Reflecting on the 2022 Country Music Hall of Fame Class
The Country Music Association announced the 2022 Country Music Hall of Fame inductees on Tuesday, May 17th, with Keith Whitley receiving the honor in the Modern Era category, Jerry Lee Lewis getting the honor in the Veteran’s Era category, and long-time RCA executive Joe Galante being inducted in the non-performer category, which rotates with songwriters and musicians every 3rd year.
You have to be happy with this class overall. Certainly, you can look over the elongated list of other potential inductees that grows even longer every year due to the Hall of Fame’s austere approach to induction, and do a healthy level of second guessing. But if Jerry Lee Lewis was getting in eventually (and he was), better to do it when he is still around. Unfortunately, we’ve seen too many inductees and potential inductees pass before they’re able to enjoy the distinction in person.
And sure, Keith Whitley doesn’t come with the gaudy numbers of many other Hall of Fame-caliber performers. But as was expressed by Kix Brooks of Brooks & Dunn who presided over the press conference, it’s what Keith Whitley did in those four years before his death in 1989, and the influence that he left that makes him a Hall of Famer. It’s also important to remember his career in bluegrass in the service of Ralph Stanley and JD Crowe before he ever became a solo performer when regarding the full scope of his career.
In regards to the non-performer category, you knew it was going to be some label executive deeply connected to the Country Music Association walking away with the distinction as opposed to someone such as clothier Nudie Cohn, or journalist Chet Flippo, all of whom would mean much more to the country music public at large.
It’s not that Joe Galante doesn’t come with a rather remarkable list of accomplishments in his executive career. At RCA, he helped launch and foster the careers of Hall of Famers like Waylon Jennings, Dolly Parton, Alabama, Vince Gill, The Judds, as well as future Hall of Famers Clint Black and Miranda Lambert among others. But as Joe Galante admitted himself in his acceptance speech, “I came down here with no background in country music. I was blessed with a lot of people that helped me along the way. They showed me how the town worked, and what country music was about.”
One of the people Joe Galante mentioned as helping him was Irving Waugh, who some hypothesized might be this year’s non-performer inductee. Unlike Galante, Irving Waugh knew country music backwards and forwards, and from the beginning. It was in his blood. He’d started at WSM radio in the 40’s, and eventually transitioned to the CMA where he was instrumental to bringing country music to television. Waugh was the executive producer of the CMA Awards until 1993, and there is a special CMA Award named after him specifically, even though he’s not in the Hall of Fame.
But there could have been worse picks than Joe Galante. Mike Curb of Curb Records was another rumored name. With his rap sheet of offenses against artists, that would have been a catastrophe. Joe Galante may not be an exciting name to many country fans, but the stories of him running afoul of artists or sticking his foot in his mouth like Sony Nashville’s Gary Overton are slim. In his autobiography, Waylon said about Galante, “…he was one of the only executives that was ever straight with me at RCA.”
Still, when people trek to the Hall of Fame and look at the plaques on the wall and wonder why Tanya Tucker, Dwight Yoakam, Trisha Yearwood, Clint Black, The Stanley Brothers, Linda Ronstadt, and so many others are still not there, but they see a plaque for an industry insider they’ve likely never heard of named Joe Galante, it’ll be a head scratcher for sure.
It’s not Joe Galante, though, that is stirring some controversy. It’s the election of Jerry Lee Lewis. And it probably deserves some. The character of these candidates should be scrutinized, we should be out in the open about transgressions, and present these blemishes along with the accolades for these artists, as Saving Country Music and much of the rest of the media did when discussing the Jerry Lee Lewis legacy.
Still, inducting Jerry Lee Lewis into the Hall of Fame makes for an easy target.
“The fact that Jerry Lee Lewis’s many disturbing misgivings were overlooked to give him the highest honor in country music says all to know about the CMA voting block behind this decision,” says journalist and professor Amanda Marie Martinez, who has taught classes on country history. “These folks would rather die on the hill supporting [Jerry Lee Lewis] than any Black/Brown artist or woman.”
But nobody is “overlooking” Jerry Lee Lewis’s disturbing behavior. Going solely off of his importance to the country genre, Jerry Lee Lewis should have been inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame 25 years ago. The only reason that he wasn’t is because of his disturbing behavior.
