Whiskey Riff’s Political Coverage Is Deceptive and Concerning
The massive country music and lifestyle publication Whiskey Riff makes for an extremely easy target with their click bait stories, their terrible format with so many video streaming ads populating on top of each other that you can’t even read the content, and how they’ve expanded their coverage so much in the last few months that music coverage makes up a smaller portion of their content in between sports, outdoors, and general “Hey, this is the most buzzy thing on the internet” stuff like the “Hawk Tuah Girl.”
But ultimately, for all its flaws and annoyances, Whiskey Riff has been a huge player in helping to transform country music where independent artists actually have a shot at a career because a big publication will get behind them and help generate buzz. There is also a lot of jealousy at Whiskey Riff‘s success from other journalists and publications, and ultimately that’s just petty. Good for them for becoming so successful.
But their unscrupulous journalistic practices are disturbing, and they’re now being exacerbated by deciding that political coverage also needs to be part of the Whiskey Riff diet. The publication can publish whatever they want, including politics. But let’s not forget that Whiskey Riff is partially owned by the Grand Ole Opry, which makes the stakes of their coverage inexorably tied to country music in a meaningful way, while the politicization of the music space is something we all should be wary of.
In some respects, it makes sense why Whiskey Riff is getting into politics. At this point, few if anyone is reading about music anymore. That’s just a simple fact. If you’re reading these very words, you may disagree with this, because you might come to Saving Country Music or similar websites every day. But the number of people doing this is dwindling to unsustainable numbers in lieu of coverage of politics and sports, exacerbated by the looming Presidential election in the United States, as well as the recent Olympics and impending NFL Football season.
This is all currently top-of-mind after on Tuesday, Whiskey Riff posted the same basic article highlighting politically-divisive quotes from John Rich taken from a two-year-old interview, creating a massive internet stir the same way it did when they posted the quotes originally in 2022, and again in 2023.
Whiskey Riff is not alone in reposting old articles as new ones. Unfortunately, this unethical practice is common among these click-centric 2nd-tier publications. We see this from Taste of Country, The Boot, and other publications in the country music space as well. They especially love to do this with anniversaries and historical pieces. Criticize publications like The New York Times, Rolling Stone, CNN, Fox News, etc. all you want. They would never engage in this deceptive practice. It’s also against search engine policies from companies like Google.
The same basic John Rich interview story has been published now at least three times by Whiskey Riff, verified by their Facebook posts. This is different from reposting a link to a previous article on social media, which would be fine according to conventional journalistic practices.
After Whiskey Riff posted this article on Tuesday (8-13), it went viral once again, with one X/Twitter user, Zane Bearden, posting a viral response to the headline that is exploding at the moment, explaining why John Rich’s theory on Johnny Cash and Waylon Jennings is completely incorrect, which it is. But this also inadvertently brings attention back to the original Whiskey Riff story.
As an aside, John Rich’s comments never made any sense. They didn’t make sense when he uttered them two years ago when country music was on the dramatic upswing and actually pushing back against many of the forces trying to politicize the music, and it’s even more incorrect today when you have Jason Aldean out there hanging out beside Donald Trump at the Republican National Convention. Barack Obama recently put a Morgan Wallen song in his summer playlist. Maren Morris has left the genre. This fight is over, or at least, has shifted.
But the bigger problem here isn’t anyone’s specific political ideologies. It is the unnecessary politicization of the country music space that is happening through Whiskey Riff‘s political coverage. Previously, the concern had been Rolling Ston and, publications outside of country music, and how political apparatchiks had embedded themselves within this media environment attempting to flip America’s rural electorate from red to blue through the forum of country music by shaming country stars to come out for left-leaning causes.
Not only did that political project fail, it was very directly counter-productive, something Saving Country Music warned about when the political project was launched. Far and away, country music is now much more outwardly right-leaning than it was before the left-leaning political project targeting country began in 2016 after the election of Donald Trump. Much of this right-leaning perspective is a backlash against the attempt to politicize country music on the left.
One of the greatest examples of this political overreach on the left was the ludicrous focus on the Instagram account of Jason Aldean’s wife. Where previously Aldean was on record (in Rolling Stone, no less) saying he didn’t want to get involved in politics at all, after The Washington Post published three dedicated articles about Brittany Aldean’s Instagram posts alone, Aldean responded by speaking out politically as well. Jason Aldean’s wife is not a country music performer. It was out-of-bounds to consider her opinions as representative of country music.
Now Whiskey Riff is publishing similar stories—if not even worse—just on the right. On August 6th, they posted an article about how the wife of a wide receiver for the Carolina Panthers criticized the Kamala Harris pick for Vice President. So you basically had a country music publication that also covers sports posting an article about how the wife of a football player said something politically. This puts you so many degrees of separation from what’s supposed to be the Grand Ole Opry-backed Whiskey Riff‘s beat that it’s ridiculous.
The top comments on X/Twitter said it all.
“I liked it better when this was just a music review site by people who never passed college English.”
“Used to enjoy when this was a music site highlighting good music now its just a political right wing site. sad.”
This is just one example of the many political stories Whiskey Riff has posted recently.
Again, there are perverse incentives to publications going in these directions since they gin up public engagement and result in tons of clicks while the amount of clicks you can garner posting about country music or the arts is plummeting. This is also exacerbated by search engines prioritizing political and sports coverage over arts coverage.
Music must remain and institution where artists are able to share songs and stories that cross the political divide and bring people together across ideologies. Even if you’re a politically active person, it’s important to recognize that it’s often a story song or a perspective shared in a song that can sway someone’s opinion significantly better than a negative political ad, or a slanted news story.
Whiskey Riff can publish whatever they want. But the public should reject the politicization of music coverage or the music itself, whether it’s coming from the left or the right. They should also be clear-eyed about the incentives in place that have led to this coverage, and cater their browsing behaviors accordingly.
Music media publications are failing at an alarming rate, and it’s not just the fault of massive publications like Whiskey Riff gobbling up market share. It’s because consumers are favoring these publications over others than put quality and objectivity first. Whiskey Riff also has good coverage, and has been a massive player in opening up country music to artists not on major labels or played on the radio. But their recent political coverage has been troubling, and at times, a bridge too far.
OlHankFan
August 14, 2024 @ 10:06 am
It’s goofy that country music would ever take an accomodating posture to the Left which clearly hates the people and way of life that gave us & sustains country music.
It’s also goofy to act like the country music industry isn’t saturated with political operators. Clearly it is. The problem is that too many of them are loyal to people who hate country music fans.
Gonna go follow Whisky Riff on Twitter. If I can help them run hateful, racists Leftists out of country music in any way that’d be wonderful.
