Sturgill Simpson, Margo Price Being Officially Considered for CMA Award Nominations
There’s still a long way to go, and a greater than average chance that he won’t make it into the final field of official nominees—let alone win anything—but Sturgill Simpson is currently in the running and being voted on by members of the Country Music Association for three of the 50th Anniversary presentation’s biggest prizes: Album of the Year, Male Vocalist of the Year, and New Artist of the Year.
Also surprising since she’s not on a major label, Margo Price has made the top 20 females being considered for Female Vocalist of the Year.
Just to make it this far feels like a coup d’etat whether Sturgill or Margo make it any closer. Currently the field of nominees for each award has been narrowed down to about 20 or so artists, songs, or albums in the respective categories. And before you say it would never happen, appreciate that last year at the CMA Awards, Chris Stapleton shocked everyone by getting nominated, and sweeping all three of the same distinctions that Sturgill Simpson is being considered for now, bolstered by the fact that Stapleton was the artist that all the voters were actually listening to instead of relying on sales numbers or some popularity contest to choose the winner.
Sturgill Simpson’s surprising showing in early CMA consideration has likely been the outcome of signing to Atlantic Records before releasing A Sailor’s Guide to Earth. Atlantic is part of the Warner Music Group, and has clout at these award shows. It has also been made possible by Sturgill Simpson’s perseverance in his career and the massive grassroots appeal for his music that he has cultivated with hard touring and critically-acclaimed albums. And just like Chris Stapleton, Sturgill has the respect of his peers—something that helped push Stapleton over the top. Keith Urban, Jake Owen, and others have publicly touted their love for Sturgill’s Music, and Zac Brown took Sturgill out on tour.
And not to get too ahead of ourselves, but if Sturgill Simpson or Margo Price end up being officially nominated, especially in Sturgill’s case since he’s up for multiple categories, they could also potentially be in the running for a performance slot on the awards November 2nd. All of this may seem implausible, but after Chris Stapleton’s implausible CMA’s and ACM’s during the last round of awards shows, who’s to say what could happen?
It all seems incredible for artists that a few short years ago were playing to small crowds in bar rooms. Sturgill Simpson’s first two records, released independently through Thirty Tigers, exploded onto the independent country scene, especially his second release Metamodern Sounds in Country Music which experienced a prolonged run popularity on its way to selling now nearly 200,000 copies. Even if Sturgill doesn’t get an official nomination for any of the awards, it’s still a feat to have come this far with no mainstream radio play. Same for Margo Price, who after spending years on Nashville’s bar circuit has seen multiple surprising opportunities, including playing Saturday Night Live and other late night shows around the release of her Third Man Records debut, Midwest Farmer’s Daughter.
And speaking of Chris Stapleton, his incredible run may still have some steam left. In early voting, Stapleton is being considered for the biggest distinction of the CMA’s: Entertainer of the Year. And with the year Stapleton has put together, especially in album sales, it’s not crazy to think he could end up in the final field. Stapleton is also being considered for Male Vocalist of the Year again, as well as Single of the Year for “Nobody to Blame.”
Other notable early nominee contenders include Album of the Year consideration for Brandy Clark’s Big Day in a Small Town and Jon Pardi’s California Sunrise, Brandy Clark and Jon Pardi for New Artist of the Year, Brandy Clark and Lee Ann Womack for Female Vocalist of the Year, the Randy Rogers Band for Vocal Group of the Year, and Joey + Rory for Vocal Duo of the Year. Eventually the fields of 20 will be pared down to the five official nominees.
Again, we are very early in the voting process and there is a chance none of the above highlighted artists make the final cut of nominees in favor of the same tired pop country names. But through the revelation of the first round finalists (which has not been made public in recent years), we’re finally starting to see where artists that worked their way up the ladder and are favored by the independent ranks are beginning to break through, even for the highest mainstream distinctions in the genre.
Parth Venkat
August 23, 2016 @ 6:56 pm
I know i’m way newer to Country music than most readers of this blog but it blows my mind that it’s a big deal that Sturgill is nominated … he should win Album of the Year easily … then again we live in a world where Blake beat out Kacey and Miranda won for Platinum, ugh
Jeremy
August 23, 2016 @ 10:15 pm
What is wrong with Platinum? It won every single country award possible. ACM, Grammy, CMA. It was on just about every prominent end of the year lists in 2014. It got rave reviews. It was her biggest debuting album. I have noticed a lot of animosity for Miranda on this site and I just don’t get it. In a genre of total shit lately, she is one of the few country artists that has the respect of the entire music industry.
