Sturgill Simpson Shocks the World with ‘A Sailor’s Guide’ Album of the Year Grammy Nomination
“Mark my words, I have a feeling that this will not be the last time you will hear about Sturgill Simpson or this band, from me or others.” —Saving Country Music, January 23rd, 2011.
– – – – – – – – –
That moment when you realize your little music scene is all growns up.
If you didn’t get that sense in 2015 when Chris Stapleton was nominated for arguably the biggest distinction in all of music—the Grammy for Album of the Year—then perhaps you will now that the individual who kicked the doors open for Stapleton and others is finally being allowed to walk through them himself.
On Tuesday morning (12-6) the nominees for the 2017 Grammy Awards were announced, and Sturgill Simpson’s A Sailors Guide to Earth is right up there with Adele, Beyonce, Drake, and Justin Bieber competing for the Album of the Year. And he just might win it. The album is also up for Best Country Album—a little bit strange seeing how his more country effort Metamodern Sounds in Country Music got slotted in Americana. But the simple explanation is Americana is seen as the JV team for country by some (even though it shouldn’t be). Nonetheless, Sturgill Simpson is now running with the big boys, and the impact on music could be huge.
But will he win? Adele has to be seen as the clear front-runner, and frankly nobody has a real chance against her blockbuster and universally-acclaimed 25. Hell, even Saving Country Music was singing the praises of it. But if there’s a Dark Horse, it’s definitely Sturgill in a field with massive pop stars who could all steal votes from each other like has happened in previous years until the small guy walks away with a majority, however small. But don’t hold your breath.
The victory has already been won by Sturgill with the nomination. It puts him at the very top echelon of American music, whether he’s comfortable admitting it or holding that position. All it can do is legitimize him, and legitimize the music, and a lot of the principles he stands for. It also ensures he will get a major performance slot on the telecast, if he wants it. Beyond that, we’ll just have to see what happens in February.
Other important notes from the Grammy nominations includes a nomination for Willie Nelson for Summertime: Willie Nelson Sings Gershwin Nelson under the Best Traditional Pop Vocal album, and Americana and American Roots nominations for Robbie Fulks, Sarah Jarosz, Lori McKenna, The Time Jumpers, and Rhiannon Giddens. Beyond that, frankly there’s an excess of pop country that received nominations this year, including Kelsea Ballerini and Maren Morris who are both up for New Artist of the Year.
But let’s not bury the lead. The Sturgill Simpson nomination is a huge upset, and cements Sturgill’s place as a generational artist, and one that started in the very shallows of independent, authentic country.
Album Of The Year:
25 — Adele
Lemonade — Beyoncé
Purpose — Justin Bieber
Views — Drake
A Sailor’s Guide To Earth — Sturgill Simpson
Best New Artist:
Kelsea Ballerini
The Chainsmokers
Chance The Rapper
Maren Morris
Anderson .Paak
Best Traditional Pop Vocal Album:
Cinema — Andrea Bocelli
Fallen Angels — Bob Dylan
Stages Live — Josh Groban
Summertime: Willie Nelson Sings Gershwin — Willie Nelson
Encore: Movie Partners Sing Broadway
Best Country Solo Performance:
“Love Can Go To Hell” — Brandy Clark
“Vice” — Miranda Lambert
“My Church” — Maren Morris
“Church Bells” — Carrie Underwood
“Blue Ain’t Your Color” — Keith Urban
Best Country Duo/Group Performance:
“Different For Girls” — Dierks Bentley Featuring Elle King
“21 Summer” — Brothers Osborne
“Setting The World On Fire” — Kenny Chesney & P!nk
“Jolene” — Pentatonix Featuring Dolly Parton
“Think Of You” — Chris Young With Cassadee Pope
Best Country Song:
“Blue Ain’t Your Color” — Clint Lagerberg, Hillary Lindsey & Steven Lee Olsen, songwriters (Keith Urban)
“Die A Happy Man” — Sean Douglas, Thomas Rhett & Joe Spargur, songwriters (Thomas Rhett)
“Humble And Kind” — Lori McKenna, songwriter (Tim McGraw)
“My Church” — busbee & Maren Morris, songwriters (Maren Morris)
“Vice” — Miranda Lambert, Shane McAnally & Josh Osborne, songwriters (Miranda Lambert)
Best Country Album:
Big Day In A Small Town — Brandy Clark
Full Circle — Loretta Lynn
Hero — Maren Morris
A Sailor’s Guide To Earth — Sturgill Simpson
Ripcord — Keith Urban
Best Americana Roots Performance:
“Ain’t No Man” — The Avett Brothers
“Mother’s Children Have A Hard Time” — Blind Boys Of Alabama
“Factory Girl” — Rhiannon Giddens
“House Of Mercy” — Sarah Jarosz
“Wreck You” — Lori McKenna
Best American Roots Song:
“Alabama At Night” — Robbie Fulks
“City Lights” — Jack White
“Gulfstream” — Roddie Romero And The Hub City All-Stars
“Kid Sister” — The Time Jumpers
“Wreck You” — Lori McKenna
Best Americana Album:
True Sadness — The Avett Brothers
This Is Where I Live — William Bell
The Cedar Creek Sessions — Kris Kristofferson
The Bird & The Rifle — Lori McKenna
Kid Sister — The Time Jumpers
Best Bluegrass Album:
Original Traditional — Blue Highway
Burden Bearer — Doyle Lawson & Quicksilver
The Hazel And Alice Sessions — Laurie Lewis & The Right Hands
North By South — Claire Lynch
Coming Home — O’Connor Band With Mark O’Connor
Best Music Film:
I’ll Sleep When I’m Dead — Steve Aoki
The Beatles: Eight Days A Week The Touring Years — (The Beatles)
Lemonade — Beyoncé
The Music Of Strangers — Yo-Yo Ma & The Silk Road Ensemble
American Saturday Night: Live From The Grand Ole Opry — (Various Artists)
Judd
December 6, 2016 @ 8:41 am
Who do you think wins Country album of the year? Morris?