The Hall of Fame waited until basically the very last possible moment to induct the 86-year-old while he’s still living. It’s fair to point out that Jerry Lee Lewis also paid with both his popularity and his prominence in music in the era when he engaged in questionable behavior. And now that he is finally being honored, it’s not because he exemplified sterling character, but for his musical contributions that are indelible to American music, and country music specifically.
When Amanda Marie Martinez says, “These folks would rather die on the hill supporting [Jerry Lee Lewis] than any Black/Brown artist or woman,” this is misleading, and lacking context.
The “any” is key here, because it’s patently false, and actively participates in the erasure of the legacies of the women, and the Black and Brown people that have been honored by the Hall of Fame. This month, on May 1st—just two weeks ago—Naomi Judd and Wynonna Judd, along with Ray Charles, were formally inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame in the latest Medallion Ceremony. They were also inducted before Jerry Lee Lewis.
To characterize that the Hall of Fame inductors would rather “die on the hill” of inducting white males when we’re less than a month removed from the induction of The Judds and Ray Charles exemplifies how some of the of the intellectuals and journalists who are primarily interested in country music for the political implications are acting in bad faith, and are more responsible for erasing contributions of women and minorities to push a slanted narrative than celebrating their achievements. They are the ones who are truly hyper focused on gender and race, often to sow social capital in academia.
They are also overlooking what might be the most important takeaway from the entirety of the 2022 Country Music Hall of Fame induction class. Some would have you believe that these inductions were for white men, by white men, affirming the white male dominance over country music. But along with a woman in the CMA’s CEO Sarah Trahern presiding over the process, it was a country music woman that was the linchpin to the 2022 Hall of Fame class.
Keith Whitley got into the Country Music Hall of Fame from his own merits. But few if any would argue that he would have never even been considered if it wasn’t for the work of Lorrie Morgan. It wasn’t a cabal of whites dudes making this decision to affirm their dominance, it was Lorrie Morgan’s dogged determination over many years, lobbying hard for her former husband, both in the public and behind-the-scenes, that finally made this happen.
This was Lorrie Morgan keeping her promise to make sure Keith Whitley’s legacy is never forgotten. It’s truly a touching, inspiring story in country music, and it’s one that deserves to be told. And if you want to know more about Lorrie Morgan and Keith Whitley’s relationship—and what lengths Morgan went through to keep Keith alive as long as she did—check out Episode 5 of Country History X.
Lobbying for diversity in the Country Music Hall of Fame is a noble cause. Characterizing that the Country Music Hall of Fame is purposely avoiding inducting individuals solely due to race and sex is a gross oversimplification of the issue that only tunes people out, and unnecessarily politicizes and polarizes the issue.
Besides, with Jerry Lee Lewis now in, it means there is a very good chance Tanya Tucker is the 2023 Veteran’s Era Hall of Fame inductee, with Linda Ronstadt and her Hispanic heritage also on the short list, along with Crystal Gayle. And with Keith Whitley out of the way in the Modern Era category, it means the women of 80s and 90s country such as Trisha Yearwood, Martina McBride, Shania Twain, Patty Loveless, and maybe Lorrie Morgan herself will have an opportunity in the coming years.
And if there’s somebody specific that you think deserves to be in the Hall of Fame, or a certain group of entertainers you want to see better represented, you can grouse on social media, or you can do something about it. Start a petition, or sign a petition. If you’re in the media, lobby for those who you believe should be in with strong arguments for them, not just conspiracy theories of why the CMA is against them. The nature of the Country Music Hall of Fame is that everyone feels their favorites are being excluded, and the only way anyone gets in is with a significant, organized push, like Lorrie Morgan just accomplished.
This is because there are just not enough people per year being inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame to keep up with the names that deserve it. That’s a concern we should all be able to get behind, and would solve a host of problems—including the ones concerned with diversity—if it was finally addressed by the institution.
Terry
May 18, 2022 @ 8:52 am
Great thoughts Trigger. The backlog of quality candidates just seems to grow each year.
I know baseball started subgroups to help with their backlog to represent different eras, with the votes for not happening every year.
The CMHOF might benefit by having a Veterans Committee for pre 1950’s candidates, then 1950’s to the 2000’s, or expand the Modern category to two time periods.
