Song Review – Blake Shelton’s “Came Here To Forget”

What’s great about a sham celebrity marriage is that after you’ve worn all the tread off the tires by selling your wedding photos to grocery store rags, cutting sappy co-writes, and boring the masses with awards show duets, you can hit up everyone again as they head for the exits with post-Splitsville divorce records pitting the respective fan bases against each other as rumors of who did who wrong help stir the pot. It’s a great way to keep everyone focused on the cult of celebrity as opposed to the music, because in the end the songs are never that great.
Blake Shelton is first out of the gate in the post Blake/Miranda country music world with a song called “Came Here To Forget.” If nothing else, the title is promising, and the song is built upon a solid lyrical hook. Not entirely original, but not terribly bad, in the corporate country world where it’s eternally summer and most songs are about suds, pickups, and hot babes, a tune about a tear-soaked heartbreak is a welcomed change of scenery.
However, despite “Came Here To Forget” starting off with a solid foundation and premise, it’s all the garbage they use to fill in the gaps in a slipshod songwriting effort, and the terrible adult contemporary production that makes the song flimsy enough for the big bad wolf to blow down with one puff.
No different than the endless references to beer and backroads in modern country songs, so is this prevailing trend towards breakups where revenge is the best attitude to deal with the emotional letdown. We’ve also heard this in other recent big singles like Luke Bryan’s “Home Alone Tonight.” The heartbroken protagonist is so full of spite and self-aggrandization, the song becomes all about how it’s necessary to get back at an ex-lover instead of delving into the real emptiness of lost love where the deepest emotional impacts lie. The self-reflection that usually accompanies a breakup is replaced with revenge selfies with rebound lovers looking to scar an ex you previously deeply cared about.
The other constant in these spiteful breakup songs is how the perspective of the world is run through a 4 x 6-inch screen of a cell phone. Though it’s probably a pretty accurate portrayal of a modern corporate radio-listening robot, it still lacks the self-awareness and reflection that takes a breakup song from good to great.
“Go ahead and check your phone, like I’ve been checking mine. Nobody’s ex texting for a rewind,” says “Came Here To Forget.” What mundane details these are. It doesn’t make you commiserate with the subject of the song, it just reminds you they’re probably one of those assholes who holds their phone up to the stage during an 1 1/2-hour concert, blocking your view the entire time. Maybe your lover wouldn’t have left you if you spent less time with your mug buried in your phone screen.
Still, “Came Here To Forget” has some good lines. “Doing our best to make the best of the worst of it,” and others are not terrible, but others like “keep salting the rim” are squeezed in there to give mainstream listeners enough culture reference points so they don’t get lost in any lyrical depth. The timing of the delivery where Blake rushes to fit in words in that Max Martin-style hip-hop cadence make the listening experience that much more jarring for a country listener.
And that’s to say nothing of the production, which is so stylized and billowy, and relies on some sort of digitized whistle that sounds like it was lifted from Mike & The Mechanics’ “Silent Running” that it ruins the song if nothing else does. Blake Shelton said recently, “Country’s not always about exactly what you sound like, but it’s about what you want to represent with your music.” Blake tried to represent a classic country theme in “Came Here To Forget,” but it got lost in the production, and the filler between the song’s quality lines.
READ: Blake Shelton Advocates for the Protection and Exclusivity of Country Music
And what in the everloving hell did they do to Blake Shelton’s eyes in the artwork for this thing? It looks like he’s trying to burn a hole through the back of your skull. This decision in itself probably deserves a failing grade.
“Came Here To Forget” is not a terrible song. It’s a decent song that they made into a poor effort by taking a decent premise, loading it up with radio-friendly buzzwords, and stylizing it to the “Hot AC” crowd in the production. In other words, it’s destined to be a super hit on country radio.
1 1/2 of 2 Guns Down (3/10)
Songwriters: Craig Wiseman and Deric Ruttan.
March 8, 2016 @ 12:39 pm
Sorry to disagree, but I knew it was terrible at 20 seconds in.
March 24, 2016 @ 8:54 am
I can’t help but wonder if Blake’s HORRIBLE new song is some of Gwen’s influence….thankfully my office radio has a remote, I either mute it or quickly flip to another country station. I absolutely hate this song.
March 8, 2016 @ 12:43 pm
” Silent Running ” …..Right on Trigger .
I detested this from the first bar of FAKE music. Far too pseudo hip and far wordier than need be , as are most of these ridiculous contemporary songwriting attempts at conveying emotion in a lyric and melody. Guess what ….its WAY easier to do that than these writers seem to think . If they want to crawl through broken glass and barbed wire to get to the nut of a lyric ….fine ….but I’m not gonna follow them there . That said …this is a boring ‘song’ with no dynamics or semblance of near- memorable melody to even be talking about past this sentence .