Trigger
December 6, 2016 @ 8:49 am
I think with Sturgill being nominated for the all-genre Album of the Year, it cements him as the front runner for Country Album of the Year for sure. But the Grammy Awards are historically unpredictable, and you can see that reflected in the nominations, so who knows. Everyone does seem to be hot to trot for Maren Morris, so I would put her in the running as well. It’s Sturgill’s to lost though.
Judd
December 6, 2016 @ 8:52 am
why the love for MM? The new flavor of the month on music row? “My Church” was a good start but the rest of the album is hot garbage.
seak05
December 6, 2016 @ 10:23 am
actually the album is very good, it’s just not excellent country…but that matters less to the grammy’s
Andrew
December 6, 2016 @ 2:34 pm
Exactly right. If you take away the country label, it’s a pretty good album.
BJones
December 6, 2016 @ 8:45 am
It’s a shame this didn’t happen for Metamodern Sounds, a far superior album in my opinion. This album is better than anything else that’s up for album of the year but no way it’s the best country/roots/Americana album of the year.
Trigger
December 6, 2016 @ 9:08 am
Just like Jason Isbell, who got snubbed for “Southeastern” (didn’t even receive a nomination), but then won for “Something More Than Free,” the Grammy Awards sometimes are a cycle behind getting it right. But I honestly think this is also a distinction for “Metamodern Sounds,” because without the momentum from that record, this nomination would never be possible.
Also remember Metamodern was nominated in Americana, but then lost. Nonetheless, it put Sturgill on the Grammy radar.
Sunseeker
December 6, 2016 @ 10:08 am
I was getting ready to make the exact same comparison. “Southeastern” was in my opinion a btter album than “Something more than Free” (don’d get me wrong – I love that album as well) but wasn’t nominated. Excited for Sturgil. I swear if he loses to Bieber I will puke….
Sunseeker
December 6, 2016 @ 10:09 am
Excuse all the typos….Finger happy
AT
December 6, 2016 @ 8:49 am
I was surprised to see Eric Chirch’s name omitted from the list. They did a lot of campaigning.
Glad to see Joey + Rory score a nod for their Hymns album in the gospel category.
Country Album has been the only on-air trophy presented the past few Grammy ceremonies….how beautiful that would be to see Sturgil take it.
Trigger
December 6, 2016 @ 9:11 am
Yes, and this should also ensure him a performance slot, if he wants one.
seak05
December 6, 2016 @ 10:26 am
I was stunned to see Church left out. The Grammy’s generally balances the award with some commercially successful albums that aren’t as critically acclaimed (see Drake & Beiber getting a bunch of noms). With Rory & Joey in the gospel category none of the three big selling country albums released this period got noms: Carrie, Blake & Eric. I had figured for sure Eric was a lock, as a commercially successful album with critical buzz.
Nadia Lockheart
December 6, 2016 @ 1:03 pm
I thought “Mr. Misunderstood” would be more likely to garner an Album of the Year nomination than “A Sailor’s Guide to Earth” because Eric Church has more well-rounded commercial and critical appeal att this time than Sturgill Simpson does.
Either way, I concede this year the major categories are all but certainly going pop this cycle. Here’s how I would rate the probability of all five album nominees:
*
Adele: “25”: 55% (Easily the safe pick. “25” is the biggest seller, head and shoulders above the rest, and also has reasonably favorable critical reception.)
Beyonce: “Lemonade”: 42% (This has to be viewed as the most likely “challenger” to the incumbency. What’s going for Beyonce is superior critical acclaim to that of Adele’s album, as well as “Lemonade” being more likely to generate water cooler conversation. It’s easily the more artistic effort between these two female commercial powerhouses. What works against Beyonce, however, is the confrontational tone to some of the subject matter and possibly the polarizing Super Bowl performance. The committee tends to play it safe more often than not, and may demur in favor of Adele because of mixed sentiments regarding Black Lives Matter and feminism. It’s a shame if that’s their excuse, but they have a reputation for playing it safe.)