Interstate Daydreamer
August 14, 2024 @ 11:25 am
The right claims to care about the common people but every single thing they do is to benefit big corporations. The left is the side that actually cares about common people.
The right is so full of hate.
Dontwannafallinlove
August 14, 2024 @ 11:38 am
In November the banks, media, newspapers, big tech, big business, big pharma, all will be voting Horrible Harris. I’ll take trump any day of the week. I want a president who cares about the common man. And that ain’t the Democrats. You notice how unions are voting trump this year? Democrats used to be about the working class, jobs, economy. The republicans are now that party. All Democrats want to do is call trump supporters racists. I’m voting trump all day long. Fuck all the woke sjw blm supporters in Nashville. They have no place in country music and in our industry. I support police not criminals and thugs. We were told to view fentanyl saint Floyd as some sort of hero. Ain’t never was a hero to me. I supported and still support the police in that situation. Chauvin is a hero and it’s not his fault a drug addict criminal died. If anything I think the police should and need to do whatever is necessary to force a suspect to comply, what chauvin did is well within those bounds. I support it.
Trigger
August 14, 2024 @ 12:03 pm
I understand there is a political quotient to this story. But if the focus becomes right vs. left and things like which one “hates” more, this comments section will be shut down. This is a very important story involving how the media covers country music. Your thoughts and opinions on that topic are encouraged. Leave the other stuff to Facebook.
Interstate Daydreamer
August 14, 2024 @ 1:02 pm
Careful, Kyle…the MAGAts might consider that a threat to stifle free speech.
Catchmearoundherebuzz
August 14, 2024 @ 1:04 pm
While I agree the focus needs to be on the music, this is one story where is disgree with you, politics isn’t just a part of it, it’s the entire story. How you feel about WR dipping it’s feet into political content is solely dependent on which side of the aisle is “your side”. Interstate and others who are aghast at this and unfollowing WR would have no issue with it, and would cheer it on if WR were posting content propping up their candidate , and I am man enough to admit the obvious I’d be upset and pissed if WR did that. But as they seem anti woke I love it. That’s why my OP comment focused so much on how politics is people’s identities these days, in a way it never was. Country artists of the past may have been one side or the other on the past, but was it wasn’t their ENTIRE identity. That’s changed, on both sides of the aisle. But on different sides. How one judges this story is completely an individual thing, dependent on if you are red or blue. That isn’t a part of the story. It is the entirety of it.
Trigger
August 14, 2024 @ 1:15 pm
“How you feel about WR dipping it’s feet into political content is solely dependent on which side of the aisle is “your side”.”
The problem here is not just that they’re dipping their feet in political content, it is how they are doing it. When you deceptively post the same article three times, that is a direct ethical violation of any and all journalistic standards, especially when it’s done knowing it will stir political acrimony.
And I fail to see how highlighting the opinions of a wide receiver’s wife about a Vice Presidential pick is in any way newsworthy no matter where you fall on the political divide, especially if you’re supposed to be a country music publication.
We’re not talking about Whiskey Riff coming out against “wokeness.” We’re talking about them using political acrimony to attempt to farm clicks in a way that is deceptive and disruptive to the country music community.
Wasitthesunsetonhercheeks
August 14, 2024 @ 1:37 pm
Understood, but I guess main point still stands. Over the last 8 years Nashville and country have been politicized, it’s just it’s gone one way and now as you pointed out country is very right wing once again. My question would be why weren’t there journalists calling the politicization of the music out in 2020? The Opry shouldn’t be political , agreed there. But they took a stand against Morgan and have been about DEI stuff since 2020. That’s not championing the music either. Which is what I was saying. No one, including you trigger had an issue in 2020 when country music bent over backwards to accommodate BLM and talk about antiracist bs. That’s not upholding the country music standard either. Interstate likely supported that stuff. I think the difference is people in Nashville have finally tired of only blue state voices being heard. Apple TV claiming Nashville is all about DEI in that moronic tv show also was explicitly political. All one has to do to see my point is bang on is to read this comment section. The people supporting WR are red, the people opposed are blue. You may look at it through a non political lens but we, your readers do not. I’d hope you also wrote articles castigating the Opry and CMTs when they have gone woke on their content. I seem to remember the IG account of the Opry posting political content on it. You caint call out one side and act silent when another side engages in it. The Opry HAS BEEN vocally political these last few years. And how one views that again depends on your side of the aisle. You think Isbell dislikes when Nashville is political? No, he dislikes it when Nashville is politically conservative. There is a difference. Let’s be open and fair here trigger. You think if WR we’re openly pro democrat and lgbtq that the left side of the aisle would have an issue with WR? Come on, now .
Trigger
August 14, 2024 @ 1:56 pm
“No one, including you trigger had an issue in 2020 when country music bent over backwards to accommodate BLM and talk about antiracist bs.”
“You think if WR we’re openly pro democrat and lgbtq that the left side of the aisle would have an issue with WR? Come on, now.”
I wrote at length in many dedicated articles about the political project that was launched in 2016/2017 after the election of Donald Trump where folks in the media and academia targeted country music as a way to reshape the American electorate from red to blue. I even talked about this at length in this article specifically, and how that effort was counter-productive, and ultimately led to artists like Jason Aldean and others coming out on the right, with links to those articles.
There are numerous other examples, but here is one that calls out Rolling Stone specifically:
https://savingcountrymusic.com/rolling-stone-country-breaks-promise-to-not-get-political/
As for the BLM stuff, this is a bit more complicated, because I do consider myself against racism. I think a lot of folks bought into the BLM movement because it felt like the right thing to do. Later when the corruption and the real estate schemes were revealed, there was a lot of distancing by folks, but not a lot of reconciling. This includes in country music. But I also think that a lot of folks have moved on from that, and COVID as well. Lots of mistakes were made. Few want to go back and re-litigate them because it’s tough to admit when you’re wrong. But whether it was the mandatory lockdowns or the “posting of black squares on social media” to bend a knee to BLM, I opposed it as authoritarian in real time.
Again, I could post numerous examples, but here is one:
https://savingcountrymusic.com/willie-nelson-dolly-parton-more-on-misguided-accountability-list/
CountryKnight
August 14, 2024 @ 3:35 pm
Anyone who paid attention to BLM in 2020 knew about the scandals and schemes. All that information was readily available. However, since the mainstream media is nothing more than a propaganda machine and the average American believe what the TV says, they got away with burning down city blocks in the name of justice.
“Mostly peaceful protests” said CNN as flames raged in the background.
Michelle
August 14, 2024 @ 9:30 pm
“MAGAts”, really? You seem nice.
The Original WTF Guy
August 15, 2024 @ 10:21 am
“because I do consider myself against racism. ”
Well, hallafuckingluleh!!!
