Album Review – Jesse Welles – “Middle”

#560 (Country Rock), and #571.1 (Folk-inspired Americana) on the Country DDS.
It is difficult to impossible to be accused of falling into hyperbole when trying to articulate the creative explosion that songwriter Jesse Welles has been riding upon for going on a year. A pioneer of what could be called “fast folk” where he synthesizes current events in real time into incredibly clever, complex, and insightful songs, he makes wickedly entertaining music while somehow overriding the political and cultural binary that so many musicians, pundits, and the public itself have fallen prey to.
Even before Jesse Welles wrote, recorded, and released this fully formed 10-song studio album amid sometimes daily song releases on social media, his musical output hovered somewhere near the impossible. Just like all of his songs and endeavors, Middle meets or exceeds expectations, despite the lofty ones Welles continues to set for himself.
Jesse Welles takes the complex thoughts, opinions, worries, and fears that anyone who endeavors to lead an examined life is challenged with on a daily basis, and somehow simplifies them into succinct phrases matched to original melodies. Nothing is off the table when it comes to what Jesse Welles might tackle next, and perhaps he’s even better when he challenges your belief system as opposed to affirming it.
But Middle is less concerned about tackling the news, and more interested in zooming out to address more broad, and more difficult subjects like God, war, and religion. It’s also unafraid of taking a more simplistic approach to more common subject matter, like love, and leaving the heady thoughts for another time. Middle also proves that Jesse Welles isn’t just a one-trick pony. He’s an artist who could be defining of our time.
Middle is a folk rock and country project that delves into the war we all wage inside our heads where our self-righteous ego attempts to wrangle control for our more cool-minded rationality. You want to be conscious of others in the world, and how your daily actions can affect things on a global scale. But you can’t be so eaten up by the troubles of the world that you begin to lose touch with it. This is all so well-articulated in the opening song “Horses.”

Welles invites you to listen closely, because at any point he could drop a dollop of wisdom whose teaching could be prophetic. He says early on in the second song “Certain,” “You’ll become what you hate if you seek to replace what you hate.” It’s lines like this that speak to this contentious moment when otherwise rational people let their emotions get the best of them, and they become the very thing they despise.
We knew whatever Welles delivered in this album would include landmark writing. Translating what he does into the full band aspect was the challenge. To help, Welles solicited the services of producer Eddie Spear, who faced similar challenges working on Zach Bryan’s American Heartbreak, and recently shared in Sierra Ferrell’s four Grammy wins for her album Trail of Flowers. Both of these albums were also named Saving Country Music Albums of the Year.
Even when Middle turns loud and electric, it always includes a rootsy and earthen approach to the music. “Anything But Me” is a legitimate country song, and a track where Welles doesn’t try to outdo himself, finding a sensible, poetic mood. The next song “Every Grain of Sand” is even more country. If nothing else, Jesse Welles is an artist for the moment. And though his background is in rock, he understands the potency of country and roots sounds in the present tense, and how perfect of a medium they are for his songs.
Accessibility is another positive attribute Welles has weaved into his music, despite the weighty nature of the material, and this is extended further through this album. Melody construction is often the under-appreciated portion of songwriting in Americana circles, and no different than his lyrics, Welles is a marvel at finding the right notes for his words. The second half of the album does trend a little more obtuse. But Welles also gives plenty for listeners to unravel in repeated listens.
Sometimes while you’re living through moments, it’s hard to assess the gravity of them. But what Jesse Welles is expressing and accomplishing feels like it will stick out like a sore thumb when history looks back at this tumultuous time to find someone who spoke to this era, and encapsulated it in song. It’s nothing short of Dylan-esque. Middle is far from mid. It will be a significant part of that Jesse Welles legacy.
8.2/10
– – – – – – – – –
Jesse Welles is the reigning Saving Country Music Songwriter of the Year. He was also just named as the recipient of the Newport Folk Festival’s 2025 John Prine Songwriter Fellowship.
