Album Review – Billy Strings – “Highway Prayers” (+ Song Reviews)

#520 (Bluegrass) on the Country DDS.
If you’re a traditional country or bluegrass fan, it’s always felt like your Billy Strings fandom would come with an expiration date. You’ve been stealing yourself for the moment that Strings takes a hero’s journey dose of psilocybin mushrooms, mashes the effects pedal that makes his acoustic guitar sound like an electric one, and ventures off into the world of psychedelic rock never to return to the bluegrass side except for some fleeting bouts of nostalgia.
With Billy’s last album Me / And / Dad being a collaborative work with his father on classic country and bluegrass standards in traditional form, you just knew his next recorded project would be heavy with 15-minute jams interpolated with tape feedback, taking the listener into the far reaches of outer space, and far away from simple fiddle, banjo, and flatpicking music.
But once again—as he continues to do throughout his illustrious career—Billy Strings proves those fears of his bluegrass fans unwarranted. Aside for some very minor detours, Highway Prayers is a full throttle road trip into 20 original and traditional bluegrass tracks, with some killer tunes, surprisingly involved writing, while still delivering the spellbinding improvisation that is at the heart of Billy’s unique appeal.
If you’re a Billy Strings bluegrass fan first and simply tolerate all the jam band stuff, Highway Prayers doesn’t meet your expectations, if far exceeds them. In many respects, the approach to this new album makes perfect sense. Heretofore, Strings has struggled to capture the frenetic energy and and freak spontaneity of his live shows in the studio, and has admitted as much publicly. He’s a live artist first and foremost.
So instead of struggling to try and bottle those live moments, just do what you know you do well in the studio. Live albums like Billy’s recent Live Vol. 1 is where you can explore the deeper musical world uninhibited, and in a way where the energy of the audience is conferred to the recording. This allows both sides of the Billy Strings appeal—and those that straddle both worlds—to walk away satisfied.

In many respects, this balance of live vs. recorded is what the Grateful Dead perfected in their career. Another good comparison from the jam band world would be the Phish album Farmhouse. Similar to what Strings does here, Phish focused more on songwriting and songs as opposed to extended jams on that album, while still dabbling in the jam side of their music to keep it true to themselves.
With any 20-track album, you worry about quality control. But since Billy’s last original album was in 2021, he’s had plenty of time to compose new songs. Though Strings wrote many of the new songs himself, he also relied on sessions with Thomm Jutz, Aaron Allen and Jon Weisberger, as well as Shawn Camp and mandolin player Jarrod Walker to bring the songs of the album to life.
And though the sound of Highway Prayers might not be as expansive or adventurous as you might be used to from a Billy Strings album, that doesn’t mean it lacks depth or a cohesive theme. On the contrary, this is an album written on the road and for the road, bookended by a song about embarking, and ending with the send off “The Beginning of the End” that you could hear capping off Billy Strings sets for decades to come.
Billy’s jam band fans may feel like this album is a bit dry for them, and that’s probably fair from their perspective. No song ventures over 5:50, and most hover around 3:00 or 4:00. But this also feels like the Billy Strings album that has a chance to finally find some legs with general audience listeners. He doesn’t ask too much from the audience, though he delivers a lot.
Traditionalists in bluegrass will lose their marbles over this assertion, but Billy Strings is perhaps the most important bluegrass player since Bill Monroe, or certainly Flatt & Scruggs. He’s taken the music to the arena and beyond. And every time you believe he’s going to abandon the discipline or stretch it too far, he doubles down on his bluegrass roots like he does with Highway Prayers.
It’s the age of Billy Strings in bluegrass, and the world is better off for it.
8.5/10
– – – – – – – –
Purchase Highway Prayers
Song Reviews:
1. Leaning on a Travelin’ Song – (Billy Strings, Thomm Jutz)
A straight bluegrass song starts off this album and sets the table for the road trip you’re about to embark on. The twin fiddle melody really takes the song to the next level.
2. In The Clear – (Aaron Allen, Billy Strings, Jon Weisberger)
Another solid, straightforward bluegrass song that fits with the traveling theme to help start off the album. Nothing special, but a really sensible song to get you warmed up.