I hope it didn’t hurt too much to write that.
I hate to even consider what the alternative to considering oneself against racism might be.
Trigger
August 15, 2024 @ 11:15 am
The reason I worded it that way is because I was responding to a comment that mentioned “antiracism,” which is considered more an ideology than being “anti racist.” I do consider myself to be against racism, and I wanted to emphasize that. But that doesn’t mean I espouse all that is lumped into “antiracism” by people on both sides, which is stuff like assuming everything is racist until proven otherwise.
Interstate Daydreamer
August 14, 2024 @ 12:56 pm
Your post has everything but the obligatory “I’m not racist, but…” at the start of it. Bravo for hitting every trope. If the third verse of “You Never Even Call Me By My Name” were an internet comment, this would be it.
Lunchbox
August 15, 2024 @ 7:37 am
“The left is the side that actually cares about common people.
The right is so full of hate.”
also…
“MAGAts”
Luckyoldsun
August 14, 2024 @ 4:55 pm
Funny, Trump was just laughing with Elon about firing union activistss or strikers.
hamster
August 14, 2024 @ 1:22 pm
GOP, DNC different sides of the same corrupt corporate coin
Facts about Americans illustrating “nothing will fundamentally change” failures of billionaires/corporations that control the corporate duopoly of the GOP and DNC
39% of Americans have skipped meals to pay their rent; 44% of millennials
25% of Americans live with medical debt
61% of Americans live paycheck to paycheck
37% percent of Americans could not afford an unexpected $400 expenditure
+15.8% “All Goods” Inflation (since 2018)
+19.7% “Food at Home” Inflation (since 2018)
In 2020, 46% of American renters spent 30% or more of their income on housing, including 23% who spent at least 50% of their income on housing
Renters across the U.S. have seen the average rent rise 18% over the last five years, outpacing inflation
Eviction/foreclosure-related moves rose 56% from 2021 to 2022
Ben
August 14, 2024 @ 10:13 pm
If your inflation stats are correct, that only works out to 2.5-3% compounded for 6 years. Which is a little higher than we’ve been accustomed to since the gfc in 09, but not terribly high.
BDE
August 15, 2024 @ 4:50 am
Whats your secret to not knowing what groceries cost? Do you grow all your own food on a self sustaining homestead?
CountryKnight
August 15, 2024 @ 8:22 am
“Not terribly high.”
How considerate. Spoke like a true limousine liberal.
Strait
August 14, 2024 @ 7:49 pm
I’m confused as to how you do not know that the heads of almost all of the big corporations are Liberals. The Democrats openly lie to your face about being for the common working man but then turn around and do the same things that you blame the Republicans for supporting.
Do you only look at politics in a cartoonishly simple way of Republicans = Bad, and Democrats = Good?
Trigger
August 14, 2024 @ 8:13 pm
Let’s please try to not allow the discussion to get bogged down in straight left/right politics. Let’s please try to keep it centered around the specific topic at hand.
Ben
August 14, 2024 @ 10:20 pm
Corporations are mostly apolitical in my experience. They want to make shareholders money. And they can’t make money if their customers have nothing to spend. They tend to get involved in politics to the extent that some regulation impacts their business, or if social policy is interfering with talent acquisition and retention.
Ken
August 16, 2024 @ 4:22 am
And the Republicans with Project 2025 want to end the system of government we have . There in lies the problem you on the right are in a much bigger echo zone than the left is.
Trigger
August 16, 2024 @ 7:26 am
Again, expressly political comments are discouraged here and subject to deletion. We’re not going to solve the left right gap in the comments section of a country music website. Please keep comments on the subject broached by the article. Thank you.
JoseyWales
August 15, 2024 @ 8:34 am
This is the type of comment I can’t stand. You are so absolutely delusional you need to take a long look in the mirror and reevaluate your entire life. You truly in your heart believe that this country is left vs. right. Spoiler alert, it isn’t. Its a dog and pony show. These politicians are all the best of friends who just want us to think they hate each other so we will why they pick our pockets and trying to create such a civil hatred for one another. Grow up.
Trigger
August 14, 2024 @ 12:06 pm
“Gonna go follow Whisky Riff on Twitter. If I can help them run hateful, racists Leftists out of country music in any way that’d be wonderful.”
This is the exact type of blind team loyalty that comes part and parcel with politics that makes it so necessary to keep free from music. All of a sudden people are listening to Jason Aldean or Maren Morris solely to get back at the other side of the political perspective even though both are releasing terrible music.
OlHankFan
August 14, 2024 @ 12:14 pm
Now do Sturgill fans who showed up once he started being loudly Leftist.
Or Oliver Anthony listeners who first heard him when he was talking about politicians who are only on the lookout for minors on an island somewhere.
Or the fight over Morgan’s public platform when he said something he shouldn’t have.
This political neutrality you’re referring to doesn’t exist. Life has big questions and often the gov’t is involved. Stringbean sung about about 20 cent cotton and 90 cent meat. It is unavoidable. The issue is which side (a) doesn’t want to destroy the culture & people that country music comes from and which sustains it to this day as well as (b) which side comes to the country music community wanting to re-engineeer society through it vs. those who want to describe rural + blue collar life.
People see these things, experience them, and are going to sing about them. And write about them on commentary sites.
Tony R.
August 14, 2024 @ 1:25 pm
Thank you for playing “Missing the Point Entirely!”
glendel
August 14, 2024 @ 10:18 am
Someone should have interviewed Aldean’s first wife to get her take on the comments from the second wiife. 😎
kross
August 14, 2024 @ 10:30 am
just playing Devils advocate, but If a Boy Named Sue were released today it would probably labeled transphobic. And, Waylon would likely be canceled for providing the theme song and voice narration for the Dukes of Hazard. We all know what happened with that show because of the General Lee. He’d most certainly be considered guilty by association. That’s how wokeness works. That’s what I thought John Rich probably meant anyways.
Interstate Daydreamer
August 14, 2024 @ 11:26 am
“Woke” is not the insult you think it is, Junior.
kross
August 14, 2024 @ 11:35 am
I didn’t mean it as an insult. I was just using commonly used vernacular to describe a potential scenario. How did you know that I was named after my father? weird
CountryKnight
August 14, 2024 @ 3:15 pm
He is thegentile 2.0.
Jake
August 14, 2024 @ 10:52 am
Don’t read that site, don’t really care, but I will say, just look to places like Vice, Buzzfeed, and countless others that let politics take over their operations and eventually killed them. Be good at your thing, whatever it is, and that will drive the eyeballs. Inject politics and watch at least half (probably much more) go somewhere else.
Lee
August 14, 2024 @ 10:53 am
I’m unfollowing them.