March 8, 2016 @ 12:54 pm
Lost me at the beginning with the drum loop and cheesy computer sound in the background. It’s a shame because Blake actually is a very good singer. Waste of talent.
March 10, 2016 @ 10:59 pm
Completely agree. I can not even get through the song because of the sound and production.
March 8, 2016 @ 12:59 pm
Well, it sure is forgettable. Like “Neon Light,” a decent concept ruined by soulless pop production. Any effort at making a relatable song goes out the window if the music is so stylized it doesn’t make you FEEL anything.
(That caption on his picture though… hilarious!)
March 8, 2016 @ 1:08 pm
This recent spate of “revenge” songs is really bad. Our country gatekeeper Mr. Shelton should be well aware that puttin’ you down won’t square the deal.
March 9, 2016 @ 7:31 am
Very good! I didn’t fully appreciate the meaning of that line until now. Thanks!
March 8, 2016 @ 1:09 pm
Well well well hahaha. Almost in the same breath as he spoke about guarding the gates of country music, Blake tries to lay down a few hip hop style runs and lets the electro-drums ring lmao.
March 8, 2016 @ 1:15 pm
When I heard that awful Luke Bryan song about taking pictures of yourself I started punching the steering wheel uncontrollably. I just hate him so much
March 8, 2016 @ 1:27 pm
It’s a crappy pop country song for sure, but still better than most of what’s out there. Ya know, Blake actually has a pretty good voice. He’s in a different league than the Aldean’s and Bryan’s, in my opinion, it’s just his voice is wasted on his songs. His songs aren’t even AS bad as most of the bros and metro-bros. Why do a lot of “country” songs revolve around iPhones? Can’t get more “country” than that… It’s getting to the point where there’s no way they can possibly defend the countryness of their songs, yet the average Joe still doesn’t see it.
March 8, 2016 @ 1:52 pm
Depends on who you think the average Joe is. If it’s the average Joe country music fan, then he probably DOES see it and is no longer listening to country radio. If it is the average Joe country radio listener, then he probably doesn’t have a clue about what country music really is anyway.
March 8, 2016 @ 1:31 pm
It seems that most country ballads these days feature production that is basically mid 00s adult contemporary with little bits of sterile R&B bass stutters. It really kills most ballads for me.
It sounds like if The Calling or Lifehouse decided to try to appeal to the R&B listeners of 2001. But then threw in some pointless references to beer and whiskey, a picture message on a cell phone and an old bar.
March 8, 2016 @ 1:55 pm
Blake can sing but for some reason doesn’t on this song? It is like he wants to get Gwen fans to buy the single so made a non country tune. Also there are like 3 lines repeated over and over, not very deep for “the song that best represents my life more than any other song I’ve release” like Blake has stated. It will be #1 w/ of the Warner radio/soccer Mom hook up. I agree he looks weird on the picture they released. Everything about this is fake- picture/Song vocals. Was expecting a deeper song but who was I kidding that was like Blake 4 TV seasons ago.
March 8, 2016 @ 2:11 pm
It’s the rat race for country radio, & it sort of stinks. The studio’s choose the single’s and they’re clearly gunning for another #1 & as a result playing it safe.
Just a guess, this one wasn’t Blake’s choice as single a)mostly bc it was recorded in Feb 2nd & Blake had talked in interviews this past fall about releasing a single in Jan. and b) he keeps saying he actually wrote for this record & then the first single was written by someone else. But again, studio clearly wanted to play it safe.
Interestingly on pre show for his tour Blake has been playing Sangria acoustic, could see this song getting the same treatment.
I don’t think Blake is really bro-country in same vein as some of the other big names out there & most of his catalog is ballads, but him/his studio are clearly more concerned about mainstream radio success than taking a risk. Will be interesting to see what rest of record contains.
March 8, 2016 @ 2:16 pm
You hit it right on the head with the thematic comparison to Luke Bryan & Karen Fairchild’s recent hit, “Home Alone Tonight”.
The incessant immaturity on behalf of all these A and B-list entertainers from a songwriting standpoint as of late is absolutely incredible. Why is there even a motive to “get even with” while drinking away heartbreak at a bar? GET OVER IT ALREADY! It leaves me wondering if all these songwriters and the respective narrators indeed are diagnosed with Narcissistic Personality Disorder in real life and, much like Donald Trump, will still be brooding over the same sore punchlines three decades from now and are no less litigious in their temperaments.