3. Escabana – (Billy Strings)
This is the kind of instrumental that has put Billy Strings in arenas, and makes him the foremost purveyor of bluegrass for our era. Strings doesn’t need words to create waves of emotion, or to hold the audience in rapt attention. He just needs a smart composition that works like a jumping off point for himself and his band. Skill and imagination do the rest. They come in at an efficient 4:34 on the studio rendition of “Escabana,” but this is definitely the kind of song that could stretch out to 12-15 minutes live.
4. Glid the Lily (Billy Strings, Jarrod Walker)
The first non-traditional bluegrass song of the album gives you Jerry Garcia gone bluegrass vibes. You could see Grateful Dead lyricist Robert Hunter writing this one. “Glid the Lily” has a great lyrical hook and sets a good vibe.
5. Seven Weeks In County – (Billy Strings, Aaron Allen)
Bluegrass and Western? Yes, please. Billy Strings explores some new textures on Highway Prayers, and turns to Western, country, and old-time to do so. This song isn’t groundbreaking or anything, but it is cool to hear Billy venture into some Western-adjacent territory and do well with it.
6. Stratosphere Blues/ I Believe in You – (Billy Strings)
The two-minute “Stratosphere Blues” is the only truly trippy moment on the entire 20-song album. But it’s important it’s there because this is part of the Billy Strings experience.
“I Believe in You” is less a bluegrass song, and more a singer/songwriter moment. Strings assure folks that whatever they’re trying to overcome, they can do it. Despite Strings seeming to sing to the audience, you get the sense that he’s singing this song to himself as well.
7. Cabin Song – (Billy Strings)
This is a great traditional bluegrass song Strings has been playing for a while live, and really shows off Billy and the band’s chops. It was also featured on the recent Hunger Games soundtrack. You could hear the Osborne Brothers cutting a song like this in 1967. Great stuff.
8. Don’t Be Calling Me (at 4AM) – (Billy Strings, Shawn Camp)
This is a mid-tempo bluegrass song that’s really a country song at heart, centered around the writing as much as the instrumentation. Billy and co-writer Shawn Camp combine a timeless sentiment with a somewhat modern twist as cell phones lighting up in the dark from drunk dials and lonely hearts is something that has become an occurrence of regular life for many.
9. Malfunction Junction – (Billy Strings)
If you’re one of those Billy Strings fans who could care less about all the fluff and just want Billy’s compositional and instrumental prowess injected straight into your veins, navigate to “Malfunction Junction” and jam the repeat button down.
This song really highlights the genius of the approach to Highway Prayers. This is a 15 minute song live, but understanding that playlist listeners don’t have the patience for that, they serve up the kernel of the song here, and then can expand on it live and give the audience something they’ve never heard before. It’s also cool that this track is mostly mandolin driven by Jarrod Walker with Billy just along for the ride.
10. Catch and Release – (Aaron Allen, Billy Strings, Jon Weisberger)
A fun little interlude of a song that Strings originally released a while back. It’s a true story with “Vince” being Vince Herman of Leftover Salmon. The song combines Billy’s avid pastimes of fishing and partaking in a little green. It’s tracks like these that keep Highway Prayers interesting throughout, and give the album and overall fun aspect.
11. Be Your Man – (Billy Strings)
Billy Strings doesn’t do a lot of love songs, but this is a good one with a great chorus that accentuates his vocal strengths. Really cool production decision to feature piano playing the solo part in this song as opposed to guitar. Also interesting to note that Billy welcomed in his first child (a son) shortly after this album was released. Perhaps we’ll get more love songs from him in the future.
12. Gone a Long Time – (Billy Strings, Jarrod Walker)
Billy Strings and co. return to the traveling theme in this great little traditional bluegrass tune that mentions Traverse City where Strings got his start in the music scene. It’s the 2nd shout out the northern Michigan town receives on the album. Great solos on this song.
13. It Ain’t Before – (Billy Strings, Thomm Jutz)
Refusing to allow the 20 tracks of the album to become monotonous, Billy Strings and the band approach this song more as an old-time tune than a bluegrass one, featuring clawhammer banjo, juice harp, and harmonica.
14. My Alice – (Aaron Allen, Billy Strings, Jon Weisberger)
What an excellent song, and perhaps the best-written one on the album. You have to double check the liner notes to make sure this isn’t some old bluegrass standard lost in time since the writing feels so faraway in time, but still captures a relevant feeling. There’s lots of great instrumental moments on this album, but don’t overlook “My Alice” as one of the standouts.