Dontwannafallinlove
August 14, 2024 @ 11:04 am
Agree and disagree trigger. Whiskey riff is the face of country music for many young people which is great. But their politics front and center is a sign of the times in general. Politics is like religion to most people especially in the states, where religion has declined. Everything is political, from the tv shows and music you consume to the comedians and tech platforms you support. I wish it weren’t this way, but in 2024 that’s the reality. I think as you said a lot of it is pushback from red conservative Nashville where we’ve had liberal bs shoved down our throats for a decade and told this is real country and that if you vote trump you are evil. You had that Apple TV show shoehorning in dei trash and suggesting that’s real country. You had Kelsea and the cmt awards a few years back bringing out drag queens during a performance. You had Nashville shun Morgan and stop playing his music and continue to blackball and ignore him for major awards, like him
Or not he is the face of country music. You had the industry cowtowing to blm terrorists in 2020 and telling us lies about George Floyd and “racist” cops. And as you said they’ve been pumping the music with Marxist tropes for years trying to sway us to their side. The backlash and the right wing swing in country is a result of all that. I don’t want to be told I’m evil for voting trump. I don’t want to be told I should be ashamed of my skin color, heritage or my “privilege”. I want high quality country music, period . If that also includes traditional America values and politically incorrect lyrics in the music, then all the better. Country music is a lifestyle. And it’s not Marxist, no matter what isbell, or Karen Morris or Mickey try to tell you. None of the outward right wing swing to country would have occurred without the in your face sjw Marxist garbage being shoved down our throats without our consent. Aldean and BK are so vocal about the views at the moment precisely because people like isbell and others have for years suggested Nashville needs to push people like Aldean and BK out because they are conservatives. The problem isn’t whiskey riff, it’s the overt leftist agenda Nashville has peddled to
Us all including to us conservatives without our consent. It’s demonized traditional values that are the bedrock of our culture, our history, our nation and yes our music, country music included. Until people like isbell and Karen Morris and Mickey are forced out, shunned and booed loudly, the overt aldean and BK anthems will continue on and will be warmly welcomed by us red staters and trump voters
Heyday
August 14, 2024 @ 11:44 am
I missed the part where you were forced or coerced to listen to the music. How was that accomplished? Legislation? Tax incentives? Did the government shut down radio stations it deemed “conservative” and you were only left with stations that played Jason Isbell and “Karen” Morris?
glendel
August 14, 2024 @ 12:15 pm
“and Mickey…” Do you mean Mickey Raphael? What did he ever do or say to you? :0
JT
August 14, 2024 @ 11:27 am
Iv’e been noticing and trying to ignore the little political jabs inserted into their music “news”. I did not realize ‘riff was Grand Old Opry propaganda… makes sense they care more about clicks than music.
Interstate Daydreamer
August 14, 2024 @ 11:27 am
As bad as Whiskey Riff may be, at least they don’t try to hide their political slant. Kyle tries to convince his readers that he’s unbiased, but he’s clearly got a political axe to grind with anyone left of center.
MH
August 14, 2024 @ 11:45 am
LOL you’re a paranoid pussy.
Cap’n B
August 14, 2024 @ 12:18 pm
You’re one of the three or four commenters I can always count on to be here to bash Trig when there’s the slightest hint of politics. “Believe everything I believe or you’re far right and must be publicly shamed!”. Tiresome.
wayne
August 14, 2024 @ 12:53 pm
I disagree with your statement about Trigger. He actually tries so hard to be neutral. If anything, he, to me, leans a bit left of center just because a large swath of country music listeners tend to be more conservative and he tries to be balanced. Maybe he tries too hard to be balanced. However, I have no problem with Riff. Of course, many who do seem an issue with them seems to have no problem with Rolling Stone, who have been peddling liberal politics for years. Just seems like there is only a problem when it is the “right” who gains a voice.
By the way, Trigger did call out RS in his post Kudos for that.
Adam S
August 14, 2024 @ 1:18 pm
I have a problem with both, and have expressed that. I’ve agreed with criticisms of the left on many things. Just because the right has no standards except for double standards doesn’t mean actual liberals do too. The hypocrisy in the comments section is pathetic.
Of course he called RS out, he shoehorns complaints about the left into any articles that he can.
This isn’t the right “gaining a voice”, it’s just more culture war bullshit, and you’re lapping it up because it’s from your side.
CountryKnight
August 14, 2024 @ 3:17 pm
Laughable hysteria.
Any time a celebrity or a company slightly leans right, the left comes complaining.
Adam S
August 14, 2024 @ 6:49 pm
I’m not complaining about the right, I’m calling out hypocrisy when you snowflakes whine about the left then turn around and cheer when the right does the same thing. That’s laughable.
CountryKnight
August 15, 2024 @ 8:20 am
The left set the terms of engagement. That is how the game is played now.
The Right tried being polite. It went nowhere. You don’t beat back barbarians with peace treaties; you win by fighting back.
Strait
August 14, 2024 @ 4:25 pm
I am going to come to his defense here. The fact that he details issues with a political slant in a usually objective way that I would sign off on for the most part, is better than most people who are card-carrying Liberals. People can have their biases. I just get annoyed when people don’t do any research beyond reading a headline and are completely unwilling to change their views when presented with new information.
There will always be people who are on whatever the left side is, and the other half will be on whatever the right side is. Above all I hate censorship. I firmly believe that bad ideas die in the sunlight. History is clear that the people who are doing the censoring are never the good guys.
Luckyoldsun
August 14, 2024 @ 5:04 pm
@ID–Funny, this whole article is essentially Trigger calling out a country music site for pandering to the right wing, but your take is that it shows that he has an axe to grind with anyone on the left.
I don’t doubt that you have an exquisitely complicated reason for why that’s so.
Mike D
August 14, 2024 @ 11:32 am
Like Jake said above, be good at your thing.
Quite a few publications are bought out or have “investments” by aspiring media conglomerates. The product then morphs to appease Wall Street thinking of more sales/clicks instead of sticking to what the initial founder of said product was attempting.
Travis
August 14, 2024 @ 11:48 am
Comment section shut down in 5, 4, 3,…
Julie
August 14, 2024 @ 12:07 pm
It’s sad because the best of lists and country music recs on Whiskey Riff are actually good, but you have to wade through a lot of crap to find them. I was today’s year old when I found out about the Whiskey Riff-Opry connection.
Tom C
August 14, 2024 @ 12:21 pm
“ Criticize publications like The New York Times, Rolling Stone, CNN, Fox News, etc. all you want. They would never engage in this deceptive practice. It’s also against search engine policies from companies like Google.”