Its funny because when you think about it, with all the great candidates, wouldn’t it be the best thing for the HOF to include a couple more names every year? Nobody would say its watering it down, rather inducting more worthy candidates.
Kevin Smith
May 18, 2022 @ 9:12 am
Great response Trig, to a typical ill- informed journalist looking to draw clickbait, and prosyletize. As for Jerry Lee, he was a bad boy. No doubt. Thats not news. But why exclude him? Is he really worse than so many others in the Country Hall of Fame, and Rock and Roll Hall of
Fame? Im thinking of Michael J, George Clinton, Chuck Berry, Phil Spector, James Brown, and on and on. All upstanding choir boys? Hardly. Hank Sr, Hank Jr, Hag, Cash, Lefty, Elvis, Faron Young, all had sketchy, shady things about them. Point is, its purely about their musical accomplishments, period. Never look too deep into your heroes, youll always be disappointed.
Eric
May 18, 2022 @ 9:30 am
Nothing irks these virtue signalling “journalists” like a meritocracy where people are rewarded based on their actual talent and contribution to the genre, as opposed to their allegiance to the modern cult of ideas.
RyanPD
May 18, 2022 @ 11:29 am
Michael Jackson was proven innocent.
Todd Peterson
May 18, 2022 @ 12:25 pm
Proven innocent? Sorry, Ryan, but that’s a huge stretch. That’s all I’ll say.
RyanPD
May 18, 2022 @ 12:37 pm
Elaborate, Todd.
Luckyoldsun
May 19, 2022 @ 12:03 pm
One of the arguments that Jackson’s sycophants made at the time was essentially that the kid had it coming because his parents allowed him to spend the night in the Great One’s bedroom. lol.
Eric
May 18, 2022 @ 9:23 am
If every other sentence out of someone’s mouth involves race, maybe it isn’t everyone else that is “racist” * cough* Amanda Marie Martinez *cough*
Trigger
May 18, 2022 @ 9:53 am
Look, I don’t want to make this all about bagging on Amanda Marie Martinez. She represents a much broader mindset in music. We have our opinions, they have theirs, and we can discuss them in a civil manner. This does illustrate how people both in the media and in academia love to selectively present facts that fit their agenda as opposed to the truth of the matter to let the public (or students) decide on their own. We all remember The Judds and Ray Charles were JUST inducted into the Hall of Fame. I mean, Naomi Judd committed suicide the day before. It was kind of a big deal, and a bit hard to brush under the rug. We also know there are other women and minorities in the Country Music Hall of Fame. Could there be more? Sure. But name them, and make a case for them. Don’t demean the contributions by acting like they’re only in there because they’re male and white, and shade out those that aren’t white and male that also made it in off of their merit.
If these people really want to advocate to get certain people in the Country Music Hall of Fame, they should take the time to understand the process, and how these three individuals were elected in 2022. That is why I broke it down in detail here. If you think this is simply white males affirming other white males because they want to keep the white male dominance in country music going, you’ve so grossly misdiagnosed the issue, and thus, you’ll never find the understanding of how to solve it in your favor.
Eric
May 18, 2022 @ 10:28 am
100% agree, and I applaud how well you constructed this article. My comment was not to take away from that, but to throw an insult at the small group of people hellbent on inserting race here.
Eric
May 18, 2022 @ 10:32 am
People like Amanda Marie Martinez really annoy me because they freely call everyone else racist, and when it’s pointed out how they themselves are being racist according to the dictionary definition of the word, well that’s not being civil.
I can’t think of another genre that has been as inclusive for women from day 1.
Di Harris
May 18, 2022 @ 9:25 am
Doesn’t hurt that Galante is mobbed up.
Trigger
May 18, 2022 @ 9:28 am
This would be a hell of a lot funnier if I wasn’t worried you actually believe this, Di.
Di Harris
May 18, 2022 @ 9:33 am
Oh, c’mon : D
Oh alright …. Will give props to Galante, for Waylon, alone …
Great job, Joe.
And, awesome on Jerry Lee Lewis, & Keity Whitley getting in.
MH
May 18, 2022 @ 9:34 am
“journalist and professor Amanda Marie Martinez”
“Journalist” and “Professor.”
That’s all you need to know.