15. Seney Stretch – (Billy Strings)
This is the more thoughtful, mid-tempo, introspective instrumental on the album. Though it runs the risk of being overlooked or buried within the 20 other tracks, it’s a nice song that you can hear folks warming up to and eventually becoming one of their favorites from the album.
16. MORBUD4ME – (Billy Strings)
A silly and stupid stoner song taking lighter clicks, bong rips, coughs, and looping them. This kind of throwaway track would have been cool in the ’90s maybe, but now it just feels superfluous and lends to the stereotype of the dumb stoner. There is a space where you can tie the prohibition of alcohol and bootlegging songs to songs about marijuana these days and the similar themes. But this just feels like a waste.
17. Leadfoot – (Billy Strings)
The was surprisingly picked as the lead single since it doesn’t really represent the album. Played mostly by Strings himself, it’s more of a primitive country song than a bluegrass one. It’s a fun song and a fun video that helped introduce the album’s artwork, but doesn’t really feel like a track that will ultimately graduate to being timeless in the Strings catalog.
18. Happy Hollow – (Billy Strings, Thomm Jutz)
Another solid little traditional bluegrass song, but one that fails to make a strong impression, and lends to perhaps the softest portion of the album as it nears the end.
19. The Beginning of the End – (Billy Strings)
A great song to conclude the journey that Strings takes you on through this album, and a song that perhaps might be overlooked in the short-term, but you could hear becoming a fan favorite and a show closer for years to come. “The Beginning of the End” has a great melody that lingers with you the more times you listen.
20. Richard Petty – (Billy Strings)
An excellent little a capella track and a great way to conclude the album. It reminds you that bluegrass is just as much a vocal discipline as it is an instrumental one. “Richard Petty” has already become a favorite of Billy’s live shows.
October 1, 2024 @ 8:41 am
Really cool to see Thomm Jutz and Jon Weisberger on some of these cuts! Really great bluegrass folks.
October 1, 2024 @ 8:52 am
I think Strings was smart to bring in some co-writers and tighten up the writing, especially when releasing 20 songs. I wouldn’t consider this a songwriter’s album or anything, but the writing is really solid throughout, and “My Alice” is stellar.
October 1, 2024 @ 9:20 am
It’s really great. Surprised to hear you say In The Clear is nothing special. It gives me huge Steam Powered Aeroplane vibes and might be my favorite original in Strings’ catalogue. Also really love Seven Weeks in County – big Marty Robbins vibes!
October 1, 2024 @ 9:21 am
I always enjoy your reviews and appreciate all the good music you have turned me on to. Curious if you’re planning to address the recent Billy Renewal festival? I was there and have my opinion about what happened and what should have happened but would love to hear your take.
October 1, 2024 @ 9:35 am
I was not planning on addressing Renewal Festival until I reviewed the album, which got delayed by the death of Kris Kristofferson, and maybe now the Renewal news is old news. But we’ll see.
I’d actually be interested in your take. I wasn’t there, so it’s hard to give a firm opinion. I can’t blame the guy for wanting to be there for the birth of his son. I can blame them for booking his own big festival within the window of when his son might be born. That’s seems like bad foresight.
October 1, 2024 @ 9:42 am
I mean sure but I’m sure these plans have been in place for before the pregnancy was found out about. I am sure it was pretty disappointing for everyone, but it seems as though they did their best to make it up with a pretty unique experience, of course that’s easier said when not having attended
October 1, 2024 @ 10:34 am
I definitely don’t begrudge him leaving to be there for his son’s birth. Nothing compares to becoming a parent and I’m truly happy for him. That said, why did this not get cancelled or rescheduled? The festival was literally on his wife’s due date. I understand there are a million contracts at play, but it seems like it could have been dealt with in time. There also appeared to be no plan B for this likely scenario. Friday nights sets were middling and fortunately Molly Tuttle stepped up Saturday night and was amazing along with Jerry Douglas leading, but she said that she was surprised to be asked to fill in, meaning this wasn’t part of any plan. Technical difficulties with the larger group of musicians and a somewhat lame Beatles covers part of the set leads me to believe they really had no contingency in place. It would have been my first time seeing the phenomenon that is Billy Strings and I wound up having a good time and enjoying myself but I still feel Bonfire promotions dropped the ball big time on this.