Sturgill Simpson: “A Sailor’s Guide to Earth”: 8% (IF the vote is split right down the line between Adele and Beyonce, and a sizable chunk of the committee views Sturgill Simpson as the only stand-out alternative, Simpson can pull the upset. I wouldn’t place money on a bet, but I do acknowledge there is an opening or him that both Drake and Justin Bieber lack entirely.)
Drake: “VIEWS”: 0% (It’s his least critically-received album to date, and doesn’t resonate to a broad enough listening demographic for it to have any viable shot at winning. It’s a non-starter with the baby boomers and even among Generation X-ers Beyonce will be favored.)
Justin Bieber: “Purpose”: 0% (Give Bieber at least this: he instinctually knew he had to broaden his sound to fit Adult Top 40 and Adult Contemporary sensibilities if he were to avoid fading into obscurity outright. He definitely has made a tremendous impact at radio over these past eighteen months. That said, it is a travesty this somehow got nominated over “Blackstar” and “Stranger to Stranger”: especially when he is directly competing against three fellow Top 40 radio mainstays and, thus, has NO chance at winning to begin with.)
Nadia Lockheart
December 6, 2016 @ 1:08 pm
(tugs collar) I’m an idiot. I forgot to add up my percentages to 100% before clicking “Post Comment”.
I think Adele has a coin-toss chance, Beyonce 42% likelihood and Simpson an 8% likelihood.
AT
December 6, 2016 @ 8:53 am
If I’m remembering correctly, this is also the first time in Grammy history that two country-associated acts will go head to head in the Best New Artist category.
John
December 6, 2016 @ 8:29 pm
I think 1997 would be first time two country acts were nominated for Best New Artist, if you count Jewel as country-associated. LeAnn Rimes won that year. Also, if you want to include folk in with country associated, then a case could be made for 1963 (Peter, Paul and Mary, and The New Christy Minstrels) or 1973 (John Prine and Harry Chapin). But it certainly does’t happen often either way.
It is a little bit strange that Ballerini was nominated over folks like Alessia Cara or Shawn Mendes, who have both had tremendous success in genres that aren’t represented in Best New Artist. But since the Grammys also nominated Chance the Rapper and Anderson .Paak, maybe they just felt like doubling up this year.
dft
December 6, 2016 @ 9:00 am
It’s also worth noting that Hillary Scott got 2 noms for her CCM/Gospel effort in the relevant categories.
Michael
December 6, 2016 @ 9:01 am
Should get a significant performance slot?
Trigger
December 6, 2016 @ 9:12 am
Yes, unless the Grammy Awards break protocol, all Album of the Year and New Artist of the Year nominees get performance slots if they want them.
Let’s just hope he doesn’t fumble the opportunity like Stapleton did last year (in my opinion).
hoptowntiger94
December 6, 2016 @ 9:07 am
Holy Fuck!
This means he’ll get an on air performance, right?
Trigger
December 6, 2016 @ 9:13 am
And probably in a prominent position in the telecast. Could we have another Stapleton moment like we had at the 2015 CMA Awards, only in front of an even bigger audience? One can hope.
Jacob Ware
December 6, 2016 @ 10:53 am
Thought he wouldn’t show up. Ain’t that his thing. Can’t snubb CMAs and not Grammy, not if you meant what you said, not if your up against beiber. Well see if his publicity machine, which has purposely kept him independent, can pass up this launch pad opportunity to maintain his integrity. I love sturgill everyone knows, in just sayin, I wouldn’t go if it was me. Grammys have committed just as many country music crimes as CMA.
Trigger
December 6, 2016 @ 12:14 pm
A couple of things:
First off the Grammy Awards are not the CMA’s, and they’re certainly not the ACM’s. Yes, it’s an awards show, but it’s also an organization. The Grammy Awards recognize bluegrass, Americana, American roots, blues, instrumentalists, and behind-the-scenes musicians. They also do lots of work in the field of music advocacy, in schools, trying to get healthcare for musicians, lobbying Congress, working on reform of copyright laws for songwriters, etc.
Second, this distinction is not just about Sturgill Simpson. It’s about all the people behind him. It’s about his manager Marc, it’s about Thirty Tigers and Dave Macias, it’s about Dave Cobb, it’s about his people at WME, it’s about his band and Laur. It’s about all the people who have gotten him to this point. It’s also about all the independent artists out there also ignored by radio who dream of making it big some day, or even making a decent living in music, and the promise this Sturgill nomination embodies. It is about hope for music. It is about all the effort put out in the last decade to turn the tables of the industry, and now all of that hard work is paying off.
