Bruce Springsteen’s Desert Drift on New Album “Western Stars”
New solo album brings a slightly more hopeful chapter to Bruce’s fascination with the West.
– – – – – – – – – –
Editors Note: This review is a contribution by writer John Duffy. Let’s make him feel welcome here at Saving Country Music.
Bruce Springsteen has been so long associated with the working-class East Coast that it’s easy to forget he has spent almost as much of his career looking westward. In 1980 he may have sang about going “to where the highway ends and the desert breaks out onto an open road,” but a generation of restless young men and women “pulling out of here to win” eventually had to land somewhere. The road is long, but it does not, in fact, go on forever.
But most found the same uncertainty and confinement they were running from. In the sweeping vista of Bruce Springsteen’s Western Stars they find if not peace, perhaps a final vindication in their roaming. Choosing a life on the road may mean never being able to go home again, burning your bridges. It is almost exclusively on his solo albums that Bruce has confined his distinctly Western tales, and each time the stakes are higher and costs are greater for the characters he gives voice to. In the land of Bruce, the West is a place to take chances, to risk everything. There are more horses than cars, and more chances missed than resolved.
It was on the sparse echo of Nebraska, recorded shortly after discovering both Hank Williams and James Agee, where Springsteen first looked over the Appalachians. Songs about nihilist murder sprees and lawmen with conflicted loyalties naturally demanded a lonelier, emptier setting than New Jersey. Heck even “Atlantic City” had as much to do with Las Vegas as it does the Jersey shore. After a decade living in Southern California—before settling he’d been regularly driving there, mostly alone, since the late 1960’s when his parents fled New Jersey—he gave us The Ghost of Tom Joad. And a whole new crop of adventurers and outcasts filled the Southwest borderlands and desert interiors. The all-or-nothing landscape of Steinbeck and Guthrie was alive and well.
In 2005 Bruce revisited the west on Devils and Dust. Now the stories were even more harrowing; drowned Mexican migrants, prostitutes, runaways, drug mules, aging hobos, homeless vets, restless convicts all lured by easy money, a second chance, or a last chance. And they all paid a serious price for their shot at possibility: a brother’s violent death, addiction, permanent moral compromise, and guilt. The West was an unforgiving place that never quite delivered on its promise, and the songs were almost universally bleak, more so thanks to their religiously simple folk instrumentation: voice, guitar, maybe harmonica.
The intimacy of Bruce’s earlier “West” records is replaced by a truly cinematic scope, because things are still possible here. Pedal steel and throaty, tremolo guitars paint pastoral soundscapes interwoven with sweeping strings and orchestral horns; more Countrypolitan than country. Glen Campbell, not Gram Parsons. Think “Wichita Lineman,” “Good Time Charlie’s got the Blues.” And if you still have an actual stereo system, you’re in luck. Western Stars is a big sound the demands big speakers. Makes total sense when you think about it, after all this is a guy whose childhood Saturday afternoons were lensed by John Ford and scored by Elmer Bernstein.
On Western Stars the West is finally a place of redemption…for some. Others are still wandering, but they haven’t given up. The aging cowboy actor of the title track—here Bruce uses “stars” as a sort of pun—still happily gets free drinks for his past exploits and still drives out to “ride and rope” in what still sounds like a landscape of endless imagination. “The Hitch Hiker,” and “The Wayfarer” both see domestic life as a one-way ticket to misery, the latter counting the white lines of the highway, not sheep, as he drifts off.
“Tucson Train” finds a man who fled domestic strife waiting for his happiness to return and start anew. “Hello Sunshine,” the album’s first single and perhaps the record’s most insular tune, finds a man who once craved loneliness now seeing the daylight itself as a harbinger of better times. The youngster who left everything behind to go “Chasin’ Wild Horses” up in Montana may have found no escape from the memory of who he left behind, but he’s not dying under an overpass or blown up in a meth lab. If Nebraska, Tom Joad, and Devils were space for restless, marginalized, fallen characters, Western Stars is for the lucky ones, of the ones for whom the romance of the West has not yet dried up.