If this is intended to serve as “a direct look into his life”, then I’m not sure I want to look any further. How is this interesting? How is this inspiring? Why would I want to relate to a a character whose motivation is vengeful as opposed to either diverting his attention elsewhere or mediating the conflict? Granted it might still be a rung above the likes of Old Dominion’s “Break Up With Him”, but that’s not saying much at all.
*
And now, when considering the production, Shelton’s remarks on “The Voice” while arguing with Adam Levine just ring more hollow today.
This song ALSO shares the DNA of “Home Alone Tonight” when it comes to relying on synthetic hip-hop informed drum loops and synthesizers. If anything, it even seems like a regression from “Neon Light” in that, as marred by compromising synthetic production as it was, nonetheless featured some organic country instrumentation. Here, there is no semblance of such instrumentation. Instead, you have a cross between the watery guitars of “Sangria” with the droning spaciness of “Gonna Wanna Tonight”…………………..which just makes for an uninspiring, forgettable track all around.
*
Is this as bad as, say, “Boys ‘Round Here”?
Well, it certainly doesn’t insult your intelligence like that song does. But honestly, I’m finding it hard to decide which is worse because as obnoxious as “Boys ‘Round Here” was………………..he still sold it with a smirk and had ample charisma to at least try and back it up. Sure, it still sucked badly………………..but there can be a case to be made that he was winking as he offered that abomination.
Here, it’s just an all-around unsettling kind of obnoxiousness. The kind of obnoxiousness that isn’t fun at all and basically screams for sympathy when it isn’t deserved whatsoever. And I’d dare argue that’s worse than merely singing an over-the-top stupid sing-along song.
Yeah, I don’t particularly like this one bit. I’m thinking a Light to Decent 2 out of 10 for this.
March 8, 2016 @ 6:53 pm
“The incessant immaturity on behalf of all these A and B-list entertainers…..”.
I stopped there with your quote Nadia because I believe all of this immaturity is on purpose in an effort to appeal to a very young ( immature ) demographic who might find this kind of spoon-fed lyric ” deep ” and possibly relate able due to their youthful inexperience .No excuse for outright pandering , though . These ” artists” need to sing something age-appropriate if they are ever to be taken seriously ….although that ship has pretty much sailed for most of them .
March 8, 2016 @ 3:07 pm
To be honest, I myself have a hard time forgiving and forgetting, and I often have a vengeful mindset. Does that make me narcissistic? BTW I am majoring in psychology, so I know what Narcissitic Personality Disorder really is. No, but I can relate to the guy in the song. You can NEVER tell somebody to get over it. They have to get there on their own, and that may take a while. And sometimes a little payback is warranted. Pop country sucks though.
P.S. Nobody besides white, sexist racists will vote for Trump. There aren’t enough of those to win him the Presidency. Vote for Hillary, so America will stop being so sexist and start paying women the same as men.
March 8, 2016 @ 5:20 pm
WHY is payback warranted when we take lyrics like these, or those of “Home Alone Tonight”, “Redneck Crazy”, “Before He Cheats”, etc………………….at face value?
Are we supposed to just assume that the worst-case scenario in every one of those instances? That perhaps the ex was physically and emotionally abusive toward the narrator?
We don’t know. It’s never made clear what justifies such vengeful temptations. At any rate, I just consider revenge a childish resort in the vast majority of instances. It should only be called upon when your life is in danger or that of your loved ones, or a small handful of other extreme circumstances.
And I know, technically, the narrator doesn’t act upon his vengeful desires in the course of this song………………but then again, with the lazy delivery and tepid production…………I’m left unconvinced it was anything particularly cold.
*
I was hesitant about citing Donald Trump here anecdotally, but decided to because regardless of one’s political leanings, he just smacks as the archetypal advanced case of Narcissistic Personality Disorder when considering accounts like that of his thirty-year old feud with the editors of Spy Magazine regarding the size of his hands.
I mean, it just seems like quite a handful of songs being serviced to country radio over these past four years are rife with similar pathological undertones. “Redneck Crazy” takes the cake, but there’s plenty other examples as well. And then there are songs like this one where that may not be the case, but the narrator just comes across as utterly childish rather than a reasoned adult taking a more nuanced reflection on the failed relationship and where he may have went wrong himself.
February 19, 2020 @ 7:18 pm
So wrong, Kale.
Haha.
March 8, 2016 @ 3:10 pm
I’ve got no love at all for Blake Shelton, but I was willing to extend him a little good will if he really meant what he said on The Voice. Then I heard this song on the radio today. Obviously he was just talking out of his ass with that quote. Which just makes him that much worse than if he never said anything at all.
