besides their own
July 29, 2024 @ 2:19 pm
I just got back from a cross country road trip with teenage daughters and nieces. I hate pop, but listened to so much Olivia Rodrigo and Noah Kahon that I have to admit it’s not bad. We listened/ sang along to lots of Tyler Childer too.
July 29, 2024 @ 2:33 pm
Country music has always been a musical stew. Didn’t Jimmie Rodgers collaborate with Louis Armstrong on Blue Yodel #9? Oh yes he did! Charlie Rich didn’t start out doing country and neither did The Killer. Sounds like a slow news day.
July 29, 2024 @ 3:16 pm
They did a pretty good job of that.
I hadn’t heard of Olivia Rodrigo before (showing my age there, no doubt). Sings quite well and she looks gorgeous, although I guess that’s a prerequisite for any popstar.
July 29, 2024 @ 4:56 pm
Olivia has broad musical interest including country. She said as a kid at one point she was a ‘country bumkin’. When she has done invited duets, they have al all been with artists twice her age. She really likes Noah Kahan. And they covered each others songs. I am happy to hear if some are taking country back to its roots. — Especially Blue Grass … I have long loved Doc Watson.
July 29, 2024 @ 5:56 pm
Olivia rodrigo singing with Tyler. Country music really is on the up and up will this be sustianable though trigger
July 29, 2024 @ 6:21 pm
The first thing that happens before a fall is the super hot emphasis on something that outpaces it’s actual worth. I think this is a very real concern with so many pop stars “going country.” But I don’t think this one-off collaboration has anything to do with that.
July 30, 2024 @ 9:02 am
Good for music. Good for both acts. It is a win win for all. There have been many collaborations between country and non-country singers over the years. Some very good.
July 30, 2024 @ 12:22 pm
Looking up Oliva Rodrigo, for a young artist she has accomplished a lot. She has invited folks like Sheryl Crow, Jewel, Noah Kahan, and Tyler Childers on tour. She performed with Billy Joel at MSG and covered Carly Simon at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. I have no issues with Tyler being a guest at her show. They could be friends. Overall, I like seeing the mutual respect between musicians especially in different genres.
August 1, 2024 @ 11:26 am
I’ve got news for the crotchety old bastards. My 16 year old is listening to both of these artists and Zach Bryan and Noah Kahn and Taylor Swift and Ice Spice. She’s all over the place with her listening and it sounds as if this audience is too. The beauty of Spotify and Apple Music is your exposure to all genres is so much more today.
August 11, 2024 @ 11:48 am
Music is like food, the kind you like and the kind you don’t.
The main bitch country fans have is when they are trying to sell us horse shit that we know isn’t country.
This was just a cool collaboration it seems and everyone at her show knew all the words, so good on them for doing something cool.