Sure, Waylon skipped his Hall of Fame induction and laughed off awards. But he was also a bitter son-of-a-bitch later in life.
I want Sturgill Simpson to attend. I want him to perform. And I want him to win. Not just for himself. But for all the people that have helped him along the way, so they have a moment to celebrate, even if it’s just to see his face briefly on national television. And for all the struggling musicians out there looking for someone to give them hope that someday their sweat and toil may pay off.
Fuzzy TwoShirts
December 6, 2016 @ 5:51 pm
Good thoughts. I am divided on this.
On one hand, Sturgill HAS to perform. It will cement everything that has been toiled for: independent acts having freedom and success with quality art and not just corporate bean counters
On the other hand: if he performs, he risks the kind of personal image fault that a lot of celebrities are held to.
The dude cussed out other awards shows. If he doesn’t stick to his guns he risks being called out as “just a grumpy egotist who only hates awards shows if they aren’t about him.”
I might be the only regular commenter to see both him and Stapleton in the same year, so I’ll add this, to your thoughts about last year’s stapleton moment at the November 44th awards. And I’m sorry for the typos, my computer is getting old and starting to wear out and spellchecking is becoming a chore.
I would add that Sturgill Simpson is far and away a better stage presence than Chris Stapleton. By comparison Sturgill is more energetic, dynamic and engaging, and on a major awards show slot he’d make huge waves. He’s simply exciting, whereas Chris seems almost lethargic and unengaging by comparison. and MOST of the people who tune in to Grammy shows are more musically open-minded than your average Bro type music fan and would be instantly more engaged by someone like Sturgill. Who has the kind of background most celebrities only wish they could have. I mean he worked on the railroad. WHAT is more American, more Heartland, and more authentic than that?
Will he win? Who knows? it can’t be discounted. Never underestimate Sturgill Simpson. He’s got an honest, likeable atmosphere about him, a more approachable “one of us” sense than the others. Adele is so much celebrity that she seems less than a normal person, whereas Sturgill never outgrew his “humanity.”
I really don’t think he’ll win both. I thhink, and this is coming from someone who initially thought that Chris Stapleton’s meteoric rise would hurt Sturgill Simpson by drawing away the “Country music Savior” crowd who lauded Sturgill even here in this comments section, so maybe I’m wrong again, but I think he’ll win the bigger of the 2 awards and lose out on Genre-specific awards.
But what do I know?
BetsyG
December 6, 2016 @ 5:07 pm
He’s got a kid due the first two weeks of February. Even if the spot is offered, he may not take it for that reason.
jtrpdx
December 16, 2016 @ 3:07 pm
Sturgill’s beef with the CMA’s (and specifically their Haggard award) is a totally different thing. The Grammy’s are backed by a much more respectable organization. Also, the voting process is much more legit.
Clint
December 6, 2016 @ 9:10 am
Ripcord over Mr Misunderstood? Thats tough to defend.
Jack WIlliams
December 6, 2016 @ 9:17 am
Could not agree more.
Trigger
December 6, 2016 @ 9:17 am
I won’t try and defend it. Who is seriously talking about “Ripcord” as anything but a disappointment? It must be label politics involved.
As I said in the article, aside from Sturgill’s nomination, and a few other bright spots like Robbie Fulks, otherwise there is a lot of pop in this year’s country nominations.
Fuzzy TwoShirts
December 6, 2016 @ 6:01 pm
honestly? I think this is one of the best lineups ever.
I mean come on? Mark O’Connor, Loretta Lynn, Sturgill, Dolly Parton, Time Jumpers, Kristofferson, Bob Dylan, Josh Groban?
All artists I get a huge kick out of.
I’m rooting for “Stages Live” all the way. Best album of Musical Theatre stuff in a long time. Right up there with Colm Wilkinson’s last record. Michael Ball and Alfie Boe JUST released a duets record but it was a major let-down for me.
but Stages? Josh Groban’s “Stages” is a fantastic album. and the live version (though less refined and organized) is really exciting.
Josh Groban’s voice is so pure, so flawless, and yet he’s got tremendous power and range that never interfere with his tone.
his performance of ‘What I Did For Love” is my favorite ever.
But Mark O’Connor? the dude was my fiddle hero growing up. It’s so good to here new music from him that isn’t just his weird progressive funky stuff. I love what he’s been doing, saw him live to do that improvised concerto the man is a genius, but he’s always been a Bluegrass and Country fiddler better than a jazz fiddler or a classical violinist.
Willie sings Gershwin is just a novelty, I fear.
Willie is amazing, but the Gerswhin album is so lacking of his typical wit and craftiness that it almost showcases how far his voice has fallen since his glory days.
The dude could write great lyrics like “if this is what you refer to as love, I’d rather you didn’t love me” but his voice was always complimentary to his lyrics.
A Gershwin album showcases some of his shortcomings that his own material doesn’t, and though the album is without fault, I found it to be partly without strength either. A good album not because of strong moments, but because of an absence of weak ones.