Trigger
August 23, 2016 @ 10:20 pm
“I have noticed a lot of animosity for Miranda on this site and I just don’t get it.”
2/3’rds of it is from Blake Shelton sycophants and surrogates who only come here pointed by someone on social network to defend him and rip her.
Brian
August 24, 2016 @ 6:37 am
I don’t think that is necessarily true. I have never owned a Blake album and was once a huge fan of Miranda. I think the problem a lot of people have with Miranda is it just all became a little too much, especially with her winning all the awards non-stop and winning with average and below average material at times. These last 3 or 4 years she has just been winning everything and her material was not even close to being the best or deserving of winning the awards. If she would have kept putting out great material and winning, then I don’t think the backlash would have been near as critical. Sure she is better than the average bro-country, however I could argue a lot of her material of “blowing my boyfriends stuff up” that made her popular was following the same formula as a lot of those songs.
Parth Venkat
August 24, 2016 @ 8:24 am
I thought it was by far her worst record to date. I LOVE her earlier work (and other things she’s done more recently) and just found Platinum totally eh.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 9:19 am
On the last few articles here dealing with Blake Shelton or Miranda Lambert, there have been dedicated campaigns to come here, and attack me and Miranda on Twitter, using the fact that I mentioned Blake or Miranda to tee off. Trust me. Not saying that’s your motivation or any other dedicated readers. But if you’re now to this site, you might see these comments and wonder where all the Miranda hatred is coming from.
Bill Goodman
August 24, 2016 @ 1:54 pm
You should see some of the people that defend Blake on some of the mainstream country sites.
Fuzzy TwoShirts
August 24, 2016 @ 3:27 pm
“I have noticed a lot of animosity for Miranda on this site and I just don’t get it.”
“2/3’rds of it is from Blake Shelton sycophants and surrogates who only come here pointed by someone on social network to defend him and rip her. ”
actually the animosity comes from the fact that she is a one-trick pony rehashing the same brand of angry woman songs for nearing a decade and has no real singing ability and is completely outclassed by REAL musicians making REAL Country Music instead of her grass-roots-meets-Sugarland “at least its not Bro-Country” kind of bland filtered down “Country” music.
And the fact that she married, and therefore CONDONED Blake Shelton’s criticisms of us Old Farts.
She married him, and not only didn’t speak out, she’s practically encouraged his assaults on our Genre Identity.
Stringbuzz
August 25, 2016 @ 9:08 am
You are a trip!!
Parth Venkat
August 24, 2016 @ 8:39 am
Nothing was wrong it it per se just think this reviewer nailed it https://savingcountrymusic.com/album-review-miranda-lamberts-platinum/
It’s just nothing special (and I truly LOVE Miranda)
kiwicountry
August 24, 2016 @ 4:09 pm
I agree with Brian, I am not a Blake fan and I don’t hate Miranda at all, in fact I like her music. But its the fact she keeps winning the CMA FVOY award again, and again, and again, and again….. that has got a lot of fans of other female singers up in arms. Is she deserving of a nomination this year? I would say yes. Does she deserve to win? Defiantly not! There have been four other females this past year that I would say are more deserving of this award, Carrie Underwood comes to mind first (yes I am a Carrie fan as well) she has had an incredible year and worked her ass off which includes going to Europe and playing C2C, her massive tour, clothing line and going to fashion week, Sunday night football and so much more and all while raising a newborn. Forget FVOY give her a damn Olympic medal! She would be my number one pick for both FVOY and EOY. CAM had a great year and Burning House was one of the best country songs that I heard the past year. Maren Morris and Margo Price are my dark horses for this award. I would love to see either of them win because it wouldn’t be expected. But if 100% honest I’d just love to see someone other than Miranda win. Miranda has been a very deserving recipient of this award in the past but she is not the only female in country music that has a great voice, sound and has worked their butt off. It’s time that WME stopped pulling the strings and let some of the other artists get a look in. People are already starting to make comments about the voting. It’s not gone noticed how biased these awards have been.
Parth Venkat
August 23, 2016 @ 6:58 pm
Ha and we’re 5 years removed from this garbage group
Album of the Year 2011 Jason Aldean MY KINDA PARTY – Broken Bow
Album of the Year 2011 Blake Shelton ALL ABOUT TONIGHT – Warner Bros.
Album of the Year 2011 Taylor Swift SPEAK NOW – Big Machine
Album of the Year 2011 Brad Paisley THIS IS COUNTRY MUSIC – Arista
Album of the Year 2011 Zac Brown Band YOU GET WHAT YOU GIVE – Southern Ground/Atlantic
KC
August 23, 2016 @ 8:09 pm
I don’t see too much wrong with Paisley’s album or that one from ZBB.