February 21, 2025 @ 9:24 am
You know objectively I should like this guys but there’s something about I just can’t quite get, maybe it’s that everything is just so on the nose and blunt that I just can’t get into it. Not that there’s nothing really wrong with that style but I feel like I need of mixture of it, gonna give it another try though!
February 21, 2025 @ 10:01 am
For me, that’s what’s so cool about this album, and why it’s so important to his legacy. It’s not “on the nose” like so many of his video songs. It shows that he can work in nuance, and that his songs are not exposed through a full studio sound.
February 21, 2025 @ 12:06 pm
Thats great to hear, for sure gonna give this a dedicated listen this weekend!
February 24, 2025 @ 12:00 pm
YouTube playlist is here: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_mukQS4Cs1pcI61jmXVoKCL376UiGPexvo&si=2pD_9pvjAqH9L_Qi
Still doesn’t show up on his page
February 24, 2025 @ 1:43 pm
Actually it does show up now. Excellent!
February 21, 2025 @ 9:57 am
“It’s nothing short of Dylan-esque.”
Horses sounds like it could have been recorded during Dylan’s Desire period. As soon as I heard the fiddle it brought me back to the fiddle on Hurricane and Black Diamond Bay.
February 21, 2025 @ 11:57 am
During that first song all I heard was Hurricane as well.
February 21, 2025 @ 10:42 am
Can’t stand this guy. He seems like a total grifter.
Voice is also nails on a chalkboard for me.
February 21, 2025 @ 2:13 pm
I’m not sure who he would be grifting here, or what kind of mechanism he could use to “grift” people. He posts his music free online. If you don’t like him, fair enough. “Grifter” is a pretty scathing charge.
February 22, 2025 @ 11:39 am
His voice sounds better if you take your MAGA hat off.
February 22, 2025 @ 11:57 am
: D Aww, precious – feel better?
February 21, 2025 @ 11:36 am
Listened to the whole album today and didn’t add any of the songs to my playlists. Idk I have never really listened to him before because I was intentionally waiting on an album. Maybe this will grow on me the way Zach Bryan has. My main reaction was to go listen to a Bright Eyes album who feel like a better version of this type of thing.
Bob Dylan is my favorite artist of all time so someone in that area definitely appeals to me. But for whatever reason one listen through didn’t really hit for me. Maybe I just need to wait and see which song people decide is the best one and focus on that. Often when I have struggled with an artist it took one particular great song to unlock the rest of their stuff for me. Thanks for the review!
February 21, 2025 @ 11:53 am
Something about his music always makes me want to go listen to some Uncle Tupelo, Son Volt, or Wilco instead.
February 21, 2025 @ 11:59 am
Hey guys I think he has ALL the answers if only THEY would listen.
Overly cynical? Maybe, but just my feeling from his past YouTube videos. Maybe I’ll give the album a shot based on Trigger’s review though.
February 21, 2025 @ 2:11 pm
“Hey guys I think he has ALL the answers if only THEY would listen.”
This is perhaps the exact opposite message Jesse Welles delivers on this album, especially through a song like “Certain.” In many respects, this is an album about self-doubt. I think a lot of people roll up to his music and see the mechanisms of activist folk music, and immediately begin making assumptions.
February 21, 2025 @ 3:15 pm
No doubt.
February 22, 2025 @ 1:28 pm
Trig,
Good comment but I think the reason many approach this assuming the “Active folk music” is his past body of work. When one establishes a precedent, it sometimes is hard to broaden.
February 22, 2025 @ 7:03 pm
And here I was thinking I just pulled it out of my ass.
February 28, 2025 @ 8:55 am
Man, his message is one that your audience hates. Maybe that should lead to you doing some reflecting of your own. Because for most folks it’s an easy message to swallow.