I’m betting on “Jolene” too. That duet, on such an iconic song “Should” win outright for sheer star power and significance.
Mcs
December 6, 2016 @ 9:28 am
Unbelievable.
Dangles
December 7, 2016 @ 5:58 am
Ripcord should win worst album of the year maybe.
scottinnj
December 6, 2016 @ 9:12 am
I’d just add that I’m quite pleased to see the strength of the American Roots Performance category. That Lori, Sarah and Rhiannon are nominated is a pleasant surprise – I would have been happy for any one, for but was not expecting to see all three nominated. Not so much that these are all female (though there is that) but that we seem to have a passing of a baton to a younger generation. Prior years included Bela Fleck, Greg Allman, Buddy Guy – so that the average age is much lower is a good sign as well. The American Album skews a bit older but have to start somewhere that people under 50 are making a contribution. It’s a start.
Brian
December 6, 2016 @ 9:13 am
I would love to be in the room when the nominations are taking place. Somebody just starts throwing out names I would guess, and then they put the name into the category that isn’t full yet. Lori McKenna recorded the CMA song of the year on her album AND it’s nominated for best country song and her album is still classified as Americana? But I guess to make it fair Maren Morris only has one country song on her album too… And while I like the new sound from Sturgill Simpson, it’s way too much of a stretch to put the album in the country category.
Also still trying to figure out how Keith Urban’s name got in there with the sub par mediocrity that reminds me of Blake Shelton’s recent lack of anything interesting. Keep the banjo, get rid of the electronic drum beat cannon fodder bullshit.
One last thing since I could go on for a while… I’m really hoping Brothers Osborne can take the country duo/group performance since the others were either terrible or boring. Though credit to Chris Young for not getting an outside voice to draw popularity and sticking with a current (though not hugely popular country (somewhat) singer.
Danny Stephens
December 6, 2016 @ 9:14 am
Please let Sturgill win then Kanye gets op spouts off about how Beyonce should have won and promptly gets KTFO! It would make my year.
Lucas
December 6, 2016 @ 8:31 pm
“Yo, Sturgill. I’m really happy for you, and I’mma let you finish, but Beyonce has one of the best albums of all time!”
Stringbuzz
December 6, 2016 @ 9:21 am
I’ve been following Sturgill for many moons now.
This is awesome and well deserved.
I do understand ASGTE may not resonate with this site’s followerss as much as the last, but damn it is an impressive work of art that deserves the accolades.
I’ve seen Sturgill live starting in small venues and slowly working up. ASGTE tour took it to a new level. You could see it on people’s faces.
Again this is all personal opinion and taste, but this is awesome.
Music Row and the Bros maybe in cardiac arrest today..
Thank you Atlantic Records. Looks like you investment has made you look pretty brilliant.
I find this pretty amusing:
“Just how does the hyper-collaborative nature of making contemporary R&B, hip-hop and pop records affect Grammy Award nominations?
Consider the album of the year nominees. If country-Americana musician Sturgill Simpson’s “A Sailor’s Guide to Earth” should win, six trophies will be handed out: two to the Kentucky native himself as the artist and producer, and four additional statuettes would go to the album’s engineers and mixers.
But if the award goes to nominated albums by Drake, Adele, Beyoncé or Justin Bieber, a basketload of more than 30 Grammys will be distributed to the bevy of featured performers, producers and engineers involved in each.
Adele’s “25” would generate 32, Drake’s “Views” would trigger 35, Beyoncé’s “Lemonade” ups that to 37, while Bieber’s “Purpose” would yield a whopping 41 Grammys for the village that helped make it.”
thehornet
December 6, 2016 @ 9:32 am
I will echo this statement. Sturgill blew the doors off the Ryman in late October with his ASGTE show. Dude plays with such intensity. It’s like watching the music version of Ray Lewis up on stage. Stomping around and screaming at random. I loved it. It’s so cool he is going to be up there at the Grammy’s!!
Jf
December 6, 2016 @ 9:25 am
Hey, let’s not forget Reckless Kelly for best packaging! They own that category. I do like what’s on the inside too.
Gena R.
December 6, 2016 @ 9:30 am
Best Country Solo Performance:
“Love Can Go To Hell” — Brandy Clark
Best Country Song:
“Humble And Kind” — Lori McKenna, songwriter (Tim McGraw)
Best Country Album:
‘Big Day In A Small Town’ — Brandy Clark
‘Full Circle’ — Loretta Lynn
Woohoo! 😀
Gabe N.
December 6, 2016 @ 2:03 pm
As much as I like everything else I’m gonna disagree with country solo, I can settle for a split win between Brandy & Carrie
CaseyK
December 6, 2016 @ 9:53 am
My vote for best country album is between Sturgill and Brandy Clark. Her second album is fantastic and may just have a chance. The fact that both of them are nominated is fantastic!
