Saving Country Music’s 2017 Album of the Year
Country music will not be saved by just one soul, even though this is a thought process many fans and much of the media tend to buy into, often putting an unfair burden on the careers and purpose of certain artists, and placing them at odds with what they should be focused on, which is the creative process. In truth, it will take a generation of artists to erase the decades of backsliding country music has experienced, and even more to maintain that balance where the roots of the genre are well-represented right beside the contemporary sounds in a more healthy and inclusive country music genre.
Each new artist that emerges and carries with them the promise of helping to right the direction of country music does so through the efforts of the artists who came before them. Hank Williams III made it possible for a country music artist to build a grassroots network of support, allowing them to circumvent the need for Music Row’s career models. Sturgill Simpson proved that an artist could take that independent model and make it so overwhelmingly successful, they could eventually win a Grammy. Sturgill also proved you could make a record your way, with your own band in a matter of a week or two, inspiring Chris Stapleton to take the same approach, which then proved you could have such overwhelming commercial success with it, you wouldn’t need commercial radio.
And onward and upward where the newest artists are boosted up by the achievements of the artists before them who built foundations, and shattered glass ceilings. And of course all of these modern artists carry with them the legacy of the Outlaws and others who trudged forward the independent way, and helped keep the roots of the music alive.
Tyler Childers is no more a new artist than Chris Stapleton or Sturgill Simpson were when they first struck a national narrative. For more than half a decade before he became the hot name in independent country, Tyler Childers was the hot name in small circles in Kentucky, West Virginia, and certain parts of Tennessee for the folks with their noses to the ground, looking for the “next one.” Saving Country Music never received more suggestions about an artist who could be the “next one,” or inquiries of when new music might be on the way than with Tyler Childers as the years elongated between the time when he released his first original album in 2011.
But it wasn’t Tyler’s time yet. The work hadn’t been achieved by his predecessors to make it possible for an artist as authentic as Tyler Childers to find the type of wide reception his music deserved. It took two other Kentucky natives in Sturgill Simpson and Chris Stapleton breaking down barriers for the time to come right for Tyler Childers. And now that Chris Stapleton has ascended to such latitudes it seems silly to say his name in the same breath as other underdogs, and Sturgill Simpson has moved on to things that don’t always constitute traditional country music, it’s time for an artist like Tyler Childers to take their place as a traditionally-inspired country artist independent fans can champion. And he has done so resoundingly with Purgatory.
Country music is music from the people of the country, and that’s what you get with Purgatory. Within the songwriting and the music is a rawness and honesty often not welcome in the mainstream, even though an appetite for the type of soul Tyler Childers captures within the phrases is widespread.
It was a difficult year to choose who ascended to the top of the heap when it comes to country music records. John Moreland released a career effort that it feels almost criminal to place second to anything, but was inched out from being more singer/songwriter than country. Jaime Wyatt’s Felony Blues might have been the most infectious, and was only held back by the shortness of the project. Any time Jason Isbell releases a record it’s probably worth regarding as one of the top efforts, and for people “in the know,” the same goes for Joseph Huber. Zephaniah Ohora will undoubtedly be back to challenge for this distinction in the future if This Highway is any indication. Marty Stuart proved he’s not content sitting on his laurels with Way Out West. And slotting the Turnpike Troubadours 2nd to anyone seems just about criminal.
But this Album of the Year distinction seemed dangling out there for Tyler Childers to snatch up for years. It just wasn’t the right time yet. Now it is. Tyler exuded patience, until everything aligned where he could put the record together he knew he was capable of, even if the rest of us were impatient in waiting.
READ: Nominees for the 2017 Saving Country Music Album of the Year
December 26, 2017 @ 10:52 am
Slow clap.
December 26, 2017 @ 10:55 am
Also worth noting that Tyler Childers ran away with the popular vote here in the comments section. That made a very difficult decision this year a little bit easier for me.
December 26, 2017 @ 10:59 am
I thought about this extensively, spinning my tires for the most part. I concluded that the best album for me personally is a tie between Nashville Sound from Jason Isbell, and Purgatory.
I’m not upset about this decision in the least bit. It is a timeless effort on behalf of Mr. Childers. I am definitely listening now.
December 27, 2017 @ 7:53 am
Jason Isbell seems, to me, to really be breaking out with this album. I keep thinking its almost mildly unfortunate, because the album is very good and has some GREAT songs. But I actually don’t think it’s as good as either of the previous two from him, Something More Than Free or Southeastern. Completely subjective, obviously, but I find myself wishing that people just discovering him would be doing it with one of those. I’m clearly wrong though, because this album certainly seems to be working for him! (My fave is Molotov.)
December 27, 2017 @ 8:31 am
I would say he broke out with Southeastern and the momentum has continued to steadily build because of two more first rate efforts and his and the 400 Unit’s reputation as a killer live act.