I really wish more people understood this. NYT may frame stories with a bias, but their news division will never publish stories without verifying the information themselves and abiding by journalistic codes. They also have a clear separation between their News division and Editorial Board. Ditto for WSJ, and to a large degree, CNN and Fox News.
It is a good thing that folks are interested in telling the news. But without any training or understanding of journalistic ethics, they’ll cause more harm than the anything the MSM does.
I always appreciate when you put these clickbait publications in their place.
OlHankFan
August 14, 2024 @ 12:27 pm
It’s wild to me people still believe this stuff about legacy corporate media, despite all we learned over the last ~5 years.
Wild. But I guess some still do.
CountryKnight
August 14, 2024 @ 3:18 pm
It is wild to me that people still believe the government wants best for America and that they shouldn’t be questioned.
King George III must be laughing. We revolted over a minor tax in 1775 and today we are overtaxed and it is considered patriotic.
Heyday
August 15, 2024 @ 1:23 am
Uh, no. Your grasp of American history is shaky. The Colonies revolted over “taxation without representation.” Remember that phrase from elementary school social studies?
thegentile
August 15, 2024 @ 6:19 am
shaky is putting it lightly. ck has full-blown history parkinson’s.
unless he’s bringing up a historical figure to flaunt his bigotry. he’s pretty good at that.
https://savingcountrymusic.com/this-is-why-tyler-childers-played-a-benefit-for-the-blackfeet-tribe/#comments
CountryKnight
August 15, 2024 @ 8:11 am
High taxes also triggered the revolt.
CountryKnight
August 15, 2024 @ 8:12 am
Because England’s taxes on America in the 1760s and 1770s were minor compared to our tyrannical burden today.
Hence, why George III is laughing.
Tom C
August 14, 2024 @ 10:26 pm
When it comes to real reporting, MSM (including WSJ and Fox News) are some of the best reporters we have.
The opinion pieces and talk shows are of course all fluff. But in terms of regular reporting and abiding by industry standards, they blow cheap publications like Whiskey Riff out of the water.
parkn63
August 14, 2024 @ 12:33 pm
Political songs are generally the weakest songs in any artist’s catalogue. And they do nothing. The most politically “important” era of music was the 1960s, and absolutely nothing would have changed about the War in Vietnam or Civil Rights movement if Dylan had never written Blowing in the Wind or The Times are a-Changing. On the contrary, his best protest song is probably the Ballad of Hollis Brown, which only Dylan fans would know.
Evan
August 14, 2024 @ 7:24 pm
Hurricane and Lonesome Death of Hattie Carrol are better
MichaelA
August 15, 2024 @ 7:07 am
Hurricane is an extraordinary song.
I would put Neighborhood Bully up there too. Especially relevant today.
Stephen R.
August 16, 2024 @ 3:45 am
Heh, I would say more than Dylan fans know The Ballad of Hollis Brown. Back during my more punk phase, I learned the song because my favorite band at the time (Rise Against) covered it for a Bob Dylan tribute album.
Daniel Anderson
August 17, 2024 @ 3:04 pm
His best protest song is probably “The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carroll”
Mick
August 22, 2024 @ 9:43 pm
Tom MacDonald. Ever heard of him? His music is some of the best out there.
RJ
August 14, 2024 @ 1:04 pm
Trig, you posted this exact same article two years ago.
Kidding of course. I just visited their site for the second time. There is an article about Hardy, Post Malone, Megan Moroney, another Post Malone, Obama, Jelly Roll, and Lainey Wilson.
I hope you never get jealous of them Trigger because that content is poop on a stick. Clickbait poop on a stinky stick of not real country.
CountryKnight
August 14, 2024 @ 3:20 pm
Trigger has posted the same article about the lack of women artists or declaring a country music holiday over and over again. However, he is a good writer, so it doesn’t feel odious.
Ryan
August 14, 2024 @ 1:18 pm
I used to visit an automotive site called Jalopnik. The editors were left of center but kept it on a leash. Some time before Trump’s election they got bought by private equity because the parent company was sued out of existence. From them on it wasn’t so much that the newer writers and editors were more left politically, it’s that they started taking any opportunity to work it in.
Something about cars? Well it’s got to mention how building the interstate was used to create Black ghettos. And how fossil fuels are poisoning the Earth. I believe those things but I don’t want them to take up half an article when the headline didn’t mention either of those subjects. That’s a bait and switch.
And then they began making huge reaches to comment on the political fight of the day no matter how unrelated to their theme and purpose as a media outlet. Writing as if their opinions were, in fact, foregone conclusions. Pushing biking and public transit stories to the top even though they were usually only of passing interest to most of the audience.
And worst was the community in the comments. Question a widely-held opinion or voice a concern that’s unpopular? Expect to have half a dozen people try to start arguments or call names rather than have a discussion. So I just stopped going there.
It did help that some of the writers left and started their own site. So if anyone reading also used to frequent Jalopnik and doesn’t anymore I’d recommend theautopian.com They’re not afraid to talk politics when it’s relevant but don’t go off the rails and they seem to keep an open mind.
Seriously, I agree with a lot of those people’s positions and they drove me off. I don’t know if there’s enough people like me to make the click bait extremism (on both sides) unprofitable or to make up an audience for publications that hold themselves to a higher standard. The Autopian has a membership system and I’m thinking about it, not for merch but to support the kind of journalism I want to see. Maybe that’s the way forward.
SnarkyAnarky
August 14, 2024 @ 3:11 pm
man, i used to read that site daily 15yrs ago… now i miiiiight check it once a month if i’m bored. i just want to read about cars, tell me about cars. i’ll def have to check out theautopian, thanks for that
similarly, i’ve gone to Whiskey Riff occasionally over the past year or so and wondered why i bothered because i never learn or discover anything.
would love to find more music sites. SCM is a multiple times a day visit… NoDepression i check once a week or so… AmericanSongwriter is actually not great but i’ll check it out if i’m bored… Hollar and a few others on occasion but they all feel very very click-baity
liza
August 14, 2024 @ 1:24 pm
I’m disappointed to learn that the Opry has an ownership stake in that click-bait rag.
Tommy
August 14, 2024 @ 3:14 pm
I don’t mind Whiskey Riff for what it is when it comes to some of their sports pieces and stuff. It’s usually got enough sarcasm in it to get a chuckle out of me. They’re there to pump the newest names in mainstream music which does nothing for me.
As far as politics, the biggest problem is the fact that anybody believes that any of these politicians give a rats ass about the “common man.” They don’t. You don’t matter to them. Stop lying to yourself.
CountryKnight
August 14, 2024 @ 3:21 pm
There is one party and none of us are invited.