Parth Venkat
August 23, 2016 @ 8:12 pm
I never listened to the Paisley disk and actually like the ZBB one a lot so touche
The Senator
August 24, 2016 @ 12:46 pm
Paisley’s album was enjoyable, I especially got a kick out of the instrumental with Clint Eastwood’s cameo.
Zac Brown Band was still worthwhile when they came out with You Get What You Give. Such a huge disappointment they went down the road they did as of late, I really talked them up in my circles back then.
The others on the list were not in my consideration.
Koozie
August 24, 2016 @ 8:34 pm
Totally true. ZBB was a very bright star for a while there, even if their stuff got a little beach at times. They had gorgeous, organic vocal harmonies with a simple approach that struck a serious nerve in a ton of country fans nationwide. It’s a shame they turned to utter shit.
Parth Venkat
August 24, 2016 @ 10:22 pm
yeah i got my years mixed up and thought that was their 3rd album which had some good tracks but was a big step down from one and two. Love me some colder weather and that cover of Oh My Sweet Carolina
Ben
August 23, 2016 @ 8:16 pm
Awesome. So well deserved and overdue. Let’s hope they can at least get in the final cut. My only complaint is Sturgill wasn’t nominated for album of the year with High Top Mountain.. That is still one of best SOLID country albums of the past several years….
Matt M.
August 23, 2016 @ 8:38 pm
I guess this is why Sturgill changed the lyrics to “Life Ain’t Fair and the World is Mean”.
seak05
August 23, 2016 @ 8:54 pm
I find Sturgill’s nominations highly ironic since in reality they’re all that’s wrong about the CMA’s..although his music is good. 1) He’s not a new artist 2) he’s spent half the year railing against the CMA’s 3) his album isn’t country (& yes this is true of most of the albums up for consideration, that doesn’t make it a good thing) 4) He’s getting considered because he’s with the right political group.
This was also true by the way of Chris last year, yes him winning was an upset, but he’s with WME, a non-WME artist winning would be a far greater upset.
Margo Price getting nominated is great. The fact that all 20 nominees in the musicians category are male is flat out terrible.
albert
August 23, 2016 @ 10:27 pm
I’m in complete agreement , seak . It’s almost like its suddenly hip to nominate what’s suddenly hip regardless of the ‘country’ factor .
Saying that ….points to CMA folks for at least recognizing honest artistic endeavor and actual talent
Tyler Pappas
August 24, 2016 @ 5:02 am
Remember way back in 2003 when Gary Allan was nominated for the horizon award (Best new artist) when his debut was in 1996.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 9:20 am
This has been going on for years. “New” means new to the mainstream, always has. I consider Sturgill Simpson a new artist, and I’ve been covering him longer than anyone.
Scott S.
August 23, 2016 @ 8:58 pm
Too bad Sturgel had to release a non country album to get nominated. And honestly, I feel he should have been in the running for his last two albums, but his latest isn’t the best country album this year in my opinion. But they never take my opinion into consideration.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 9:21 am
Sturgill didn’t release a non country album to get nominated. He release an album on a major label to get nominated.
Scott S.
August 24, 2016 @ 10:40 am
I didn’t mean that he released the album to get nominated, but that it is sad that the CMA is only now giving him recognition.
I’m sure Sturgel didn’t have awards shows on his mind when he decided the direction of his music.
Jt
August 23, 2016 @ 9:52 pm
Who cares? Dude just makes great music. Screw labels. Screw ‘country radio’ and Nashville execs. Sturgill, Isbell, Cody Canada, Reckless Kelly, the White Buffalo. These folks have proven you don’t need Nashville to make good living, through touring and grass roots fan bases, controlling your own career and make great music.
Texas music scene, independent artists, real musicians…
justin casey
August 23, 2016 @ 10:03 pm
if only cody jinks new one had come out earlier it probably would have been up for consideration too
Trigger
August 23, 2016 @ 10:20 pm
Cody Jinks may have just released his “High Top Mountain.” Keep an eye on him.
justin casey
August 23, 2016 @ 10:29 pm
couldn’t agree more took it on an hour drive through houston with my dad on monday and listened to it from start to finish and no one laid a hand on the radio the whole time (he brought cody to my attention) not sure if you saw but it debuted in the top 5 on the billboard country albums chart he already has a following but this may be the album that puts him on the map and makes those who haven’t heard him yet stop and take notice
James Hooker
August 24, 2016 @ 1:18 am
I’ll be voting (last minute) today. Whoopee!