February 21, 2025 @ 1:00 pm
Nice coverage in the NYT
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/12/arts/music/jesse-welles-middle.html
February 21, 2025 @ 2:02 pm
was really looking forward to this project. I’m a huge this genre and I was hoping Welles would do the impossible and find a way to marry his Tik Tok folk to a studio album but i’m just left feeling like i’d rather listen to the greats instead (Dylan, John Prine, Jeff Tweedy, Tré Burt, Neil Young). Besides “Simple Gifts” and “Middle” I find the music is incredibly average if not Karaoke-esque and the lyrics a bit try hard and tiresome. I think his tunes work best when presented in video form as it adds an element of entertainment that doesn’t need to solely rely on the music. I could definitely see myself eating it up in my high school days, however.
February 21, 2025 @ 3:27 pm
I’ll be digging into this record later this evening. I caught on to him via Youtube a year or so ago, and he’s as consistent a songwriter as I’ve heard. Oddly, the topical songs are impressive to me (his song “Fentanyl” is my runaway favorite), but I really like when he waxes philosophic. He’s also as melodically advanced as any songwriter working, and if you just listened to the melody alone, you’d be impressed.
I made sure I turned my co-workers on to him, and I’d definitely go see him live.
February 22, 2025 @ 6:39 am
For some reason this just doesn’t do it for me. I am honestly surprised that you make such a big deal of him. Guess there is something I haven’t figured out yet. The lyrics to me feel so heavy handed, and the mix so agressive and thin that I couldn’t listen to more than a few songs at a time without having to shut it off before going crazy.
February 22, 2025 @ 10:02 am
Right now, Jesse Welles is the artist that is absolutely SURGING in popularity no different than what we saw from Sturgill Simpson, Tyler Childers, Zach Bryan, The Red Clay Strays, and Zach Top. He’s selling out every live date he posts. Every festival is trying to book him. At this point, he has dozens of viral videos, and is seeding more on a sometimes daily basis.
None of this means you have to like him, or like this album. The fact that people are shocked that others like him, or that I deem him as important artist illustrates the massive disconnect that is no different than when I first touted Sturgill, or Zach Bryan, while the rest of the media sat unaware, and then had to play catch up.
I can tell from many of the comments that a lot of this disconnect has to do with politics and culture war, which right now is raging at 10 on a 1 to 10 scale. The reason Jesse Welles is surging like he is, is because he cuts through that culture war. But for some, they see signals that he’s a part of it, and it turns off the part of their brain that would otherwise be accepting of what’s happening here.
I don’t think this is some amazing album. I think it’s a good album. But most importantly, it’s an album that illustrates that Jesse Welles is not just the guy that posts viral videos about current events. He can be more conventional. He can write more complex and nuanced songs. It’s not any one of his viral songs or this album itself that exemplifies why we’re seeing him explode in this moment in time. It’s the entire package.
It’s complete understandable if folks don’t like this music. Not everybody is going to like everything. But frankly, I feel bad for anyone who is not along for this ride.
February 22, 2025 @ 1:13 pm
100% not the politics or culture war keeping me from buying in on this guy. For me it comes down to authenticity. The others you mentioned all have something novel about them that wasn’t born from some sort of party trick. It was always about their songs with a capital S. Welles on the other hand is obviously very skilled at turning the news into a diddy and that’s what caught the masses attention. Carrying a lot of that weight is the presentation of it: a jim morrison haircut, cheeky smiles, man with guitar in the woods. It lands more like Oliver Anthony to me.
the topical songwriting that gained him fame (while still very impressive in execution and output) is a different muscle than writing songs more personal in nature. I think people new to him are in large unaware that he’s had a whole career before where he was going for the whole Cobain thing in style physically and sonically and when that didn’t work out he shape shifted into the Dylan type character he’s playing now.
It’s a really smart play on his part to augment his older alternative sound with his new folky persona. A great way to leverage his newfound attention to bring people to the alternative rock music he tried to get off the ground years ago. He just comes off as a guy who’s really good at mimicking other artists and it leaves me wondering what this guy actually sounds like. If this new album is the answer then i’m unamused.
The album is presented as a folk purist reinventing himself but I just hear a really smart repackaging of his earlier brand of uninspired dylan-coded alt rock. So I think people are sensing that and feeling played.