Tommy
August 14, 2024 @ 3:46 pm
That’s it. I live in a red state, and they think Trump cares about them. My brother lives in a blue state and is surrounded by people who think Kamala cares about them. They’re all wrong. These people give no shits about those of us who they hope vote for them.
Strait
August 14, 2024 @ 4:37 pm
This take is accurate. Nearly all politicians are beholden to their donors. I have a preferred candidate because I want less regulation, lower taxes, and I want globalist policies to be rejected. (Electric car mandates, Climate change mandates)
The black-pilled side of me doesn’t think that much can be done to stop an eventual globalist and authoritarian takeover because the military industrial complex pulls the strings of politicians. They are the ones who conspired to kill JFK – which is why military efforts immediately ramped up under LBJ right after.
CountryKnight
August 14, 2024 @ 3:31 pm
Anyway, John Rich’s point is laughable. Cash would absolutely have gone along with the current topics. The man never missed a chance to pander to popular causes (hence his popularity outside the genre. The country stars most loved by America: Cash, Willie, Dolly all embraced popular causes). His entire prison albums are odes to criminals while casting the wardens and guards (you know, the people who weren’t killers and rapists) in a bad light.
“Folsom Prison Blues” received its biggest cheer during the “shot a man in Reno” part. There is a great answer song by Adam Pope called “Shot in Reno.” The real victim we should feel sorry for not the sociopath in the prison cell who deserves Old Sparky.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vR1oy32ZCss
The singer who would have been cancelled is Marty Robbins. “Ain’t I Right” an excellent song isn’t on Spotify. You can figure out why by listening. He has another song against foreign aid. (Also linked below). Robbins was a great American.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0XxYwWg7F8I
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KFkg50qMLRs
Adam S
August 14, 2024 @ 6:56 pm
Marty Robbins was a great country singer, but I don’t know how anyone on the modern right supports a bootlicking song like “Ain’t I Right” that supported the Vietnam War. But I guess it’s the same strategy you use, just label everyone you don’t like as a Communist, so no wonder you like it.
Your bar for great Americans is pretty low.
thegentile
August 15, 2024 @ 6:29 am
to be fair to ck, he sometimes calls us socialists too since the terms are apparently interchangeable.
CountryKnight
August 15, 2024 @ 8:17 am
https://www.getprinciples.com/the-godless-roots-of-socialism/
“Therefore, all communists are socialists, though some socialists are not communists. In what follows, I will generally treat socialism and communism interchangeably, since socialism is the broader category to which all communism belongs.”
They are kinfolks, belonging to the same intellectually bankrupt family.
Trigger
August 15, 2024 @ 8:26 am
This is not relevant to the discussion. Any further comments on this topic will be deleted.
Adam S
August 16, 2024 @ 10:05 am
Lol imagine posting to a Christian blog as if they’re an authority on economic systems.
CountryKnight
August 16, 2024 @ 3:54 pm
Adam S,
Instead of being narrowminded, read the author’s credentials. They are based on economics.
Jake Cutter
August 14, 2024 @ 9:01 pm
Embraced=pandered to
Euro South
August 16, 2024 @ 4:18 pm
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3_0ktIJcoBA
DCinOK
August 14, 2024 @ 4:08 pm
I’m the Right Wing of the Right Wing, but when it comes to Music and Music Journalism, I want to hear about instrumentation, melodies, and lyrics. I love Steve Earle and REM’s Michael’s Stipe…love their music, hate their politics. It can be done.
Strait
August 14, 2024 @ 4:18 pm
I’m not sure why people still want John Rich’s take on anything; he had one hit song….20 years ago.
Waylon and Willie wouldn’t be accepted in Country music today but for different reasons. They heavily used drugs and were rough around the edges and behaved in ways that today is seen as a liability. Also Waylon, Willie, Kristofferson, Haggard and more were not conservatives. They were left leaning in many ways. The political paradigm has shifted but they were not frumpy Fox News blowhard conservatives.
There is a lot of valid critisism that can be thrown on Tim Walz and it annoys me when people are careless and don’t stop and filter out fake news. Walz and his wife did openly support the riots and destruction in the city that Walz was governor over at the time.
Marcel Ledbetter
August 14, 2024 @ 4:24 pm
Left wing, right wing same fucking bird! Identity politics in this country , is out of control!
Scott S.
August 15, 2024 @ 6:16 am
Amen
Di Harris
August 17, 2024 @ 3:02 pm
Not even close.
EmmonsDay
August 14, 2024 @ 4:28 pm
Man Whiskey Riff is some real bullshit. I’ve never followed or liked or clicked but it’s all over my fb feed. Basically a reality show designed to poke idiots into poking back. Also worth noting – if you work in music and in country and in Nashville, you know John Rich is famously a loudmouthed dumbass click whore as well, sometimes masquerading as a country artist. Since 9/11, these bloated fucking tits pretend they’re outlaw bad boys who back the blue and lick the boots. Oh, and the music …good lord. Also, really enjoying the comment section today. Sincerely, good job responding to the anonymous twats. Must take some time.
TwangBob
August 14, 2024 @ 7:39 pm
Sigh… reading these comments make me wish there was a thumbs down (dislike) button to click.
RJay
August 14, 2024 @ 8:25 pm
I really don’t understand how people have time to pay attention to this. Don’t have instagram, don’t ’follow’ anything. Anyway, Spencer Burtons new album North Wind from earlier this year is excellent.
RJ
August 15, 2024 @ 2:25 am
Thank you for that one. First quick listen – if going fishing and farm life don’t out a smile on your face, then here is something wrong with you.
SixtyThreeGuild
August 14, 2024 @ 9:46 pm
It’s just like anything these days, they’ve ran the numbers and know that shitty political headlines generate clicks which generate ad revenue so do it with integrity be damn. Lot of people are missing Trigs big point of you can print whatever, but being misleading and getting too click baity will catch you in the long run and run people off.
The blind loyalty of treating political parties like sports teams is one of the biggest damn issues in this country these days. For those saying well “this company only goes for this candidate” do some research because 9 times out of 10 the big wigs behind them are donating to both parties to cover their bases for whoever wins.
PeterD
August 14, 2024 @ 11:07 pm
Whenever I see a website or YT channel, or even an artist echo my thoughts politically and I am on the centre left of UK politics I see it as an echo chamber and realistically they could go the other way and I would be butthurt. So I prefer them to keep their noses out of politics and focus on what they are supposed to focus on, even if they mirror my views.
Also I remember a time when WR were singing the praises of FGL so fuck them.
Noneya
August 15, 2024 @ 3:18 am
I took one look at Whiskey Riff & sites of the same & immediately knew they were shit.
Saving Country Music is the only one I’ve encountered that’s worth a damn.