I think Southeastern is a landmark album and the best of last three, but both SMTF and The Nashville Sound were among my favorites of their respective years.
December 27, 2017 @ 9:10 am
You’re right about Southeastern. Break out wasn’t the right word. But he seems to be getting more mainstream recognition with this album. And I really like this album, by the way.
December 27, 2017 @ 1:16 pm
I prefer it to SMTF, which sounds a little sterile outside of Palmetto Rose.
Southeastern might be my favorite album of the last 5 years, though.
December 30, 2017 @ 1:20 pm
I had given the earlier albums a brief listen, but nothing really stuck to me. Then, after Nashville Sound, I went back to relisten, and found both of those albums are stellar. I think a lot of people, like me, find them to be an acquired taste.
December 26, 2017 @ 11:01 am
I’m ambivalant about this album, I love Universal Sound and Lady May off of this record, but didn’t really care for Banded Clovis and Purgatory. little too much fiddle for me. At least Isbell didn’t get it this year.
December 26, 2017 @ 11:51 am
NO such thing as too much fiddle.
December 26, 2017 @ 5:32 pm
Megan, I do believe you are correct.
December 27, 2017 @ 9:53 am
I don’t much like Banded Clovis, but I think Purgatory is fantastic. This album definitely wins the year for me, followed by TPT and Isbell.
January 3, 2018 @ 3:25 pm
I hate to question the musical direction of an artist, but I’ve heard Tyler perform these songs acoustic and solo for months/years prior to this album. I agree some of the instrumentation seems a little overdone based on how well I’ve come to know them Acoustically. I’m so happy for Tyler. He’s the real deal and it’s great that he’s finally getting recognition for his songwriting abilities.
December 26, 2017 @ 11:14 am
I would suggest to people to get Tyler’s Red Barn albums. Both the blue and red additions. Great songs on both.
December 26, 2017 @ 5:33 pm
Bottles and Bibles is another worthy one to check out.
December 26, 2017 @ 11:17 am
I honestly didn’t enjoy this record. It almost sounds too authentic to take it seriously. And it really adds little to the canon of country music. I don’t doubt the sincerity of the effort but for my tastes it’s just bland. Also, I disagree with the assessment that John Moreland comes off as more singer/songwriter than country. If anything I think Tyler Childers is the more singer/songwriter of the two. To me Big Bad Luv was just too good to not win out here.
December 26, 2017 @ 11:59 am
Maybe it’s a weakness for pop, but I felt that Big Bad Luv, like ALWFYH, suffered from a lack of showstoppers relative to previous efforts.
It needed a High on Tulsa Heat, a Nobody Gives a Damn About Songs Anymore, or a Break My Heart Sweetly to tie the whole thing together.
December 26, 2017 @ 12:14 pm
It’s a shame when you can only give something to one person that it feels like a slight to everyone else when that’s not what is intended. John Moreland put out a career effort this year, and I listened to “Big Bad Luv” more than I did “Purgatory.” He definitely came #2 in the running.
December 26, 2017 @ 8:09 pm
If you lke Moreland, check out Jeremy Pinnell. His 2017 album is a glaring oversight, his voice has that authentic growl and pain that Moreland brings, and he is firmly grounded in country roots in his music. Moreland is great for the miserable soul he is (I also love Townes), but that shit gets a bit taxing after a while and has been done over and over.
December 27, 2017 @ 7:49 am
The White Buffalo put out an album thatvin my opinion is better than anything offered in this poll
With that said, the content that trigger puts out on this site is truly amazing
Thank You for all of your hard work
December 26, 2017 @ 11:39 am
I’ll give it a listen. But, my vote for the best of the year had to go to Moreland. It was just stunning and stellar from opening to close. It was perfectly produced (for once), the vocals shone, and the whole effort was cohesive and timeless.
December 26, 2017 @ 11:52 am
For me it was a 3 way tie between Tyler, Colter Wall’s self titled, and Jason Isbell’s latest.
December 26, 2017 @ 11:55 am
Tyler Childers?!
Well…a good reason to listen to the album. So far “Universal Sound” is the only song i know & i’m not very impressed.
My Album Of The Year: Lee Ann Womack – The Lonely, The Lonesome & The Gone
From “All The Trouble” to “Take The Devil Out Of Me”…the new songs & the cover versions…an all-around great album.
Runner-up: Gretta Ziller – Queen Of Boomtown / Jaryd Lane – American Country Southern Rock n’ Roll
EP Of The Year: Liam Kennedy-Clark – Travelling Lines
Young guy from New Zealand living in Australia now. Singer/Songwriter/Producer & Multi-Instrumentalist. Mixing traditional country music with modern elements.
My first album for 2018: Phil Doublet – Strength, Love, Music & Light
New Zealand country artist. “Hands” is on my list for best song of 2018 already now.
