Album Review – Riley Green’s “Ain’t My Last Rodeo”

To Riley Green fans, he’s the real deal in country music, and nowhere near those mainstream pop country lightweights like Dan + Shay or Parmalee. Riley Green is an actual country music star singing actual By God country music songs. And when bringing an honest assessment to the musical accompaniment and lyrical content of his songs, that judgement is generally fair. There’s ample steel guitar, some fiddle too, and the tracks definitely touch on rural themes.
But just because something is real country doesn’t always mean that it’s real good. Riley Green might be more country than most of what you hear in the mainstream. But when listening through his second full-length album Ain’t My Last Rodeo, you also most definitely hear the mainstream in his country.
Riley Green songs are all about good ol’ boys, being raised up right, saying yes sir and ma’am, saluting the flag, putting your faith in God and country, and beating your old lady with a rubber hose. Oh wait, that last one’s from a John Prine song, but you get the point. Then Riley and his co-writers fill out the verses to these self-affirming odes with plenty of references to cans of tobacco, back roads, beer, tailgates, trucks, and all the usual bluster that accompanies these kinds of songs.
In a nutshell, Riley Green and the two or three co-writers, and three or four producers he employs on each song compile the kind of list-tacular songs that in 2015 were an annoyance, in 2019 began to feel outright repugnant, and in 2023 are so antiquated and tired, it undermines the entire listening experience, no matter how “country” they are.
Hank Jr.’s “A Country Boy Can Survive” is an all-time country music classic. But even Bocephus would tell you one is enough. The B-side to “Country Boy” was “Weatherman,” for example. Meanwhile, Ain’t My Last Rodeo is like one version of “A Country Boy Can Survive” after another. The second song on the album “They Don’t Make ‘Em Like That No More” even borrows the Bocephus line “shotgun, rife, and 4-wheel drive.”
Ain’t My Last Rodeo is a merciless run of list songs that doesn’t relent. It’s not that the premise of a song like “Mississippi Or Me” is entirely terrible, or that “Damn Good Day To Leave” isn’t a good song idea. It’s the boilerplate way the songs are fleshed out with paint-by-the-numbers country-isms that makes Riley Green songs like living clichés.

Take any one or two of these songs and separate them from the herd, and sure, they’re clever and entertaining. You understand why he has an audience, and it’s not exactly Riley Green’s fault that the list style of country songwriting has been so worn out over the last many years. But even though he might be one of the most country performers in popular country, his music is still basically Bro-Country, just without the hip-hop beats or cadences.
There is some respite from this formula though, thankfully. “Workin’ On Me” is still kind of a standard mainstream country love song, but it’s not a list song, which is a relief. The ending song “Ain’t My Damn To Give” ain’t a Riley Green co-write, it but concludes the album strongly. And unquestionably, the title track “Ain’t My Last Rodeo” makes for the album’s best moment. Sentimental and sincerely written, it’s no surprise that it’s also Riley’s only solo written track on the album.
This is the way mainstream country goes: The more cooks in the kitchen, the more generic the outcome, and the more repetitive the music. In fact, a study published earlier this year affirmed this as a statistical certitude. Riley Green and Ain’t My Last Rodeo is a great example of this. And when you see the CEO of an artist’s label in the producer credits—in this case, Scott Borchetta of Big Machine—it’s never a good sign.
The album also starts with the song “Damn Country Music.” Yes, it’s the same one that was the title track of Tim McGraw’s 2015 album. Not that it’s forbidden to cover someone else’s song in country music. Far from it. But it’s a strange decision to make the opening track to your album a song that was the title track from a previous album from the same record label.
Though Riley Green has certainly found his successful niche in the mainstream as country music’s good ol’ boy who’s not going to bend to the trends, whether they’re “woke” songs or wiggy thump production, he’s surprisingly and frustratingly unoriginal. He could be a really big part in the country revolution helping to reshape mainstream country in a more country frame. But for now he’s the reason when listeners hear Zach Bryan or Tyler Childers, it seems like night and day. The songs of Riley Green just can’t compete.
If you’re truly “country,” you don’t have to field an album of songs affirming it. It’s self-evident. Being country is more of a state of mind than it is posturing and a series of positioning statements. Riley Green is better than many of his mainstream counterparts, and Ain’t My Last Rodeo is probably better than this review would lead you to believe. But his upside potential remains much higher than his output, because his songwriting is still so stuck on the mainstream sauce.