Jacob Ware
August 24, 2016 @ 3:31 am
That’s cool. But sailor’s guide isn’t near as good as metamodern. Or some other albums released during this cycle. He should have won for metamodern, this would probably not be a good thing if he wins. Could set in motion a lot more expectations, don’t want it to effect the artistic integrity of his next album.
Biscuit
August 24, 2016 @ 4:35 am
Margo Price’s album is the best country album of the year so far, in my opinion. She and Jack White certainly are part of the Nashville scene. Both Sturgill and Robert Ellis released great albums too and should be recognized for their talent, not put on the fringes because their music isn’t Brad Paisley-type country music.
Erik North
August 24, 2016 @ 7:29 am
I’d even take it a step further and say that Margo’s is among the best albums of this year in any genre, hands down.
Jack Williams
August 25, 2016 @ 8:13 am
That’s an album I didn’t pick up initially as I wasn’t gung ho on what I heard initially. I did eventually pick it up and I thoroughly enjoy it now. Also, got a chance to see her live and thought she put on great show. I’d say on the level of Lindi Ortega, who I’ve seen 3 times and she killed each time. Got to meet Margo after the show and was impressed with how genuine she was and how she seemed to really enjoy talking to the fans.
Big Cat
August 24, 2016 @ 4:44 am
Wait, a week ago you said Sturgill moved on from country.
He deserves the recognition. Lot of hard work paying off for that man. Brilliant artist who stays out ahead of the pack even at the detriment of album sales; I respect him for that. Make no mistake SGTE is without doubt a country album. It might not be your version of traditional country but it his version.
Brent
August 24, 2016 @ 7:19 am
Agreed. Sturgill Simpson IS a country artist. It’s a part of him. e opens his mouth and country comes out. Make no mistake about it.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 9:26 am
“Wait, a week ago you said Sturgill moved on from country. “
I’m not sure what I said, but I didn’t say that.
I think I said in a comment that his sales have trailed off considerably because he walked away from his country fan base, which is true. Not sure what his CMA nominations have to do with this.
Big Cat
August 24, 2016 @ 10:05 am
Walked away, moved on. I consider those synonyms.
I also disagree with your take on his sales. SGTE sales are way ahead of where MMSCM were at the same point after release. Will they catch up? Maybe not. But to believe any act’s album sales should increase on every release is flawed in my opinion. His concert ticket sales continue to grow and thrive. There has been no falloff there.
I appreciate and respect artist who try something different even at the expense of critical commentary such as yours. Don’t get me wrong, I respect your opinion, but you are no more the gatekeeper of defining country music as any other fan out there. My personal taste really don’t give two shits what lable someone puts on music. I either like it or I don’t. The last thing any of us want is 100 guys/girls all doing the same thing. I believe people should appreciate someone like Simpson going outside the box.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 10:30 am
The difference from what you’re saying I said, and what I did say is that you seemed to imply there was a permanence to Sturgill leaving country. In this same comments section people are jumping my ass because if I was really Saving Country Music, I would never be happy that SGTE was nominated for a country award. Meanwhile I’m having to defend my opinions about Sturgill and SGTE, which remain positive on both fronts. That’s why I was in adulation over these nomination prospects and posted this article.
See, this is the perfect example of how Sturgill Simpson has become a polarizing character when before he was experiencing more universal acclaim. And sales for SGTE have fallen off sharply compared to Metamodern. Months after Metamodern it was still in the Top 20 on the albums charts. SGTE sold way more records out of the chute, but it has not experienced the same longevity. This is not my attempt to somehow criticize Strugill or downplay him, it’s just simply a numbers game. He’s no longer the “hot new thing” in country. This topic probably deserves its own dedicated article.
Big Cat
August 24, 2016 @ 12:23 pm
Well said and that’s my entire point….he’s no longer the “hot new thing” because HE decided HE wanted to do something different even at the expense and risk of previous success.
I bet if you poll other artist such a move gains more respect than any other action in the business…and takes major major balls.
All I’m saying is I commend the guy for taking that risk.
A.K.A. City
August 24, 2016 @ 5:50 am
Sturgill’s considerations may be more of a culmination of his work as opposed to Sailor’s Guide, specifically. It’s a good album, but I agree that it is not as outstanding as Metamodern (the album that officially made me a country fan). Any way, this is encouraging news… hopefully we see some SCM faves in the official nominations.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 9:27 am
“Sturgill’s considerations may be more of a culmination of his work as opposed to Sailor’s Guide, specifically.”
Exactly.
Not sure why so many feel ambitious to find the negativity in this news.
