The Brother Brothers Capture The Original Joy of Music in “Some People I Know”
We are missing out on the original magic of music, and it’s our own damn fault. By demanding endless access to music in both on-demand inventory and limitless mobile accessibility, we’ve lost touch with how precious of an intellectual commodity music truly is. In previous eras, you experienced that adrenaline rush as your favorite song came on the radio, or you tore off the cellophane of an LP or CD, and wrestled with that stupid little piece of theft-preventing tape running the spine of a jewel case that never peeled off properly. Now, you can’t even give your old CDs away at a garage sale.
With so much access to music, we’re missing out on how it used to take six or seven trips through a record before you really “got” it. We’re missing how you may only have enough money for one, maybe two albums a month, and had to feed off of them until the next allowance or payday, or would head over to your friend’s house simply to listen to a record or song they had, and you didn’t. Even if you didn’t love a record, you still liked it, found the beauty in it, marveled at its creation and the artwork it was enveloped in. It was a trip to a world away from the one you lived in.
Today the world is so busy, and we’re so over-served with information and entertainment, we don’t have the time to truly regard or appreciate anything. Even if we love an album we may forget about it the next day. We’ve run out of bandwidth. Recorded music is no longer something to sit down and ingest in an active and dedicated manner where we can let the waves of magic overtake us in brilliant swells of imagination. Music is background noise and a passive distraction, while those moments of sheer, pulsating magic we experienced during adolescence and early adulthood become faded memories in the endless march of efficiency and priority.
In this musical environment, it’s rare to impossible to discover anything that allows you to unlock that original allure of music; something that makes you slow down to listen, and salivate for the next time you get to spend within its audience to the point where you plan an evening around it, prioritize other things beneath it, and blow off other obligations for it.
Enter the world of The Brother Brothers. Identical twins Adam and David Moss have done something that is not just remarkable in roots music, but in modern music in all its incarnations. They have re-connected with that original magic that compels you to stop, take a deep breath, shove everything else to the side, and truly give yourself to a listening experience. Where most modern music is getting louder to command your attention in a distracting world—ripping through torrents of rhythmical stunts and layers of production to vie for your attention—The Brother Brothers work across the grain, stripping it all back, slowing it all down, exposing the bones and roots of sound and story, demanding you lean in to listen, and compelling you to clear your mind to focus lest you miss a single moment of the magic they conjure.
In a word, the Brother Brothers’ debut full-length album Some People I Know is astounding, and only short of declaring a masterpiece because time must be allowed to give its own fair judgement upon a given work of music before settling on such significant praise. Some People I Know certainly leans in the direction of highly-crowned company though, spellbinding with the purity it conveys, cunning in the attention it commands, and generous with the welling emotions it inspires in an audience.
The best of music must be grounded in an authenticity, not measured necessarily by genre or circumstance, but in the sincerity of its expressions. The Brother Brothers are not country, and they’re not bluegrass. A particular song on this record (“In The Nighttime”) is as close as they’ll ever come to either, but instead of being an effort at inclusion or acceptance within these most commercially applicable versions of roots music, it’s almost like a parody, like “You want us to be a stereotypical modern string band? Here you go. Now leave us the alone to do our thing.”
The Brother Brothers’ thing is a sincere and strikingly relevant version of folk music tied straight to the classic American sounds harbored by the original musicians in New York’s Greenwich Village, not far from Adam and David’s home in Brooklyn. Yes, there are many acts who could battle for consideration as the modern Simon & Garfunkel. But only The Brother Brothers fit that description so strikingly that goosebumps swell on the skin. At the same time, the advantageous, almost unfair ascendancy the duo captures as identical twins gives them the dexterity and appeal to transcend any specific comparison to predecessors or contemporaries, geographical scenes, or even genres. The Brother Brothers deserve their own phylum upon an advanced musical strain not yet categorized on the roots music family tree. They are the true sound of roots music evolving.
It’s so tempting as a musician today to be swayed from your original purpose, and the genius of your purest expressions that come bursting out when you’re in clear audience with yourself. Artists often get swept up in pursuing acceptance from creative peers, following the trends of modern expressions, or bucking preconceived notions of themselves under the often careless notion of reinvention. On The Brother Brothers’ Tugboats EP that preceded this new record, the pair laid out the perfect plan to do something unique yet classic, and didn’t allow themselves to be swayed from that purpose when they were signed to Compass Records. They didn’t get swept up in adding layers of instrumentation, bringing in horn sections (though “The Gambler” places the most exquisite and delicate saxophone), or work to separate themselves from the herd. Their ultimate purpose was to capture the true essence of themselves.