December 26, 2017 @ 12:17 pm
” So far “Universal Sound” is the only song i know & i’m not very impressed.”
No matter how you feel about “Universal Sound” (and it’s the song that draws out the most opinions on the record), I think everyone who has listened to “Purgatory” at least once would agree that is the absolute worst song to judge this album on. It is far and away the outlier. I happen to think it’s great. But I think it’s better in the context of the album, and can see how it would be exposed without it.
December 26, 2017 @ 12:35 pm
Am I the only one who liked the title track? Really?
December 26, 2017 @ 3:37 pm
I’m listening to the Tyler Childers album right now. So far the best track is “Whitehouse Road”.
December 26, 2017 @ 12:21 pm
Yasss to Lee Ann Womack. Now THAT’S an album full of authentic country music. I’m really surprised no other women made the nominations list…Chelle Rose being another that should have been on this list.
December 26, 2017 @ 12:32 pm
Jaime Wyatt’s “Felony Blues,” Lilly Hiatt’s “Trinity Lane,” and Sunny Sweeney’s “Trophy” were all nominated. Here were the nominees:
https://savingcountrymusic.com/nominees-for-the-2017-saving-country-music-album-of-the-year/
Also, Sunny Sweeney’s “Bottle By My Bed” won for Song of the Year, so I think it’s a little tough to call gender bias here.
There will also be a much more extensive “Essential Albums List” posted soon, so if there are albums you see that you feel are left out, understand they may be highlighted in the future.
December 26, 2017 @ 11:56 am
Good choice that is hard to argue with. I wouldn’t have disagreed if Eady or Stewart won, but it’s hard to beat Purgatory this year.
December 26, 2017 @ 11:57 am
This is a great album and my most played of 2017. I think perhaps its only flaw was that it could have been even better. As an album, it’s great, but I can’t pick one song that absolutely blows me out of the water on its own, and sometimes I felt like he was playing a bit safe vocally. All small nitpicks and criticisms worthy of an artist whom I feel is capable of so much and characteristic of the high standards to which I hold him. I don’t even think Tyler Childers knows how good Tyler Childers is, and it’s his next album which I think will be the one to be even more career-defining and blow everyone away.
December 26, 2017 @ 12:23 pm
Couldnt agree with this choice more! Im very biased being from kentucky but as a country music fan, Purgatory has it all. Outlaw anthems, bluegrass, indie, and folk storytelling, its all here! Very deserving effort from Tyler.
December 26, 2017 @ 12:30 pm
Is it weird that I actually squealed a little when I scrolled far enough to see the winner?
Being that I’m from one of the those areas of WV that Tyler started out in, Purgatory is such a beautiful ode to home for me. I just wish my papaw was still alive to hear that the front porch music of his childhood still lives on.
If Tyler Childers is the future, we’re in damn good hands.
December 26, 2017 @ 1:40 pm
+1
This is an album rooted in a place. Even the title suggests that interest. With so much placeless music being stamped out these days, Tyler’s record is a reminder that home-grown music draws from deeper roots. Hydroponic crap has no flavor. Tyler does. I hope when success hits him he doesn’t fold. He’s a real fine writer, one of the best of his generation.
December 26, 2017 @ 12:36 pm
¡Purgatorio!
December 26, 2017 @ 1:19 pm
Should have been land of cotton by Jonathan east
December 26, 2017 @ 1:27 pm
I’ve been reading you for a long time, Trigger. I finally needed to leave a comment letting you know how much I enjoy this site. I’m someone who likes some of the folks in the world of popular, mainstream country music world, but I also love finding all of the great independent musicians who are making really good, authentic music, that doesn’t get recognized by the industry. I’m a long time fan of Chris Knight and I wanted to find more good musicians and song writers like him. Thank you for helping intodruce to me to some of those artists such as Whiskey Myers, John Moreland, Cody Jinks, and Tyler Childers. I love this record and can’t stop listening to it, and I’m glad to see you recognize it again. I live in middle Tennessee, and we have a radio station that helps with this, but you’re the main reason I know so many of these musicians. Keep doing what your doing.
December 26, 2017 @ 2:09 pm
Thanks for reading Jeremiah.
December 26, 2017 @ 2:40 pm
There were a lot of quality albums this year.
I really explored many of them albums to the point of knowing them well, understanding them, etc. Most of your nominations.
The album that just keeps getting played is Purgatory. Everyone has their tastes. This was my album of the year.
A bit of bias, I did have the pleasure of catching a couple Tyler shows this year. This was after he added the fiddle/guitar/etc player. Along with the story telling he does and just the pro he is live, it added even more to what the album was to me.
I was also amazed how this album has caught on with my wife (not so surprised with her, she likes some good stuff, but she can recite it now.lol.) and friends. Play on dart teams out with a jukebox all the time. He is now being played quite a bit.
There are a dozen people in my circles with tix to see his next show.