Incidentally, I also heard that new Dierks Benley single for the first time today. I nearly cried. What the ever loving fuck, Dierks bentley?
Fortunately I spent the rest of the afternoon listening to Jason Isbell. 🙂
March 8, 2016 @ 8:36 pm
Yep, I never thought I’d turn off a Dierks Bentley song on the radio. I was wrong. 🙁
And this song, I agree, Trigger, it had a chance to go somewhere … but didn’t. It could have been country … but isn’t. I could have left it on when I heard it on the radio more than once … but didn’t. 🙁
March 10, 2016 @ 4:00 pm
Dierks too? I thought he would be one of my last holdouts. Oh well.
March 8, 2016 @ 3:25 pm
Somebody needs to play his first album back to him and maybe he might realize his younger self was more country than this bullshit
March 8, 2016 @ 3:34 pm
It sucks. Blake Shelton is the most overrated country singer of my lifetime. He has maybe four quality songs in his decade long career, which is the same amount of hits a star should have on one CD. All of his songs sound the same and yet he wins all of the awards and is the face of our genre on TV. What the hell?
And if anyone things he did more on Lambert’s award-winning “Over You” than type her lyrics into a computer, you’re pretty naive.
March 8, 2016 @ 4:33 pm
Craig Wiseman has certainly taken a swan dive into a huge vat of shit, hasn’t he?
March 8, 2016 @ 7:01 pm
Man you can say that again MH
March 8, 2016 @ 4:47 pm
I Came Here To Forget…….. that I haven’t had a decent song since at least 2008 – Blake Shelton quote.
March 8, 2016 @ 6:06 pm
This song sucks
March 8, 2016 @ 10:26 pm
Yikes thought the creepy pic of him was the worst of it & then I listened to this song. Is it a song w/ like just a sentence or 2 in rotation? It is clear to see that they put this out in hopes of getting all genre interest b/c of the “NEW” old couple Shelton/Stefani. I mean pandering at its worst but like stated above Warner is putting lots of $ into promoting so it will be #1. Another fluff song long forgotten. Blake has enough star power you would think they could dig a little deeper but can’t risk the #1 at radio streak!
March 9, 2016 @ 5:28 am
I have been amazed that Saving Country Music hasn’t said a word about the new albums from Gene Watson and Loretta Lynn. Both are excellent, from two artists who have been around for years and have never strayed from their original style of music, unlike Shelton, who began as a traditionalist but is now FAR from it. Watson’s new album is titled Real. Country. Music. and is just that, pure and true to form. Loretta’s album is a revelation as well, her first in 12 years, offering bang-up new versions of some of her iconic songs as well as excellent new material. A site that purports to “saving country music” should realize that not all real country music is or should be made by young artists.
March 9, 2016 @ 11:04 am
Glenn,
I appreciate your concerns and feedback. Gene Watson’s and Loretta Lynn’s albums are obviously both on my radar, and I have not ruled out reviewing both records. However it is not true that Saving Country Music hasn’t said a word about them. Both records were featured in my 2016 preview of upcoming records:
https://savingcountrymusic.com/facts-rumors-the-albums-to-look-forward-to-in-2016/
I also did dedicated articles about Loretta Lynn signing to Sony:
https://savingcountrymusic.com/loretta-lynn-signs-with-sony-new-album-on-the-way/
And the announcement of “Full Circle” and the PBS Special:
https://savingcountrymusic.com/loretta-lynn-announces-new-album-full-circle/
I also promoted the PBS special through social media last week.
All that said, I take issue with your concern, “not all real country music is or should be made by young artists.” I feature older artists all the time. I posted a review for Willie Nelson’s latest record, and guess what, it was the least-read article on this site in the last two months. Why? Because in the end, nobody wants to read these articles. I still write them, and I will always write them, but despite comments like yours that I see all the time, nobody reads these articles. People just want to know they’re there, an have their opinions reinforced. But nobody likes or shares them on Facebook so nobody sees it, resulting in the misconception that I don’t even comment on the albums, when in truth I’ve spent hours covering them in dedicated articles, just like Loretta Lynn’s album.
The reason I cover younger artists is because if I don’t, NOBODY will. Loretta Lynn had an entire PBS special to support her release, and tons of press. But who is going to write about Dori Freeman if I don’t? Actually, a ton of people are writing about Dori Freeman now, but it took that first spark of interest to start the fire. I’d rather give press to someone who has none of it, than write about someone everybody already knows about.