Racer53
December 6, 2016 @ 10:02 am
This made my day. It’s awesome to think how far Sturgill has come the last few years. Above everything he is an ARTIST. From his songwriting and singing down to the artwork of his album packaging. Not to mention kick ass live shows.
bamstrait
December 6, 2016 @ 10:17 am
Drake and Beyonce will split the urban vote
Adele and Beyonce will split the female vote
Drake and Justin will split the “cute boy” vote
Simpson wins!
Trigger
December 6, 2016 @ 11:47 am
Look, I think we should all be honest with ourselves about the fact that Sturgill Simpson is a very big long shot. This is Adele’s to lose after the massive showing “25” put up. But if he wins it will be because of a similar scenario of vote parsing that you described.
The other scenario is current events compel folks to vote strictly on politics, and Beyonce wins simply because she represents the antithesis to Trump.
Ah.
December 6, 2016 @ 6:47 pm
You are really discrediting Beyonce though. She had one of the most critically acclaimed albums in recent memory. It was also commercially successful and not to mention that she lost in 2015 to Beck, so they might want to make up for that loss this time. So what I’m trying to say is that if she wins, it certainly won’t be due to politics alone.
Trigger
December 6, 2016 @ 9:42 pm
I’m not discrediting Beyonce any more than I’m discrediting Sturgill Simpson. This is Adele’s to lose. She saved music with “25.” She rewrote the record books commercially, while also being a critical favorite. That’s not a knock on Beyonce whatsoever, but of course Beyonce’s fans see Beyonce as the center of the universe, so anything that is not saying she’s the best artist ever is a perceived slight. Beyonce got more nominations than any other artist today, and her fans have spent the entire day bitching. What a miserable existence.
Ah.
December 7, 2016 @ 4:12 am
I am not a fan of Beyonce, Trigger. I’m simply arguing that a Beyonce win doesn’t necessarily have to be motivated by politics.
I’m a longtime reader of your website, ever since 2012. You’re putting me off with this aggressive reply. It’s as if one cannot have a normal, calm music discussion anywhere.
Trigger
December 7, 2016 @ 10:13 am
Ah,
I apologize if I came across as aggressive. Frankly, I’m having to bite my tongue as once again I see Beyonce’s “Beyhive” activated over perceived slights. They are infuriated that Sturgill Simpson even received a nomination, and think it is certain now that this racist white male country star is going to abscond with Beyonce’s Grammy. See, I’m getting worked up even responding to you. I’m tired of hearing about how the world owes Beyonce. I don’t even have an issue with her as an artist. Sturgill was extremely gracious to her in his comments. Yet there is a war being brought to my doorstep, and it has to do with politics. That’s why I get so heated about the matter.
Didn’t mean to single you out with my comment. I was more using it as a springboard for a broader topic.
seak05
December 6, 2016 @ 10:28 am
Margo Price submitting in Americana instead of country now looks like a mistake. Lori McKenna really cleaned up (good for her).
Overall, in country, it was a really good year for women, the country solo performance in particular.
I’ll be totally shocked if Sturgil wins AOTY. Both Beyonce and Adele were massively commercially successful and highly critically acclaimed, and grammy voters already have to figure out how to give them both big wins.
Biscuit
December 6, 2016 @ 9:07 pm
I was surprised Margo wasn’t nominated in any category. It was one of my top 5 albums of the year. It’s also surprising that Margo won an Americana award but wasn’t even nominated in the Grammy Americana category. There really doesn’t seem to be a category where traditional country artists, like Mark Chesnutt, can be recognized.
I am glad for Sturgill’s nominations. I hope he performs live. Even if he doesn’t win, playing and gaining more attention is a positive.
I try not to get too concerned about award shows but being nominated, playing live on TV and winning does help promote the artist, often to new fans. It helps the artist financially to sell their music and concert tickets in larger venues. This is better than them being unable to make ends meet and they have to basically quit making music. So in that regard, I do find myself rooting at award time for quality artists to get a nom and a win.
Megan
December 6, 2016 @ 10:49 am
I’m very pleased to see Sturgill get this recognition, and I’m also happy to see all the female nominees, especially for country solo performance award. Maybe not all the songs I would have picked personally, but I’m counting this as a win.
wvcountry24733
December 6, 2016 @ 10:54 am
This was a great album in my opinion, and even tho Metamodern was the better one honestly he could win for whatever and id be happy. Opens alot of doors for other artists, and i hope to God he takes the performance slot it would be great exposure.
wvcountry24733
December 6, 2016 @ 10:57 am
And let me add I want to meet the dumb fucks who nominated Ripcord, which is one the worst albums of the year over Church who clearly desrves it. Hes had a great year, the albums his best, and hes helped bring substance to radio.
glendel
December 6, 2016 @ 1:37 pm
I think the nomination had nothing to do w/ Keith Urban. The broadcasters just want opportunities at the show to pan to Nicole Kidman.
scottinnj
December 6, 2016 @ 10:58 am
My other question so Sarah Jaroz/Rhiannon Giddons and Lori McKenna are nominated for best American Roots Performance. But Sara and Rhiannon’s albums are nominated for Best Folk Album and Lori’s album is nominated for Best Americana Album. What is the differentiation between Roots/Fold/Americana? Again glad there are more categories so more can be recognized, but I’m hard pressed to explain the difference (it’s not just country – Best Rock Album include Panic! At the Disco and Weezer are Best Rock while David Bowie and Iggy Pop are Alternative Rock?)