October 1, 2024 @ 10:45 am
Planning a festival like that would take longer than 9 months, but it’s still a little bizarre.
Too many musicians prioritize career over family. Kudos to Billy Strings for taking care of his wife and child.
October 1, 2024 @ 10:57 am
I wasn’t there, Trigg. But it sounds like the attendees got a once-in-a-lifetime show. Molly was the lead singer for Billy’s band. I knew that sounded like it would be unique, and it sounds like it sure was.
The folks who went up and left when Billy went to his family are going to regret it. They missed a lineup that won’t ever happen again. Hearing about how some folks went from completely devastated to blown away once they saw Molly live is a great sign for bluegrass as a whole.
Molly Tuttle is a special talent who can stand on her own separate from Billy. Glad she is getting the extra press, although it means I won’t be able to see her at the small venue in town anymore.
October 14, 2024 @ 12:56 pm
My wife and I said the same thing about Molly. I’d pay an insane amount of money to have seen Molly lead Billy’s band for a night. A few years ago we were in the first row in St. Louis when she performed at the Old Rock House, and she and her band were insanely good. I missed the chance to do that with Billy and company. My wife and I weren’t going to miss that chance with her.
October 1, 2024 @ 4:06 pm
He just announced everyone is getting a refund. Pretty thoughtful dude.
October 1, 2024 @ 2:45 pm
Strings is refunding everyone.
He’s afraid to stop moving (part of his recovery) and wants to do it all. I laughed that in his birth announcement he said he was planning on playing the Pine Knob show. Even in that moment, he’s working.
I knew he’d do the right thing. And I’m seeing comments that fans being reimbursed will pay it forward and donate the money to relief funds for western North Carolina.
October 1, 2024 @ 9:55 am
I could have done without songs 4 through 6 and the marijuana song. If he had cut it down to 12 songs, he would have a 5 star album.
October 1, 2024 @ 10:54 am
Glad you reviewed this I listened through all the way twice and it was really wonderful. There’s been some great albums this year and this is up there. I also had the thought this feels like an album that could appeal to a wider audience for him
October 1, 2024 @ 11:08 am
I know this comment is totally off topic but I think a shout out to Morgan Wallen, who gets a lot of deserved and undeserved abuse, is due for his $500,000 donation in aid of flood relief.
October 1, 2024 @ 11:45 am
I know they are a lot of work, but I love the track by track reviews- thanks!
October 1, 2024 @ 2:46 pm
My main genre is intelligently written country, so please don’t roast me for this. Is there a chance he does not go down as the best bluegrass musician ever? So much of the traditional bluegrass is so narrow in scope that it seems he is expanding that with unprecedented talent and succes that I can’t imagine he will not be seen as the best ever
October 1, 2024 @ 3:07 pm
Yeah. Billy wouldn’t even be in the top fifty most important bluegrass musicians
Because Billy is to bluegrass what Andre rieu is to classical music
serious bluegrass fans just aren’t paying as much attention to Billy as people outside the bluegrass fold are
Making something famous doesn’t equate to doing it right. If it wasn’t famous before, then the secret is in changing the formula.
Just like George Jones wasn’t as big as Elvis, if a country singer today got that big, he wasn’t doing it the traditional way.
Billy isn’t as big a deal among serious bluegrass enthusiasts, most of whom know that Michael Cleveland can play guitar as well as Billy does, that lots of guitarists in the bluegrass fold can do what Billy does. That Billy is basically attracting many of his fans from outside the immediate bluegrass fold
October 1, 2024 @ 8:33 pm
In what he is doing for bluegrass he reminds me of the Dillards who basically made bluegrass a performance music. Still backed by talent but focusing on putting on a show.
Of course, they are hardly talked about nowadays because traditionalists don’t respect them, and casual listeners who were exposed to bluegrass in the day, are just casual.
Having said that, the influence of the Dillards is a lot deeper than anyone cares to admit (it must be 5 minutes since I heard ‘Old Home Place’, emergency at the bluegrass festival)
I think Billy might be the same. Actually highly influential, but always carrying a stigma of being non-traditional and successful.