This doesn’t happen often with them.
Good Choice.
On a side note:
Was watching something TV the other nite. It wasn’t a music channel (I don’t think) and it wasn’t a music program, just some tv show.
A commercial comes on for Jason Isbell’s Nashville Sound album, featuring the song If We Were Vampires
Nothing wrong there, but It was so unexpected to see that. LOL.
December 26, 2017 @ 11:27 pm
I was watching Forged in Fire on the History channel and saw that commercial. I had the same reaction – very unexpected. Very happy, but surprised at the same time.
December 26, 2017 @ 3:13 pm
It’s a rare thing in a man’s life when fortune provides the luxury of a song that stops him dead in his tracks. A musician that can provide that level of emotion in his music is a gift. We have a few of these artists that walk among us these days. When I first listened to Purgatory all the way through I found myself drawn in…hanging on every word. Several times I had chills going up my spine…this music is that good. Thank you Saving Country Music for recognizing how special this music is.
December 26, 2017 @ 3:35 pm
Looking over West Virginia
Smoking Spirits on the roof
She asked ain’t anybody told ya
That them things are bad for you
Great album and a great article!
December 26, 2017 @ 3:48 pm
Well, after giving it a listen I can see why you picked it, it sounds great, but too much drug use for me, and he couldn’t get past the second song without dropping an F bomb. Guess I’m just getting old or something.
December 27, 2017 @ 12:27 am
Drug use is effecting almost every family in some form in the ky wv and ohio area probably the whole country so how can You not write about it.
December 27, 2017 @ 2:51 am
An unfortunate truth. I do wish the F bomb would be reduced or eliminated. There are songs I do not share with my 78 yr old mother due to the gratuitous F drop. It may fit, it may fit easy but Merle didn’t have to use it.
December 27, 2017 @ 4:50 pm
I don’t get the idea that a songwriter should pick a different synonym to appease people. If he said messed up rather than fucked up it’d mean the same but it wouldn’t sound right to me. And it’s crazy to me that so many people think being enebriated is more ok than a word. I mean you have Hank Jr. singing about his love of infidelity and booze and drugs but “you just can’t say the F word”. That shit doesn’t add up to me.
December 26, 2017 @ 3:49 pm
Tyler Childers album was by far the best of the year. Obviously we all know about Stapleton and Sturgill.theres also Kyle Fields is another talented young artist from eastern Kentucky I’d say many folks haven’t heard yet,but will soon.He released a new album a week
Or so titled “Hillbilly Poetry” and it’s great,everyone should give him a listen.i believe he and Tyler are the same age and they both grew up here in eastern Kentucky.All these great artist make me very proud of my home state!!!
December 26, 2017 @ 3:56 pm
The choice had very little to do with the recording artist in this instance, and everything to do with the producer.
December 26, 2017 @ 5:27 pm
LOL Honky. Still got that secret man-crush on old Sturg?
December 26, 2017 @ 5:46 pm
No. But Trigger does, and it’s not a secret. That’s why he awarded this album.
Me? I like Country Music. I’d have given the prize to Mo Pitney.
December 26, 2017 @ 6:19 pm
Speaking of obsession, you’d give Mo Pitney a 2017 Album of the Year award for an album he released in 2016.
And for the record, yes, I think David Ferguson did do a great job producing this record.
December 26, 2017 @ 6:59 pm
October of 2016 would fall within the 2017 award cycle, which you know.
December 27, 2017 @ 3:47 am
Actually Honky, Sturgill producing this album had nothing to do with it winning SCM 2017 Album of the Year. Did you even read the comments when the nominees were announced on here? Childers ran away with the vote by a country mile.
December 27, 2017 @ 10:39 am
The biggest reason “Purgatory” won this year is I felt like the public sentiment behind this album was pretty overwhelming, here on the site itself, and via social media. Commenters don’t always weigh so heavily in the decision, especially if it feels more like a dedicated campaign from an artist as opposed to a true barometer of what people believe. But in such a crowded field this year and so many albums right at the top, I felt it was important the Saving Country Music reader get a bigger say so in the decision. Personally, the two records I listened to the most this year were from Jaime Wyatt and John Moreland. But Tyler Childers was right up there. I didn’t give it the most glowing review, which is also throwing some people off. But the Album of the Year isn’t just about my own personal taste, it’s about a record’s influence in the marketplace, and it’s importance in the grander scheme of things. I feel like “Purgatory” is the continuation of the efforts from Sturgill and Stapleton to give independent music mainstream exposure.
December 27, 2017 @ 4:57 pm
Trigger, does it drive you nuts that instead of being able to listen to albums that you really love you have to continually be putting them aside for new stuff? I mean obviously we are all here to find new music but not nearly in the capacity you are dealing with… Does it take away from your enjoyment of it all?