1 1/4 Guns Up (6/10)
– – – – – – – – –
October 24, 2023 @ 8:22 am
1) herd, not heard
2) Well done for pointing out ye olde Antichrist, Scott Borchetta. I wonder how much longer Big Machine will last, especially since he sold it to BTS
October 24, 2023 @ 8:34 am
I’ve never collaborated with anyone to write a song, but I’ve been involved in plenty of group projects in school, the workplace, church, community organizations, etc. The one common thread that they all seem to have is a reluctance to accept the first idea that’s suggested no matter how good it is. It’s like if every point doesn’t have input from every collaborator they they’re not doing it right. The end result is often a very clean, polished, consistent product, but also one that’s not exceptional in any way. I feel like the same thing probably applies to songwriting.
October 24, 2023 @ 9:01 am
Riley green songs are hilarious. Even before this album, my buddies and i had a running joke how all his songs are just “they don’t make em like that no more!” and then, unbelievably, there was a song with that verbatim title on the record. so great
I take riley green songs for what they are: aggressive list songs that have good country mainstream instrumentation and a good voice – a fun guilty pleasure. “Damn good day to leave” is a banger. Since its not 2015 and there are so many better options, the cliches are actually pretty fun every once in a while. There’s a reason they exist.
Jeremy Pinnell “Goodbye LA” was voted “Most Likely to Rip In a Consistent and Pleasing Manner”
October 24, 2023 @ 1:25 pm
I looked up some of his lyrics after reading your post.
“Zebco” “Hank” “Daddy” – guaranteed to show up every time. I think he’s using AI to spit these out.
October 25, 2023 @ 7:13 am
Read your comment, checked out “Goodbye LA.” Totally agree; it’s one of the best albums I’ve heard in a while. Thanks for the tip!
October 24, 2023 @ 9:20 am
Maybe I’m blinded by the muscles but I thought it was a solid album (minus the Jelly Roll song. Can’t get through it)
The title track was a solo write and a stand out for me.
October 24, 2023 @ 9:32 am
This does well encapsulating why I’ve always been lukewarm toward Green. Taken individually, most of his songs are fine. Taken as a catalogue, they’re almost offensively mediocre,
That said, The Numbers on the Cars is pretty good. And, unsurprisingly, the song that’s the most different from the rest of his output.
October 24, 2023 @ 9:43 am
One of his first tours he named “Outlaws Like Me” and had a show in Lexington, KY, about an hour from me. Being someone that listens almost exclusively to Texas country, I rolled my eyes and wrote him off immediately. Good to know I made the right decision
October 24, 2023 @ 11:44 am
I still think “I wish every road was Copperhead” might be the dumbest country lyric I’ve heard.
October 25, 2023 @ 7:32 am
“I wish even cars had truck beds” says hold my beer!
October 25, 2023 @ 6:15 pm
Try finding 453 Copperhead LN with your GPS in your El Camino when every road is called Copperhead
October 24, 2023 @ 12:10 pm
That sounds terrible.
October 24, 2023 @ 12:24 pm
just from watching the socials, it appears that Riley Green and Jessi Alexander are good friends. I know she wrote Damn Country Music, or at least co wrote it. I wonder if that might have had something to do with him recording that track. Just spit balling
October 25, 2023 @ 4:25 am
also Jessi Alexander’s version of that song is 100 times better than McGraws
October 24, 2023 @ 1:41 pm
Significant amounts of autotune, deeply repetitive themes, dull songwriting. As a public figure/celebrity he’s also had a few unfortunate instances. Not a lot for me to enjoy or root for. There needs to be a pretty big musical shift to get on board. Otherwise, hope he’s doing well but not for me.
October 24, 2023 @ 2:40 pm
I don’t really wanna be the piling on guy, but I’d given it a couple spins when it came out and tossed it aside, thinking that Trig wouldn’t review it and we’d not be discussing it. I gave it another listen today out on the bike trail, and I still feel the same way. Kind of boring Riley Green type songs slightly similar to each other, and like everyone says, lists abound. Yeah, the title track is ok; a couple of others maybe are too. I’m one of the few on here that cares about album covers, and this one fits this music to a tee. In fact, I yawned when I first laid eyes on it. Still can’t get over the fact that on a few dates this summer on Luke’s Enormodome tour, Lainey was opening for this guy??? Probably because he tossed him that duet bone. She’ll never be doing that again. To use one of my favorites…. I wouldn’t say he’s here to hurt, but he’s not helping either. Like so many of these guys, he’s just wallowing in a sea of mediocrity.
October 24, 2023 @ 2:43 pm
You’re mostly right but I really like a few of the songs, and most aren’t that bad.
Not every song or album needs to be a masterpiece. Some can be just entertaining.
Sometimes it’s nice to hear someone sing about things you like or liked, or agree with, or that remind you of better times. It’s ok to re-use a few good cliches if they serve that purpose.
