The More They Say Stella Lefty Isn’t a “Nepo Baby,” The More I Think She Is

Random Notes 17 Comments

photo: Jack Balaban

Is Stella Lefty an “Industry Plant”? Was her career “Astroturfed”? Is she a “Nepo Baby?” What do any of these damn Gen Z terms even mean? Frankly, I really don’t care. Is her music any good? And since she’s calling herself country, is her music country? That’s what I’m most concerned about. Everything else should be secondary, if not superfulous.

But the more the legacy media tries to convince me that Stella Lefty isn’t a Nepo Baby and the byproduct of privilege who’s been unfairly foisted to the front of the line in a completely inequitable manner, the more I believe that’s exactly what has happened, and the more I do care about it, and feel like making it my business.

On August 16th, Vanity Fair released a massive spread about Stella Lefty with the title “‘Boston’ Singer Stella Lefty May Be a Billionaire. But She’s Not a Nepo Baby.” This aggressively stone blind title had the internet up in arms, and for good reason. They have since changed the title, but the damage was already done. And truly, the fawning profile itself is just as bad.



You always know when a supposed “journalist” is just working as a 3rd party clearinghouse for whatever narrative an artist or their handlers want to push whenever it starts off with one of these puff piece “slice of life” observances.

“For 24-year-old singer-songwriter Stella Lefty, performing in front of thousands at Lollapalooza was nerve-wracking. Even more harrowing was what she did the next day: get an IUD. A visit to the gynecologist isn’t how anyone would choose to celebrate their first major music festival appearance, but it’s been a busy summer. Lefty—born Stella Lefkofsky—only had one free day in her hometown of Chicago, and she much prefers her doctor there to the one she sees in Los Angeles, where she lives.”

The story goes on to assert that sure, Stella Lefty’s dad is the billionaire founder of Groupon who now runs an AI company. But hey, Stella Lefty works really really hard at making TikTok content every day, and people just don’t understand what kind of time commitment that really is. And even though her dad is a billionaire 5 times over, since he’s not exactly “famous,” that means Stella Lefty isn’t exactly a nepo baby. Technically. By their definition.

Meanwhile, you have many of the actual women of country music out there literally shoveling shit as they’re growing up, even ones like The Castellows and Noeline Hoffman who’ve found some viral success, and somehow, they’re not getting puff piece spreads in Vanity Fair. It’s not fair to disqualify anyone from being able to make country music just because the come from privilege. If that was the case, we’d never have Gram Parsons or Townes Van Zandt.

But don’t try to sell me on the idea that Stella Lefty’s life is much harder than it looks on paper. Nobody wants to hear that shit, even if it’s true frankly, especially in 2026 when so many are struggling. It’s not just that it rings hollow. It’s that it’s aggressively insulting and classist. And for the most part, it is the upper class and elite who see Stella Lefty as one of their own, and are defending her because they feel she represents them.

Marissa R. Moss of Rolling Stone is a perfect example. Her Stella Lefty puff piece from back in June starts off perfectly on cue with,

“Finally, someone has succeeded in getting Sella Lefty a snack. ‘I gave her a Fig Newton!’ one of her team members proclaims as if they’d just handed off the baton to win Olympic gold. Lefty, rushing so quickly between the three appearances she is making at CMA Fest in under two hours, barely notices that something is even in her hand. ‘Oh!’ Lefty says, taking a bite and smiling big, as she almost always does. ‘I love these!'”

This is “journalism”? This is what’s supposed to humanize Stella Lefty to us? I’d include more of the feature here, but it’s paywalled, so I can’t read it. Only the privileged can partake, because that’s who it’s for. Everyone else is stuck reading Saving Country Music and fighting through the excessive ads on Whiskey Riff.

Even worse is the defense of Stella Lefty’s hit song “Boston,” which this week sits at #2 on the Billboard Hot 100 right behind Ella Langley. The song borrows heavily from Noah Kahan’s hit “Stick Season,” just like how Shaboozey’s big hit and Lil Nas X’s big hit also borrowed parts from other songs heavily. In the Vanity Fair piece, Stella says she wasn’t thinking about “Stick Season” when she wrote it. In fact she says, “When I was writing the song, I wasn’t thinking about Noah Kahan. I was literally thinking about nothing at all.”

So she was thinking about “nothing at all” when she wrote her hit song? And she was completely blind to the Noah Kahan similarity? Even though she’s covered “Stick Season” previously in multiple videos? Seems a bit too convenient. Lefty goes on to say that fans started pointing out the similarity, and then her “team” decided to bestow Noah Kahan a writing credit on it just to cover their bases. So it was an after-the-fact decision, so to speak.

The flimsy origin story of “Boston” are the kinds of details that Rolling Stone and Vanity Fair need to be attempting to scrutinize from their interview subject instead of running interference for them, or being a stenographer.

But even though none of this stuff specifically seems like it should be a scathing indictment of Stella Lefty or “Boston”—or should be a barrier to her making music any different than any other artist—cumulatively it all adds up that she’s exactly the thing she’s trying to distance from. The way you confer credibility to a country performer is not by giving her a feature length spread in Vanity Fair, or have her written up by Marissa R. Moss in Rolling Stone. That validates all priors that she’s a product of privilege, if not an agenda.

And all of this of course feeds into the concern that Stella got her start on TikTok, which is a completely corrupt system where you can pay for exposure, either for yourself or through others via the “influencer” network, and nothing seems fair, equitable, organic, and most assuredly, transparent.

This is the underlying problem Stella Lefty faces. Now that 3rd party media plays such a secondary, if not insignificant role and is unwilling to question the authenticity of anyone, we don’t know what is legitimate or not in music, and it becomes easy to assume every artist is “astroturfed” or an “industry plant,” fair or not. Ironically, all the media is doing for Stella Lefty right now is making the matter worse. She tried to pay for positive promotion, and it’s backfiring. Better go back to TikTok and the paid influencer avenues yet again.

This is not just about Stella Lefty. It’s about the integrity of the entire music ecosystem, and how it seems to be eroding in front of our very eyes. We don’t even need AI to come in and destroy music. At this point, AI might just knock over the lifeless, fatally-infected carcass of an industry that if it had any vitality, could perhaps fend it off. Everything your being pushed in your algorithm feels forced and paid-for. All the popular artists seem to be the product of a corrupt system. Everywhere you turn, its the privileged who are benefiting as the rich get richer, and the have-not’s fight for table scraps.

Stella Lefty’s music itself is fine and inoffensive. It’s not that especially great, and it’s not that especially country either. But it’s also not bad. It just kind of “is.” But since it’s what’s getting pushed, it’s rising to the top. But at what cost? For Stella Lefty and her team, spending a few thousand on TikTok campaigns and publicists to get you into Vanity Fair is a drop in the bucket. After all, as they proclaimed, she’s a billionaire.

But for the truly talented and world-beating performers out there trying simply to be heard and seen beyond their local bar who used to make their way up through local radio, opening gigs, and a nationwide talent search for the next great artist, they’re the ones that are losing out in this system.

Stella Lefty can’t help that she comes from money. It also doesn’t feel fair to discriminate against her just because she does. But she’s not a victim of public sentiment like the fawning media is trying to portray. The true victims are all the performers not getting their deserved opportunities because Stella Lefty is hogging the spotlight, and specifically due to her privilege, which ironically, is getting her even more press due to the intrigue behind it.

For so many other artists, the only option they have is “too stubborn to quit.”


– – – – – – –

If you found this article valuable, consider leaving Saving Country Music A TIP.

© 2025 Saving Country Music

, ,