February 22, 2025 @ 3:57 pm
Thanks for saying this. I don’t care for him either though our politics are aligned. I think it’s a bit weak to blame “culture war” for not liking him. It’s kind of lazy.
February 22, 2025 @ 4:15 pm
At no point did I say that the only reason people don’t like this is politics and culture war. Is that one of the reasons people are not receptive to it? Absolutely. And you don’t have to go any farther than this very comments section to corroborate that.
I appreciate everyone’s perspective here, and generally speaking, I don’t get into the business of trying to hector people into liking something they don’t. That’s not what I’m trying to do here.
But it does seem like there is a very small, but vocal minority of folks that will criticize this guy for surface level things (his hair, singing out in the woods), and so he tries to answer some of those criticisms by doing something more conventional, and now they’re calling him phony.
Meanwhile, tickets to see him in some markets are going for four figures.
Though as I said in the review, some of the songs in the second half of the album are perhaps too obtuse, I think this is a good album.
February 22, 2025 @ 5:58 pm
Eh, Trigg I don’t mean this condescendingly at all but it doesn’t sound like you’re understanding at all what folks are saying. I don’t think he’s a phony because “he tried to answer criticism with a [conventional] album”. It’s not the guys first album he’s been around for a decade or so. I’ve tuned in and out since 2018 myself. The album tries too hard. I love folk and country music and its tradition of sharing licks and melodies but Welles dangerously treads being essentially a cover artist.
The first song has him blatantly attempting to proxy his image closer to Dylan, belligerently stealing the sonic DNA of hurricane with that fiddle line. Very corny. Hell, “Every Grain of Sand” is literally the title of a Dylan song.
Unfortunately there’s many instances of very beige and cheesy call backs to 70’s guitar riffs and motifs that disrupt whatever flow he has going with the song and stops and makes you think “what song is this making me think of, where have I heard that before it’s at the tip of my tongue?”
The (in italics) “sound” of the record is reminiscent of some angsty musician archetype on a teen sitcom. War is God sounds like a my chemical romance B side. Yet that song is more him than the others and is where I imagine he’s ultimately trying to pull his new audience. And I hope he succeeds Id rather see him be himself than a masturbatory hodge podge of every songwriter that’s ever lived.
Just for the record I’m pretty sure Pitbull tickets also go for 4 figures in some markets as well.
February 22, 2025 @ 8:14 pm
“Just for the record I’m pretty sure Pitbull tickets also go for 4 figures in some markets as well.”
Yeah well, when Pitbull starts to sing about Big Pharma and the Military Industrial Complex, then we’ll have an apples to apples comparison.
I respect this album isn’t for you. I’m just a little surprised at the the aggressive nature of the criticism.
February 22, 2025 @ 9:48 pm
It does read a bit aggressive sorry about that. I respect your insight too and I love talking about music. I think I was trying to be articulable for anyone else sensing something a little off seeing as Saving Country Music is the only pub who’s reviewed the album. Good on ya Trigg keep up the good work.
February 22, 2025 @ 8:56 am
I like Jesse Welles as a songwriter and performer. I can’t get enough of Jesse Welles’ songs. To be honest, I was kinda hoping there would be 16-18 songs on the album especially when given his prolific output of videos/songs posted on his YouTube page. Too many of the songs on this album have been released which lessens my desire to purchase the album. But… as a fan, I will buy it anyway to support Welles. At least he is not doing a commercial grab of releasing an album with multiple album covers. Cheers & Twangs!
February 22, 2025 @ 11:47 am
Good song and review. I will give the album a listen.
February 22, 2025 @ 5:40 pm
I’ve been following Welles on his social media journey of impressive songs. The album certainly isn’t as consistently loaded with “truth bombs” as his more socially-minded material suggests, but is more introspective. Production-wise it sits squarely in the middle of alt-folk/country/Americana, nothing remarkable there. However, the caliber of songwriting is high and his gift for melody underrated, so there is a lot to be gained from repeat listens.