Brandon F
August 24, 2016 @ 5:54 am
You mention the possibility of a performance slot if he is nominated, but would Sturgill even show up? He’s never seemed to be a fan of the CMAs.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 9:28 am
Obviously they wouldn’t give him a performance slot if he didn’t want one. Would he show up to the awards? Good question. We’ll just have to see. But first he has to be officially nominated.
Eduardo Vargas
August 24, 2016 @ 6:02 am
We said the same thing a year back; that Chris Stapleton had no chance to win in the CMA Awards and he walked out with all of them; whose to say we won’t see Sturgill win at least one price?
John B
August 24, 2016 @ 6:38 am
Sturgill should have been the biggest “new” name in country music last year with the incredible momentum gained from the Metamodern Sounds sales and his (by all accounts) great live show. But nada. Nothing. Zip. Zilch from the mainstream “country” industry because he wasn’t signed with a big talent rep or on a major label. If was as if he didn’t exist. Now all the sudden he releases a, by his own admission, rock album and he’s up for three awards? Because he’s signed to a major label? Yeah, I’m inclined to agree with some of the folks commenting here. This is more an example of what wrong with the CMA (or any major music award group, really) than a sign their finally seeing the forest for the trees.
Kind of reminds me of when Guns N’ Roses quipped about getting an award for an album released two or three years prior during their acceptance speech.
Regardless, I’m happy for Sturgill that he’s finally getting some mainstream recognition within the industry.
Big Cat
August 24, 2016 @ 8:32 am
He’s never said it is rock album. He said in several interviews “I don’t even know if it will be considered country (anymore)”
Again, who gives a shit what it’s called. I just know it’s good….
and critically speaking, it’s considered very good.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 9:35 am
Signing to a major label no doubt helped Sturgill get this consideration. But let’s not act like it’s the only reason. It certainly isn’t the reason Margo Price, Randy Rogers Band, and Joey + Rory got nominated, because they’re not on major labels. The reason Sturgill was nominated is due to the culmination of his efforts over the past few years, including doing so well that he attracted a major label to his doorstep that was willing to give him a contract under his terms.
Cosmic Cowboy
August 24, 2016 @ 7:33 am
Stapleton sold out already. Head the tune Parachute on a truck commercial. To bad I had high hopes for the boy.
MH
August 24, 2016 @ 7:48 am
Did you say the same thing about Waylon and Willie when they starred in a Pizza Hut commercial in the 90s?
Cilla
August 24, 2016 @ 7:48 am
I am happy to see how the CMA’s are Trying to get it together when it comes to LOOKING at artists that CAN produce music for this genre. Strugill Simpson Deserves to be considered and Margo Price is really a talented artistes in this field. I say let’s give them all the mentions for their work,because the more the talk,the more for better music coming out of Nashville. Chris Stapleton opened doors…..now the Country music critics have a clear path to getting Country music FAR AWAY FROM BRO COUNTRY.
The less mention of Luke Bryan,Jason Aldean and FGL is a VERY GOOD THING! C’mon, think about last year and all the talk about Chris Stapleton,that brought a lot more listeners to check out his music and venture to what else artists like Jason Isbel (this,yrs Grammy winner) and
Strugill Simpon have to offer. It’s a step going in the right direction……as I have said,it’s going to take a good yr or two more for Pop County and BRO Country to fade. Its is now happening with recognizing artists like these for CMA AWARDS. The Bros are leaving …lets rejoice.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 9:32 am
Wow, someone actually deciding to see the positivity in this news as opposed to launching into conjecture and conspiracy theories of why to be negative.
Good music was just handed a gift. It may not be perfect, but let’s be happy.
Kevin Smith
August 24, 2016 @ 9:36 am
Sailors Guide to Earth is a fine album, sure. Yes he has a country twang in his voice and there is some steel guitar there, but calling it country per se is very debatable. It’s a rock oriented concept album. Fine…but does that make it a contender for CMA award? If you really care about Saving Country Music then his last album should have gotten the big awards. So, because they admittedly goofed and overlooked the last record they must atone and award his rock album?
That said, I believe his country sound will return in the future, it’s what he does best. Yes I agree with many here, who cares about CMAS and country radio anyhow. However, like many on this site, I like my country country and my rock , rock. Nothing wrong with some genre bending though….but don’t label something country that aint. No criticism on Sturgill, and I found it simultaneously awesome and ironic that some are saying he made them country fans. If that’s your case, then now you can have the pleasure of discovering Waylon, Willie, Johnny, Merle and the other greats.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 10:41 am
“If you really care about Saving Country Music then his last album should have gotten the big awards.”
