An Open Letter to Austin City Limits About Mike & the Moonpies

Dear Terry Lickona and Austin City Limits,
To begin with, thanks as always for everything Austin City Limits has done over its historic and unprecedented run to help chronicle many of Austin’s musical legends, as well as highlighting important artists from around the country and world, both from the country and roots music community, and beyond.
Over the years, I’ve been very conservative about who I take the time to lobby for to make an appearance on the program. I can only imagine how many people are pulling at your sleeve and making very compelling arguments as to who should get the next opportunity to take the Austin City Limits stage for a taping. It was very heartening to see Ray Wylie Hubbard and Dale Watson finally get their due, not to mention newer artists such as Charley Crockett and the Turnpike Troubadours who definitely deserved their ACL berths.
But this is one of those moments where I feel like a glaring omission has presented itself in the list of ACL alumnus, and I feel that it’s my duty to make you aware of it, while weighing both the gravity of the honor, and the rarity of the opportunities you have to bestow.
Whenever I think of the quintessential Austin honky tonk band, I think of Mike and the Moonpies. A true Austin original and homegrown Austin band, they were forged in the city’s honky tonks playing those 3 to 5-hour sets for the two-step crowd, as well as residencies at some of the city’s most iconic spots like Hole in the Wall and The White Horse. For years, Mike and the Moonpies paid their dues in a way that has made Austin the musical destination that it is.
But what’s happening with the band right now has a become decidedly national and international in scope, and it deserves to be preserved for posterity on the hallowed Austin City Limits stage. Mike Harmeier is the perfect frontman with his mix of country humility and cocksure self-awareness, not to mention being one of the best songwriters in the business at the moment.
Steel guitar player Zach Moulton might be the very best at the discipline, both live and in the studio, and in regards to both taste and technique. It was bass player Omar Oyoque joining the band in 2018 that took Mike and the Moonpies to the next level, making them perennials at the very top of Saving Country Music’s “Best Live Acts” list every year with the energy and enthusiasm he brings to the position.
Catlin Rutherford is the perfect fulcrum and lead player for the rest of the band to pivot around, holding everything together as madness ensues on stage. And drummer Taylor Englert delivers that extra bolt of energy to make watching Mike and the Moonpies perform live downright euphoric.
This is the best live band in country music at the moment, and perhaps one of the best bands to see live irrespective of genre, with a big stable of songs to back it all up. Mike and the Moonpies are the kind of band that Austin and it’s musical institutions should be proud to proffer forward as being emblematic of the kind of incredible talent and wild appeal that the Austin music scene boasts and cultivates.
Mike and the Moonpies are not on some big label, and do not have eye-popping sales or chart numbers, at least not yet. But perhaps this is yet another reason they need to be highlighted. They’ve already played The Grand Ole Opry in Nashville, got their hands in the Hall of Fame at Billy Bob’s in Ft. Worth, and have played massive stages across the country at some of independent country and Americana’s biggest festivals. Now it feels like it’s time for Austin’s hometown heroes to get an opportunity on the most important and iconic stage in town.
Mike and the Moonpies recently released a live album, and on that album they covered Gary P. Nunn’s legendary “London Homesick Blues,” which I don’t need to tell you served as the Austin City Limits theme song for so many years. Mike and the Moonpies are the direct link to all those legendary Austin honky tonk bands, from Willie’s Family Band featured on the pilot episode of ACL, to Jerry Jeff Walker and Billy Joe Shaver, and everyone in between. They’re the extension of that distinct Austin legacy. All the more reason to give them this deserved distinction that they’ve earned every bit of.
Thanks for your consideration,
—Kyle “Trigger” Coroneos
savingcountrymusic.com
October 24, 2023 @ 10:56 am
Couldn’t agree more, Trig. Been telling my friends about these guys for years now, just waiting for them to get their much deserved (and much delayed!) due
October 24, 2023 @ 11:01 am
Amen.
October 24, 2023 @ 11:08 am
I’m glad you mentioned just how incredible their steel player is. That fella absolutely tears it up on the steel and I was lucky enough to watch it happen front row at an intimate venue (Will’s Pub) last year. They 100% deserve to play Austin City Limits!
October 24, 2023 @ 11:43 am
Nice album bud, been streaming it plenty since release.
October 26, 2023 @ 6:11 pm
I appreciate it JD!
October 24, 2023 @ 11:15 am
Facts
October 24, 2023 @ 11:36 am
Abso-damn-lutely
October 24, 2023 @ 1:58 pm
Still wondering why they aren’t playing larger venues or drawing larger crowds.
October 25, 2023 @ 12:13 pm
I wish some big-name mainstream star (or even Zach Bryan) would come out as a fan of theirs and ask to have them as an opener on his’her tour. Not a bro-country dinosaur like Tyler Hubbard, but maybe a Parker McCollum or Ashley McBryde, or even, if you’re thinking bigger, Dierks Bentley or even Thomas Rhett?
October 24, 2023 @ 4:45 pm
I second this motion!
October 24, 2023 @ 4:51 pm
I strongly agree with every word in this letter!
October 24, 2023 @ 5:26 pm
One of the best live bands I have seen in years. I concur that the bass player is fantastic. They are way too small. If only Mike was 23.
October 27, 2023 @ 7:06 am
You have a long way to go !!!but that is a good start?
October 24, 2023 @ 5:55 pm
ACL didn’t move up to Oklahoma with the rest of the late Austin music scene yet? #TCL
October 24, 2023 @ 6:17 pm
We saw them at a small venue in the last year. The crowd was down due to bad weather, but it was still shocking how few were there for such a good band. Those present enjoyed the heck out of the show. I keep telling people about them, and no one knows who I’m talking about. Not sure what it’s going to take to get them to the next level, but they deserve it.