As multi-instrumentalists with incredibly careful ears, each song on Some People I Know is delicately crafted. There is no conflict, no compromise within this music whatsoever. The twin telepathy, the eternally-similar life stamp makes each song, each expression seamless. There are other twin singers, and sparsity itself is not expressly rare in modern music. It’s the mixture of the perfect singing pair, along with a vision of what to do with such a gift, and the proficiency and skill to see that vision through that makes The Brother Brothers something to behold.
And what The Brother Brothers accomplish here should not be just for roots music aficionados, but anyone who values being in the audience of breathtakingly pure expressions, so pristine and aerial it feels like a feather could harm it, yet it could hush a thunderstorm, and causes the internal voices and outside noise ever-presently swirling in the modern human brain to finally stifle, leaving you wholly in the audience of one thing, consecrated and purified, free from distraction and priority, and enjoying the simple heartfelt expression of another human. Or in this case, two of them.
10/10
– – – – – – – – – –
MH
October 23, 2018 @ 8:55 am
Really digging it. Thank you for ALL that you do, Trig!
BJones
October 23, 2018 @ 9:27 am
This is Simon and Garfunkel shit. Go kick rocks.
Trigger
October 23, 2018 @ 9:30 am
You say that like it’s a bad thing.
BJones
October 23, 2018 @ 9:36 am
Ha. To me it is. Oh well. John Howie’s new album is much better than this.
Trey
October 23, 2018 @ 9:43 am
I saw them open for I’m With Her last week. They’re great live as well.
Coyote Choir
October 23, 2018 @ 10:11 am
Music as a utility has without doubt cheapened the experience of listening for most of the limited attention span audience. For those though who truly love music, the abundance of riches that is streaming has opened a cornucopia of lost gems, never experienced classics and deep catalog mining of both beloved and unexplored artists. It’s really a magic genie’s lamp to rub Amazon Unlimited and out comes heretofore unheard Doug Kershaw or Etta James. When those records we missed because they fell between paychecks can now, years later, be enjoyed at our leisure, there can be no better listening time than now.
I recall the thrill of tearing off the cellophane of Bridge over Trouble Waters or Deja’ Vu and listening to those remarkable harmonies. The Brother Brothers have that in spades. What an incredible instrument is the melding of two nearly identical voices. Probably the sound the angels make.
Ron
October 23, 2018 @ 3:01 pm
Well said. I was a little late to streaming but now I’ve been digging into all kinds of older stuff. Lately it has been Curtis Mayfield.
Seth of Lampasas
October 23, 2018 @ 10:26 am
I’m gonna check this out, and whether I like the album or not, I will say that this is a 10/10 amazingly beautifully written review Trigger.
Clyde
October 23, 2018 @ 12:54 pm
I agree that for what this music is, a 10/10 is appropriate. I generally prefer things less pristine, but this is really well done. The combination of voice and guitar in Goodbye Ol’ Silver is hypnotizing.
OlaR
October 23, 2018 @ 10:45 am
UN/popular opinion: well…i tried the listening experience thing…& fell asleep.
It’s not bad music…it’s just not my kind of music.
In the pipeline:
The Western Swing Authority – Big Deal – Album – 10/26 (Guests: Ray Benson, Buddy Spicher, George Canyon, Jason Blaine…)
Kip Moore – Room To Spare: The Acoustic Sessions – EP – 11/16
Released:
Lefty Frizzell – An Article From Life – The Complete Recordings – Box Set (20 CDs) – 10/18
Including a book (264 pages) & the story of Lefty Frizzell written by his brother David Frizzell.
An early christmas present for myself…
Corncaster
October 23, 2018 @ 5:51 pm
I’m with you, Ola. These guys have sharp skills, but it’s not my thing, either. Any thoughts about the Lefty collection?
I just picked up Drew Kennedy’s CD, “At Home in the Big Lonesome.” Really nice work.
JB-Chicago
October 23, 2018 @ 11:00 am
“or you tore off the cellophane of an LP or CD, and wrestled with that stupid little piece of theft-preventing tape running the spine of a jewel case that never peeled off properly”
I got this exact feeling of excitement yesterday when my Whitey Morgan disc came in the mail and I carefully ripped off the plastic so I wouldn’t ruin the cardboard. Unlike most albums these days I hadn’t heard this whole album yet so I couldn’t wait to put it on. I love it!
I’m at work and I can’t listen to the Brothers yet but as soon as i get home…………
matthew rutledge
October 23, 2018 @ 11:42 am
Phenomenal Trig.
Mark
October 23, 2018 @ 12:32 pm
The music is very nice,
That is a beautifully written review.