Well of course it should have, but I don’t run the CMA. If it was up to me, yes, Metamodern Sounds would have won the CMA for Album of the Year. That’s why I named Metamodern Saving Country Music’s album of the year. But now I’m supposed to slam Sturgill’s album and instead throw my weight behind Dierks Bentley, Keith Urban, or Blake Shelton’s new albums, all of which are godawful, just because Sturgill put some horns on his record? Screw that, I’m going to support Sturgill because it is the best album, and frankly, more country than any of the other serious prospects. Now if it goes up against Brandy Clark’s “Big Day in a Small Town,” perhaps I throw my weight behind Brandy. Because her album is country.
I have written reams of content for Saving Country Music on the conundrum of Sturgill’s new album not being particularly country, including this one titled “You Have Every Right to be Disappointed if Sturgill Simpson Chose Not to Make a Country Record.”
https://savingcountrymusic.com/you-have-every-right-to-be-disappointed-if-sturgill-simpson-chose-not-to-make-a-country-record/
I totally understand why people are disappointed by Sturgill’s new album. I am disappointed he didn’t make another country album too. But I still think his new record is a solid effort, and IF he gets nominated, or God forbid actually wins, then that will do nothing but bring more attention to his first two records which are solidly country, and all the other great independent country artists who’ve been working their tail off and deserve more recognition.
Kevin Smith
August 24, 2016 @ 9:45 am
And I forgot to mention….A Sailors Guide to Earth is definitely more country than Sam Hunt!
Lunchbox
August 24, 2016 @ 9:45 am
the only thing good about those award shows are coming here for running commentary.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 10:47 am
When you’re getting attacked at the same time for being both too hard on Sturgill for not making a country record, and for not being hard enough on him because he didn’t make a country record, that’s when you know you’ve got an artist who has all of a sudden become a polarizing character in music.
Yes, other Strugill records and years probably deserved these distinctions. But better late than never in my opinion. There is plenty to be negative about in the world, and in country music. Why not celebrate the positives when they’re tossed into our lap with no strings attached?
Biscuit
August 25, 2016 @ 12:29 pm
Trigger, I see a lot of similarities in the path Robert Ellis and Sturgill are following. Both had early albums that leaned towards trad country/folk/rock and both released albums this year that expanded their sound to include traditonal country instruments-both guys have top notch pedal steel players, for example–but incorporated horns, keyboards and strings to broaden the musical palette. Both have “country sounding voices” but think of themselves as singer/songwriters/guitarists not specific to genre, although both have a clear admiration for and history playing traditional country music. I think both are exploring, which is exciting to hear, but confounds those who want to put them in a particular genre box. It will be fun to see what these guys can do.
Martha
August 24, 2016 @ 11:55 am
I’m very happy that Sturgill, Margo, Joey+Rory, and Randy Rogers Band are getting some consideration, in spite of the fact that I’m very confused about it. Margo, RRB and Joey+Rory are indie artists.. They are getting some consideration. I know I read a while back that Jason Isbell submitted “Something More Than Free” to the CMA’s for album consideration last year and was rejected. I wonder why that is? I don’t expect anyone on here to have an answer for that. I guess I’m just thinking out loud and pointing out how screwy the whole process seems.
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 12:06 pm
Martha,
The most important thing to consider here is that we have never had access to the first tier of candidates who eventually make up the five or so nominees in each category. There may have been a time in the past when that occurred, but not that I can remember. This is part of the CMA’s effort to curb labels and artists spending money on elaborate promotional campaigns for votes. I wrote about that in detail here:
https://savingcountrymusic.com/cmas-new-rules-help-reduce-campaigning-but-will-it-slow-wme-dominance/
The CMA is letting everyone know who is being considered for nominations to try and be more transparent. I think it is a good thing, and is resulting in a promotional boon for these artists. For all we know, Jason Isbell was on this last year, and was “rejected” when the final nominees were cast, and he wasn’t included. Or, maybe they rejected him outright, I really never saw any elaboration on that point. If I find out more I will let folks know, but those are the new rules of the game that have allowed us to see who is being considered. Hell, for all we know, Sturgill’s “Metamodern” was considered a couple of years ago. We just don’t know because that information was not being made public at that time.
Colt
August 24, 2016 @ 12:15 pm
Anarchy!
Jeff
August 24, 2016 @ 1:25 pm
Mark Chesnutt-Tradition Lives is more country than any of them.
WRS
August 24, 2016 @ 3:38 pm
Well if Sturgill gets nominated he will have his foot in the door and hopefully his future albums will be nominated as well
Martha
August 24, 2016 @ 3:41 pm
I know this is off topic, but since Sturgill is mentioned here I’ll post here. A couple of weeks ago, I was reading Native American creation stories. Each tribe has their own take on the creation. And while several of the stories are similar to the Genesis account, there were others that were rather “trippy”. The Iroquois tribe believes that the earth was created and rests on the back of a turtle. Needless to say, I LOL’ed when I read that. Just thought I’d share.