Rich
August 15, 2024 @ 6:21 am
I agree entirely with Trig’s position on this. Music sites – just don’t, please don’t. As for Whiskey Riff, I scroll (flip) through it very quickly and only stop when there’s something worth reading. I use an app called Flipboard which is actually really good and I follow them and other music sites on it. There’s no ads or pops when using it. I open the Whiskey Riff tab and flip past the garbage one dumb story about a moose eating a bear or whatever at a time. When I see a story about Red Clay Strays playing live with Dave Cobb (yesterday) I click on it and watch the video. On a daily basis I’d say there’s 3 to 4 music related stories worth reading. The other 10 articles are silly crap. Anyway, for those that do appreciate some of the stuff WR puts out about actual music iflipboard is a great way to get to them without all the other bullshit.
Scott S.
August 15, 2024 @ 6:23 am
Just a glance at the comments I see the same ole regurgitation of the same ole talking points. (Insert eye roll.) Not sure why anyone would take Whisky Riff seriously. They long ago stopped being a music news site. They are more of a lifestyle site catering to young people who’s attention span is barely above zero. They use sensationalized headlines to grab attention to sell advertisement and hawk their merchandise.
I don’t think Whiskey Riff has any particular political slant. They go where the trend blows to keep clicks coming and dollars flowing.
Trigger
August 15, 2024 @ 7:33 am
“I don’t think Whiskey Riff has any particular political slant. They go where the trend blows to keep clicks coming and dollars flowing.”
That perspective is outdated in August of 2024. They are most definitely posting right-leaning content on a daily basis. They did again yesterday when they posted an article abut how sports commentator Stephen A. Smith called out Kamala Harris for not doing interviews. Fair criticism, but in no way related to a country music site underwritten by the Grand Ole Opry.
Whiskey Riff is stuck in the same cycle now as every single other business in America. Each quarter they must show growth, or it’s considered a failure. So as attention for music coverage plummets, they must find other avenues for attention.
Scott S.
August 16, 2024 @ 6:01 am
The economy is bad, we are not too far out from Covid lockdowns, and inflation has people struggling. As Jim Carville once famously said, “It’s the economy stupid. ” And the economy has young people trending right. Especially in the demographic of young people who tend to listen to country music. Whiskey Riff is catering to where their viewership is flowing right now. They are posting what brings them responses and ad revenue, as opposed to a site like say Rolling Stone, who is not merely reposting other’s stories, but is attempting to write the narrative with their own stories and editorials.
And as I emphasized in my comment above, I think what is outdated is framing Whiskey Riff as a Country Music site. It has been a long time since they concentrated on just music. They are more geared towards a lifestyle type site, with country music as part of that lifestyle. Not sure what control the Grand Ole Opry has over Whiskey Riff, if any, or if it’s just as a non controlling investment. Don’t think many even realize there is a connection. I didn’t before this story.
I don’t believe Whiskey Riff has any agenda other than finding what their readership responds to and posting more of that. The Hoc Tua girl, Travis and Taylor, current politics, and whatever else brings clicks. Mostly reposts of whatever happens to be trending. So when the political winds blow the other way, I have no doubt they will follow.
Trigger
August 16, 2024 @ 7:34 am
The idea they’ll start covering stuff on the left once “the wind blows in that direction” is ludicrous. That’s what’s happening at this very moment. The winds are blowing left. When you’re covering outdoor/hunting/country music, your demographic is going to be on the right. So they’re covering the right. I agree that they can cover whatever they wish. I agree they have become basically a “lifestyle” website, not a country music one. I think everyone needs to understand and recognize that as such. That was part of the reason for this article.
But the Grand Ole Opry did invest $10 million in them. They didn’t spend that money for nothing. And $10 million is a lot of money. So yes, this does concern country music.
When Rolling Stone Country went political after expressly stating they wouldn’t, they got criticized. Now it’s Whiskey Riff’s turn. And just read the comments under their political posts. Their own readers are not liking this stuff. It’s not like their coming out and espousing right-leaning ideas in smart ways. A wide receiver’s wife hates the Vice President pick? Nobody cares about this bullshit. It’s such a stretch.
Scott S.
August 16, 2024 @ 8:30 am
Don’t want to debate which way the political winds are blowing. Reality and media reporting are two different things. I’m not trying to defend Whiskey Riff either. They are puff piece garbage that does nothing more than repost others stories with sensationalist headlines.
I just don’t agree that they have some agenda they are trying to push. They just aren’t really legitimate media that anyone really takes seriously. Unlike most of entertainment media that actually write stories, post opinion articles, and pretty much promote a leftist narrative and democrat party talking points. Media, including entertainment media, have been shills to the left for decades.
As far as the Grand Ole Opry, I understand you feel that what Whiskey Riff publishes reflects on them since they are investors. But besides you, and maybe others with inside information into the country music scene, does anyone else really know or care that the Opry is invested in a puff lifestyle website?
Trigger
August 16, 2024 @ 11:08 am
I never claimed Whiskey Riff had an “agenda.” What I explained in detail in the article is how with the implosion of interest in country music coverage, the explosion of interest in political coverage, Whiskey Riff is following the clicks, which has led them to covering politics from a right-leaning perspective since that is what fits best within their established demographics.
As for the public not knowing that the Grand Ole Opry is a financial investor, that’s on the public. That doesn’t somehow make that fact irrelevant just because the public doesn’t know. That makes it more imperative on the press to divulge this information to inform the public. When the Opry/Whiskey Riff deal happened, I wrote about it:
https://savingcountrymusic.com/on-the-grand-ole-opry-investing-in-whiskey-riff/
People might not care if the Opry is invested or not. My point is that the Opry is finally backstopping this coverage. This is one of the reasons it is relevant to country music. Whiskey Riff is no longer a completely independent media company. They’re part of one of country music’s most important institutions.
Mark Hart
August 15, 2024 @ 7:26 am
Geez man.
From the outside looking in,I just shake my head and hope it doesn’t get this far over here.
M-A
August 15, 2024 @ 8:31 am
John Rich is not wrong. Johnny « Where’s the Truth » Cash, speaking his piece to Nixon in the name of the youth, calling out djs on their racism about native people, also championing the Cajun people, would probably have a hard time to exist today… cause he would be deemed « too woke » 😉
claiborne
August 15, 2024 @ 9:51 am
right x left – blue x red …
… none of that killed country music: it was the people who bought, or played on the jukebox, mediocre songs, like the one that goes “…girl you look so good in what’s left of those jeans… ”
I blame..
HBZ
August 15, 2024 @ 11:55 am
I’m so tired of people crying about how “wokeness” is cancelling anything. Go listen to Waylon Jennings and Johnny Cash all you want, who fucking cares? No one is stopping you. Question would it be made today? Who cares, it’s fucking made already. It just being used a divisive bullshit by politicians and media for money and clickbait. People act so scared of this boogeyman called wokeness. Just calm the fuck down, conservatives.