Blackh4t
October 23, 2018 @ 12:34 pm
That’s why I buy cds. That way i get to listen to something that my brain wants to get at least $20 of value out of and wants to keep listening until I’ve got every pearl out of it.
Love this, will buy it even if i have to import it to Australia. Some of us have good taste :p
BigJaker
October 23, 2018 @ 1:16 pm
No way Tom Buller and Colter Wall are coming off the rotation for this. Sorry Trig, not my up of tea.
Digs
October 23, 2018 @ 1:42 pm
I did not have high expectations for this based on their EP, which i liked but didnt love, but i can honestly say i have been blown away by this from first listen.
Excellent record…..definitely will be in my top 5 for the year.
Hoping these guys play Minnesota soon!
Ben
October 24, 2018 @ 6:26 am
They have been through MN twice in the past year. I saw them last December at Cedar.
Jimmy's Carhartt
October 23, 2018 @ 2:07 pm
Excited to give this a listen…but they’ll have a hard time topping Cairo, Illinois or Tugboats.
'Ol Yables
October 23, 2018 @ 2:11 pm
Pure harmonies and some really sweet chord progressions, especially on songs like “Colorado” and “Red and Gold”. They are super mellow (“In the Nighttime” aside): but immaculately crafted and performed. I also appreciate that these songs don’t wear out their welcome with extended solos and other unnecessary noodling. There’s a sonic efficiency these guys have captured here. Great recommendation, but certainly not for modern country fans. The closest “country” artist to compare these guys to would be Nickel Creek, (especially in songs like “Angel Island”).
ScottG
October 23, 2018 @ 2:15 pm
This is more than a review of an album to me. It describes exactly what I like about buying full albums in physical form, and the value of “pure expression” as you describe it. Will have to give these guys a shot.
Wes
October 23, 2018 @ 4:58 pm
I think Garrett Bryan made a much better effort this year and it was his debut. I’m still singing damn it Diana. This to me I mean I don’t like to see terrible because the songwriting structure isn’t but how they execution was is…. sorry
Bill from Wisconsin
October 23, 2018 @ 5:16 pm
Well they would have to crank it up a few notches for me.
But Trig, your write-up reminded me of 40 years ago, pedalling my 10-speed downtown to the record/head shop, slapping down five bucks of grass cutting money, and sticking that album I had been salivating for under my arm and pedalling back home. After everyone else was in bed I would throw it on the Pioneer turntable (part of the stereo system I convinced Mom we needed) and lay on the floor in the dark with the headphones cranked. Back then it would have been Tull, Nugent, Rush, Seger, Stones, or maybe even some new wave stuff. People don’t have that experience anymore.
G Harp and a Larrivee
October 24, 2018 @ 3:55 am
Wow – word for word that was my childhood too, right down to the artists. Throw in some Steve Winwood, maybe. Thanks for sparking such vivid nostalgia! My record/head shop was called The Flip Side, what was yours?
Bill from Wisconsin
October 24, 2018 @ 2:47 pm
Pipe Dreams! I also had Marshall Tucker, CDB, Pure Prarie League, etc.
albert
October 24, 2018 @ 12:05 am
Among your best reviews ever Trigger .
This is Milk Carton Kids , Paul Simon territory .
HOW BEAUTIFUL IS THAT !!!
Really beautiful , quietly adventurous , masterfully restrained and thoroughly engaging in its execution and timeless nature .
The right rating , Trigger . So few albums really nail a consistent vibe . I’m assuming from what I’ve heard and your comments that this one does .
Jack Wiliams
October 24, 2018 @ 4:13 am
Well, the rare 10/10 rating definitely got my attention, so I listened to both songs to the end. Like others, it made me think of Simon and Garfunkel, who I like fine but not enough to even buy their greatest hits. I won’t deny their greatness. Personal taste is all.
I’ll have to give this album a full listen with my morning coffee.
Charlie
October 24, 2018 @ 8:24 am
Get Giles Martin to produce next time.
Now that would really be something!
Charlie
October 24, 2018 @ 8:37 am
I prefer these guys:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3XuUbkVtmT0
kapam
October 24, 2018 @ 4:09 pm
That is certainly one of the most eloquent reviews presented on this site.
I absolutely love all the sentiments expressed in the early paras – especially the “We’ve run out of bandwidth” statement. Tremendous.
The Brothers Brothers aren’t really for me though. The Simon and Garfunkel references (great though they S&G were) remind me a little too much of my Parents’ taste in recorded music. Nonetheless, a beautifully written review and a pleasant-enough listen.