Tony R
May 19, 2022 @ 2:45 pm
Can we please stop with the ad hominem approach to journalism and scholarship? It’s so boring. Being educated is not a bad thing, contrary to popular belief.
MH
May 22, 2022 @ 9:42 am
Judging by the shit churned out by the mainstream media and mainstream media wannabes as well as the shit born within the realm of higher education on a daily basis?
No, we can’t.
CountryKnight
August 2, 2022 @ 8:44 am
Except modern journalists and professors aren’t educated. They are indoctrinated.
David B
May 18, 2022 @ 10:54 am
Pioneer category is needed. Jerry Lee will likely be the last artist pre-1970 to ever get in if another special category is not added. Steve Wariner, The Gatlins, Roseanne Cash, and others who made big hits in the 80’s are all now eligible in the veterans category. The 90’s stars will dominate the modern era. CMA needs to wake up.
Robert's Country Blog
May 18, 2022 @ 11:25 am
I agree. The hall of fame began in the sixties, and very few of the early stars have been honored. The first artists to sing country on the radio, the first artists to make country records, and the first artists to have number one country hits when the charts began aren’t in. The whole thing is absurd.
robbushblog
May 18, 2022 @ 9:42 pm
Still waiting on Johnny Horton’s induction. I complain about it every year. Stonewall passed away without getting in. He and Mickey Gilley and the Osborne Brothers won’t be eligible next year either. Charlie Rich died about 27 years ago. And how do musicians get inducted, but Don Rich isn’t in yet? Tanya Tucker isn’t in yet. Lynn Anderson isn’t in. I think a year like 2001 is due, when 12 acts were all inducted together, including many all-time greats.
Angelo Ronaldi
May 18, 2022 @ 11:36 am
Maybe the backlog will eventually grow thinner. I don’t see the HOF risking their reputation by inducting Toby Keith and Kenny Chesney any time soon. Tim McGraw is the only “modern” superstar post-Garth who has some substance, but there are many black spots in his catalog too.
They really need to introduce a deceased category though
Mars3
May 18, 2022 @ 12:39 pm
Jerry Lee Lewis is on the short list of the greatest performers in American popular music, in any genre. He is as worthy as any artist currently in the Country Music HoF, and more deserving than many inducted before him. And that’s just the way it is.
Jack
May 18, 2022 @ 12:40 pm
To play devil’s advocate, I would like them to see perhaps an all-female year or I’d at least like a woman to be inducted next year. Considering how significant the contribution of women is to country music, I don’t necessarily think the HoF reflects this and I think that’s due to only 3 inductees being selected each year. There are only 23 women in the HoF (and that’s counting each person individually e.g. The Judds counts as 2) which seems insane.
I’m not saying that the men inducted aren’t worthy at all but I just think that if you knew nothing about country music and looked at the HoF, it doesn’t really represent the significant contributions of women to the genre (from 2000-2010, Emmylou Harris and Barbara Mandrell were the only women to be inducted).
Echoing the comments of the majority of fans, I would like to see some of these artists get their recognition while they’re still alive. People like Wanda Jackson, Jeannie Seely, Anne Murray, Jessi Colter, Tanya Tucker and Crystal Gayle should know how much we value their contributions before it’s too late and before they start getting overshadowed by the likes of Patty Loveless, Alison Krauss, Trisha Yearwood, Martina McBride, Pam Tillis and Shania Twain.
MH
May 18, 2022 @ 2:19 pm
“To play devil’s advocate, I would like them to see perhaps an all-female year or I’d at least like a woman to be inducted next year.”
Then you don’t want females inducted for their contributions to the genre.
You want them to be inducted because they have a vagina.
robbushblog
May 18, 2022 @ 9:19 pm
Who would that woman suggest be inducted who are people of color? Johnny Rodriguez, Freddy Fender, and…? There really haven’t been a whole lot of entertainers of color who are qualified to be inducted into the CMHoF. You can debate and/or ponder why that is, but it is. As far as I know, just one of my Hispanic friends listens to any country music at all, and she rarely strays from Elvis’s country stuff or Patsy Cline. I can’t think of a single black friend who listens to country music at all. It is music that is vastly and overwhelmingly performed by white people for a vastly and overwhelmingly white audience. So, again, who does she think should be in who is not, as far as people of color go?