M-A
August 15, 2024 @ 1:53 pm
Always fun to hear people complain « you can’t say anything anymore » and then see them go on saying it everywhere…
Myron
August 15, 2024 @ 3:29 pm
I feel like I can speak for the far right, when I say please quit trotting out John Rich. Big n rich did more to destroy country music than anything else I can think of.
stereojoe
August 16, 2024 @ 10:51 am
Slant just depends on from what angle you’re viewing. Whiskey Riff also ran a positive article telling people not to dismiss Post Malone’s new album just because he’s known as pop artist. I’d bet Post Malone is not known amongst his friends as Mr. Republican. There’s also a positive article about Tyler Childers who has been in defense of left-wing causes. Don’t forget the article about Barak Obama’s playlist including Morgan Wallen. That’s just what I found scrolling their front page today. To throw Whiskey Riff under the bus by only using John Rich as the example doesn’t seem all that fair.
Trigger
August 16, 2024 @ 11:44 am
Not sure what positive articles about Post Malone and Tyler Childers have to do with any of this. But for the record, folks do consider Post Malone as “Mr. Republican” after collaborating with Morgan Wallen, and appearing on the Joe Rogan podcast and Kill Tony.
The John Rich wasn’t the only example cited. It was the one highlighted because they had posted it three times, and each time presented it as new. That was the issue with that, not concerns about “Slant.”
The article also cites a Whiskey Riff article where the wife of a wide receiver criticized the Vice Presidential pick. Not sure how that in any way is relevant to country music, or even sports. Then just yesterday they posted an article about sports commentator Stephen A. Smith criticizing Kamala Harris for not giving interviews.
I could cite dozens of examples. Just didn’t want to be pedantic.
stereojoe
August 16, 2024 @ 4:37 pm
Well, your opinion is what it is. If you think going on Joe Rogan and Kill Tony instantly makes you a Republican then I don’t know what to tell you. Is Bernie Sanders a Republican? Neil Degrass Tyson? Again, political slant is viewed from an angle and yours seems to be no different than the people you criticize.
Trigger
August 16, 2024 @ 4:44 pm
I’m not saying that’s what I think. But there was definitely a backlash against Post Malone when he collaborated with Morgan Wallen. All I’m saying is the idea that he codes left is probably unfounded, or at least outdated.
Di Harris
August 16, 2024 @ 12:59 pm
You need to calm down.
It makes you furious when someone doesn’t follow your agenda.
And, you can relax about stating how unpolitical you are.
You are political to the extreme.
Trigger
August 16, 2024 @ 4:47 pm
Never stated I was “unpolitical,” ever.
I agree I’m a political extremist. I believe the entirely of our political system is corrupt, should be abolished, and most nationally elected officials should be imprisoned. Politics is a Cancer that is consuming our society and results in stupid comments like yours seething with hatred and making wild-eyed assumptions about someone you don’t even know.
MD
August 16, 2024 @ 9:10 pm
I am thankful SCM called out Whiskey Riff with this article. We are all here for country music, no matter what side you lean on.
hoptowntiger
August 18, 2024 @ 4:56 pm
I became real uncomfortable with Whiskey Riff years ago over their obsession with graphic animal death/ injury videos. It was like that kid your mother told you stay away from in school because he liked to pull the wings of butterflies … some serious Jeffrey Dahmer behavior. I’m convinced someone over there is a serial killer and we’ll find out about it in later years.
Publius
September 6, 2024 @ 12:03 am
Trigger, I get your point.
Politicizing Country music is a potential act of destruction, it could change it from a popular art to something much flatter and less interesting than commercial color by numbers. Social realism began as an avant garde artistic philosophy, once it was embraced by the Soviets it became an aesthetic checklist and a set of ideological guardrails. If you didn’t conform you were censored, perhaps imprisoned.
Two caveats. First, for the past fifteen years the left has been much, much more concerned with censorship than the right. Authoritarian leftism is a totalizing ideology, bordering on religion. Everything must bend the knee to the party. In this setting cancel culture is the sacrament of wokeness. By that I mean, you demonstrate how woke you are by denouncing the heretics and symbolically burning them at the stake by destroying their public life.
Second, Country is the product of a resistant subculture and the Empire is trying to strike back. Regular working Americans have been getting the short end of the economic stick since NAFTA. Rural America has borne the brunt of the globalist economic agenda. (offshoring manufacturing, financializing the economy, allowing oligopolies) The looting of America has been followed by social destruction, witness not just the opioid epidemic, but the startling increase in suicides, alcoholism and declining rates of marriage and household formation. Most shockingly there was a decline in life expectancy. Country music calls this destruction out. Much like rap music in the inner city, Country music is the CNN of rural/traditional America. It tells stories that the mainstream media, whether news or music, won’t touch. Country music celebrates traditional America and tries to stitch the tatters of society back together. The-powers-that-be found that annoying but tolerable until Trump came on the scene.
Our political system is designed to ‘manufacture consent’. Team Red and Team Blue include populist, even semi-radical elements. These elements are encouraged to participate, but in the end the system consistently produces centrist (pro-war/pro-globalism) Uniparty candidates. This keeps the fringe on the team and maintains the legitimacy of the system. You saw this on the left when Bernie Sanders was literally cheated in 2016 and then muscled out in 2020 when the party coalesced around Biden. The right successfully neutralized Pat Buchanan in 92 and 96 (installing a former CIA director!) then Ron Paul in 08 and 12 (selecting a private equity looter!) The exception to this rule is Donald Trump. He ran as a populist (opposing the two central values of the Uniparty: pro-war and pro-globalism) managed to beat the ‘right wing’ establishment in 16. (And boy is the establishment angry, viz the Cheney, Bush endorsements of Harris)
The Uniparty is determined to prevent a recurrence of populist revolt. Part of the plan is to destroy the social structures that support populism. Hence the urgent attempts at increasing the commercialization of country music and encroachments by other genres. The investment by NBC in Opry can be seen as an establishment buyout. Literally everything you hate is being done on purpose to destabilize and undermine Country so that the Uniparty’s control isn’t threatened again.
In this setting Country music could hope that if it minds its own business it will be left alone. But I don’t think so. As I mentioned in the beginning, authoritarian leftism is a totalizing ideology, bend the knee or be destroyed. If the assault on Country continues, in ten years Cowboy Carter will be the good old days. The most natural response to a cultural and economic attack is for rural/traditional America to look for a champion. Trump is the People’s Tribune, Country music embracing him and entering the culture war is an authentic act of self preservation.