All that said, I still do plan to cover as many albums as I can from people like Gene Watson and Loretta Lynn. But please don’t think just because I wrote about Blake Shelton means I DIDN’T write about somebody else. That is never the case. I write about whatever I am passionate about at any given moment.
Thanks again for the criticism, and I hope this explanation makes sense.
March 10, 2016 @ 6:14 am
Thanks for the reply, Trigger, I really do appreciate it. I had read your previews of both albums back then, they got me really excited for the new music from these two great artists. When I attended a Gene Watson concert a couple months ago, he mentioned that he had the new album coming out and got a great round of applause in response. He was effusive in thanking the audience for coming to his shows and still buying his music. Real genuine appreciation, I like that.
When I heard Loretta’s album I was blown away. Yes, at 83 her voice is showing age, but she is adapting well while still keeping her style intact.
Thanks for all the work you do on the site, we all appreciate it very much.
March 9, 2016 @ 9:43 am
Holy crap I think there was less photoshop and CGI in the transformers movies than that album cover.
March 9, 2016 @ 10:28 am
Yet another weak-sauce effort from Shelton. I think “Sangria” was significantly better than this.
It took me a minute to figure it out, but Blake’s look in that cover is creepily reminiscent of the late Paul Walker….
March 9, 2016 @ 12:48 pm
I like what Dolly said. She’s so diplomatic and careful not to offend. That’s an art.
Dolly said she likes all three of them very much.
That said. I don’t want to see nude (KK) selfies or hear such literal takes on who was at fault and the ole back and forth. I don’t . I would rather hear a song that I can get lost in and think about my life or someone I know. I want a song that weaves a story about me or anyone I know.
I want to hear Go Rest High on That Mountain, Coat of Many Colors and bawl my eyes out. I want a song that will take me right back to the position in the floor I was standing when I first heard it…or where I was on the road.
This won’t do it. All I’ll be able to think about is the tabloid bashing. I’ll remember M’s sad face up on the stage accepting an award. It will make my stomach churn with their miseries. I don’t want to remember all of that.
I want a song like All My Ex’s Live in Texas.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jk7uXaNuWNE
We know you got Ex’s but we don’t want their noses rubbed in it. We want something that makes us think about ex’s without besmirching them in any way. We don’t want to be left with a bad taste in our mouth.
We want both of you to take the higher road and let us continue liking both of you like Dolly does. Be the VOICE of reason. I don’t want to surmise who’s really at fault.
That is all.
March 9, 2016 @ 7:52 pm
Good stuff. I dig it.
March 10, 2016 @ 12:59 pm
Hey, Sign Guy Dudley! What, that “Lou E. Dangerously” character didn’t pan out for you?
March 10, 2016 @ 3:52 pm
Well, I will admit that I haven’t listened to this song yet. I did read the lyrics. They’re ok. I agree with others that they are too close to other songs out on the radio (Luke’s). I’m stalling on listening to the music on this one. Like others have said, it probably sounds too pop oriented, and over produced. Sigh. I don’t know about this song, but I’m pretty sure the duet he and Gwen are going to put out will be a complete horror. The marriage of Interscope (puke, they’re the WORST), and Warner group, can’t be good for country. Although the song will be a corporate label’s wet dream. Watered down pop and watered down country, able to be in BOTH markets at the same time! I will probably put off listening to that one indefinitely.
April 8, 2016 @ 8:17 am
Sorry all you haters… love the song!
June 5, 2016 @ 9:39 am
Nice article. I’m definitely not a country music fan although I did grow up in the 70s watching a lot of Hee Haw and enjoying much of the country hits on the radio during that era. I also bought a Garth Brooks album or two in the nineties. If it’s good and I like it I’ll listen whether it’s country or something else. My wife however listens to country all the time and it drives me out of my mind when were in the car. if any progress has been made against the usual redneck country music stereotypes in the last couple of decades it’s all been ruined now. Every song I hear is about getting drunk or getting laid or pay back or whatever, it’s shallow, it’s ridiculous, it’s pathetic. Came here to forget sounds like a rap, he’s not really singing he’s talking. The country music industry along with the rock and roll music industry have basically streamlined commercialism to the point that it makes me want to puke. I wish a big hole in the ground would just open up and swallow all of the industry decision-makers who are guilty of taking part in this so we can start all over again. From the unoriginal trend-shallow lyrics to the photo-edited album covers these people are so far gone they couldn’t find their way back if they had to it. They’ve destroyed the music industry because of money. The saddest part is the younger ones growing up today, this is all they know. They have no reference point when music was actually good unless their parents are turning them on to it.