KYChris
August 24, 2016 @ 8:08 pm
Just gonna throw this out there; A Sailor’s Guide to Earth is a good album. A very good album. I love Sturgill and I hope he gets nominated and wins any award he is put up for. With that said, the best country album of the year was released a few weeks ago. Cody Jinks released the best country album that I’ve listened to all year. Others were good. Cody’s was pure country. In my opinion, Cody is putting out what we all wished Sturgill was. Cody simply may not have the “it” factor (right now) that Sturgill has. It’s a shame because I’m Not The Devil is the best album I’ve heard this year and Adobe Sessions may also be a better “country” album than Sailor’s Guide.
Let the bashing begin… Sigh
Trigger
August 24, 2016 @ 9:49 pm
I certainly don’t think that’s a controversial opinion. I rated Cody’s album above Sturgill’s. I think “I’m Not The Devil” is Cody’s “High Top Mountain,” meaning this is the moment that folks are waking up to him being a serious force in independent country.
KYChris
August 25, 2016 @ 8:27 am
Trig, not that I don’t agree with you but I believe that Adobe Sessions was his Hightop Mountain. I was fortunate enough to see Cody and Whitey in Louisville this past spring. I can tell you that the place was packed for Cody, who opened for Whitey. I know everyone around me was singing every word of his songs from Adobe Sessions. Hell, the place actually was clearing out before Whitey finished his set. I honestly believe that I’m Not the Devil is the confirmation that Adobe Sessions was not a fluke and hopefully he’s setting himself up for some late night shows and maybe a little mainstream attention, sort of like Sturgill has done.
Trigger
August 25, 2016 @ 9:21 am
You could be right. I think we need a few weeks to really determine where Cody Jinks is at. But I think we can all agree he’s on his way up and it will be interesting to see where it goes from here.
Garth Clark
August 24, 2016 @ 8:09 pm
Brandy Clark album Big Day In a Small Town is the best album released in any genre this year. I’m hoping the masses get a chance to experience what I’ve had on repeat for the last few months. Love love love that album
RedDirtCyclone
August 24, 2016 @ 9:15 pm
If Pop music can be nominated for a CMA then Sailor’s Guide more than deserves a bid. Is it pure country? Nope. Is it more country then previous winners at the CMA? Yep.
Also, I agree with the other posts. Cody Jinks’ new record is pure Country and the best thing I have heard in years. But I am a huge Jinks fan
Greg
August 25, 2016 @ 7:27 am
I tell you CD that SHOULD be up for a CMA nomination: Loretta Lynn:
Full Circle.
Loretta’s CD entered the Country album charts @ No.4,enterted the top 200 in the top 20.Our local Cracker Barrel has had to re-order Loretta’s CD at least seven times,if not more,because they keep selling out.
But the CMA’s have little,if any,respect for the stars who have made,and are still making Country Music great (like Loretta,Dolly,Gene Watson,Mark Chesnutt,etc,is doing).In fact,the only time I watch the CMA Awards anymore is when Loretta is on.
When Loretta was on the CMA Awards a few years ago,I tuned in just to see her.I had the TV on mute,and read a book until Loretta’s portion came on.When she did come on,I turned the TV up to hear her.Once Loretta’s segement was done,I changed the channel.
What will be interesting to find out is if the CMA’s give a proper tribute to Merle Haggard this year.I hope & pray they do,but I’m not holding my breath.
Biscuit
August 25, 2016 @ 5:28 pm
Greg, i agree that any new Loretta album is an event worth recognizing.Full Circle was nicely produced by John Carter Cash. Ironically, I picked up mine at Cracker Barrel and it was the last copy in the rack that had held several copies a few days prior.. It would be nice to see her recognized by the CMAs or they will deserve a trip to Fist City.
They will likely do a tribute to Hag, but it’s likely to be by people many of us on here might prefer stay seated.
Greg
August 26, 2016 @ 7:27 am
Thank You Biscuit.
Your right,any new album by Loretta is worth recongnizing.Even if the CMA’s nominated Loretta’s new CD,and it did not win,the fact that would have at least gotten a nomination would be better than no recongnition at all.Of course we want the CD to win,but if the CMA’s would at least nominate her at least they would be acknowledging the contributions Loretta is still making to Country Music.