October 24, 2023 @ 3:16 pm
I did a soft listen, it isn’t that bad at all. I’m not sure there is anything great on it like I wish grandpas never died but I’ve heard worse. I like the line in the review about it’s like night n day between Zach Bryan, tyler Childers and Riley, I find it very amusing. Can’t say a hundred percent about Childers though I don’t have any of his stuff on any playlist so maybe I could. But anyhow it might be nice if Bryan could write a good a song as I wish grandpas never died, I might consider him to have some talent. Night n day indeed.
October 24, 2023 @ 4:20 pm
Riley green I love your song so much Karen
October 24, 2023 @ 7:24 pm
I thought Riley Green put out a good Album it was at #1, so cant be all bad news the one critic Criticized……
Riley has a totally distinct style from other artists. For me, I could understand his words to his songs and relate. Some of these artists, i couldnt tell u the words there singing!.
Im just leaving it there. He did have a good album release, critic cant deny him that,
Thank you for listening.
October 24, 2023 @ 7:57 pm
So he’s just Blake Shelton with some fiddle
October 24, 2023 @ 9:05 pm
I hear pretty much total mainstream country radio songs in Green’s songs. Whenever I hear a country song with somebody saying it’s not like it used to be, I feel annoyed and pretty much turn it off. I know it’s nearly impossible to come up with new subject matter, but a true artist would try to package it differently.
October 25, 2023 @ 1:19 am
One of the best country albums so far in 2023
October 25, 2023 @ 4:37 am
Al Green or Peter Green are better Greens to listen to
October 25, 2023 @ 5:48 am
Riley Green is like the independent country version of Dustin Lynch. The guy has no real identity. He started out playing generic Bro-Country, and since morphed to whatever is currently trending. Rap Country, Hip Hop Country, Luke Combs Country? and now appears to be trying to establish himself as Real Country. Guy must be hoping no one looks to far back into his back catalog.
Green may have wiggled himself into a mainstream deal and a little more spotlight, but he is far from real country. Even if he managed to release an album that sounded something similar to country music, I would pass knowing it was just the latest attempt by Green to fraud fans into thinking he’s a Real Artist.
October 26, 2023 @ 6:49 pm
Not the biggest Riley Green fan but don’t know of him ever really playing “rap country” or “hip hop country”. He’s pretty much just played basic mediocre songs to more country sounding instrumentation since the beginning. If anything, he’s never morphed.
October 26, 2023 @ 7:13 pm
I had a friend that tried to get me into Riley Green a few years back. He definitely has songs in his back catalogue where he tries to rap. You’re right, most of his stuff is generic country and bro country, but rapping was one of many things that put me off on him.
I tried to do a quick search for songs I’m talking about, but wasn’t that motivated. He’s been around for awhile as an independent before signing with Big Machine, so he’s got quite a bit of music out there.
October 27, 2023 @ 5:59 am
Just to prove to myself that I’m not crazy, I went through some of Riley’s earlier releases on Apple Music. It didn’t take long to find the song Trouble With You in which he raps. I stopped there but I’m pretty sure there are others. There’s older parts of Green’s catalog not on Apple Music as well. I’m also pretty certain he has done some collaborations with country rappers as well, but I don’t remember who, and I’ve tortured myself enough for one day to keep searching.
I don’t think Green is horrible. He’s just nothing special. His singing is bad, though production from Big Machine has cleaned it up some, and his music is just bland,
October 27, 2023 @ 7:00 pm
I agree with you there. I probably got bored of his back catalog to even find that song. Saw him open in concert, he does sound pretty awful live, if he didn’t he’d have slightly more appeal
October 25, 2023 @ 9:35 am
Judgment. Not judgement. Not judging. Love the site.
October 25, 2023 @ 11:04 am
Many joke that he sings to fund his hunting/outdoors lifestyle, which he seems way more passionate about. For me, his music is just a sort of bland country-oke type of sound. Not a particularly interesting voice, singing not particularly interesting or poignant lyrics, with melodies that all sound the same/aren’t memorable. I just listened to the new Luke Grimes EP and it has a similar feel for me. After a verse and chorus of these songs I’m feeling meh… and skip to the next. Check that box & move on, never to return again. It’s a head-scratcher because both these guys write with good songwriters.
Really sick of the ‘list songs’ and the ‘songs that mention other songs’ in the hopes to gain popularity. I don’t mind if people cover songs – I wish they did it more actually. But some of the song choices (like this one) also leave me scratching my head.
October 26, 2023 @ 8:01 am
There are some nice tunes for sure, but with all of those ‘things were better in the good old days’ lyrics there’s the nagging doubt as to whether it’s genuine or we’re all part of some elaborate hoax that is the career of Riley Green.
October 26, 2023 @ 10:02 am
Boo to your review. Love me some Riley Green!! This is a good album. Talk all the smack you want about it but the fans love it and really, that’s what really matters!!