Di Harris
May 18, 2022 @ 9:40 pm
This is pretty insulting – though i think you did not mean it to be.
There are a lot of black women, men, and families who listen to good country music.
Do you think black people do not enjoy listening to the Gaithers?
Do you think white people do not enjoy listening to outstanding black gospel?
Do you think white people do not enjoy R & B?
Not coming at you.
Just want you to think a little deeper
Jack W
May 19, 2022 @ 5:32 am
These are pretty much my sentiments. Even if one thinks that people of color have been actively kept of country music, the reality is that not many such artists have had a HOF worthy career. And even given that, the CM HOF just went outside the genre to honor Ray Charles because of his significant contribution to the genre in the early ’60s (and also maybe for political reasons). So they seem to be aware of the issue and did do something. This is a much more different issue than people of color not getting played on country radio in the present day. We can’t go back in time.
Brian B
May 20, 2022 @ 2:21 pm
But wasn’t Ray Charles inducted last year? I do believe so. And Charley Pride certainly should be there.
And then two female country-pop hybrids, Anne Murray and Linda Ronstadt, should also be there soon.
robbushblog
May 18, 2022 @ 10:31 pm
I was only speaking on a personal level, anecdotally. I know a lot of people where I live, and I just don’t know any of my local friends who are people of color who listen to country music. Hell, most of my white friends don’t even listen to it. The one Hispanic friend I mentioned lives 3000 miles away. Maybe people are more diverse listeners where you live. And to answer your questions:
I don’t know that anyone I know listens to the Gaithers.
I personally enjoy listening to outstanding black gospel.
I personally enjoy R&B (as long as it’s old).
Michelle
May 19, 2022 @ 12:23 am
Isn’t there a way to convince this secret cabal to expand the number of inductees? It’s patently ridiculous to limit the number to three. I honestly don’t get it. The R&R Hall of Fame inducted seven this year. I doubt that any of the inductees feel slighted because the group is too large. Country music has such a backlog of deserving artists that we won’t see some of them inducted until, say, 2098 (if then).
Robert Turner
May 19, 2022 @ 4:22 am
Here’s a few names that have been overlooked Johnny Paycheck , Wynn Stewart , Bob Mcdill, Gary Stewart, Moe Bandy and Gene Watson
Country-Bluegrass Fan
May 19, 2022 @ 6:30 am
Jessi Colter? Why? I like her but how many top tens and number ones did she have?
WuK
May 19, 2022 @ 10:43 am
An interesting and thought provoking article. Hard to disagree with this years inductees but there is always someone who has to bring in the race issue. Totally unjustified. Those that got it deserved it.
Jim
May 19, 2022 @ 5:47 pm
What is the criteria to be in the HOF?
Trigger
May 19, 2022 @ 5:51 pm
Here’s an article about the rules, at least as we know them:
https://savingcountrymusic.com/how-are-performers-elected-to-the-country-music-hall-of-fame/
Erik North
May 20, 2022 @ 7:24 am
I can’t complain about this year’s list of inductees myself, including Jerry Lee Lewis. What I do find amusing in a way is that The Killer’s biggest C&W hit was actually his torching, rocking version of “Chantilly Lace”, which I think spent six consecutive weeks at #1 on Billboard’s C&W singles chart in the spring of 1972, and narrowly missed going Top 40 on the pop chart. It was proof, along with such classic material as “What’s Made Milwaukee Famous” and “She Even Woke Me Up To Say Goodbye”, that he was not an artist you could ever mistake for anyone else, be it country or rock and roll.
In terms of the backlog that gets created by only letting in three acts total per year–as I’ve said before, there needs to be a Legacy/Pioneer category for those artists that have never been recognized, like the Maddox Brothers and Rose, and whose impact on, and furtherance of, the country music genre is absolute and easy to document. There are obviously tons of them out there that haven’t gotten the recognition they deserve, and this really needs to be rectified something fierce (IMHO).
NewEnglandCountryFan
May 21, 2022 @ 9:14 pm
It has to be Martina McBride in the Modern Era next year.
Blockman
May 31, 2022 @ 10:37 am
About fuckin time The Killer made it in. That string of records from late 60s into the 70s was unmatched. No one had the bravado that Jerry had since Hank and Jimmie before him. What a legend. One of the all time greatest. Period.