I like it, and will be recommending Middle to my friends and fellow musicians. I hope Welles keeps up his ongoing commentary, it’s terrific.
February 22, 2025 @ 7:11 pm
You may be getting some pushback on this review because your review is for an album that’s not available to listen to on YouTube just yet. The only place I could find it is Amazon. I bought the album after listening to a few songs and it’s a really good album. He’s a fantastic songwriter. He plays a lot of political, almost satirical, songs on YouTube solo, but this album isn’t like that. He’s better with a band and in a studio, although I find his short YouTube songs entertaining.
February 22, 2025 @ 8:11 pm
That is actually a good point. Anyone who regularly reads the reviews here knows there are usually two song examples that are included with every review. Because this album didn’t populate on YouTube in full yet, I could only use one. I was also hoping to include “Certain” or “Anything But Me,” which give a pretty different signal off compared to “Horses.”
February 23, 2025 @ 10:07 am
After listening to the album this is one where the songs are actually better when listening to the album as a whole. It flows well. That’s a mostly lost art. Thanks for the review, please keep em going
February 22, 2025 @ 8:51 pm
I heard ‘War Isn’t Murder’ today and while I completely agree with the message, I also can’t help noticing that it’s the same kind of moralistic social-conscious music that pulls punches for the side that it voted for – and that is simply not brave.
February 22, 2025 @ 10:29 pm
This album does not seem to be available on YouTube Music?!?
February 23, 2025 @ 9:57 am
It’s on Amazon only right now. Hopefully it’ll be on YouTube soon
February 25, 2025 @ 9:27 am
I’ve seen a lot of people compare him to Bob Dylan, but really I think the comparison isn’t very strong. Jesse Welles certainly leans into the Dylan personality, (He’s seeing it works for marketing.) but he’s more of a Phil Ochs if he’s going to be anything that’s happened before. (Which he hopefully is not… Time will tell.) Dylan’s political commentary over songs weren’t so heavy handed and he was more of a flower pot politically than a spade.
I think the satirical and harsh language present in Jesse Welles’ music reflects Ochs much more aggressively. His song “War Isn’t Murder” almost eerily seems like a call to Ochs’ “The War Is Over”, down to even how he holds his guitar up toward his face when he finishes playing it live. Not sure if this is intentional. Both are very straight forward in their writing, their “singing the news” is blunt and the degree of poetry around it is what’s necessary to change it from facts to song. Bob Dylan once chastised Phil Ochs telling him “You’re just a journalist!”. Dylan was never a fan of this kind of song writing and I think if he and Jesse Welles had met each other while Dylan was still young he would have disliked his work just as much as he disliked Ochs’.
There is a point to be made about the evolution of their work musically. So far as tone and instruments, I think I can draw a parallel between their “Middle” and “Pleasures of the Harbor” as albums, but I write words I don’t play songs. I’ll leave that to someone who knows what they’re talking about.
While both Jesse Welles and Phil Ochs are/were capable of writing dreamy non-political songs (Though often they still may have some kind of ideological message baked in, simply presented less upfront.) it didn’t stick for Ochs commercially because he was overshadowed by giants of the time who did it better. I hope that Jesse Welles is not subjected to this same fate. Ochs’ is mostly forgotten by time now because his most popular songs had “expiration dates” on arrival, such is the way of a protest singer.
There is also simply the fact that topical songs often make people uncomfortable or even feel preached at. Like Phil Ochs, Jesse Welles will be exactly as popular as he is meant to be, which is to say, not universally loved, but appreciated dearly but those who love him. I just hope people will remember him 50 years later.
March 9, 2025 @ 9:14 pm
I was not familiar with him until this article and went and watched some youtube stuff and really liked it – but he is oversaturating his market and becoming to be a parody of himself….really seems like he’s trying to make money on youtube etc…the songs I once thought where clever are now kinda boring. Had high hopes after a few listens but it wore on me quickly. Definitely talented but trying too hard…he needs a couple of months without tiktok.