October 25, 2023 @ 4:48 am
Totally agree, i was lucky enough to see’em live in a hole in the wall somewhere in Germany and they blew the roof off! Omar is a death metal fan but oddly fits in perfectly and you’re also right about that steel guitar, sweet!!
October 25, 2023 @ 5:29 am
Great piece, well crafted and persuasive.
I wonder if the Moonpies could get a big boost out of the Grateful Dead method. Invite tapers and exchange of live recordings. Maybe regularly release free soundboards. Maybe give someone on their crew a camera and put shows/pieces of shows on YouTube regularly.
It might really work for them, even though their music differs from improv rock.
October 25, 2023 @ 7:00 am
I have seen them play either in WI or FL five times. Saw them on a week night during the Steak Night Tour in Milwaukee and I was one of 23 people. Next time, it was on a weekend and was more like 100. Florida shows were part of Mile 0 Fest so the crowds were naturally larger. If they have not broken through by now I am not sure they ever will. Great band, great shows.
October 25, 2023 @ 8:50 am
I’m not sure who all you people are wishing for them to become more popular are? I love being able to pay 20 bucks to see one of the most entertaining bands out there and having them appear on ASL will only screw that up.
I will gladly contribute to a fund that keeps them from the arena tour/ticket master bullshit that has become popular.
October 25, 2023 @ 12:13 pm
Should have said ACL. ASL might help with another group of people.
October 28, 2023 @ 10:15 pm
I agree with you, I hate when my favorite gift bands get big. By the same token, it’s nice for them to be able to make a living so that they can continue to tour and put out new music. I am pretty sure playing in small clubs for 20 or 30 people for $20 per person and traveling around in a van will drive them to the poorhouse pretty quickly.
October 25, 2023 @ 9:09 am
This is a response from an Austin local musician (since the 80s).
ACL Televison Show made a decision to appeal to a new and ever changing demographic around year 2000.
They once did a “Showcase” of Austin locals as a sixpack. Don Walser, The Derailers etc. I’m certain it had little worldwide inpact. But in reality does an artist of the stature of Kacey Musgraves RECEIVE any additional import or impact from an appearance on a relatively small PBS show?
October 25, 2023 @ 9:25 am
There’s a few reasons why they aren’t bigger than they are:
-Mike’s voice isn’t the greatest.
– Not a lot of stage presence / heartthrob appeal.
– Their lyrics are somewhere in a no man’s land between profound and cheesy love songs. The melodies are good but not super memorable.
I say all of this as someone who has all their albums and had a blast at their show. I think they’re great but I can also understand why they haven’t caught on more, if I’m honest about it.
October 25, 2023 @ 6:03 pm
All true. I saw them when they first started out and they were full of energy and their fun in playing translated into the audience having a great time. It was packed the two or three times we went to see them, but it was free shows. I saw them a few years later when they showed up to a festival clearly hungover and not wanting to be there. Absolutely no stage presence and mediocre songs and vocals. I hope alcohol isn’t the issue but they didn’t win over any fans that day.
October 25, 2023 @ 7:01 pm
“Not a lot of stage presence / heartthrob appeal.”
I strongly disagree. I think that the stage presence of Mike and the Moonpies is unparalleled.
I would agree they’re not exactly underwear models like Midland, but I don’t know how that would preclude them from being popular in 2023. Luke Combs and Jelly Roll don’t really fit that mold, and they’re massive.
I think if the Moonpies had formed in 2019 like bands such as 49 Winchester and The Red Clay Strays, they would be getting buzzed like those bands are now. But some consider them a known quantity, and so they get overlooked until they’re experienced live.
This is what was critical to the Turnpike Troubadours explosion. They’re hiatus/breakup allowed them to start anew, and they were able to achieve the heights we all knew they were capable of before.
I’d still take the long perspective on Mike and the Moonpies. You see the crowds and interest growing. They release the right album and get some good live opportunities, and they could find the next level. But they do almost everything in-house, and will only get big doing it their way.
October 26, 2023 @ 7:54 am
I like their stage presence, but I’m obviously not talking about what you or I think.
And yes if you have a great voice or write lyrics that speak to enough people, you don’t have to be an underwear model.
October 25, 2023 @ 10:19 am
Why would ACL have the Moonpies on when they could have another punk pop emo band in sticking with the tradition started by Willie Nelson in the 1970s? Austin City Limits don’t give a shit about the Austin music scene
October 26, 2023 @ 6:48 am
Agree. M & the MP’s are top shelf country music. I place some blame too on the Sirius Outlaw channel. I’ve heard M & MP’s a few times on there but not nearly as much as the Nashville bestowed/NPR crowd country artists – who I do enjoy hearing as well. But both these outlets – ACL and Sirius Outlaw – ought to take a lesson from Trigger and own up to the responsibility of properly curating current country music.
October 26, 2023 @ 8:53 am
In my opinion, their name does them a disservice. Sounds like a satire band. Also, considering Chattanooga Bakery, Inc. owns the Trademark to “Moonpie”, I’m curious if they have had any contact with the band concerning that issue. Otherwise, they are one of my favorites.
October 26, 2023 @ 9:17 am
I feel the same way about Reckless Kelly. They deserve an invite.
October 26, 2023 @ 2:42 pm
Second the motion, Trig. SCM is what turned me on to them about two years ago, and being that Atlanta doesnt get a taste of them often, ive been clamoring for them to come back. Next month, Ill be front row when they are in town….and telling anyone who will listen how great they are.