December 27, 2017 @ 8:34 pm
Oh, the joy of music left me years ago. Every once in a while I hear something that actually reminds me what it’s like to love music, and that’s when I know it’s good.
December 26, 2017 @ 4:07 pm
Good album. I would almost give it to him on the strength of his live performances, as silly as that sounds. Watched this kid play one night with Colter and actually felt bad for colter. Talk about dynamic.
December 26, 2017 @ 5:12 pm
Saw them together in Charlotte and I was shocked when Colter quickly lost at least half the crowd after Tyler’s set.
December 27, 2017 @ 11:53 am
so purgatory is not your favorite album of the year but what you considered would be the best for your website, this is sad because hands down felony blues is by far the best (and i have the impression thats your personal opinion too), and its YOUR opinion, and recods like hers why i visit this site regularly …
December 27, 2017 @ 12:48 pm
this is a response to Trigger DECEMBER 27, 2017 @ 10:39 AM not pats comment
December 27, 2017 @ 5:06 pm
It’s the job of a critic to attempt to put their personal tastes aside and try to look at the bigger picture. One of the reasons I lean on feedback from readers is to help me do that. Not only did Jaime Wyatt not receive many votes, it was pointed out that her record was too short to be considered a true “Album of the Year,” and I think that’s a good point. If the album would have included two more songs, and they were as equal quality to the rest, I very well might have named it the winner, regardless of what readers thought. But at only 7 songs, it made it difficult.
This is in no way a slight to Jaime or “Felony Blues.” Think of how many hundreds of albums were released in “country” this year, and I thought “Felony Blues” was at the very top of the very top. It just happens to be there was one that was just very slightly better.
December 27, 2017 @ 6:26 pm
Your handle is killer. Get your website going and hand out your own album of the year to J-Wyzzy and call it a day. We all win. I thought her album was overrated as shit by this website. But the reality is this trigger person gets it right on average. a lot more than he gets it wrong.
December 26, 2017 @ 4:49 pm
Let’s listen to the first lines of each of Tyler’s songs:
I only had a couple drinks last night
and a few good hits from an antler pipe
Well my buckle makes impressions
on the inside of her thigh
I am now the one she left
a haunted tale for someone else
Once I was a dying breed
chewing on an ancient leaf
Early in the morning when the sun does rise
laying in the bed with bloodshot eyes
Tina Nola had a man with a good place for sifting
he invited me digging, so I picked up my screen
Will you pray for me
when the roots of the oak
I was out of my mind the first night we met
I was feeling lonely and blue
Up in Pocahontas in the Cranberry Glades
ain’t got bars, nor the charge, to call her anyways
I’m a stone’s throw from the mill
and I’m a good walk to the river
Every one of those openers is a surprise, a recognizable voice, and a bullseye. He’s a bona fide natural writer and could probably write stories if he wanted to. But the main thing is that we’re *not* hearing Predictable Commercial Bullshit. We’re hearing a musical voice with self-deprecating wit. Gold.
December 26, 2017 @ 5:08 pm
Hey Trig
Greetings from sunny Australia
As a long time fan of alt-country, Americana and country in general, may I say your site is the go to for me. It used to be No Depression but it seems to have lost its mojo.
For mine Jase’s effort was clearly No1 but I’m biased.
Loved John Moreland’s effort as I did Colter Wall, Lee Ann Womack , Tunpikes and a score of others.
Unfortunately Aus ITUNES does on offer Ty’s Purgatory so I’m going to have to get it from elsewhere and then judge if he tops Jase.
DUDE
December 26, 2017 @ 5:16 pm
Good call. I listen to this all the time. He has a nack for super catchy phrasing that is all his own. Very catchy songwriting but it’s all his own. Not one tune on Purgatory felt like a track that a bunch of schmucks gathered together with the mind of writing a hit – but every song on it should be, even universal sound, just in it’s more natural state.
December 26, 2017 @ 5:23 pm
Albums like this are literally “saving country music” and this distinction is deserved! Good call Trigg!
December 26, 2017 @ 5:26 pm
Definitely the correct choice. I loved Colter’s album too, but Purgatory just blew me away. The only reason I checked out the album in the first place was because Sturgill’s name was attached to it, but I ended up leaving with a new favorite artist. I immediately bought all the other music Tyler had to offer. Looking forward to his next venture. Excellent pick, Trigger.
December 26, 2017 @ 5:26 pm
Great choice! It was a great year, but I agree Ty’s was the best.
December 26, 2017 @ 5:58 pm
i grew up in east Kentucky – And in Tylers song whitehouse road the line “take my troubles to the high wall” really hits home. Those old abandon un-reclaimed strip mines all had a “high wall” where they blasted away the side of a mountain and that was where the party was – set a tire on fire, break out the guitars, break out the goodies – courtesy of the local bootlegger where u could get anything and they didnt care how old you were. During the day that is the place to ride the dirt bike or swim in a “strip pond”.also good place to sink stolen cars, every now and then a body would float up of someone that had been missing awhile. Then the government came in the 90s and started reclaiming them and they turned in to shopping centers – subdivisions – federal penitentiary -kind of sad as all the old playgrounds are gone – it is sacred ground for those of us from the era.