I sure hope your right about the CMA’s doing a tribute to Merle.While they did do a tribute to George Jones (which I watched on you tube),someone told me the CMA’s did not do a tribute to Kitty Wells,which was wrong on the CMA’s part.Still though,we can only hope & pray they do a tribute to Merle.
Our local Cracker Barrel,in nearby Florence KY,has had to re-order Loretta’s new CD @ least 7 times.It’s selling great!
Charles Brown
August 31, 2016 @ 2:19 pm
Greg I am upset that Loretta Lynn’s Full Circle was not nominated for anything by the CMA. Do you know if it was even in the running at all?. From what I understand they have a top 20 then a top ten which gives you the finale top five
Stringbuzz
August 25, 2016 @ 12:17 pm
Any chance to introduce themselves to a larger audience without having to compromise themselves I guess is a positive and Artists can decide if they offered to accept. I see Sturgill telling them to F off, but who knows.
I am in line with some of the others, I love country if it is good, but I also love all kinds of other music.
Personally, interesting to see where Sturgill goes from here. Honestly, I think the country label could be hurting him a bit.. I understand what the true country folks and the purest may not be into the new album.. That’s fine..
For those who don’t give it a chance, or are just dedicated to the genres you like, that is fine too, but your loss.
He sure has put out an impressive album that I really think has a broader appeal to music lovers who may not give it a chance because of the country label attached to it. Look at what the public is told is country these days with support of CMA and others. It is freaking disgusting.. The country label is a turn off because of it for a lot of people.
I think he is doing fine.. SSGTE is critically acclaimed and highly rated out of all albums/and genres released this year.. His tour is doing great. He is doing exactly what HE wants and paying the bills and prolly will have a nice comfy career for the rest of his life.
My favorite albums this year. No particular order.. and there are others, but these are the ones I just keep listening too (these are also per the subject matter of this website, I am not going to get into some of the other music styles) I think this has been a good year for music. just my opinion.
Sturgill
Luke Bell (Trigger.. Thank You.. This usually isn’t my style, but this album is infectious)
Austin Lucas (had the pleasure of seeing him live in a small intimate place, just with an acoustic. I probably hung out with him for a couple hours during the whole gig, watching other bands and talking. It was a very cool experience and he’s alright)
Brandi Clark
margo price (I love this album. Honestly I keep thinking though if the vocals were a lil stronger this could be a masterpiece.. Imagine a voice like J Joplin sing this stuff?)
Cody Jinks has been in constant rotation too (again, not criticizing, I love this, there are just times I wish the band or song or something kicked it up another level in spots. I am hoping to see something when I see him live and hear the stuff..)
And I’ll say it.. The Wheeler Walker Jr album has gotten way more play from me than I would’ve ever expected.. LOL. For some reason, my wife loves that album. He was great though live.
Dave Cobb Southern Family..
I am not saying there hasn’t been better stuff released.. I also can’t listen to everything, but those have been my favorites..
Kevin Smith
August 26, 2016 @ 7:03 am
How does the country label hurt him a bit? It hasn’t hurt Stapleton or Margo.
Stringbuzz
August 26, 2016 @ 7:56 am
There are some who don’t consider listening to country music these days.
Some of it is taste.
Some of it is the disdain for what radio and media has been presenting as country music and just don’t want to go near it (I mean just look at all the network broadcasts. It has become silliness and stereotypical pop).
SSGTE, I feel has such a broader appeal to it. There are many I think who would love it, but may not consider it do to association with the country labeling of it.
I guess that thought of mine doesn’t only apply to Sturgill though.
Although, the funny thing is: I play darts two nites a week. So I am always in a bar playing the jukebox. I play the new Sturgill.. Most people identify it as country.
IDK Maybe my thoughts are rambling. Been a long work week.
Kevin Smith
August 26, 2016 @ 8:32 am
We agree on most things good sir. Most of us on this site hate radio country..and most of us listen to numerous genres. I find it interesting that I can go to a blues festival one weekend, a rockabilly concert another night, a western swing show another night, an alt rock show the next weekend and a Dale Watson show after that and see many of the same faces at all of them! Blame it on Adhd!
That said…never forget you are on Saving Country Music. Many of us are proud to fly the country banner, and could care less what people think. I think in Sturgills case, hipsters have embraced him big time. ( in my town for sure) it seems like the ones who don’t know who he is are mainstream country radio listeners. So that’s why I don’t see the Country label hurting him. In fact, as a fan of real country music I never wanna say being labeled country is gonna hurt an artist.
Anyhow, Sturgill is doing fine and the thing that interested me so much is that here’s a guy who sounds a bit like Waylon…and that’s a rarity these days. What his future holds is the big guess right now.