– – – – – – – – – –
June 14, 2019 @ 8:26 am
Never been the biggest Springsteen fan (not enough pure guitar-rock riffs and hooks for me – which strikes me as weird since he was touted as the savior of American “rock & roll” in the 70’s), but I’ve always respected him. Especially his live show, which I’ve seen at least once. Guy is a beast, especially considering his age. I thought maybe he’d finally win me over with this album, what with the explicit country western influences and references. But, after giving it a whirl today, I’m not sure it’s gonna happen. A little too polished. Maybe a little too hokey too.
June 14, 2019 @ 7:07 pm
I’ve not heard it yet, but I think I know what you mean. I think he’s an excellent songwriter, but the production on his records – especially with the E Street Band – kinda kills it for me. I think *Nebraska* and *Tom Joad* are unimpeachably brilliant from start to finish, but everything else? Overproduced. Bruce alone with a guitar does it. Everything else, I think, gets in the way of his songwriting.
June 15, 2019 @ 2:11 pm
Have you ever listened to Tunnel of Love? Pretty sparse. Came out when I was in HS so I didn’t appreciate the themes like I do today. One Step Up and Two Faces are two of my favorites on the album.
June 16, 2019 @ 3:31 pm
I never hear anyone talk about the Seeger Sessions record. Excellent Americana.
June 17, 2019 @ 4:26 pm
And the follow up live in Dublin double album. Its great
June 18, 2019 @ 1:08 pm
I completely agree. The Seeger Sessions is a great album. I loved it and keep on listening to it today. “Shenandoah”, “Old Dan Tucker”, “John Henry”, “Pay me my money down” or “Jesse James” are awesome songs. This album is a masterpiece. It’s a major reference for americana and folk lovers.
June 14, 2019 @ 8:42 am
Been listening to it this morning. Some of his best songwriting in a long time too especially the title track. The production seemed a little too polished on first listen and it may not be country in the traditional sense but if the intent is to pay homage to the 60’s recordings of Glen Campbell it succeeds.
June 14, 2019 @ 7:48 pm
Webb and Glen crossed my mind immediately . And THAT excited me , being a fan of both those gifted guys
June 14, 2019 @ 8:42 am
Welcome, Duffster. Nice piece. And your article’s pretty good, too. 😉
I’ve heard one track of this so far. I expect this will be a good release for the boss, and that I’ll like it some better than his other solo releases mentioned above.
That said, I’m not sure I’d ever head to Bruce for my fix of country tinged folk-rock western music, but I do appreciate his take on things. I am a moderate fan–having purchased most of his stuff up through the eighties, and Darkness on the Edge of Town being one of my top 25 songs of all time. If he could translate the feel of that song to stuff like this release he’d really have something.
June 14, 2019 @ 9:20 am
Admittedly not though with my first pass through the album yet, is this perhaps the soundtrack for an upcoming Costner or Pitt flick?
Seriously, it doesn’t strike me as particularly Country. More of a Western music filtered through a pop rock orchestra vibe. Not hating it. Can see it being presented live with full band/orchestra, and a video backing with depicting appropriate scenes. A concert with a videotrack, if you will.
Doesn’t unrelentingly grab me like Born to Run or Darkness on the Edge of Town, but interesting.
June 14, 2019 @ 10:37 am
See I’m on the other side, I’m a fan of Born to Run and Darkness and I could hear some of the instrument styles on this album alongside the strings and the Pedal Steel guitar, and I think this is his best since Born to Run.
June 14, 2019 @ 10:19 am
Just to add to everyone’s tore of information with respect to The Boss and The West:
Another one of the Boss’s “Western” excursions happened in 2007, when he was featured on a tribute album to the great Italian-born film composer Ennio Morricone. He did a version of Morricone’s theme music to the 1969 Sergio Leone masterpiece ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST (it won a Grammy for Best Rock Instrumental).