December 26, 2017 @ 6:16 pm
It weren’t even a choice.
December 26, 2017 @ 7:22 pm
For my money , the half dozen or so songs I’ve heard by Childers are country music , if much more sophisticated lyrically than what most of us , I believe , would consider trad country music .
I think his vocals are emotion-fueled ..and seem founded in personal experience or an intimate working knowledge of those experiences .And these vocals are unique , oozing character in the way Stapleton or Bonnie Raitt (yes …Bonnie Raitt ) ooze character . You hear him , you know him .
Not so in most mainstream country .
My disclaimer here : I don’t know this album in particular but I have listened to a few songs from it and a few from elsewhere by Childers .
So …..as much as I can find lots to love about this Artist and his thoughts …..and I mean Artist in the truest sense , not in the record biz sense , I can’t find enough to love his songs . What I have listened to seems lacking in melody , rhythmic variety and memorable musical hooks . These are important and necessary ingredients in giving a song a chance to resonate , to stick and have life over time, I belikeve. What I’ve heard seems to suggest a sameness to TC’s material which wears on my ears pretty quickly.
Nit-picky ? yeah …maybe it is ….and maybe the absence of the aforementioned ingredients doesn’t matter to folks who just love the authenticity of ‘ where he’s coming from ” . And I totally appreciate that But for me , these are terrific poems and prose in need of stronger melody to be called great SONGS .
Stapleton’s” Broken Halos’ is , perhaps a good recent illustration of my point . Simple , honest , timeless and real lyrically but with a very strong melodic component which effectively supports and drives the point home and is the difference , in my opinion , between it being a good song and a great one . A song is melody and cadence and rhythm and phrasing ,variety , contrast and many more things than just good or even great words that rhyme and tell a story . TC is very obviously a talented writer with a keen eye for detail and a passionate delivery . But perhaps to be considered great , timeless songs his catalogue could use a bit more crafting to support his raw and unique gifts ?
December 26, 2017 @ 7:36 pm
One man’s melody is another’s “over-singing”
December 26, 2017 @ 8:15 pm
Like what Trig talks about on In The Throes?
(Which I’ll take over Big Bad Luv, dammit!)
December 26, 2017 @ 9:53 pm
I think this comment is the closest to how I feel about this album. I’ve listened to a few times and think:
Production: A+
Instrumentation: A+
“Authenticity”: A+
Songs: This is where I struggle. I think that Every Single Song on “A Long Way From Your Heart” is as good or better than the best song on this album.
Not saying it’s bad by a long shot, I just can’t seem to get even one deep hook out of it, for whatever that’s worth. However, I realize I’m in the minority on that and understand why it’s picked.
December 26, 2017 @ 10:40 pm
I see where you’re coming from. I like Whitehouse Road, otherwise not a lot of memorable hooks or catchy choruses. A lot of the independent stuff shy’s away from the elements traditional country would strive for.
December 27, 2017 @ 8:32 am
I’m not sure that indie artists don’t try to write hooks. By hooks I don’t mean cheesy pop gimmicky hooks…I just a melody that grabs you. There are plenty of indie artists in all a genres that write great melodies & hooks including most that were nominated this year. TT, JI, CW, JM all had crazy good melodies, amount others. Most of them are indie too btw.
December 27, 2017 @ 2:26 pm
A ‘hook’ seems to get a bad rap as being an evil mainstream device and it shouldn’t .
A musical hook ( as opposed to a song hook ….an idea that catches a listener’s attention AND ear cuz of an insight a la The House That Built Me or a clever interpretaion of a common phrase such as ‘The Second One To Know ) is soooo important to ensuring your ideas and observations stand the best chance of cutting through the din of sameness in nearly ALL genre’s today . It can well be the difference-makedr in that respect . A musical hook is just a smart , effective execution of one element of craft . And , as pointed out above , a lot of indie stuff tends to either not be aware of many imporatnt elements of craft OR chooses not to use them .In either case , you do a disservice to your ‘statement’ , your perspective , your recounting of your experience in not availing it of any and all elements of craft which can help it stand apart , rise above or cut through , as it were. Craft and hooks are NOT bad words . They are tried and true methods of helping your art connect . If a writer comes up with newer elements which she may feel can deliver in this role , great. But to simply NOT use elements of craft and hook is , to put it bluntly , stupid .