Mind you, I love his live album. And also the Dillards first live album. (Especially the comments about Bob Dylan)
October 1, 2024 @ 3:16 pm
Trigger you’ve admitted in the past bluegrass isn’t your area of expertise but don’t you think it’s a stretch to say he’s as important as Lester earl and bill?
Never mind that on the country side of things people bringing outside fans in by altering the formula has gradually eroded the genre. Let’s just go in good faith and say Billy strings won’t Grateful Dead up the bluegrass space
Why are we taking that as an assumption? I’d say it’s a fair assumption
Let’s just look at the statements: do you honestly think anything Billy brings to the table will be here as long as foggy mountain breakdown? Jed clampett? Earls breakdown? Blue moon of Kentucky?
I don’t. There hasn’t been a new true blue bluegrass standard in years. Most true bluegrass standards all originated within the first fifteen years of bluegrass, about a third came in the second generation
Most serious bluegrass players don’t count Billy as one of theirs anymore than Chris thile
Those guys wind up in a genre-defiant void where musicians who are so good they have nothing left to lose push the limits
Chris thile, bela fleck? Great players beloved by many bluegrass fans but not taken seriously as bluegrass players
And Billy isn’t doing something no one else can do in the space. Michael Cleveland can improvise and go far out in long jams just as well
Billy isn’t a talented pop superstar coming into a genre of lesser talented people on a short leash by the label the way Ed Sheeran would humiliate Luke Bryan
He’s a great player in a world where greatness is the expectation, not the anomaly.
The greatest bluegrass figure since bill Lester and earl is J D Crowe (honorable mention to Alison Krauss, Ricky Skaggs and del mccoury) and that’s a statement most bluegrass know-it-alls will agree with
October 1, 2024 @ 3:33 pm
Let’s be clear: bluegrass is enjoyed by two primary groups: the genreless “folk” fans who love goat rodeo sessions and bela fleck and flecktones and nickel creek
But not all of those acts are loved by every bluegrass fan
Billy would be a hit at wheatland, where everyone loves bluegrass and other stuff too
Billy might not go over as well at bean blossom
Bluegrass fans are some of the most musicianship-loving fans, they’ll enjoy good artistry from other genres but for most of them nickel creek or bela fleck is like lobster newburg.
Who eats lobster newburg at every meal?
Most people in the community have straight up bluegrass as their meat and potatoes.
Bluegrass fans love good musicianship from outside the genre, like Andy statman and Michael Cleveland doing superstring theory together
But they’ll always specify that it’s not bluegrass
And if we’re calling Billy strings true bluegrass then Michael Daves is too and if we do that Billy doesn’t have a chance because most people in the know on guitar playing know Daves would smoke Billy
October 1, 2024 @ 3:53 pm
“Billy might not go over as well at bean blossom”
: D How many times have you been to Bean Blossom? Or, Brown County?
Billy would go over like a stratospheric orgasm at Bean Blossom.
We would eat him alive.
Every single one of us.
The bikers.
The Mom & Pops.
The Professionals.
October 1, 2024 @ 4:30 pm
Billy Strings has spread the love of bluegrass to the biggest audience the genre has ever enjoyed. Billy Strings is also a very good bluegrass musician.
I have no desire to get into a technical argument about talent, speed, or technique. I’m simply speaking from a bird’s eye view. And I think that assessment is hard to argue against. To say he’s not very well-known or respected in true bluegrass circles I think is patently incorrect. That may be true in “certain” bluegrass circles, or the circles you run in. I heard the Telluride House Band of Jerry Douglas, Bela Fleck, Sam Bush, Bryan Sutton, et al say Billy String has done more for bluegrass than anyone else since Bill Monroe this summer, though I’m sure you these these guys are fringe bluegrass dudes as well. I wouldn’t say this is my assessment. I would say this is the prevailing assessment of Billy Strings.
October 1, 2024 @ 8:38 pm
Recent bluegrass standards:
Wagon wheel
This Mountain
Various Steeldrivers songs
Yes, thats not many, but they do still happen
October 10, 2024 @ 2:49 pm
Don’t know if you’ll see this seeing how I missed this article due to Hurricane Helene and being without power and internet for 10 days. Can you post some links to videos or cite examples of recordings with Michael Cleveland jamming out on guitar to the degree Billy does? I obviously love Michael as a fiddle player and have even watched the Flamekeeper documentary. I’d love to dive into his guitar playing. I know he plays mandolin really well (love Lonesome Desert).