June 14, 2019 @ 10:20 am
Given the artists of stature we’ve lost over the last few years, I’m happy to have anything new from Bruce, and find this one really intriguing. Looking forward to putting it on the turntable tonight.
June 14, 2019 @ 11:44 am
Welcome John. Nicely written review. My only constructive criticism, and not uncommon in most reviews, is the emphasis on the lyrics and themes. Of course this is just my opinion, and I realize that musical melodies and hooks (in other words the musical quality of the songs) are subjective, but I find it strange that so few critics are willing to rate the quality of the actual music. This review was great at putting Bruce’s themes on this album in context with past works, etc, and did touch on the instrumentation, but what I want to know (in addition to what you have stated), is… before investing some time in this album is: Is the MUSIC, in your opinion, good? Will any of the melodies get stuck in my head? How does the musical song craft compare to his past albums?
Thanks again and welcome.
June 14, 2019 @ 2:34 pm
The songs are not his best. I was losing the will to live actually getting through the thing. Nothing memorable at all except the appalling songs and even worse production where all the strings, even the accordian, sound like they are synthesised. It’s not country. It’s not good either.
June 14, 2019 @ 5:05 pm
Thanks, appreciated!
June 14, 2019 @ 10:32 pm
Hey Scott G,
Just to clarify, Scott Duffy reached out with the idea of writing a feature on “Western Stars,” and it was so well-written, I couldn’t turn it down. I don’t think he meant it to be solely a “review,” though I would consider it very similar to review aside from sharing more specific opinions about the music.
June 15, 2019 @ 8:38 am
Cool. And now he’s another Scott? ????
June 14, 2019 @ 4:15 pm
Bruce certainly has a vivd imagination, and way with lyrics and a simple melody.
He wrote a song I like a lot in the same vein called “across the border” Emmy Lou Neil Young Linda Ronstad ….
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OfCS1yXg8gk
Don’t have to have lived a certain life to be able to write a good song about it.
Very Interesting review, thanks…. I look forward to more from John.
June 14, 2019 @ 7:46 pm
How interesting and refreshing is this song musically . VERY .
How hard would that be for ANY up-and -coming main-streamer to deliver ? NOT VERY . But you have to WANT TO . And so few do .
Pretty -much that’s why I’m liking this track . Lyrically …maybe a bit ambiguous …but it sets a mood and that’s half the mission , of course . It’s audible and its not syncopated for syncopation’s sake . Bruce delivers a second-to-none vocal performance and the trad instruments are sheer icing . Lyrically ,as I said , I’m on the fence . But that feels way better than being put out to pasture .
June 14, 2019 @ 8:35 pm
I’d rather listen to fingernails scraping across a chalkboard than Springsteen, so I probably won’t li ke this…
June 14, 2019 @ 10:30 pm
I for one welcome John here. This blog/site is a massive undertaking for 1 (albeit incredible) person to handle everyday etc…. So I appreciate Trig acknowledging that. That being said this artist was never my “boss” and although I understand he’s a legend in some musical circles this album or man has no bearing on my current or past life whatsoever. There’s way too much actual Country music to discuss and listen to………. of course as I write this I’m “Good and Drunk” as I just got back from watching Ward Davis tear up Joe’s On Weed St. 🙂
June 15, 2019 @ 3:42 am
I’m a BS fan and i don’t have to stretch out is one of the greatest songwriter and performer of our generation. That said he always had “production” issues in his records and now in his 70s i’d rather listen to him with a 60s Nashville orchestral arrangement than a noisy pastiche with Tom Morello on guitar(high hopes).
June 15, 2019 @ 5:46 am
I’m a huge fan of the boss, the hop half of my right on is a Springsteen tattoo.
I’m sorry but this album is corny, contrite, patronizing, manufactured and full of cliches Springsteen has never lived or understood.
Will not be played twice within earshot of me.
June 15, 2019 @ 9:33 pm
Oh, relax.
And that is a foolish thing to tattoo on your body, Knucklehead.