December 26, 2017 @ 8:26 pm
What also needs to be talked about is this album is the result of a week long recording session, at the insistence of Sturgill. It’s all Tyler, don’t get me wrong (and from what I have read Sturgill was adamant about that), but the re-working of the songs is apparent and the Sturgill frantic marathon recording stuff is super interesting to me. Metamodern and sailors guide were done the same way. That liberal asshole (Haha!) might be on to something. My fear is that he never puts out another album and just makes his future millIons by marketing himself as the badass one week miracle worker.
December 26, 2017 @ 10:14 pm
And, of course, the marathon suggestion for Metamodern came from Cobb, and was also adopted by Stapleton for Traveler.
December 27, 2017 @ 8:33 pm
Simply not true. You really think a polished up Stapleton album could be done that way? See the article below. Traveler Was recorded over 3 months, and it was Stapleton’s idea to use Studio A, not Cobb’s. https://www.grammy.com/grammys/news/oral-history-chris-stapletons-traveller
December 26, 2017 @ 8:49 pm
Excellent pick! Funny all the comments about Universal Sound and I am surprised it gets airplay. It’s truly the only song on the record I don’t care for but the rest is pure gold. I’ve seen him live several times and some of his best songs aren’t on any of his records. But I love Purgatory
December 26, 2017 @ 9:35 pm
Good album, but Allison Krauss put out the one I’ve come back to most over the course of the year.
December 26, 2017 @ 10:17 pm
Good pick. Especially a fella from eastern Kentucky without a penny of worth to his name, wasting his life on a burning desire and chasing that honky tonk flame.
December 26, 2017 @ 11:06 pm
I s’pose “This Highway” was just too niche.
December 27, 2017 @ 3:49 am
Hearing the kind of songs he’s playing live right now that have yet to be released, this award might be his again in either 2018 or 2019, whenever his next record drops.
December 27, 2017 @ 6:06 am
You’re not kidding. The new songs I’ve heard live are ridiculously good. I get the feeling that writing songs comes so naturally to him that he can practically write them in his sleep.
December 27, 2017 @ 9:01 am
My tops for 2017…
Joseph Huber, “The Suffering Stage”
Songwriting that’s a straight shot to the soul, with perfectly fitting accompaniment, and music that is not trying too hard to be anything other than the best fitting vessel for the words.
Zephaniah OHora, “This Highway”
Beautifully played and maybe the best care and attention regarding production I have ever heard in an album.
Turnpike Troubadours, “A Long Way From Your Heart”
Just masters of the craft. Such incredible storytelling music.
The Deslondes, “Hurry Home”
The Deslondes have a magical way of making me nostalgic for places I’ve never lived. They just kinda sound like the places they hold dear are themselves making the music.
Sarah Shook & the Disarmers, “Sidelong”
A re-release after they signed to Bloodshot, but I overlooked it when new in 2015 and should not have. So, it was new to me in 2017, and it rules. Attitude without fakery, real and raw.
Other Mentions
Tyler Childers, “Purgatory”
Tyler definitely lives up to the hype. The only problem I had with this album is that the music doesn’t always fit the mood of the words, in my opinion (whereas the Huber album, or TT’s, the music is spot on to deliver the songs). I think he’s best with just a guitar. “Lady May” is certainly one of my top songs of the year.
The Country Side of Harmonica Sam, “A Drink After Midnight”
Just a little too hokey to make my top 5. But nonetheless, a great listen, and perfectly captures a bygone era of country. Nice work from a buncha Swedes.
Texas Gentlemen, “TX Jelly”
If the whole album kept on the trajectory of the first four songs, this release would have definitely been among my top. “Bondurant Women” is a revelation.
Charlie Parr, “Dog”
So glad this album is finally getting Charlie some of the recognition he deserves. “Hobo” is a killer. What a song from one of America’s shining gems.
Casey James Prestwood and the Burning Angels, “Born Too Late”
The kings of Denver’s country scene delivered on this album. Always rooting for these great dudes.
Gotta mention Colter Wall. Lots of folks talking about him. Yeah, he’s an immensely talented songwriter for 22 and is going to continue to blow up, I assume. But, I’m not a Johnny Cash fan, and Colter’s voice doesn’t do it for me. He’s kinda reminiscent of Lost Dog Street Band, but I like their stuff far better, and the heartache in their tunes rings truer to me. That said, I never see Lost Dog mentioned on here. Bet a lot of y’all would dig them if not familiar. Look up “Hungry For You Blues” on YouTube.
Anyway, long time reader but first time commenter. Have come across loads of great music from this site. I respect the Childers pick, and like the album more after chewing on Trig’s perspective of it.
Big THANKS to him and the other commenters for the excellent suggestions year after year.
December 27, 2017 @ 10:29 am
Thanks for reading HR.
December 27, 2017 @ 12:22 pm
“I’m not a Johnny Cash fan”
My brain literally refuses to process the words copied and pasted above.
December 27, 2017 @ 2:51 pm
Haha, fair. Guess I should more accurately say, “I’m not a fan of Johnny Cash’s vocal style.”