October 1, 2024 @ 6:39 pm
I love this album and Billy Strings is taking bluegrass places no one could have ever imagined. Witnessing how Del McCoury, Sam Bush, and Willie Nelson interact with Billy Strings, leaves me no doubt Bill Monroe, Lester Flatt, and Earl Scruggs would be mighty impressed.
I love watching how the big three (in my opinion) – Tyler Childers, Zach Bryan, Billy Strings – handle their business. Each so different, independent, and wildly successful. And unimaginable 15-20 years ago, because none of them would have had any success under the weight of the Nashville machine.
I agree everything you wrote and I am for one thrilled Strings keeps “doubling down on bluegrass.”
October 1, 2024 @ 6:59 pm
Par for the course on another solid Billy album.
Daresay on the first couple of listens that this is probably his most “accessible” release to date.
I do question the length of the album (album didn’t need two weed songs) and some of the sequencing – “Beginning of the End” is a perfect closer, and sounds like it was purposely written to be an album closer, but then wasn’t.
Overall those are pretty minor nits though, lots of great tracks here.
“In the Clear”
“Glid the Lilly”
“Leadfoot”
“Beginning of the End”
Will all be in steady rotation.
October 1, 2024 @ 9:44 pm
My favorite Billy album by far, although I’m a newer fan and definitely lean more toward the bluegrass side of things, so take my opinion with that in mind.
That being said, I am also a frequent user of mushrooms, and I was lucky to be tripping when this album dropped. Listened to the whole thing in one sitting, and Gild the Lily was immediately added to my “relax” playlist. That song will be on repeat for me for a while. From a stoners perspective, I actually quite enjoy MORBUD4ME, in life of how “cheesy” it can feel. Not many country artists put songs out like this, so, while I agree with your experience of it as a “silly and stupid stoner song”, this stoner appreciates it above other non-country, silly, stupid, stoner songs. For what it’s worth.
October 1, 2024 @ 11:40 pm
If you haven’t seen the official “lyric movie,” you should check it out.
https://youtu.be/HtOLVO2AMHc?si=qhLhU7Pz2QtnE3Fe
October 1, 2024 @ 10:27 pm
This album delivers. It would be my first choice, besides a show, to introduce someone to him.He is something very special. It’s silly to me that people are saying there are better players out there. Idk what the criteria is, but it’s not really a competition or judged sport. People respond to him and he sure has a list of people that want to play with him.
October 2, 2024 @ 1:39 am
Tell it like it t-i-s.
October 1, 2024 @ 11:45 pm
The mister and I watched the “Highway Prayers (Official Lyric Movie)” over the weekend, and Wow!! It’s fun. A whole set of connected, inter-related animated videos in movie format – kind of like that thing Sturgill did with anime several years back. It tells the story of the movie with the kind of characters and animations we’ve seen from his team previously. The various songs are like concert posters come to life. Give a whirl when you have 75’ish minutes to kill.
5 stars/highly recommend
https://youtu.be/HtOLVO2AMHc?si=qhLhU7Pz2QtnE3Fe
October 2, 2024 @ 5:37 am
Really good but a little long. I personally prefer albums to be around 40-50 minutes. And there are a few songs to skip on here.
October 6, 2024 @ 2:28 pm
Highway Prayers is much more consistent than I was expecting a 20 song album to be. It lacks the greatness of personal favorites like Turmoil & Tinfoil, Meet Me at the Creek, Away From the Mire, Heartbeat of America, and In the Morning Light, but it is solid and has lots of stuff ranking alongside Know It All and Taking Water—– Seven Weeks in County, Escabana, Beginning of the End, and My Alice are current favorites, though I expect others to rise over repeated listenings.
October 9, 2024 @ 11:19 am
Billy Strings‘ new album, Highway Prayers, has reached No. 1 on Billboard’s all-genre Top Album Sales chart, marking the first time a bluegrass album has secured the top spot since 2002.
October 19, 2024 @ 5:30 pm
I loved this album all the way through! Especially the inclusion of Gospel style vocals on certain songs like Richard Petty!
Also MOREBUD4ME gives me strong Hank 3 vibes, specifically the second half of Ghost To A Ghost/Guttertown with the more experimental looping and stuff