June 15, 2019 @ 6:34 am
I’m and Bruce and Southside Johnny guy and have been since the late ’70s. When I heard about this upcoming project, I was intrigued but took a “wait and see” attitude. I haven’t really enjoyed a Bruce album of originals since Devils and Dust in 2005 and I wasn’t sure I’d really be into this new direction anyway. After my first listen (a casual one with my morning coffee and bagel), I wasn’t terribly moved. But because it’s Bruce, I sat down and gave it two listens last night and was won over. Ordered it and listened to it again this morning just for the pleasure of it. It feels good to be happy with a new Bruce album again. It’s been a long time comin’ but now it’s here.
June 15, 2019 @ 7:33 am
Yeah… It takes a couple of listens to get it. Just about every review I’d read of the record prior to it’s release said the same thing.
June 15, 2019 @ 4:26 pm
“There Goes My Miracle”
Song of the year.
Springsteen is God.
June 15, 2019 @ 8:04 pm
Final Track, Moonlight Motel: I know Bruce has been admiring Jason Isbell’s work recently like most of us have and everytime I hear this song it makes me think that maybe Isbell had an influence in Bruce’s writing of that song. Like I could not only hear Isbell singing it, but also felt like he wrote it.
June 15, 2019 @ 8:51 pm
Yes, It’s Bruce….no more need be said, except…..it’s still more country than any Luke Bryan song.
June 16, 2019 @ 3:29 pm
As someone stated above, think I’m gonna need a couple of runs through it to see if it sticks.
And I’m still waiting for the media’s pronouncement that not only is this a country album, it’s one of the best country albums of the year.
Mark my words, it’ll happen.
June 16, 2019 @ 3:49 pm
I’m not seeing or expecting that at all. In fact I think the bigger problem here is that country fans are pronouncing it a country album and judging it as such, when Springsteen isn’t even saying that. He’s just calling it a solo Springsteen album.
June 16, 2019 @ 5:42 pm
I hope you’re right, but Bruce has always been a mainstream music media darling (especially RS), and in today’s climate regarding country music and how it’s defined, I just see this lining up perfectly for them to jump all over.
June 16, 2019 @ 6:35 pm
The problem is he’s not political enough on this record, and he’s a while male. I’m sure it will get some love, but when Margo Price releases a record proclaiming American as a great Satan, it’ll inch out an EP from Lil Nas X as the top in country.
June 16, 2019 @ 8:04 pm
That comment would be a lot funnier if there wasn’t so much truth within.
June 18, 2019 @ 10:32 am
Lifelong Jersey boy plus Bruce and country music fan here. It’s a good not great album, mainly due to the songwriting keeping to simple changes and melodies, which aren’t particularly memorable, and relying on orchestration to prop up the songs. That said, There Goes My Miracle has a terrific chorus, Hello Sunshine has that late 60s shuffle like Merle’s I Take a Lot of Pride or Nilsson’s Everybody’s Talking, and Stones, Tucson Train and Western Stars are all good. But there’s a sameness to it that tends to make it fade out into the background after a while. “Tomorrow Never Knows” from Working on a Dream shows what he can do when he really wants to write country.
June 19, 2019 @ 6:18 pm
I’m a 30 year old lifelong Springsteen fan, who has recently been really diving deep into Country music. This website has been a really great resource to point me in the right direction and avoid the bullshit. I really enjoyed this album tremendously. Springsteen could have easily cashed out and made a very political record. Instead he seems to have made the record he felt like making from a passion stand point.
June 19, 2019 @ 7:24 pm
Glad you found the site!
June 20, 2019 @ 5:18 am
Now Mansion Bruce is pretending that he understands the plight of struggling westerners.
Great.
June 20, 2019 @ 6:48 am
Almost like DraftDodgin’ Donald!
June 20, 2019 @ 5:41 pm
TDS claims another triggered victim!
June 21, 2019 @ 7:25 am
TDS? Trump Draft-dodging Syndrome? Nah, I served my country. Watch out for those wind turbines today, Country Quixote. They cause bigly cancer.