December 27, 2017 @ 9:41 am
OK.
I’ve listened to it nine times hoping to feel … something, anything.
Mostly I feel like it’s a good album. Not great. Nothing that makes me think, feel or want more. Just OK. The writing doesn’t speak to me. The singing isn’t anything that I feel. The music is country. So … OK.
So, OK.
I wouldn’t have picked it, but that’s fine. OK.
December 27, 2017 @ 1:22 pm
Purgatory and Colter Wall are my albums of the year. in that order. We got a lot of good releases this year, though. A LOT.
December 27, 2017 @ 4:36 pm
The last two albums of Isbell’s have been very good, but neither holds a candle to Southeastern. Southeastern is a tour de force in the range of human emotions.
December 27, 2017 @ 4:37 pm
Pardon me, this was supposed to be a reply to another comment.
December 27, 2017 @ 4:39 pm
I really like Purgatory, but I don’t understand the universal love for it and don’t find it worthy of this distinction. A Long Way From Your Heart has a much broader range of audience to reach and will do more for authentic country music than any of the other nominated albums. Having a soft spot for Tyler Childers is just fine, and hey, I’m glad he got the attention he deserves, but I think Album of the Year needs to include reasoning other than which album is your personal favorite. Just my 2 cents on the matter. It’s your site.
December 27, 2017 @ 4:59 pm
“Purgatory” was not my personal favorite of 2017. In fact I’m catching hell up above for calling it Album of the Year when it wasn’t. It was one of my personal favorites, or I wouldn’t have nominated it or named it the winner. But there were other records I personally listened to more. The main reason that I considered it for album of the year was the overwhelming sentiment from readers and commenters saying it was their personal favorite, and the most “country” record of the year. I concurred it was an excellent album worthy of distinction.
December 27, 2017 @ 8:39 pm
Not trying to be an outsider for the sake of being one, but I had a long drive today and gave the Turnpike album another shot. I just am not hearing much more here than a Counting Crows album with some added fiddle (too much on many songs btw) and a little steel. I fail to see the overt praise. Decent album? Sure. But the over the top praise is crazy to me. They seem like great guys and I love that they are getting more and more popular, but they are followed by a formula that isn’t all that interesting.
December 27, 2017 @ 8:40 pm
*flowing a formula*, that is.
December 27, 2017 @ 5:59 pm
I mean it is up to you, obviously. I’m not here to start an argument. I just don’t think it was as impactful as Turnpike’s record.
For the record, “Feathered Indians” is my favorite track from Purgatory and definitely up for my Song of the Year distinction.
December 28, 2017 @ 2:17 pm
Once again SCM points me to an artist I want to hear. Much appreciated. I had recently listened to the interview with Childers on Chris Shiflett’s Walking the Floor podcast and was struck by how flat it was. Shiflett said in his intro that Childers was tired and he sounds like it, but there also seems to be a lack of connection between interviewer and interviewee, which isn’t usually the case with that podcast. Beyond Childers’ fatigue, some of the distance seemed cultural – LA roots vs. Kentucky roots (the LA guy coming to country through heavy metal while the Kentucky guy comes to country through country). This exchange is an example:
CS: What are your old country influences?
TC: I listened to a lot of Merle Haggard and Buck Owens in high school.
CS: How did you end up listening to them?….I’m sure the vast majority of your classmates weren’t listening to Merle Haggard and Buck Owens records.
TC: Well, I lot of ’em were…. I had a couple of buddies who got down with Buck Owens but everyone seemed to be able to agree with Merle Haggard.
On the other hand, Shiflett asks Childers who his literary influences were, and Childers says Kerouac and the beat poets, which (I admit) surprised me a bit. Says something about his songwriting.
December 28, 2017 @ 4:07 pm
Excellent choice.This album would fit in any years best..
December 29, 2017 @ 1:52 pm
One of many albums deserving of this honor. 2017 was a strong year for albums (if you ignored the “mainstream” garbage).
December 29, 2017 @ 11:22 pm
This is definately the best album in COUNTRY music this year. I checked Tyler Childers out as soon as you did a story about this album and the fact that Sturgill Simpson was producing it. I bought it the day it came out and have listened to it almost daily ever since then. This is real country music. I have not heard such a distinctive sound in a long time. The instrumentation is amazing and the songwriting is incredible!! Universal Sound is definately my least favorite song, but aside from it, the rest of the album is great!
John Moreland and Jason Isbell are not country…at least thats not what I consider country music!!
December 31, 2017 @ 10:27 pm
You are spot on, Sir. And that is not taking anything away from Isabell or Moreland. Good writers of miserable wowe is me songs, but Childers is rooted in country and God bless him for that. Also, he does the more sensitive stuff without sounding so pathetic and depressed, which both Moreland and Isabella could take some notes from.