Colt
December 6, 2016 @ 10:58 am
Anarchy!
JC Eldredge
December 6, 2016 @ 11:14 am
Good for him! Now let’s hope that all of the county artists aren’t overshadowed by the buzzing bee hive that is losing its mind on twitter right now because their queen wasn’t nominated for best country song.
JC Eldredge
December 6, 2016 @ 11:15 am
***Country*** Damn autocorrect.
Nate
December 6, 2016 @ 3:31 pm
hey at least it eliminated the “r” and not the “o”
JC Eldredge
December 6, 2016 @ 7:04 pm
lol, true.
Megan Conley
December 6, 2016 @ 11:28 am
Look how many women are represented…and not just pop stars and wannabes like Kelsea Ballerini…take note CMA’s.
Jared S
December 6, 2016 @ 11:37 am
Could be a big day for Lori McKenna. “Humble and Kind” has to be a front runner for Country Song (though “My Church” or “Vice” could take it), and her album and especially the song “Wreck You” are outstanding.
Mamma Coal
December 6, 2016 @ 11:53 am
Hell yeah! Congrats to Sturgill!
Benny Lee
December 6, 2016 @ 11:58 am
If Sturgill wins the big one, and then returns to full-on country for his next album, that will single-handedly save country music!
Nadia Lockheart
December 6, 2016 @ 12:03 pm
I thought for sure David Bowie would get a nomination for “Blackstar”, and am gutted he didn’t! =(
Anyway, I’m equally as gladdened Sturgill Simpson got a nomination! I think Adele will quite likely be his greatest competition, although I wouldn’t rule out Beyonce. The key to a Sturgill win will likely depend on a split of the Adele/Beyonce vote, since Simpson simply has to be viewed as the dark horse here.
Corncaster
December 6, 2016 @ 12:58 pm
Grammy categories are anachronisms and generally suck. The only ones that make sense as specific categories and therefore as competitions are:
Childrens
Comedy
Engineered Album
Gospel/Contemporary Christian
Musical Theatre
Reggae
Spoken Word
Surround Sound
Packaging
As for the others, they’re so general as to be meaningless. “Alternative”? “Latin”? “World Music”? Please. Even “Music Video/Film” is stupid, as if feature films should compete with some marketing fluff from Luke Bryan Camel Toe, Inc. The only justification for these moronic categories is the marketing of year-on-year award histories.
This is one of the reasons why the Grammy awards are only interesting in so far as they promote individual careers and trends, like Sturgill’s. I suppose better categories is just too much to ask.
Trigger
December 6, 2016 @ 2:54 pm
The Grammys pick the categories. It is the voters who nominate the contenders. Don’t blame the Grammy Awards. Complain too much, and they’ll just eliminate the category, like they did for Western Swing. The voters need to be more aware of genre.
Corncaster
December 7, 2016 @ 8:49 am
Well, the Grammys could make them more aware of genre by articulating a better list. The problem is that there are hundreds of genres. I’d like to see something along these lines:
Traditional Music
– country, rock, folk, rap, reggae, salsa, symphonic, etc.
Experimental Music
– country, rock, folk, rap, reggae, salsa, symphonic, etc.
Improvisational Music
– group, duo, solo
Service Music
– film, video, theatre, television, etc.
Something like that. Preserve the traditions, and give some spotlight to the new. Improvisation is a different kettle of fish and is not reducible to “jazz.” Miles Davis hated the term jazz and preferred to call what he did “social music.” Move away from “genres” and into “approaches,” and you’ll get a better playing field. IMO.
seak05
December 6, 2016 @ 1:50 pm
Stapleton’s performance was part of a tribute. If the Grammy’s doe s a Haggard tribute I could see the same thing for Sturgill. I would also expect Maren and Kelsea to be paired, possibly with each other.
WOTSON DE ASSIS
December 6, 2016 @ 3:30 pm
Do not forget Kris Kristofferson with two nominations and Loretta Lynn with an indication.
Amanda
December 6, 2016 @ 4:28 pm
The NY times just shared an interview from today with Sturgill. He sounds honored and grateful. He does reveal that his second child is due at the beginning of February, so he may not be able to attend. Not sure if they”ll give you a performance slot if you can’t commit to being there…but fingers crossed! http://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/12/06/arts/music/sturgill-simpson-grammy-nominations.html
Justin
December 6, 2016 @ 4:57 pm
Honestly I don’t give a flyin’ phurk about the Grammys. Just a bunch of weirdo freaks patting each other on the back for mediocre output (with a few exceptions like Sturgill and Stapleton).
Tunesmiff
December 6, 2016 @ 4:59 pm
And this just across NBC~ only Adele and her Bee-ness were named for record of the year, with a spin/slant towards… Drum roll please ~ Queen B~ who also got a plug as potentially Time Magazine’s “Person of the Year” ~
Andrew
December 6, 2016 @ 5:57 pm
Wow, there’s a least a decent artist in all of those categories!
Ethan
December 6, 2016 @ 6:01 pm
I think the day’s most interesting development is Sturgill’s quote from the New York Times:
“I really, really wish, honestly, and no [expletive] — I would’ve liked to see Frank Ocean’s name where mine is. But that’s not my place to say. I totally understand [his protest]. I just thought that record [Blonde] was really groundbreaking. I listen to just about everything except country music, so it’s strange.”
AC
December 6, 2016 @ 6:12 pm
It’s a joke Mr. Misunderstood wasn’t nominated. Far and away the best mainstream country release of the year and Church’s best work to date.
Old Brett
December 6, 2016 @ 6:16 pm
I would like to see Sturgill close (or open) the Grammy show with an eight-minute version of Call to Arms.
Jim Bob
December 6, 2016 @ 6:49 pm
Hell yes!! He’d sell a million records before the damned awards show even finished (whether he opens or closes, wouldn’t matter.
Larry
December 6, 2016 @ 6:48 pm
Hmmmm. Is that Brandy Clark i see on that list??? 🙂
Martha
December 6, 2016 @ 7:01 pm
If Sturgill really is serious, as he said in an interview a few years ago, about plotting music row’s destruction, I think he really needs to show up to the Grammy’s and perform. His exposure to me would be so beneficial not only to him but to independent artist across the board. Sure hope he can make the show but I totally understand if he can’t with a child on the way.
Jimsouls
December 6, 2016 @ 7:43 pm
Sturgill can win it. “Lemonade” isn’t even the best 2016 album by a Knowles sister.
Jack Williams
December 7, 2016 @ 9:29 am
I gave a listen to a few of the songs on the new Solange album. I liked them and wish there was more R&B like that coming out these days.
Jimsouls
December 7, 2016 @ 11:43 am
She is very much her own artist. I like how the record has roots without being consumed by them. She keep the music moving forward.
Zach M
December 6, 2016 @ 7:51 pm
I discovered Sturgill after reading your HTM review on this site. I’m sure I’m not the only one. Thank you Trig for helping me discover his music, and please take note that what you do with this site IS WORKING!
Charlie
December 7, 2016 @ 5:29 am
And if he’s lucky, he will beat out Justin Bieber–for an award judging the quality of the music each produces.
You know when you are forced to be in close proximity to someone with that BO that gets into your pores and has you tasting their stench into the next day? #GrammysBeLikeThat
Erik North
December 7, 2016 @ 8:27 am
I know it was a compilation collection for the most part, but I was a touch disappointed that THE COMPLETE TRIO COLLECTION by the terrific threesome of Dolly Parton, Emmylou Harris, and Linda Ronstadt wasn’t considered somewhere, perhaps in the Americana field (it was released in time to meet the deadline for this year’s nominations). And there’s a further small twinge of disappointment that Margo Price didn’t get a nod for MIDWEST FARMER’S DAUGHTER. That album ranks as one of the best releases of 2016 in any genre, in my humble opinion.
Still, seeing Brandy Clark get her nominations is a good thing, as is Sarah Jarosz getting Americana notice. Both artists will be here in L.A. this Sunday to perform with Jackson Browne, J.D. Souther, and Maria Muldaur in a benefit for Parkinson’s research, and to honor Linda, who suffers from that disease and lost her voice because of it.
Greg
December 7, 2016 @ 9:27 am
I hope & pray Loretta wins,but even if she does not,Thank God she at least got a nomination! That says a lot!
Tom R.
December 8, 2016 @ 5:09 pm
I’m delighted for Loretta’s nomination too although I feel John Carter Cash’s production was uninspired and the album would have been better with somebody else at the helm.
Tom R.
December 8, 2016 @ 5:06 pm
Tributes to Hank Williams and Jimmie Rodgers are nominated in the Jazz and Blues categories!!! Says a lot that modern “country” acts fall over themselves trying to perform or pay tribute to rock acts yet serious musicians outside the genre seem to respect the icons of country more than contemporary acts who call themselves country.
“Best Improvised Jazz Solo – John Scofield, I’m So Lonesome I Could Cry
“Best Traditional Blues Album” – Vasti Jackson, The Soul of Jimmie Rodgers